Analysis of the Mandatory “Divided Equally Over Four Years” Provision in the Colorado Enterprise Zone Research and Development Tax Credit (C.R.S. § 39-30-105.5)

I. Executive Summary: The Mandate of Four-Year Equal Division

The phrase “Divided Equally Over Four Years” mandates that the total calculated Colorado Enterprise Zone Research and Development (EZ R&D) Tax Credit (C.R.S. § 39-30-105.5) must be claimed in four equal, consecutive annual installments of 25% each. This mandatory four-year allowance establishes the maximum credit available to offset income tax liability in any given year, while any unused portion of that annual 25% installment is granted an indefinite carryforward until fully utilized.1

A. High-Level Overview of Mechanism and Dual Limitation

The Colorado EZ R&D Tax Credit is a state income tax incentive designed to encourage investment in research and development activities within specific geographical regions designated as Enterprise Zones (EZs).3 The credit is nonrefundable, meaning it can only offset tax liability and cannot generate a cash refund for the taxpayer.5 The structure of the credit imposes a critical dual constraint on its utilization.

First, the mandatory four-year Allowance Period requires the taxpayer to phase in the total calculated credit amount over four tax years, regardless of immediate profitability. In the year the qualifying expenditures are made (Year 0), only 25% of the total credit is activated and eligible for use. The remaining 75% is deferred into three subsequent 25% annual allowances (Years 1, 2, and 3).1

Second, the Utilization Period dictates how long the credit remains viable if it exceeds the tax liability in any given year. Crucially, C.R.S. § 39-30-105.5 stipulates that any unused credit amount that was allowed in a specific year can be carried forward indefinitely until it is fully applied against future tax liability.2 This long-term carryforward provision mitigates the risk associated with nonrefundable credits for businesses experiencing low profitability during the initial R&D phase. The legislature intentionally restricted the immediate availability of the economic benefit to manage state revenue distribution over time, effectively transforming one year’s R&D investment into four years of guaranteed minimum tax benefit allowance.

II. Statutory Foundation and Credit Calculation Methodology

The allocation requirement of the credit is inextricably linked to its statutory foundation and initial calculation methodology, which defines the total amount subject to the four-year division.

A. Legislative Authority and Scope

The authority for the EZ R&D credit is found in the Colorado Revised Statutes (C.R.S.), specifically § 39-30-105.5, which grants a credit against the income tax imposed by Article 22 of Title 39.1 This incentive is part of the broader Enterprise Zone Program, which aims to encourage economic development in designated areas characterized by economic distress, such as high unemployment rates, low per capita income, or slow population growth.3 The program is overseen by the Colorado Office of Economic Development & International Trade (OEDIT), with local EZ administrators managing certification.3

B. Definition and Qualification of Research Expenses (QREs)

To qualify for the state credit, the expenditures must align with the definitions provided in Section 174 of the Federal Internal Revenue Code, pertaining to research and experimental activities.2 These activities must be conducted within a designated Enterprise Zone for the purpose of carrying out a trade or business.2

Qualified Research Expenses (QREs) applicable under the Colorado credit include:

1. Wages paid to employees directly involved in the performance of R&D activities within Colorado.
2. Payments made to subcontractors involved in performing such R&D activities.4

Furthermore, the research itself must meet specific federal criteria, including resulting in new or improved products, services, processes, or software; eliminating technological uncertainty; being technological in nature; and including experimentation processes.4

C. Calculation of the Total Credit Amount

The Colorado EZ R&D Tax Credit is calculated using an incremental method, comparing current QREs within the EZ to a rolling average base. The total credit is determined before the four-year allocation is applied.

The calculation steps are as follows:

1. Base Determination: The base amount is calculated as the average Qualified Research Expenditures conducted within the same Enterprise Zone during the two immediately preceding tax years.5 This requirement necessitates meticulous geographic cost accounting, as QREs performed outside the designated EZ boundaries cannot be used to calculate the base or the current year expenses.
2. Excess Calculation: The taxpayer computes the amount by which the Current Year EZ QREs exceed the two-year average base.5 If the current QREs do not exceed the base, no credit is generated for the year.
3. Credit Rate Application: The total credit amount is equal to 3% of this positive excess amount.3

Once this total amount (100%) is calculated, it becomes the figure subject to the mandatory division over four years.

Table I illustrates the prerequisite calculation that yields the total credit figure:

Table I: Initial Colorado EZ R&D Tax Credit Calculation (Year 0)

III. The Mechanics of Allocation: The Four-Year Division Rule and Indefinite Carryforward

The “Divided Equally Over Four Years” rule is the core mechanism that controls the pacing of the tax benefit. Its correct interpretation requires distinguishing between the mandatory Allowance Period and the unlimited Utilization Period.

A. The Allowance Period: Mandatory Four-Year Claim Schedule

Colorado law dictates that the total calculated credit must be mandatorily apportioned into four equal blocks of 25%.1 This is the annual allowance cap related to a single year’s R&D expenditure.

The timing of these allowances is sequential:

1. Year 0: The first 25% of the total credit is allowed to be claimed in the tax year the expenditures were incurred.1
2. Subsequent Years: The remaining 75% is scheduled as three additional 25% increments allowed in each of the subsequent three tax years (Years 1, 2, and 3).1

This structure ensures that in any single tax year, the maximum claim derived from a specific year’s R&D activity is strictly capped at the 25% mandatory allowance.6 The rule functions purely as a deferral mechanism, ensuring the credit cannot be realized as a lump sum benefit, which assists the state in budgeting for the tax expenditure.

B. The Utilization Limit: Tax Liability Constraint

The allowed credit must be applied against the Colorado income tax liability after all prior credits have been claimed.8 Since the EZ R&D credit is nonrefundable, the amount utilized in any year cannot exceed the tax liability owed for that year.5 This limitation is what frequently triggers the carryforward provision, particularly for early-stage or rapidly expanding companies that may experience low taxable income during the years immediately following the R&D expenditure.

C. The Indefinite Carryforward Provision (C.R.S. Interpretation)

Understanding the indefinite carryforward provision is essential to accurate compliance and strategic tax planning, as it directly addresses the implications of the Utilization Limit.

1. Statutory Basis for Indefinite Carryforward

The relevant statute, C.R.S. § 39-30-105.5, specifies the treatment of unused credit amounts. It states that the amount by which the credit allowed in any one taxable year (i.e., the 25% installment) exceeds the amount deducted against the tax liability for that year “may be carried forward until the total amount of the credit is used”.2 This is reinforced by guidance from the Colorado Office of Economic Development & International Trade (OEDIT), which explicitly confirms there is “no limit on the number of years your business may carry forward this credit”.3

2. Reconciling the Four-Year Allowance vs. Utilization Period

A common misunderstanding in tax advisory circles is that the carryforward period is limited to four years.7 This interpretation conflates the allowance period with the utilization period.

The four-year requirement is solely focused on the scheduling of the allowance of the credit; it defines the period during which the four 25% tranches are activated. Once a 25% tranche is activated and becomes available for use, any portion that is not utilized due to insufficient tax liability is not lost after four years. Instead, the remainder transitions into an indefinite carryforward pool. This mechanism ensures that the economic benefit generated by the R&D expenditure does not expire due to temporary low profitability or financial distress. This long utilization horizon provides significant economic security and differentiates the Colorado EZ R&D credit from many federal and state R&D credits, which often impose strict usage limitations (e.g., 20-year sunsets). Tax planners must rely on the clear statutory language of C.R.S. § 39-30-105.5 2 and associated guidance from OEDIT 3 when projecting utilization.

D. Managing Concurrent Credits (Multi-Generational Tracking)

For a taxpayer conducting R&D activities every year, the allocation structure creates a complex system of concurrent credits. In any given tax year, a company may be claiming:

1. The current year’s R&D credit (the first 25% installment).
2. The second, third, and fourth 25% installments related to expenditures made in the three immediately preceding years.7
3. Indefinite carryforward amounts accumulated from unutilized portions of all previous annual allowances (tranches from the current year and all past years).2

Effective compliance requires meticulous tracking of each “vintage” of the credit to ensure the 25% annual allowance derived from that specific expenditure year is correctly calculated and that the cumulative indefinite carryforward balance is accurately maintained.

IV. State Regulatory Guidance and Mandatory Compliance Filings

The Colorado Department of Revenue (CDOR) and the Office of Economic Development & International Trade (OEDIT) impose mandatory administrative steps and specific forms to validate and track the four-year allocation and utilization.

A. OEDIT Pre-Certification Requirements

Prior to claiming the credit on an income tax return, taxpayers must satisfy a mandatory pre-certification process with the local Enterprise Zone administrator.5 This process involves completing an application via the OEDIT application portal or submitting specific forms.3 The requirement extends to pre-certifying each business location within an EZ.3

Upon successful review and certification, the local administrator issues a tax credit certificate. This certificate is a required document that must be submitted alongside the taxpayer’s Colorado income tax return to validate the EZ R&D credit claim.3

B. CDOR Reporting: The Crucial Role of Form DR 1366

The primary mechanism for verifying compliance with the “Divided Equally Over Four Years” rule and tracking the indefinite utilization period is the Colorado Department of Revenue Form DR 1366, the Enterprise Zone Credit and Carryforward Schedule.1 This form must be completed and submitted with the Colorado income tax return.3

The DR 1366 serves as the explicit audit trail for the EZ R&D credit. It mandates the detailed tracking of:

1. The original certified credit amount (100%).
2. The calculated 25% installment amount that is allowed for the current tax year.
3. The amount of unused credit applied from prior years’ indefinite carryforward pool.
4. The amount of current year credit used against liability.
5. The new running balance of the indefinite carryforward pool for all unutilized credits.6

The requirement to file the DR 1366 is paramount for compliance verification. The form’s structure enables the CDOR to ensure that the taxpayer adheres to the 25% mandatory cap on the annual allowance and accurately accounts for the accumulated carryforward amounts. Any deficiency in filing or errors in tracking the multi-generational carryforward balances documented on the DR 1366 could jeopardize the validity of future credit claims upon audit.

C. Compliance for Pass-Through Entities (PTEs)

For entities structured as S corporations, partnerships, or others treated as partnerships for tax purposes, an additional step is required to distribute the credit to the owners. These entities must file Colorado Department of Revenue Form DR 0078A, the Pass-Through Entity Enterprise Zone Credit Distribution Report.1

The PTE utilizes the DR 1366 to calculate the total available credit (including the current 25% allowance and all carryforwards). The allowed credit amount is then allocated pro-rata to the partners or shareholders via the DR 0078A.5 The individual owners subsequently use their own completed DR 1366 forms to claim their allocated share of the credit against their personal Colorado income tax liability.12

V. Detailed Case Study: Multi-Year Allocation and Carryforward Modeling

To illustrate the technical application of the mandatory four-year division and the resulting indefinite carryforward, the following case study models the compliance schedule for a hypothetical company.

A. Scenario Parameters and Initial Credit Determination (Year 0 Expenditure)

Assume EZ Innovate Corp. (EZIC) operates within a Colorado Enterprise Zone and completes its EZ R&D credit calculation for Year 0.

1. Initial Credit Calculation

The calculated credit is determined based on the 3% incremental increase rule:

2. Allocation Parameters

• Total Calculated Credit (100%): $6,000
• Mandatory Annual Allowance (25%): $\frac{\$6,000}{4} = \$1,500$.5
• Allowance Period: $1,500 allowed in Year 0, Year 1, Year 2, and Year 3.

B. Tracking Utilization, Tax Liability, and Indefinite Carryforward (Years 0-5)

The schedule below tracks how EZIC uses the $6,000 credit over six tax years, modeling scenarios where low tax liability in the early years triggers the indefinite carryforward provision (C/F Indefinite).

Colorado EZ R&D Credit Utilization and Indefinite Carryforward Schedule (C.R.S. § 39-30-105.5)

C. Interpretation of the Carryforward Model

The case study rigorously demonstrates the function of the dual constraint mechanism:

1. Mandatory Allowance (Years 0-3): The credit is phased in over four years, guaranteeing $1,500 is available annually for use.
2. Utilization and Carryforward (Years 0 and 1): In Year 0, EZIC’s $1,500 allowance exceeded its $1,000 liability. The unused $500 immediately entered the indefinite carryforward pool. In Year 1, the second $1,500 allowance was activated, providing a total available credit of $2,000 (the new allowance plus the $500 carryforward). Because liability was only $500, the remaining $1,500 was added to the indefinite carryforward pool.2 This prevents the loss of the benefit due to low or negative taxable income in the initial R&D period.
3. Consumption (Years 2 and 3): As EZIC’s profitability increased, so did its tax liability. In Year 3, the final 25% allowance ($1,500) was activated. Combined with the remaining indefinite carryforward ($1,000), the company had $2,500 available. Because the liability was high, the entire remaining credit was utilized, fully exhausting the original $6,000 credit amount.

The critical long-term planning implication of this structure is evident: although the expenditure occurred in Year 0, the final utilization of the benefit did not conclude until Year 3. If EZIC’s profitability had remained low, the remaining $2,500 in Year 3 would simply have remained in the indefinite carryforward pool, available to offset tax liability in Year 4, Year 5, or any future year until fully consumed. The credit’s utility is therefore tied to the eventual profitability of the taxpayer, not a fixed statutory sunset.

VI. Conclusion and Strategic Compliance Recommendations

A. Summary of the Dual Constraint Model

The core meaning of “Divided Equally Over Four Years” in the context of the Colorado EZ R&D tax credit is the mandatory allocation schedule of the benefit, establishing the four-year Allowance Period.1 This rule operates solely as a pacing mechanism, preventing the full credit from being claimed in a single tax year. This limitation is strategically paired with the indefinite Utilization Period.2 This combination ensures that while the economic benefit cannot be taken immediately as a lump sum, its value is protected over the long term, regardless of the taxpayer’s annual income tax liability.

The system is designed to provide sustained, long-term tax relief to R&D intensive firms located in Colorado Enterprise Zones, securing the benefit even if initial R&D activities result in losses or minimal tax obligations.

B. Compliance Mandates and Strategic Recommendations

Tax directors and controllers managing the Colorado EZ R&D credit must adhere to rigorous administrative and accounting procedures to maximize utility and ensure compliance:

1. Strict Adherence to the 25% Allowance: Taxpayers must never attempt to claim more than the 25% installment amount (plus any accumulated carryforward) related to any specific year’s expenditure within its four-year allowance window.5
2. Meticulous Documentation and Tracking (DR 1366): Meticulous documentation, particularly the accurate completion and submission of Form DR 1366, is non-negotiable.1 This form is the state’s mechanism for auditing the simultaneous utilization and indefinite carryforward of multiple 25% tranches from different tax years. The failure to correctly identify and track these specific amounts could lead to the denial of carryforward claims upon audit.
3. Long-Term Financial Forecasting: Companies should incorporate the mandatory four-year allowance schedule and the indefinite utilization provision into their long-term financial forecasts. Unlike many federal credits, the Colorado R&D credit requires sustained compliance visibility and carryforward tracking visibility far beyond the four-year allowance period, potentially spanning the entire indefinite utilization lifecycle. This requires a dedicated and accurate system for managing the indefinite carryforward balance.
4. Verification of Statutory Carryforward: When seeking professional advice, the taxpayer must confirm that the utilization period is indefinite, citing C.R.S. § 39-30-105.5.2 Any advice suggesting a four-year carryforward limit risks prematurely writing off valuable, unused credit balances.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/