Detailed Analysis of Supplies Used in Qualified Research (EZ Specific) in the Context of the Colorado R&D Tax Credit

Supplies Used in Qualified Research (EZ Specific) are defined as tangible materials consumed directly during experimentation and research activities conducted exclusively within a designated Colorado Enterprise Zone, excluding all tangible property that is of a character subject to the allowance for depreciation.

This category of expense is a critical component of Qualified Research Expenses (QREs) for businesses seeking the Colorado Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit under the Enterprise Zone (EZ) Program, offering a 3% incremental benefit on increased R&D investment within economically distressed areas of the state.

I. Executive Summary: The Definition of Qualified Research Supplies in Colorado EZ

The Colorado Enterprise Zone R&D Tax Credit provides a substantial incentive for businesses engaging in innovation within specific geographic areas of the state.1 To qualify for this credit, expenditures must meet stringent federal definitions, particularly concerning supplies. The fundamental premise is that the cost must relate to consumable tangible property directly linked to research efforts.

A. Simple Meaning

Supplies Used in Qualified Research are tangible materials consumed directly during experimentation within a Colorado Enterprise Zone, excluding any items that qualify as depreciable property.

B. Detailed Analysis Overview and Strategic Importance

The Colorado EZ R&D credit, governed by C.R.S. § 39-22-502.7, operates by adopting federal tax definitions for qualified expenditures, specifically those permissible under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 174.2 This mechanism provides an incremental state income tax credit equal to 3% of the increase in annual R&D expenses compared to a two-year historical average.3

Supplies represent one of the three primary types of Qualified Research Expenses (QREs)—alongside wages and contract research expenses—and are often a large component of the cost of physical experimentation in manufacturing and technological development.5 For the expense to be considered a qualified supply, it must be tangible property that is used and consumed entirely during the process of experimentation.2 This requires a rigorous classification process to ensure the expense is correctly delineated from capital expenditures or depreciable property, which are strictly excluded.6

The strategic importance of accurately classifying QRE Supplies cannot be overstated, particularly in the Colorado EZ program. The state law explicitly ties the eligibility of research and experimental expenditures to those subject to the federal income tax treatment prescribed by IRC Section 174.2 This requirement establishes a direct relationship between federal compliance and state credit eligibility. Consequently, any failure at the federal level to correctly classify a costly material—for instance, mistakenly treating a long-lived, capitalizable asset as a consumable supply—immediately invalidates that expense for the state credit as well. Businesses must ensure that their internal accounting and tracking systems are designed from inception to delineate between materials that are consumed in R&D (Qualified Supplies) and those that are capitalized (Excluded Assets).

Furthermore, the structure of the Colorado credit, which allows for an indefinite carryforward of unused credits, significantly enhances the long-term financial viability of aggressively tracking and claiming legitimate QRE Supplies.3 Although the annual utilization is capped at 25% of the total credit earned 4, maximizing the initial Qualified Research Expense base now generates a credit that, while non-refundable, serves as a long-term asset that mitigates future state tax liabilities, providing substantial value against the inherent risk associated with the annual usage limitation.

II. The Legal Framework: Federal and State Integration of Supplies

The qualification criteria for supplies hinge entirely on federal tax law definitions, which Colorado adopts via its statutes. Understanding the precise limits of IRC Sections 41 and 174 is essential for compliance.

A. The Federal Tax Foundation: IRC Sections 41 and 174

The foundation of the Colorado EZ R&D credit rests on the federal framework for Qualified Research Expenses. Colorado’s statute requires that research and experimental (R&E) expenditures must qualify under IRC § 174.2 These expenditures must be incurred in connection with the taxpayer’s trade or business and must represent costs related to the experimental or laboratory sense of research and development.2

The expenditures generally include all costs incident to the development or improvement of a “product,” which may be a process, formula, pilot model, technique, or similar property.2 Critically, this definition explicitly includes “Expenditures for materials and supplies used and consumed” in the course of the experimentation.2 The nature of the activity—intended to discover information to eliminate uncertainty concerning the development or improvement of a product—determines eligibility, not the success or failure of the resulting product.2

For the supplies expenditure to qualify, the underlying R&D activity must meet the four criteria of the federal Qualified Research definition.5 These tests mandate that the research must be technological in nature, intended to be useful in the development of a new or improved business component, and must constitute elements of a process of experimentation (PoE).5 Adherence to these federal rules ensures that the scope of activities qualifying for the Colorado credit is precisely aligned with the limits established by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), including the mandatory exclusions for activities such as foreign research, research in social sciences or humanities, and research conducted after commercial production.7

B. Defining “Supplies” as a Qualified Research Expense (QRE)

The term “supplies” is defined restrictively under the federal statute adopted by Colorado. IRC Section 41(b)(2)(C) explicitly limits supplies to “any tangible property other than (i) land or improvements to land, and (ii) property of a character subject to the allowance for depreciation”.6

The necessary compliance concept for supplies is the consumption mandate. This requires documentation demonstrating that the tangible property was used up, destroyed, or entirely consumed during the research process.2 This usage must prevent the item from having a useful life that extends substantially beyond the current taxable year, thereby avoiding classification as depreciable property.6

The most critical distinction that taxpayers must manage is between QRE Supplies and Depreciable Property. Examples of items that are not considered supplies because they are intangible or capitalizable include equipment, machinery, research tools, overhead, rent paid for facilities, license fees, and costs for leasing assets.2 If a material is subject to depreciation under IRC Section 168 or is otherwise eligible for amortization and has a useful life of three years or more, it must be excluded from QRE supplies.2

Furthermore, several expenditures are excluded from the definition of qualified research regardless of their tangibility. This includes costs related to the ordinary testing or inspection of materials for quality control.2 Similarly, the credit is not allowed for expenditures related to the acquisition of another entity’s patent or process.2

The linkage of the Colorado EZ credit to IRC Sections 41 and 174 necessitates that Colorado EZ taxpayers adopt the rigorous federal record-keeping standards, particularly for consumption documentation. The primary risk exposure in an audit is the failure to maintain records that definitively prove the non-depreciability or consumption of materials claimed. If a taxpayer cannot document that a specific costly item was entirely consumed or otherwise used up (meaning it could not be capitalized), the expense associated with that item is generally invalidated, regardless of the research quality or location within an Enterprise Zone.

This federal integration also introduces complexity related to specific federal exclusions, such as the exclusion of “funded research”.7 If an Enterprise Zone project is subsidized, for instance, by a government grant—a scenario common for high-tech manufacturing or energy firms—QRE Supplies must be segregated and proportionally allocated based on the funding source. Supplies related to the portion of the research funded by an outside contract or grant cannot be claimed.7 This proportional allocation is necessary to ensure that the taxpayer is only claiming costs that they themselves paid or incurred.5

Table 1: Classification of Research Expenditures (Supplies vs. Exclusions)

III. The Colorado Enterprise Zone (EZ) Program Context and Credit Mechanics

While the definition of QRE Supplies is federal, the eligibility to claim the credit is entirely dependent on meeting Colorado’s specific procedural and geographic requirements related to the Enterprise Zone Program.

A. Enterprise Zone Eligibility and Pre-Certification Mandate

The Colorado R&D credit is exclusively available to businesses operating within one of the 16 designated Enterprise Zones.2 These zones are established in areas of the state characterized by high unemployment, low per capita income, or slow population growth, and the program is designed to encourage economic development there.3 Accordingly, all claimed R&D activities and associated expenses, including QRE Supplies, must be verifiable as having been incurred within the physical boundaries of a designated Enterprise Zone.8

A critical procedural hurdle unique to Colorado tax credits is the mandatory pre-certification process. State law requires that taxpayers complete pre-certification with the local EZ administrator before commencing the activity for which credits could be earned.4 This requirement distinguishes the Colorado credit from the federal R&D tax credit, which is typically claimed after the fact. The necessary certification forms are DR 0074, DR 0076, or DR 0077, which must be submitted to the EZ Administrator.4

The mandatory nature of the pre-certification process represents a significant administrative risk. If a business incurs substantial costs in QRE Supplies—materials that otherwise meet the federal consumption and non-depreciability requirements—but fails to obtain the necessary registration or approval from the EZ administrator beforehand, the entire expenditure base becomes ineligible for the state credit due to a procedural failure. Taxpayers must prioritize this step to ensure the validity of all subsequent QRE claims, including supplies, labor, and contract costs.

B. Mechanics of the Colorado EZ R&D Tax Credit (C.R.S. § 39-22-502.7)

The Colorado EZ R&D Tax Credit calculates the benefit based on an incremental method tied to zone-specific QREs.4

#### The Calculation Method

The credit is set at a rate of 3% of the increase in annual R&D expenses incurred within the Enterprise Zone.3

1. Base Amount Calculation: The baseline is calculated as the average of the total EZ QREs incurred during the two prior tax years (Y-1 and Y-2).4 If the business had no research or experimental expenditures in one or both of the previous two income tax years, zero must be used for those years when calculating the average base.3
2. Excess Calculation: The incremental increase, or “Excess Amount,” is the positive difference between the current year’s EZ QREs and the calculated Base Amount.4
3. Credit Generation: The total credit earned is 3% multiplied by this Excess Amount.4

#### Usage and Carryforward Rules

The utilization of the credit is subject to specific statutory limits and carryforward provisions.

• Annual Claim Limit: The total credit calculated for the current year must be divided equally and claimed over four consecutive tax years. In the year the expenditure was made, and in each of the following three years, the taxpayer may claim no more than 25% of the total credit earned.3
• Non-Refundability and Carryforward: The Colorado R&D credit is non-refundable.4 It can only be used to offset the taxpayer’s Colorado income tax liability. However, any portion of the annual claimable credit (25%) that exceeds the tax liability for that year, after other credits have been claimed, may be carried forward indefinitely until it is fully utilized.3 The indefinite carryforward provides long-term value and mitigates the risk associated with the 25% annual usage limit by guaranteeing future tax savings.

The interaction between the incremental calculation and the annual usage limit necessitates specialized financial forecasting. For a company in an Enterprise Zone, a sudden, large increase in QRE Supplies generates a substantial total credit, but only 25% of that credit can be deployed immediately. This means that businesses must strategically model large supply purchases to maximize the incremental gain over the base period while simultaneously projecting their state income tax liability across the next four or more years to ensure the eventual full utilization of the resulting credit.

IV. Colorado Department of Revenue (CDOR) Guidance and Compliance for Supplies

Effective compliance with the Colorado EZ R&D tax credit requires taxpayers to merge the strict federal documentation standards for supplies with Colorado’s required administrative filing process.

A. Documentation and Substantiation Requirements

The most common deficiency leading to audit adjustments in R&D credit claims, both federally and at the state level, is insufficient documentation.10 Colorado mandates rigorous adherence to federal substantiation requirements because the underlying definition of R&E expenditures is tied directly to IRC § 174.2

Taxpayers must maintain comprehensive records that unequivocally link every dollar of QRE Supplies to a qualified research activity that meets the federal four-part test (technological uncertainty, process of experimentation, etc.).10

#### Proving Consumption and Non-Depreciability

The paramount documentation challenge for QRE Supplies is proving that the item was consumed and was not depreciable.6 To satisfy the CDOR and federal audit standards, the following documentation should be proactively prepared:

1. Project Logs and Allocation Schedules: Records must be maintained that link the supply purchase invoice directly to specific R&D projects and demonstrate the stage of experimentation at which the materials were used.2
2. Inventory Variance Records and Consumption Studies: Taxpayers must be able to document the ultimate fate of the supply. This includes inventory write-off sheets, scrap reports, test logs, or destruction records that prove the material was consumed, destroyed, or rendered unusable during the experimentation. This documentation serves as crucial evidence preventing the item from being classified as a capital asset subject to depreciation.2
3. Cost Reasonableness Justification: Documentation must demonstrate that the claimed R&E expenditures for supplies were “reasonable under the circumstances,” a requirement imposed by the adoption of the IRC § 174 standard.2

Because the Colorado credit relies entirely on the federal definition, the compliance burden for QRE Supplies is effectively 100% federal. Small businesses operating within EZs, who may not face regular IRS audits, might overlook the requirement for detailed consumption logs, exposing them to significant audit risk upon review by the CDOR. Audit defense for high supply claims hinges not merely on providing invoices but on substantive evidence, such as dedicated consumption studies or engineering material usage reports, that prove the non-depreciability and consumption of the material during the EZ research.

This necessitates strong integration among various corporate functions—finance, engineering, and inventory management—to correctly classify and track the materials. The technical teams must provide input (e.g., specifying material usage, test failure reports) necessary to substantiate the financial documentation required by the tax department to defend the QRE Supplies claim.10

B. CDOR Administrative Forms and Process

The primary mechanism for claiming and tracking the Colorado EZ R&D credit is specific state forms issued by the Department of Revenue.

• Form DR 1366: The key compliance document is Form DR 1366, the “Enterprise Zone Credit and Carryforward Schedule”.11 Taxpayers utilize this form to calculate the current year’s incremental credit based on total EZ QREs (including QRE supplies).13 Additionally, DR 1366 is essential for tracking the mandated four-year allocation (the 25% annual claim limit) and managing any resulting indefinite carryforward from previous tax years.4
• Filing Requirements: For tax years starting on or after January 1, 2012, all original or amended income tax returns claiming an Enterprise Zone credit, which includes the R&D credit derived from QRE Supplies, must generally be filed electronically.12
• Guidance and Support: The CDOR publishes guidance, such as the Enterprise Zone Tax Guide, and directs taxpayers to consult OEDIT resources for specific program information.2 Taxpayers dealing with complex or borderline classifications of QRE Supplies, especially those near the depreciable threshold, are encouraged to consult their tax advisors or request a General Information Letter (GIL) or Private Letter Ruling (PLR) from the Department of Revenue to receive specific guidance.2

V. Case Study: Calculating the EZ R&D Credit Contribution from Supplies

To illustrate the financial impact of supplies on the Colorado EZ R&D credit, the following hypothetical case study applies the incremental calculation method.

A. Hypothetical Scenario Setup: R&D Supplies in a Manufacturing Pilot Program

TechCorp, Inc., a manufacturer, operates its R&D facility within the Colorado Springs Enterprise Zone. The company is developing an innovative, high-efficiency injection molding technique. In this process, specialized materials, including high-grade polymers and custom-machined steel molds, are subject to extreme stress testing, resulting in the molds and polymers being destroyed or rendered unusable after a single test cycle. These consumed materials qualify as QRE Supplies, meeting the non-depreciability test.2

The total QREs incurred within the Enterprise Zone over three years, including the QRE Supplies component, are detailed below.

B. Calculation Walkthrough (Based on C.R.S. § 39-22-502.7)

The calculation follows the incremental method prescribed by Colorado statute, focusing on the growth in total EZ QREs.

#### Step 1: Determine the Base Period Average QREs

The base is the average of the total EZ QREs from the two immediately preceding tax years, Y-1 and Y-2.4

$$\text{Base QRE} = \frac{(\$700,000 + \$800,000)}{2} = \$750,000$$

#### Step 2: Calculate the Incremental Increase (Excess Amount)

The incremental increase is the amount by which the current year’s QREs exceed the calculated base.4

$$\text{Excess Amount} = \$1,200,000 – \$750,000 = \$450,000$$

#### Step 3: Apply the 3% Credit Rate

The total tax credit earned is 3% of the Excess Amount.3

$$\text{Total Credit Earned} = 0.03 \times \$450,000 = \$13,500$$

#### Step 4: Annual Credit Allocation and Carryforward Schedule

The total credit earned ($\$13,500$) must be divided equally and claimed over four years, with a limit of 25% per year.3

$$\text{Annual Claimable Credit} = 0.25 \times \$13,500 = \$3,375$$

#### Observation on Supplies Contribution

In this scenario, the company’s total QREs increased by $\$400,000$ (from $\$800,000$ in Y-1 to $\$1,200,000$ in Year 3). The EZ QRE Supplies component increased by $\$250,000$ (from $\$200,000$ to $\$450,000$). The substantial growth in consumed supplies was the primary driver of the positive incremental calculation, resulting in the $\$13,500$ credit earned.

Businesses should recognize that because the EZ credit uses an incremental calculation based on the prior two-year average, R&D-intensive firms must strive to manage their QRE spending, especially for large supply purchases, to minimize base inflation. A sharp spike in QRE Supplies in the current year generates a large immediate credit, but it significantly raises the two-year average base for future calculations. If subsequent year spending normalizes or decreases, the inflated base may eliminate the incremental opportunity for generating new credits in those subsequent years, highlighting the need for strategic, multi-year QRE planning.

Table 2: Colorado EZ R&D Tax Credit Incremental Calculation Example (TechCorp, Inc.)

VI. Conclusion: Strategic Planning and Best Practices

The Colorado Enterprise Zone R&D Tax Credit offers valuable state tax savings, particularly through the inclusion of Qualified Research Supplies. However, securing and defending this credit requires strict adherence to both federal definitions and Colorado-specific procedural rules.

A. Key Takeaways for Compliance and Maximization

The definition of QRE Supplies is intrinsically linked to federal law through IRC Sections 41 and 174.2 Consequently, state compliance mandates that all materials claimed meet the stringent federal requirements, particularly the exclusion of depreciable property. This adherence dictates that the eligibility standards for the supplies component of the state credit are identical to the rigorous standards required by the federal R&D tax credit.

Furthermore, the single most significant procedural risk that can invalidate an otherwise legitimate QRE Supplies claim is the failure to satisfy the mandatory pre-certification requirement with the local Enterprise Zone administrator.4 This step must be prioritized over all financial calculations, as it is a gatekeeping requirement for the use of Form DR 1366.12

From a financial perspective, the credit’s structure provides substantial long-term value. The combination of its non-refundable nature and the statutory allowance for indefinite carryforward transforms the credit into a financial asset that hedges against future Colorado income tax liabilities.3 This characteristic requires businesses to model the value of the credit over an extended timeframe, accounting for potential volatility in their tax exposure years after the QRE Supplies were incurred.

B. Final Recommendations for Record-Keeping and Financial Modeling

Effective management of QRE Supplies claims requires a deliberate, proactive strategy integrated across technical and financial departments.

1. Integrated Tracking and Classification: Companies must implement internal accounting controls that systematically separate QRE Supplies from Capital Expenditures at the time of purchase. Inventory and engineering departments must communicate transparently with the tax function regarding the ultimate disposition of R&D materials, specifically documenting whether the material was consumed or capitalized.10
2. Consumption Documentation (The Audit Key): To defend against audit challenges regarding the non-depreciable nature of the supplies, taxpayers must proactively generate clear evidence of consumption. This documentation should move beyond simple purchase receipts and include detailed test protocols, engineering notes, scrap reports, and material write-off records that explicitly address the useful life and destruction of the tangible property used within the EZ research activity.2 Since the supplies must be “consumed” and not depreciable, the most effective audit defense strategy is the preparation of a consumption study or inventory variance analysis, which proactively proves the absence of residual value for materials purchased, satisfying the federal definition required by the state.
3. Geographic and Personnel Scrutiny: QRE Supplies claims must be subject to strict scrutiny to confirm that the material was utilized solely and exclusively in the designated Enterprise Zone.8 This necessitates accurate tracking of the physical location of the supplies and verification that they were used by R&D personnel performing qualified services within the zone boundaries.5

Financial Modeling for Optimization: Businesses should integrate the incremental base calculation, including QRE Supplies projections, into their annual budget and forecasting cycles. Modeling future QRE spending allows the company to optimize the incremental growth rate, ensuring the highest possible annual credit generation without creating an unnecessarily inflated base that hinders credit generation in subsequent years.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/