The Strategic Value of the Credit for Research and Development Expenses: An Analysis of the Delaware Tax Credit Program

The Credit for Research and Development Expenses is a dollar-for-dollar tax incentive rewarding business investment in technological innovation, aimed at increasing economic competitiveness. The Delaware R&D tax credit is a highly beneficial state complement to the federal program, offering a fully refundable benefit that turns unused tax liability into a direct cash refund for qualifying companies.1

This report provides a comprehensive analysis of the Delaware research and development (R&D) tax credit program, detailing its statutory foundations, calculation methodologies, and critical compliance requirements as administered by the Delaware Division of Revenue (DOR).

I. Foundations of the Research & Development Tax Credit

A. Definition of Credit for Research and Development Expenses

The R&D Tax Credit, established federally under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) $\S 41$, is an incentive mechanism designed to reward taxpayers for the incremental increase in expenditures related to qualified research activities. Delaware utilizes this robust federal structure to incentivize in-state innovation, positioning the state benefit as one of the most competitive refundable tax credits available nationally.1

The core economic function of the credit is to counteract the market failure typically associated with R&D underinvestment. By providing a direct subsidy for research expenses, the incentive encourages firms to undertake projects that might otherwise be considered too costly or risky due to the inability to capture all the benefits generated (i.e., spillover benefits often captured by competitors). The design of the credit focuses on the incremental increase in research spending over a defined base amount, thereby intentionally driving future investment and discouraging simple subsidization of existing activities.

B. The Federal Framework: Internal Revenue Code (IRC) $\S 41$

Since Delaware’s statutory framework requires direct conformity with federal definitions, understanding the federal guidelines outlined in IRC $\S 41$ is mandatory for determining eligibility for the state credit.2

1. Qualified Research Expenses (QREs)

Qualified Research Expenses (QREs) constitute the pool of eligible costs incurred by the taxpayer during the taxable year in carrying on any trade or business.4 These expenses fall into three primary categories:

• In-House Research Expenses: These include wages paid to employees who are either directly performing, supervising, or directly supporting qualified research activities. They also cover the cost of supplies used in the conduct of research, such as raw materials consumed in testing or prototyping, and amounts paid or incurred for the rental or lease of computers used in the research process.5
• Contract Research Expenses: Payments made to third-party individuals or firms (contractors) for conducting qualified research on the taxpayer’s behalf are eligible. These expenses are generally limited to 65% of the total cost paid to the third party.5
• Exclusions: The IRC specifically excludes certain activities, ensuring the credit is narrowly focused on domestic technological innovation. Exclusions include expenses related to research conducted outside the United States and costs incurred prior to commencing a new business (as distinguished from expanding an existing business).7

2. The Four-Part Test for Qualified Research

To ensure that expenditures qualify as research, the activities themselves must satisfy a rigorous four-part test defined in IRC $\S 41(\mathrm{~d})$.8 Because Delaware statute mandates the application of federal definitions (Del. Code $\S 2071$) 2, successful navigation of this test is necessary for state credit eligibility. The application of these tests requires meticulous documentation of technical objectives and processes.

Table 1: Federal R&D Eligibility: The Four-Part Test (IRC $\S 41$)

The state’s conformity to IRC $\S 41$ provides a crucial streamlining benefit for multinational or multi-state firms. The strict adherence to federal technical qualification standards means that any R&D activity conducted in Delaware that is determined eligible for the federal credit automatically satisfies the technical requirements for the Delaware credit.3 This alignment significantly reduces the administrative burden associated with navigating divergent state and federal technical standards, allowing companies to focus compliance efforts on a unified methodology.

II. The Delaware R&D Tax Credit: Statutory Basis and Scope

A. Governing Legislation: Title 30, Chapter 20, Subchapter VIII

The statutory basis for the Delaware R&D tax credit is found in the Delaware Code, Title 30 (State Taxes), Chapter 20 (Business Tax Credits and Deductions), Subchapter VIII (Credit for Research and Development Expenses), specifically encompassing sections $\S 2070$ through $\S 2073$.2

1. Application of Internal Revenue Code

Delaware Code $\S 2071$ is foundational, explicitly stating that “Any term used in this subchapter shall have the same meaning as when used in a comparable context in the Internal Revenue laws of the United States, unless a different meaning is clearly required”.2 This provision confirms the state’s reliance on federal definitions for concepts like “qualified research” and “qualified research expenses,” as previously discussed in the context of the Four-Part Test.

2. Mandate for Research Conducted in Delaware

A critical constraint for the Delaware credit is the requirement that all Qualified Research Expenses must strictly relate to research activities conducted physically within the State of Delaware.1 For taxpayers operating across multiple jurisdictions, only the portion of QREs demonstrably incurred within Delaware is eligible for the state incentive.

B. Unique Financial Advantage: Refundability and No Cap

The Delaware R&D credit distinguishes itself from many other state programs through two core financial benefits that provide substantial certainty for corporate financial planning.

1. Refundability of Unused Credits

The Delaware R&D tax credit is fully refundable.1 If the computed credit amount exceeds the taxpayer’s state tax liability (e.g., corporate income tax), the unused portion is not merely carried forward to future tax years; instead, it is paid directly to the taxpayer in the form of a cash refund.1 This feature is particularly valuable for innovative businesses, such as startups and life science companies, which often incur significant R&D expenses early in their lifecycle while generating minimal initial taxable income. The ability to monetize the credit immediately provides a crucial source of operational cash flow.

2. Removal of the Aggregate Credit Cap

Historically, the Delaware R&D credit was subject to an annual statutory cap on the total amount of credits that could be awarded statewide, such as the $5,000,000 cap that applied in certain past years.14 When total credit applications exceeded this cap, the available credits were prorated among all qualifying applicants, leading to financial uncertainty.

However, legislation enacted for tax years 2017 and beyond eliminated this aggregate cap.16 The current law ensures that the full, approved amount of the credit will be granted to all qualifying businesses.13 The combination of full refundability and the removal of the aggregate cap is a foundational strategic advantage in Delaware. It eliminates the dual risks of forfeiting credit value due to insufficient current liability and receiving a reduced credit due to high statewide participation. This predictability allows corporate leaders and financial teams to reliably project the R&D credit benefit as a certain source of cash flow for future R&D or operational funding.

III. Calculation Methodologies and Applicability

Taxpayers must make an annual election, independent of their federal election, to calculate their Delaware R&D credit using one of two distinct methodologies outlined in Del. Code $\S 2070(\mathrm{a})$.2

A. Determining Small Business Status and Enhanced Rates

Delaware offers significantly enhanced credit rates for taxpayers that meet the definition of a small business, which provides a major incentive for growing firms.3

1. Definition of Small Business

A taxpayer qualifies as a small business if its average annual gross receipts (determined under IRC $\S 41(\mathrm{c})(1)(\mathrm{B})$) do not exceed $20,000,000.2 Taxpayers making use of the small business alternative calculation must conform to this definition, regardless of the method used to calculate their federal credit.2

2. Enhanced Rates

Small businesses receive a substantially higher incentive rate, effectively doubling the credit benefit compared to standard taxpayers under both calculation methods.2

B. Calculation Method 1: The Incremental QREs Over Base Amount (The Traditional Method)

This method mirrors the federal traditional method by rewarding the increase in Delaware QREs above an established historical benchmark, known as the Delaware Base Amount.

• Standard Rate Calculation (Gross Receipts > $20M): The credit is equal to 10% of the excess of the taxpayer’s total Delaware Qualified R&D Expenses for the taxable year over the taxpayer’s Delaware base amount.2
• Small Business Rate Calculation (Gross Receipts $\le$ $20M): The rate is substituted to 20% of the excess of the taxpayer’s total Delaware Qualified R&D Expenses for the taxable year over the taxpayer’s Delaware base amount.2

The Delaware Base Amount is calculated using federal methodology, referencing historical QREs and gross receipts to determine the baseline level of research activity that is not eligible for the incremental credit.

C. Calculation Method 2: Apportioned Federal Alternative Simplified Credit (ASC)

The Alternative Simplified Credit (ASC) methodology under IRC $\S 41(\mathrm{c})(5)$ simplifies the complex calculations required for the traditional base amount. This method is often preferred by businesses with fluctuating R&D spending or those with limited historical data.3 Delaware leverages the federal ASC amount and applies an apportionment ratio to determine the state credit.

1. Apportionment Requirement

The state credit calculation starts with the federal ASC credit amount. This federal amount must then be apportioned to Delaware using a specific ratio: the taxpayer’s Delaware QREs divided by the taxpayer’s total (worldwide) QREs for the taxable year.2

2. Credit Rate Application

• Standard Rate Calculation (Gross Receipts > $20M): The credit is equal to 50% of Delaware’s apportioned share of the taxpayer’s federal ASC calculated under IRC $\S 41(\mathrm{c})(5)$.2
• Small Business Rate Calculation (Gross Receipts $\le$ $20M): The credit is equal to 100% of Delaware’s apportioned share of the taxpayer’s federal ASC.2

For standard businesses, the 50% limitation on the Apportioned ASC rate warrants careful evaluation against Method 1 (10% incremental rate).3 However, for small businesses, the availability of the 100% ASC rate is frequently the optimal choice.2 This is particularly true for high-growth firms or those with rapidly escalating QREs, as the ASC base (which is 50% of the average QREs from the prior three years) is generally lower than the complex fixed base used in Method 1, thus maximizing the incremental research activity eligible for the full 100% credit capture.3

Table 2 provides a comparison of the key calculation parameters:

Table 2: Comparison of Delaware R&D Tax Credit Calculation Methods

IV. Delaware Division of Revenue (DOR) Compliance and Filing Requirements

The administration and enforcement of the credit are managed by the Delaware Division of Revenue (DOR). Compliance requires specific applications, adherence to a strict annual deadline, and maintaining detailed documentation.

A. Administrative Authority and Forms

To claim the credit, eligible taxpayers must submit a formal application to the DOR.1 The required form for certification and computation is Form 2070AC, Application and Computation Schedule for Claiming Delaware Research and Development Tax Credit.15 This form is essential for verifying eligibility, performing the chosen calculation method, and determining the final refundable amount. The DOR issues official guidance, including rules, regulations, and Technical Information Memoranda (TIMs), which provide crucial interpretations and details concerning the Delaware Code provisions.18

B. Critical Filing Deadlines

Compliance with filing deadlines is mandatory for claiming the benefit. Qualified taxpayers must submit their application (Form 2070AC) to the Division of Revenue on or by September 15th after the end of the taxable year during which the qualified R&D expenses were made.1

This September 15th deadline is administrative and is often non-extendable. Since the credit application must be filed separately by this date, a failure to meet this requirement results in the forfeiture of the credit for that tax year, irrespective of whether the underlying R&D activity technically qualified. Tax planning teams must establish rigorous protocols to ensure calculation, substantiation, and filing are completed well in advance of this critical date.

C. Lookback Studies and Historic Claims

The R&D credit provides a significant opportunity for historical claims through lookback studies, as federal rules generally allow for claiming credits for the last three or four open tax years.22 Since Delaware’s credit is fully refundable, companies that have previously overlooked the state R&D benefit can realize substantial cash returns by conducting multi-year studies covering Delaware QREs.1 For instance, a small Delaware company utilizing a multi-year lookback covering 2019-2021 recognized over $114,000 in state R&D tax credits.1 This reinforces the importance of conducting comprehensive studies, although any late filing must adhere to the DOR’s specific rules regarding amended state tax returns and prior-year claims.

V. Detailed Example: Applying the Delaware R&D Credit

This example illustrates the comparative calculation process required for an annual election by a small business seeking to maximize its refundable benefit.

A. Scenario Setup: Innovate DE, LLC (Small Business)

Innovate DE, LLC is a Delaware-based advanced manufacturing firm. The firm’s average annual gross receipts over the last three years total $18,000,000, qualifying it as a Small Business and making it eligible for the enhanced rates (20% under Method 1, 100% under Method 2).2

Key Data Points for Tax Year 2024:

• Total (Federal) QREs: $1,500,000
• Delaware QREs (100% of Total): $1,500,000
• Hypothetical Federal ASC Calculated Credit: $150,000 (Calculated prior to apportionment)
• Delaware Base Amount (Calculated via historical fixed base rules): $800,000

B. Calculation 1: Method 1 (20% Incremental Base)

Method 1 applies the enhanced 20% rate to the amount of Delaware QREs that exceeds the established Delaware Base Amount.

C. Calculation 2: Method 2 (100% Apportioned ASC)

Method 2 starts with the federal ASC credit and applies the state apportionment ratio, followed by the enhanced 100% small business rate.

D. Comparative Analysis: Determining the Optimal Election

The taxpayer must elect the method that yields the greater benefit.

Table 3: Comparative Analysis of Optimal R&D Credit Election

In this scenario, Innovate DE, LLC would elect Method 2, securing a refundable credit of $150,000. This example highlights the necessity of performing dual calculations annually to ensure maximum credit capture, particularly given the favorable small business rates.

VI. Conclusion: Strategic Implications for Businesses in Delaware

The Delaware Credit for Research and Development Expenses offers a powerful, low-risk mechanism for innovative businesses to generate substantial working capital. The strategic advantages inherent in the program—full refundability and the absence of an aggregate cap—position Delaware as an optimal jurisdiction for businesses focused on technological growth and R&D investment.

A. Mandate for Multi-Jurisdictional Planning

For companies with operations extending beyond Delaware, rigorous tracking of QREs by location is a fundamental administrative necessity. Accurate documentation detailing the physical location of qualified research (wages, supplies, and contract work) is required to ensure that only QREs demonstrably incurred within Delaware are included in the state calculation. Failure to properly apportion costs undermines compliance and risks disqualification.

B. The Necessity of Annual Election Modeling

The material difference in outcome demonstrated by the two calculation methods, amplified by the enhanced rates for small businesses, necessitates annual strategic modeling. Tax planning teams must perform full computations under both Method 1 (Traditional Incremental Base) and Method 2 (Apportioned ASC) to ensure the taxpayer elects the optimal approach that maximizes the cash refund. Since the election is independent of the federal method, Delaware allows for customized optimization based on the prior three years of QRE history and the current year’s spending patterns.

C. Leveraging Federal Compliance for State Benefit

The requirement that R&D activities must first meet the rigorous federal four-part test under IRC $\S 41$ means that the compliance efforts expended for the federal credit are highly leveraged for the state credit. Delaware’s statutory alignment allows companies to efficiently utilize their extensive federal documentation—covering technological uncertainty, process of experimentation, and qualified expenses—to satisfy the technical requirements for the state credit. This synergy reinforces Delaware’s competitive position by offering a highly efficient path to realizing substantial, fully refundable state cash returns, supporting the state’s high industrial R&D intensity.23

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/