Expert Report on the Colorado R&D Tax Credit: Calculating the “Increase in Expenditures”

I. Executive Summary: The Incremental R&D Tax Credit Mechanism

The “Increase in Expenditures” represents the foundational metric for the Colorado Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit. It is the positive margin by which a company’s current-year Qualified Research Expenditures (QREs) within an Enterprise Zone exceed its calculated average QREs from the preceding two tax years.

The resulting state income tax credit is equal to 3% of this increase in expenditures.1 This methodology establishes the credit as an incremental incentive, specifically designed to reward businesses for sustained growth in local R&D investment within economically distressed areas of the state. It is administered through a unique, dual compliance framework involving the Colorado Department of Revenue (CDOR) and the Office of Economic Development and International Trade (OEDIT).2

II. Statutory Context, Eligibility, and the Enterprise Zone Mandate

The Colorado R&D tax credit is not a broad, statewide incentive; rather, it is strategically tied to the state’s economic development goals via the Enterprise Zone (EZ) Program.

2.1. Legislative Mandate and Rate Structure (C.R.S. § 39-30-105.5)

The statutory foundation for this credit resides in the Colorado Revised Statutes, specifically $\S$ 39-30-105.5.3 This legislation outlines a clear, fixed rate and calculation methodology. Taxpayers involved in research and experimental expenditures may earn a 3% tax credit on the increase in such expenditures compared to a historical base amount.1

The credit is available to most corporate forms, including C-Corporations, S-Corporations, LLCs, and Partnerships, though sole proprietorships are generally ineligible.1 Furthermore, the underlying research expenses (QREs) must satisfy the federal four-part test as defined in Internal Revenue Code Section 41.5 The state’s reliance on the federal definition for qualified expenditures ensures consistency regarding what research activities are eligible. Consequently, state compliance inherently requires a robust defense of the federal QRE determination; if the activity fails the federal standard, the state credit automatically fails, regardless of the incremental calculation result.

2.2. The Enterprise Zone (EZ) Requirement

The credit’s availability is strictly limited to R&D activities conducted within specific, designated Enterprise Zones, which are established to boost economic activity in areas characterized by high unemployment, low per capita income, or slow population growth.2

The geographical restriction requires stringent cost segregation. Taxpayers must be able to identify and separate QREs spent exclusively within the EZ from any QREs incurred outside the EZ boundary.1 This precise allocation ensures the incentive remains focused on the state’s regional development objectives. The Office of Economic Development and International Trade (OEDIT) oversees the EZ program and maintains maps to help businesses verify their location.2

2.3. The Criticality of Annual Pre-Certification

Successful claiming of the credit is predicated on administrative compliance managed by OEDIT and the local EZ Administrator. The requirement for annual pre-certification serves as a fundamental administrative gatekeeper.4

Taxpayers must apply for pre-certification through the OEDIT application portal before the R&D activities commence for that tax year.2 This prerequisite prevents retrospective claims and ensures the state can track the business intent to leverage the incentive for economic growth within the EZ. Once the R&D activities are completed and certified, the local EZ Administrator issues an EZ Tax Credit Certificate. This certificate must be included with the Colorado income tax return and formally replaces prior CDOR certification forms, such as DR0074, DR0076, and DR0077.1 Failure to secure this initial administrative authorization, regardless of the calculation accuracy, will invalidate the claim.

III. Detailed Analysis of “Increase in Expenditures”

The “Increase in Expenditures” is calculated using a regular incremental method where current QREs are benchmarked against a rolling historical average. This methodology is formally codified in CDOR guidance and required forms.

3.1. Defining the Core Calculation Components

The computation follows three main steps to arrive at the excss expenditure amount 1:

1. Current QREs: The total Qualified Research Expenditures incurred within the Enterprise Zone during the current tax year.
2. Base Amount: The average QREs derived from the two immediately preceding tax years.
3. Increase in Expenditures (Excess): The amount by which the Current QREs surpass the Base Amount (the result must be a positive value).

The total tax credit generated is then 3% of this calculated excess.4

3.2. Calculating the Base Amount (CDOR Guidance and DR 1366)

The definitive guidance for calculating the Base Amount is provided in the instructions for Colorado Department of Revenue (CDOR) Form DR 1366, the “Enterprise Zone Credit and Carryforward Schedule.” Specifically, Worksheet 3: Research and Experimental Activities Credit details the step-by-step process.6

The Base Amount uses a simple two-year average of prior EZ QREs:

1. The taxpayer inputs QREs from the first preceding year (Year -1) on Line B.
2. The taxpayer inputs QREs from the second preceding year (Year -2) on Line C.
3. Line D is the sum of Line B and Line C.
4. Line E, which represents the Base Amount, is calculated as 50% of the amount on Line D.6 This explicitly defines the two-year simple average mandated by the state.

The formula for the Base Amount is:

$$\text{Base Amount (Line E)} = \frac{\text{QREs}_\text{Year – 1} + \text{QREs}_\text{Year – 2}}{2}$$

The “Increase in Expenditures” is then calculated on Line F by subtracting the Base Amount (Line E) from the Current Year QREs (Line A).6

3.3. Treatment of Zero Expenditures

An essential piece of guidance addresses taxpayers initiating R&D or moving into an Enterprise Zone. If the business had zero research and experimental expenditures in one or both of the previous two tax years used to establish the Base Amount, the expenditure for the non-existent year(s) must be calculated using zero.2

This zero-base rule strongly favors companies that are new to the Enterprise Zone or significantly ramping up their activities. By starting with a zero or near-zero base, the initial years of R&D investment yield the highest possible “Increase in Expenditures,” resulting in substantial early credits. This structure confirms the incentive’s role as a strong subsidy for initiating new R&D operations within targeted EZs.

IV. Local State Revenue Office Guidance and Compliance Requirements

To claim the Enterprise Zone R&D credit, the taxpayer must harmonize administrative approval from OEDIT with the numerical compliance requirements of the Colorado Department of Revenue (CDOR).

4.1. Navigating CDOR Form DR 1366

Form DR 1366, “Enterprise Zone Credit and Carryforward Schedule,” is the mandatory mechanism for calculating the credit and managing its utilization.7

Worksheet 3 within DR 1366 guides the taxpayer from calculating the “Increase in Expenditures” (Line F) to determining the total credit generated (Line G, 3% of F). The schedule then manages the credit’s deferred usage, determining the mandatory current-year claimable amount (Line H, 25% of G) and tracking carryforward amounts.6 Taxpayers who receive a refund certificate from OEDIT must use Form DR 1370 instead of DR 1366, but in most cases, DR 1366 is required.7

For tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2012, CDOR requires that original or amended income tax returns claiming enterprise zone credits generally be filed electronically.8

4.2. Special Filing Considerations and Pass-Through Entities

Taxpayers claiming the credit must manage two parallel compliance tracks:

1. OEDIT Certification: Securing the approved EZ Tax Credit Certificate from the EZ Administrator.2
2. CDOR Filing: Submitting the calculated credit amounts using Form DR 1366 alongside the certificate with the annual Colorado income tax return.1

For pass-through entities, such as Partnerships and LLCs, the credit is calculated at the entity level but passed through to the owners. These entities are required to complete and submit CDOR Form DR0078a, which documents the distribution of the enterprise zone credits to the individual partners or members.2 This ensures proper allocation for use against the individual taxpayer’s income tax liability.

V. Credit Utilization and Carryforward Mechanics

The total credit generated by the “Increase in Expenditures” is a tax asset that is not immediately available in full. Colorado mandates a specific deferral and utilization schedule that affects long-term tax planning.

5.1. The Mandatory Four-Year Claim Period

The total credit calculated based on the “Increase in Expenditures” must be divided equally and claimed over four consecutive tax years.1

• Annual Allotment: The entity may claim 25% of the total credit generated in the year the expenditure was made, and 25% in each of the subsequent three tax years.1
• Maximum Claim: In any single tax year, the taxpayer may claim up to 25% of the current year’s generated credit plus any applicable carryover amount from a prior year, up to 25% of that original credit.1

This required four-year spread delays the full realization of the tax benefit. A company generating a large credit must budget for this delay, understanding that 75% of the calculated asset is deferred over the following three years. This structure is intended to encourage the longevity of the business presence within the Enterprise Zone.

5.2. Indefinite Carryforward of Unused Credit

If the total amount of claimable credit for any given year exceeds the taxpayer’s income tax liability, the excess amount that cannot be utilized in that year is not lost; it is carried forward.1

Crucially, the unused excess credit may be carried forward indefinitely until it is completely used.2 This indefinite carryforward provision is a significant mitigating factor against the annual claim limitation and is vital for businesses, especially startups, that often incur losses during initial R&D phases. It ensures that the tax asset generated during those unprofitable years is preserved and available to offset future tax liability once the company achieves profitability, thereby safeguarding the long-term value of the incentive.

VI. Practical Example: Multi-Year Calculation and Credit Generation

The following example demonstrates the impact of the incremental calculation methodology, specifically the calculation of the “Increase in Expenditures” (Line F) and the management of the resulting credit through the four-year claim schedule.

6.1. Alpha Corp EZ: Calculation of the Increase

Alpha Corp EZ, located in a Colorado Enterprise Zone, has the following QRE history:

6.2. Calculation of Base and Total Credit Generated

This calculation table follows the methodology of DR 1366 Worksheet 3:

Alpha Corp EZ: DR 1366 Calculation Summary

Analysis of the Increase: In Year 1, the Base Amount is zero, maximizing the “Increase in Expenditures” to the full $500,000 of QREs. By Year 3, although the QREs have reached their highest level ($850,000), the Base Amount has also grown significantly to $600,000, resulting in a smaller “Increase in Expenditures” ($250,000) and a corresponding reduction in the total credit generated for that year. This illustrates how continuous QRE growth must outpace the two-year average to maintain credit generation.

6.3. Multi-Year Credit Utilization and Tracking

Assuming Alpha Corp EZ has an annual state income tax liability of $2,000, the following schedule shows the management of the credit over a six-year period, demonstrating the 25% claim limit and the use of the indefinite carryforward.

Annual Credit Utilization Schedule

Interpretation: The table reveals that even though the total claimable credit rapidly escalates in Years 2 through 4, the utilization is limited by the low $2,000 tax liability. This unused mandatory claimable portion is pooled into the indefinite carryforward, which accumulates to $24,250 by the end of Year 6. The strategic advantage here is that the tax asset is protected, ready to offset any significantly larger tax liabilities in profitable future years, demonstrating the long-term utility of the credit.

VII. Conclusion: Compliance Checklist and Strategic Implications

The Colorado Enterprise Zone R&D tax credit is an effective incentive for driving regional economic growth, but it places a significant burden on the taxpayer to master the dual compliance requirements and the incremental calculation methodology.

Strategic Implications for Tax Planning

The incremental nature of the “Increase in Expenditures” calculation fundamentally mandates sustained growth in QREs to generate continuous credits. The zero-base rule, coupled with the indefinite carryforward provision, creates a highly advantageous scenario for new EZ entrants, ensuring that initial research investment is immediately incentivized and that the resulting credit asset is never lost due to low initial tax liability. Taxpayers must proactively incorporate the required four-year utilization schedule into their financial forecasts, recognizing that the primary benefit of the credit may be realized years after the research investment is made. This structured benefit confirms the credit’s role as a long-term strategic asset that rewards sustained commitment to the EZ.

Comprehensive Compliance Checklist

For optimal compliance and realization of the R&D tax credit benefit, taxpayers must ensure adherence to the following steps:

1. Locational Verification: Verify that 100% of the QREs used in the calculation were performed within a designated Colorado Enterprise Zone.
2. Federal Documentation: Maintain detailed documentation proving that all claimed QREs meet the four-part test under federal IRC $\S$ 41.
3. Annual OEDIT Pre-Certification: Secure the mandatory annual pre-certification from the local EZ Administrator via the OEDIT portal prior to conducting the R&D activities for that tax year.
4. Base Calculation Accuracy: Calculate the Base Amount using the specific two-year rolling average methodology outlined on CDOR Form DR 1366, Worksheet 3.
5. Form Submission: File the completed CDOR Form DR 1366, the EZ Tax Credit Certificate from OEDIT, and, if applicable, Form DR0078a (for pass-through entities) with the Colorado income tax return.

Carryforward Tracking: Establish robust internal accounting systems to meticulously track the 25% claimable portion and the indefinite carryforward of each separate generated credit over the subsequent tax years.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/