Analysis of Sellable Credits within the Arkansas Research & Development Tax Credit Framework

I. Executive Summary: Definition and Monetization Potential

1.1. The Essence of Sellable Credits in Arkansas R&D

Sellable Credits are state income tax incentives earned by specific research-intensive enterprises (Targeted Businesses), which, unlike standard R&D credits, can be converted into immediate cash capital through a one-time sale to a third-party Arkansas taxpayer.

This transferability mechanism provides critical liquidity to eligible startups and emerging firms that may lack the current or near-term income tax liability to utilize the credits themselves.

1.2. Detailed Analysis of Transferability and Liquidity

The term “Sellable Credits” is not universally applied to all Arkansas R&D tax incentives; rather, it refers exclusively to credits derived from Qualified Research Expenditures (QREs) generated under specific programs designed for high-growth or strategic entities. This distinction is critical for corporate tax planning. The transferability feature, which allows for the assignment or sale of the credit certificate for value, transforms a deferred tax reduction into immediate cash capitalization.1

The fundamental policy objective behind allowing the sale of credits for Targeted Businesses is to address the economic challenge faced by nascent R&D firms. These companies often incur significant expenditures during their formative years, leading to operating losses and zero or negligible state income tax liability.2 If the tax credit could only be utilized through carryforwards, the benefit would be delayed for years, potentially past the point of business viability. By enabling monetization through sale, Arkansas effectively uses the tax credit program as a tool for non-dilutive financing, injecting essential liquidity directly into innovative enterprises.1 The administration of these sellable incentives requires meticulous compliance with procedures overseen by the Arkansas Economic Development Commission (AEDC) and the Department of Finance and Administration (DFA).

II. The Arkansas R&D Tax Credit Landscape and Eligibility

Arkansas administers R&D incentives across several program types under Ark. Code Ann. § 15-4-2708, with eligibility often requiring that the activity qualifies for the federal R&D tax credit (IRC § 41).3 The commission retains discretion over the approval of applications and project plans.4

2.1. Statutory Foundation: Ark. Code Ann. § 15-4-2708

The state R&D credit framework in Arkansas offers varied incentive rates depending on the type of research and the nature of the entity conducting it. These credits are intended to promote university-based research, in-house efforts, and strategic research by technology-based start-ups.2 For a business to claim any R&D income tax credit, it is their responsibility to file the claim, attaching a copy of the Certificate of Tax Credit issued by the Arkansas Science and Technology Authority or the AEDC.4

2.2. Critical Distinctions: Transferable vs. Non-Transferable Credit Programs

The determination of whether a credit is “sellable” dictates the monetization strategy available to the company.

2.2.1. In-House R&D Credit (The Non-Sellable Pathway)

This program is specifically designed for mature companies that are conducting ongoing, stable in-house research programs within the state.2 The structure is intended to reward companies with an established presence and likely continuous tax liability.

The credit allowed is 20% of the incremental amount spent on qualified in-house research expenditures (QREs) that surpasses a predetermined baseline established in the preceding year.4 Importantly, the qualified expenditure scope is narrow, generally limited to R&D salaries; related costs such as supplies, equipment, and buildings are typically excluded from the calculation.2

The utilization of this credit permits the holder to offset up to 100% of the company’s annual income tax liability.1 However, the key restriction here is that these specific credits cannot be sold.2 Any unused credits must be carried forward by the originating company for a period not exceeding nine (9) years.1 The restriction on transferability for mature firms operates as a mechanism to encourage long-term retention. By confining the value of the credit to the taxpayer’s own future liability, the state ensures that tax-positive companies benefit only by maintaining their operational and tax presence within Arkansas.

2.2.2. Targeted Business R&D and Strategic Value R&D Credits (The Sellable Pathway)

The transferability option is offered through specific programs intended for emerging, knowledge-based enterprises, primarily those designated as “Targeted Businesses” or those engaged in research in an Area of Strategic Value.2

These eligible businesses may be offered a transferable income tax credit equal to 33% of their eligible research and development expenditures.6 This attractive 33% rate is granted for up to five (5) tax years following the business’s signing of a financial incentive agreement with the commission.2

A crucial structural difference exists within this pathway: while Targeted Businesses may generate significant credits at the 33% rate with no statutory cap on the total amount generated (making this the primary vehicle for high-volume sales), research in an Area of Strategic Value is limited to a maximum credit of $50,000 per tax year.1 Regardless of the credit source within this pathway, the income tax credit may be sold upon application and approval by the AEDC Executive Director.1 This grant of transferability is the mechanism that converts a deferred tax asset into immediate operational capital for early-stage firms.

2.2.3. Program Comparison and Restrictions on Combination

The Arkansas R&D program maintains strict rules regarding the application of different incentives to prevent taxpayers from claiming multiple benefits for the same expenditures. For instance, a targeted business that claims R&D tax credits is explicitly prohibited from earning job creation tax credits or combining this benefit with other In-House R&D credits for the same qualified expenses.9

Table 1: Arkansas R&D Tax Credit Program Comparison

III. Legal and Regulatory Mechanics of Credit Transfer

The process for transferring credits is strictly controlled by state statute and regulatory guidance, ensuring integrity in the monetization process.

3.1. Prerequisite: Certification and Authorization

The essential first step is the creation and certification of the credit. A business must receive a formal Certificate of Tax Credit from the appropriate authority (either the Arkansas Science and Technology Authority or the AEDC) following the approval of its project plan.4 This certificate formally verifies the amount of credit earned and is the instrument required for filing by both the original earner and any subsequent buyer.4

3.2. Requirements for the Credit Originator (Seller)

The seller’s eligibility for sale is conditional and rigidly defined. The ability to sell is dependent upon being classified as a Targeted Business and obtaining specific administrative consent.

The business must submit a formal application to the AEDC for the sale of the earned credits, and the AEDC Executive Director must subsequently approve the transaction.1 This approval serves as regulatory validation that the credit is derived from qualified expenditures and is eligible for transfer.

Furthermore, the Arkansas Code imposes a critical limitation on liquidity: the original holder of the tax credits is permitted to sell its tax credits only one (1) time, whether in whole or in part.4 This administrative measure simplifies regulatory oversight by preventing the complex tracking that would arise from repeated, fragmented sales to multiple small buyers. The unused balance of the credit, if only a partial sale occurred, remains with the original holder for utilization within the allowed time frame.4

3.3. Requirements and Limitations for the Transferee (Buyer)

The purchaser of the credit acquires the asset but also assumes all inherent limitations that applied to the original holder, particularly concerning the timeline for utilization.

A buyer of the credit is legally subject to the exact same carryforward period.4 The sale transaction does not alter the time frame for using the credits.4 Since R&D credits generally have a nine-year carryforward period from the year earned 4, the buyer must be acutely aware of how much time remains on the credit’s life.

The utilization constraint means the buyer assumes the time value risk associated with the credit. If the purchaser fails to generate sufficient Arkansas income tax liability within the remaining carryforward period, the purchased credit may expire unused.9 This assumption of expiration risk is the primary factor driving the market discount (the difference between the credit’s face value and the cash purchase price) applied during the sale. The buyer may use the credit to offset up to 100% of their annual Arkansas income tax liability.8

IV. State Revenue Office (DFA/AEDC) Compliance and Administration

The successful execution of a transfer relies on strict procedural adherence and coordination between the economic development authority (AEDC) and the tax collection agency (DFA).

4.1. The Role of the Arkansas Economic Development Commission (AEDC)

The AEDC, alongside the Arkansas Science and Technology Authority (ASTA), focuses on the front-end process: approving the research plan, certifying the qualified expenditures, and granting permission for the one-time sale of the credit by the originating Targeted Business.1 This step ensures the economic validity and policy compliance of the incentive.

4.2. The Role of the Department of Finance and Administration (DFA)

The DFA’s Tax Credits/Special Refunds section manages the implementation of the credit programs and coordinates with economic development agencies.10 The DFA is responsible for confirming the legality of the transfer and applying the credit against the buyer’s tax liability.

The state mandates that the sale or transfer of the tax credit must be confirmed in writing by the DFA office charged with administration of the tax credit.12 For the buyer to claim the credit, they must file with their income tax return the original Certificate of Tax Credit and documentation proving the assignment (sale).4 In the absence of proper assignment documents, the tax collection authority reserves the right to refuse to recognize the credit claimed.13 While specific form numbers vary across tax credit types, the necessity of a formal Notice of Credit Transfer or equivalent documentation is consistent across similar tax credit programs regulated by the DFA.14

4.3. The Cancellation and Valuation Rule

A critical aspect of DFA compliance involves how the credit is valued once it has been purchased at a discount. DFA regulations establish the definitive rule for recognizing the credit on the buyer’s tax return.

Upon receiving the surrendered Certificate of Tax Credit, the DFA treats the credit as a payment of State income tax in the amount of the lesser of the Purchase Price or the face value of the Tax Credit Certificate.15

This mechanism establishes the buyer’s cost basis as the maximum value for the credit claim, preventing a financial arbitrage opportunity where a buyer could purchase a credit at a discount (e.g., $85,000 for a $100,000 face value) and then claim the full $100,000 against their tax liability. By limiting the claim to the cash purchase price, the regulation ensures the state only subsidizes the actual cost incurred by the buyer while still providing the immediate cash benefit to the original R&D firm.

4.4. Key Procedural Requirements for Credit Transfer

Table 2: Key Procedural Requirements for Credit Transfer

V. Case Study: Calculation, Sale, and Monetization of a Targeted R&D Credit

To fully illustrate the mechanism of sellable credits, a financial scenario for a Targeted Business is analyzed, demonstrating the tax and cash flow consequences.

5.1. Step-by-Step Credit Generation Example

Consider InnovateTech AR, LLC, a medical research company based in Fort Smith, which qualifies as a Targeted Business and is in Year 1 of its 5-year incentive agreement.2 The company has no prior R&D claim history, and due to expansion costs, expects zero taxable income for the current year.

Financial Data (Tax Year 2024):

• Total Qualified Research Expenditures (QREs) in Arkansas: $\$300,000$.16
• Applicable Credit Rate for Targeted Business: 33%.6

Credit Calculation:

The Arkansas credit is calculated as 33% of the qualified expenses, assuming the expenses meet the federal R&D standards.7

$$\text{Credit Earned} = \$300,000 \times 0.33 = \$99,000$$

• Face Value of Certified Credit: $99,000.16

5.2. Scenario Analysis: The $\$99,000$ Credit Sale

InnovateTech has earned a $\$99,000$ credit but has no tax liability, making the credit a nine-year carryforward asset. Seeking immediate working capital, InnovateTech obtains approval from the AEDC for a one-time sale of the entire balance.1

The Transaction:

• A profitable Arkansas corporation, CorpX, Inc., agrees to purchase the credit at a market rate of 85 cents on the dollar (a 15% discount).
• Cash Purchase Price: $\$99,000 \times 0.85 = \$84,150$.

5.2.1. Financial Outcome for the Seller (InnovateTech AR)

InnovateTech receives $\$84,150$ in immediate cash capital. This provides vital non-dilutive funding, converting a passive, deferred tax asset into active funds necessary for operations, mitigating the business risk associated with early-stage losses. The seller has utilized its one-time sale opportunity.4

5.2.2. Financial Outcome for the Buyer (CorpX, Inc.)

CorpX has an estimated 2024 Arkansas income tax liability of $\$500,000$.

1. DFA Registration: CorpX registers the transfer with the DFA, submitting the certified credit and the assignment documents.13
2. Credit Valuation: The DFA applies the valuation rule: the recognized tax credit amount is the Lesser of the Face Value $(\$99,000)$ or the Purchase Price $(\$84,150)$.15
3. Credit Claimed: CorpX claims a tax payment of $84,150 against its state income tax liability.
4. Net Tax Due: CorpX’s final tax liability is reduced by $\$84,150$. Since CorpX paid $\$84,150$ in cash for the credit, its effective return on investment is $15\%$, secured immediately upon utilization of the credit.

Had CorpX not been able to use the full credit amount in 2024, the remaining balance would carry forward for use in subsequent years, but must be utilized before the end of the nine-year carryforward window, which began in 2024.4

5.3. Statistical Snapshot: Program Utilization Rates

The market for transferable tax credits in states like Arkansas thrives because the transferability mechanism efficiently matches tax-positive buyers with tax-negative R&D firms. The standard market discount for state transferable credits generally falls between 5% and 20% (or 80 to 95 cents on the dollar), making the 85% transaction price in the case study reflective of typical market conditions.17 The ability for buyers to use the credit to offset up to 100% of their annual income tax liability enhances the attractiveness of Arkansas credits compared to those in states with restrictive utilization caps.5

VI. Conclusion: Strategic Implications for Business Growth

The Arkansas R&D tax credit system provides a bifurcated structure designed to serve distinct economic goals. The restriction of sales to Targeted Businesses ensures that the most vulnerable, yet high-potential, innovative firms receive necessary liquidity, while mature firms are incentivized for long-term retention via non-transferable credits.

6.1. Summary of Benefits and Risks in Credit Monetization

6.2. Final Recommendations for Due Diligence

Corporate Tax Counsel and CFOs engaging with Arkansas R&D sellable credits must prioritize rigorous due diligence in three key areas:

1. Verification of Credit Integrity: Before finalizing a purchase, the buyer must confirm that the selling entity is definitively classified under a sellable category (Targeted Business or Strategic Value) and that the AEDC has granted explicit approval for the sale. The official Certificate of Tax Credit must be secured, as it is non-negotiable for filing purposes.5
2. Calculation of Remaining Economic Life: Because the buyer is limited to the original carryforward timeline, exhaustive analysis of the date the credit was first earned is essential. The economic value of the credit declines linearly as it approaches the end of its nine-year statutory life, and the discount applied to the face value must accurately reflect this temporal risk.4

DFA Compliance and Valuation: The buyer must ensure strict adherence to all DFA filing procedures, including the submission of the Certificate and all assignment documentation.13 Crucially, corporate tax teams must budget the recognized value of the credit using the “lesser of” rule.15 This limits the recognized tax reduction to the cash amount paid for the credit, providing clarity on the final tax benefit recognized by the state.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/