Analysis of Pass-Through Entity Taxation and the Colorado Enterprise Zone R&D Tax Credit

A Pass-Through Entity (PTE) is a legal business structure that avoids corporate double taxation by passing its profits, losses, deductions, and credits directly to its owners. These owners then report the resulting business activity on their individual state income tax returns, where the income is taxed at their personal marginal rate.1

This structure contrasts sharply with C-corporations, which are subject to taxation at the entity level (the first tax) and then again when profits are distributed to shareholders as dividends (the second tax).1 For tax administration purposes, Colorado explicitly recognizes S-corporations, limited liability companies (LLCs), and partnerships as eligible PTE structures that may generate and distribute the state’s Research and Development (R&D) tax credit.3

II. Foundational Analysis of the Pass-Through Entity Structure and State Conformity

A. Definition and Federal Context of Flow-Through Taxation

The defining characteristic of a pass-through entity is its structural separation from the corporate income tax system. In the United States, PTEs—which include partnerships, sole proprietorships, S-corporations, and most LLCs—account for the vast majority of private business establishments and a significant portion of business income and private-sector employment.2

The mechanics of flow-through taxation dictate that the entity itself does not remit federal or (in most cases) state corporate income tax. Instead, the business calculates its net income, and each owner includes their proportionate share of that income, whether distributed or retained, on their personal income tax return (typically reported via Schedule K-1).2 S-corporations specifically utilize this mechanism to “pass corporate income, losses, deductions, and credits through to their shareholders for federal tax purposes,” thereby enabling the entity to escape double taxation on corporate income.1 This framework is foundational to understanding the utilization of the Colorado R&D tax credit, which is generated at the entity level but ultimately consumed by the individual owners.

B. Colorado Tax Treatment of PTEs and the Elective PTE Tax Nuance

Colorado largely conforms to the federal framework for PTE taxation. However, recent state tax legislation introduced a critical complexity involving the elective Pass-Through Entity (PTE) tax. This elective tax regime was created in response to the 2017 federal Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), which capped the federal deduction for State and Local Taxes (SALT) at $10,000 for individual taxpayers.4

To circumvent this federal limitation, Colorado permits partnerships and S-corporations to annually elect to pay state income tax on behalf of their owners at the entity level.4 The tax rate imposed at the entity level aligns with Colorado’s corporate income tax rate (e.g., 4.50% in 2021).4

This optional entity-level payment structure introduces complexities when dealing with nonrefundable tax credits like the Enterprise Zone (EZ) R&D credit. When a PTE elects into this regime, the owners are typically provided with a corresponding state income tax credit on their individual return for their share of the entity-level tax paid. Colorado’s legislation replaced an earlier income exclusion for owners with a refundable tax credit for each electing owner’s distributive share of the state tax imposed on the electing PTE.4

In contrast, the R&D credit is explicitly nonrefundable.3 Because the R&D credit is generated by the PTE but fundamentally designed to offset the individual owner’s liability, the mandatory allocation mechanism (via Form DR 0078A) remains the primary method of monetization. Consequently, when an individual owner utilizes the allocated R&D credit, they must carefully sequence the application of credits on their personal return. Nonrefundable credits, such as the EZ R&D credit, must generally be used first to offset tax liability before applying any refundable credits, such as the one generated by the elective PTE tax. This proper sequencing is paramount for maximizing the economic benefit of the nonrefundable R&D incentive, ensuring it is utilized before it is potentially rendered moot by a refundable credit that would have offset the liability regardless.

III. Statutory and Calculation Framework for the Colorado R&D Tax Credit (CRS § 39-30-105.5)

The Colorado Research and Development Tax Credit is a nonrefundable incentive designed to encourage innovation by providing an offset against state income tax for qualified research activities.3 The credit is highly specific and governed by strict location and calculation rules.

A. Enterprise Zone (EZ) Requirement and Eligibility

The most distinguishing factor of the Colorado R&D tax credit is the mandatory linkage to designated Enterprise Zones (EZs). The credit is available only for qualified research conducted exclusively within these economically distressed zones.3 Businesses must be located within a designated EZ to qualify.6

To ensure compliance with the EZ regulations, taxpayers must annually pre-certify their activities with their local EZ Administrator.3 Failure to complete this mandatory pre-certification step before commencing the claim process will void the eligibility for the credit for that tax year. Furthermore, the statute imposes significant geographical continuity requirements: a business must be established in the same enterprise zone for three years to claim this specific credit. If the company moves to a different Enterprise Zone, the three-year window restarts, effectively delaying any future credit claims.6 This imposes a critical risk management factor for growing PTEs that may experience high mobility.

B. Defining and Calculating Qualified Research Expenditures (QREs)

Colorado aligns its definition of Qualified Research Expenditures (QREs) with the federal standard found in Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 41.3 QREs must relate to research that is technological in nature and useful for developing a new or improved product or process.6

Eligible categories of QREs within the Enterprise Zone include 3:

1. Wages: Salaries for employees directly performing, supervising, or supporting qualified research activities.
2. Supplies: Costs of materials and prototypes consumed during the research process.
3. Contract Research: Payments made to third parties for qualified research services, provided that this third-party research is also performed within an Enterprise Zone.3

The state specifically excludes several common research costs, such as land or improvements to land, depreciable equipment, management surveys, costs related to adapting a product for a specific customer’s needs, and any research funded by a government entity.6 The mandatory geographic limitation means that any QREs performed outside the designated Enterprise Zone are ineligible for the state credit, requiring the PTE to maintain sophisticated internal cost accounting systems to accurately segregate eligible expenditures.

C. The Incremental Calculation Methodology

Colorado employs an incremental method to calculate the credit amount. The credit equals 3% of the increase in current-year QREs over a statutorily defined average.3

The calculation proceeds as follows:

1. Determine Current Year QREs: Identify all QREs conducted within the Enterprise Zone during the current tax year.
2. Calculate the Base Amount: The base is defined as the average of the QREs incurred in the two preceding tax years from the same Enterprise Zone.3 If the entity has no QREs in the preceding two years, the base amount is zero.3
3. Compute the Excess: Subtract the Base Amount from the Current Year QREs. This must result in a positive value to generate a credit.
4. Apply Credit Rate: The total credit generated is 3% of the positive excess amount.5

This methodology encourages continuous investment by rewarding taxpayers whose current research spending exceeds their historical average.

IV. The Pass-Through Mechanism for R&D Tax Credits and Critical Limitations

For PTEs, the R&D credit is an asset generated at the entity level but is utilized exclusively by the owners. This flow is managed by strict state rules governing annual installments and carryforwards.

A. Mandatory Allocation and Pro-Rata Distribution

S-corporations, partnerships, and LLCs (when taxed as one of the former) are eligible to earn the credit. However, due to their flow-through nature, they cannot typically utilize the credit internally (unless they elect the PTE tax and have a state income tax liability against which the credit can be claimed, although the primary mechanism is distribution).3

Instead, the total credit amount calculated by the entity is passed through to the owners or shareholders in proportion to their ownership interest or distributive share.3 This allocation is documented primarily through the filing of Form DR 0078A and then reported to the individual owners on their Colorado Schedule K-1 (Form DR 0106K).3

B. The Statutory 25% Annual Installment Rule

A critical limitation imposed by Colorado statute dictates that the total credit generated in a given year cannot be utilized immediately. Instead, the total calculated credit must be claimed in equal installments over four tax years.3

Specifically, the taxpayer may claim no more than 25% of the total credit generated in the year the expenditure occurred, and 25% in each of the subsequent three tax years.3 This 25% annual installment rule is a mandatory deferral mechanism built into the statutory definition of the credit. It operates as a restriction on the amount of the credit that becomes available each year, separate and distinct from the owner’s actual tax liability. For a PTE, this necessitates tracking the installment schedule over four years before the entire calculated credit is deemed fully distributed or available for utilization by the owners.

C. The Indefinite Carryforward Provision

While the credit generation is mandatorily spread over four years, the utilization of the available annual installment is subject to the owner’s individual tax liability. The R&D credit is nonrefundable; therefore, it can only reduce Colorado income tax liability down to zero.3

If the portion of the credit available for a given year (the 25% installment plus any carryover from prior years) exceeds the individual owner’s tax liability for that year, the unused excess amount may be carried forward and claimed in subsequent tax years until it is fully utilized.5 There is no statutory limit on the number of years this excess credit can be carried forward, often referred to as an “indefinite carryforward”.3

The interaction of these two limits creates a bifurcated constraint:

1. Generation Constraint: The entity spreads the total credit over four years (25% annual installment).3
2. Utilization Constraint: The individual owner carries forward the unused portion of the annual installment indefinitely.3

This requires meticulous tracking by the PTE owner for decades, if necessary, to ensure the full value of the credit is realized. The initial mandatory deferral over four years fundamentally affects the Net Present Value of the incentive, requiring sophisticated financial planning for optimal utilization.

V. Colorado Department of Revenue (DOR) Compliance and Filing Guidance

The process for claiming and distributing the Colorado EZ R&D credit for a pass-through entity is complex, requiring multiple specialized forms handled by both the entity and the ultimate taxpayer (the owner).

A. Mandatory Forms for Claiming and Distribution

The Colorado Department of Revenue (DOR) and the Office of Economic Development and International Trade (OEDIT) govern the necessary compliance steps.

Table Title: Colorado DOR Compliance Forms for PTE R&D Credit

The first step in the formal process is the entity obtaining pre-certification from the local EZ Administrator.3 Once the research activities are certified, the calculation of the credit itself is finalized using the EZ Tax Credit Certificates, currently documented through Form DR 1366.6

B. The Central Role of Form DR 0078A

Form DR 0078A, the Pass-Through Entity Enterprise Zone Credit Distribution Report, is the central mechanism by which the R&D credit moves from the entity to the owner.9 Partnerships are specifically required to complete and submit the DR 0078A along with Form DR 1366 and the income tax return.6

The DR 0078A serves a distinct purpose: it lists the exact dollar amount of the credit installment being passed through to each partner or investor based on their ownership percentage.9 This formal distribution report provides the necessary documentation for each owner to subsequently claim their share of the credit on their personal state income tax filing. The annual filing of the DR 0078A for the four mandatory installment years is crucial; failure to file this report for a given year would compromise the partners’ ability to claim that specific annual installment.

C. Guidance for Composite Tax Filings

In cases where a PTE includes nonresident owners, Colorado permits the entity to file a composite nonresident return (Form DR 1370).8 This process allows the partnership or S-corporation to claim the included nonresident partners’ or shareholders’ shares of the R&D credit against the entity’s composite tax liability, subject to the standard limitations (the 25% installment rule).8

However, the R&D credit remains fundamentally an owner-level asset. If the allocated credit exceeds the tax liability generated by the composite return, any credit not applied toward that liability must still be allocated to the partners and shareholders using Form DR 0106K.8 This requirement ensures that any unused portion of the credit retains its indefinite carryforward benefit at the individual level, thereby maximizing the incentive’s long-term value despite the temporary use at the entity level for administrative convenience.

VI. Detailed Numerical Example and Multi-Year Allocation Analysis

This example illustrates the generation of the credit, the application of the mandatory 25% annual installment rule, the required allocation via the DR 0078A framework, and the subsequent individual partner utilization and carryforward tracking.

A. Scenario Setup: Research Innovators, LP (Partnership)

A Colorado Partnership, Research Innovators, LP, is located entirely within a certified Enterprise Zone. The partnership calculates its tax liability based on a calendar year.

• Ownership Structure: Partner X holds a 70% interest; Partner Y holds a 30% interest.
• Historical QREs (EZ only):

• 2022 QREs: $1,200,000
• 2023 QREs: $1,400,000

• Current Year QREs (2024): $2,000,000

B. Step 1: Credit Generation Calculation (2024)

The total credit is calculated based on the excess of current QREs over the preceding two-year average (Base Amount).

1. Calculate Base Amount: The average QREs from 2022 and 2023 is $(\$1,200,000 + \$1,400,000) / 2 = \$1,300,000$.
2. Calculate Excess QREs: The difference between 2024 QREs and the Base Amount is $\$2,000,000 – \$1,300,000 = \$700,000$.
3. Calculate Total Credit Generated: The credit rate of 3% is applied to the excess QREs: $\$700,000 \times 3\% = \$21,000$.

The PTE generated a total R&D credit of $21,000 in 2024.

C. Step 2: Entity-Level Installment Schedule (DR 1366)

The total credit of $21,000 must be claimed in four equal, annual installments.

• Annual Installment (25%): $\$21,000 / 4 = \$5,250$.

Table Title: Entity-Level Credit Generation and Installment Schedule ($21,000 Credit)

D. Step 3: Distribution to Owners (DR 0078A and K-1)

The PTE must annually allocate only the claimable installment amount. For 2024, the available amount of $5,250 is distributed pro-rata according to the partnership agreement (70%/30%). This allocation is formally documented by filing the DR 0078A and is subsequently reported on the partners’ individual Schedule K-1 (DR 0106K).

Table Title: 2024 Credit Allocation via DR 0078A

E. Step 4: Multi-Year Owner Utilization and Carryforward Tracking

The final stage involves the partners applying their allocated credit against their individual Colorado income tax liability, triggering the indefinite carryforward rule if utilization is incomplete.

2024 Utilization Analysis:

• Assume Partner X’s 2024 CO Tax Liability: $2,000
• Assume Partner Y’s 2024 CO Tax Liability: $3,000

2025 Utilization Analysis (Year 2 Installment):

In 2025, the PTE allocates another $5,250 (the Year 2 installment). Partner X receives an additional $3,675, which is added to their prior carryforward.

• Partner X Available Credit in 2025:

• Prior Carryforward: $1,675
• 2025 Installment Allocation: $3,675
• Total Available: $5,350

If Partner X’s 2025 tax liability is, for example, $4,500, they would use $4,500 of the total available credit of $5,350. The unused balance of $850 would then be carried forward indefinitely into 2026, alongside the third annual installment. This dynamic tracking illustrates the significant administrative burden placed on PTE owners to manage a long-term, nonrefundable, and sequentially restricted state tax asset.

VII. Conclusion and Strategic Compliance Recommendations

The Colorado Enterprise Zone R&D Tax Credit represents a valuable, long-term incentive for PTEs engaged in research activities within designated geographic areas. However, its benefit is deeply intertwined with complex statutory limitations concerning allocation and timing, necessitating precise compliance protocols typically managed by specialized SALT professionals.

A. Strategic Compliance and Documentation

To maximize the realization of the credit’s value, PTEs must implement rigorous compliance measures:

1. Mandatory Pre-Certification: The annual pre-certification with the local Enterprise Zone Administrator is a necessary compliance gatekeeper. Failure to complete this step prior to the tax year forfeits the ability to claim the credit, irrespective of the scale or quality of the QREs performed.3
2. Four-Year Distribution Management: The PTE must maintain detailed internal records tracking the $21,000 credit over its mandatory four-year installment period. Compliance requires the timely and accurate filing of the DR 0078A annually to legally transfer the claimable installment ($5,250 per year in the example) to the owners.
3. Indefinite Carryforward Record Retention: Given the indefinite carryforward allowance for unused credits at the individual level, both the entity and the partners must preserve all documentation (QRE calculations, EZ location validation, and subsequent DR 0078A and DR 0106K filings) for as long as any partner maintains an unused carryforward balance. While the standard audit retention period may be four years 3, the indefinite carryforward extends the practical need for robust documentation far into the future.

B. Maximizing PTE Owner Benefit

PTE owners must adopt strategic approaches to fully monetize the allocated credit:

1. Prioritizing Nonrefundable Credit Usage: Owners receiving the nonrefundable R&D credit must sequence its application against their Colorado income tax liability before applying any refundable credits, such as the refundable credit generated by the elective PTE tax.4 This strategy ensures that the nonrefundable R&D credit, which would otherwise be lost if tax liability drops to zero, is fully utilized.
2. Managing Geographic Stability: The statutory penalty for moving to a different Enterprise Zone—the complete reset of the three-year waiting period—significantly affects the realization timeline of this incentive.6 PTEs must carefully weigh the tax cost of relocation against the business benefit, as shifting locations can suspend the ability to generate new credits for an extended period.

In summary, the Colorado R&D credit structure converts a calculated business expense increase into a deferred, nonrefundable, and geographically restricted tax asset that must be allocated proportionally to owners. Navigating the complexity of the 25% installment rule in conjunction with the indefinite carryforward requires continuous, highly technical oversight to avoid costly non-compliance or loss of tax benefit.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/