The Unused Credit Refund (Cash Payment): A Detailed Analysis of the Delaware R&D Tax Credit

Section I: Executive Summary: The Refundability Principle

The Unused Credit Refund, or Cash Payment, ensures that the Delaware Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit is fully utilized by businesses regardless of their current tax liability. If the approved R&D credit exceeds a business’s income tax obligation to the state, the unused portion is returned to the taxpayer as a direct cash payment.1 This unique mechanism guarantees immediate liquidity, transforming qualified research expenditures into direct working capital, particularly benefiting startups and non-profitable, R&D-intensive entities.2

Unlike many other states where tax credits are only non-refundable carryforwards, the Delaware statute provides a robust guarantee that the economic benefit derived from qualified research will be realized immediately. This feature is particularly valuable for growth-stage companies, such as those in the biotechnology or advanced manufacturing sectors, that often spend heavily on research long before generating taxable income.2 By providing a direct cash injection, the state transforms the tax incentive into a mechanism functionally similar to a non-dilutive government grant, tied directly to in-state R&D investment. This predictability and speed of return significantly enhance the state’s attractiveness to both companies and their investors.

Section II: Statutory Foundation: The Unused Credit Refund (Cash Payment) Mandate

The authority for the cash payment is directly mandated within the Delaware Code, eliminating any discretionary barrier to receiving the funds, provided the administrative requirements are satisfied.

2.1 Defining Full Refundability under Title 30, § 2070(c)

The Delaware R&D Tax Credit is codified under Title 30, Chapter 20, Subchapter VIII, specifically Section 2070, which addresses the Credit for Research and Development Expenses.4 This statute explicitly governs how any approved credit amount must be utilized and repaid.

The procedure begins with the credit being applied against the taxpayer’s qualified tax liability for the taxable year in which the research expenses were accounted for under Delaware income taxation.5 The critical legal foundation for the cash payment is found in subsection (c) of § 2070, which states unambiguously: “If the taxpayer cannot use the entire amount of the approved research and development tax credit, such unused credit shall be paid to it in the nature of a tax refund”.5 This statutory guarantee provides taxpayers with legal certainty regarding the eventual receipt of the approved credit amount, irrespective of profit status.

2.2 Competitive Advantage: Refundability vs. Carryforwards

Delaware’s mandatory refundability positions it as a market leader compared to most other state R&D tax credit programs. In states where credits are non-refundable, the value of the credit is delayed; companies must wait until they are profitable to offset future tax liabilities, often over a carryforward period of 10 to 15 years.6 This delay introduces significant risk and devalues the credit due to the time value of money.

In contrast, Delaware’s approach ensures that the credit has immediate fiscal utility. By mandating a direct cash refund for the unused portion, the state avoids the financial discount associated with deferred tax assets, providing predictable and rapid recovery of qualified expenses. This certainty of fiscal return enhances the state’s overall economic competitiveness, particularly when attracting venture-backed entities that prioritize cash flow.

2.3 Allocation and Flow-Through Rules

The principle of refundability extends to owners of pass-through entities, such as S corporations and partnerships. For partnerships, the Delaware statute follows federal rules, allocating the credit among partners as outlined in Internal Revenue Code (IRC) § 41(f)(2)(B).5 The entity calculates the credit, but the resulting refundable amount flows down to the individual owners, who then claim the cash refund against their respective Delaware income tax liabilities using the appropriate line items on Form 700.7 This allocation mechanism ensures that the full value of the credit is accessible to the ultimate owners of the qualifying business activity.

Section III: The Mechanics of Credit Generation and Enhancement

The total amount of the potential cash refund is determined by two critical factors: the taxpayer’s classification (General vs. Small Business) and the annual election of the calculation method.

3.1 Qualification Criteria: Delaware Nexus and Federal Definitions

For any expense to qualify for the Delaware credit, two requirements must be met:

1. Federal Qualification: The activities must meet the criteria established under IRC § 41, often referred to as the “four-part test” (involving uncertainty, process of experimentation, technological nature, and qualified purpose).2 Any R&D activity that qualifies federally automatically qualifies for the state credit.3
2. Delaware Nexus: The qualified research must physically take place within Delaware.5 If a company conducts research both inside and outside Delaware, only the expenses demonstrably incurred in Delaware can be used for the state credit calculation.

3.2 Determining Small Business Status

The state offers significantly enhanced credit rates for small businesses, increasing the potential cash refund amount. A “small business” is defined as any taxpayer with average annual gross receipts, determined by IRC § 41(c)(1)(B), that do not exceed $20,000,000.5

This $20 million threshold is critically important for financial modeling. Companies that carefully manage their R&D investments while remaining under this threshold are able to utilize the maximum possible credit rate, optimizing their access to the refundable cash payment during their capital-intensive, high-growth phase.3

3.3 Calculation Methodologies and Rates

Taxpayers must make an annual election, independent of their federal R&D credit determination, to use one of two methods.5 The choice of method, combined with small business status, dictates the final credit rate.

Table 1: Delaware R&D Tax Credit Calculation Rate Comparison

For most startups, Method B, the Alternative Simplified Credit (ASC) method, maximized at 100% for small businesses, provides the most straightforward and often highest credit value.3 This method calculates the state credit based on a percentage of the amount claimed on the federal Form 6765, apportioned to Delaware activity.5 This strategic choice is pivotal for maximizing the eventual cash refund, as it substantially increases the potential recoverable amount for every dollar of qualified expenditure.

Furthermore, Delaware is distinguished as the only state that combines full refundability with the elimination of any state-wide expenditure cap.3 While many states, such as Virginia, Maryland, or Pennsylvania, limit their total annual credit allocation, risking proration or denial for taxpayers 6, Delaware guarantees that 100% of the calculated and approved credit will be realized, providing critical predictability for R&D budget planning.

Section IV: Navigating the Delaware Division of Revenue (DOR) Administrative Process

The realization of the Unused Credit Refund requires a rigorous, two-phase administrative process managed by the Delaware Division of Revenue (DOR).

4.1 Phase 1: Application and Pre-Approval (Delaware Form 2070AC)

The process of claiming the R&D tax credit is separated from the filing of the annual tax return through a mandatory application and computation schedule.

• Required Form: Taxpayers must submit Form 2070AC, Application and Computation Schedule for Claiming Delaware Research and Development Tax Credits.10 This form includes the detailed calculation of the credit amount using the chosen method (A or B).10
• Documentation: Crucially, a copy of the corresponding federal research credit filing, Federal Form 6765, must be attached to the application, as Delaware’s calculation is intrinsically linked to the federal definitions and methodology.11
• Critical Deadline: Form 2070AC must be filed with the DOR on or by September 15th following the end of the taxable year in which the qualified expenses were incurred.8 This deadline is mandatory for approval and precedes the extended due date for many corporate income tax returns. Failure to meet this September 15th deadline prevents the credit from being formally “approved,” thus jeopardizing its claim as a refundable credit on the final return.

4.2 Phase 2: Claiming the Refund on the Income Tax Return (Delaware Form 700)

Once the credit amount is approved by the DOR via Form 2070AC, the taxpayer integrates the figure into their annual income tax filing, triggering the cash refund procedure.

• Credit Schedule Integration: The approved credit amount is first transferred onto the Delaware Form 700, the Delaware Income Tax Credit Schedule.11 C Corporations, S Corporations, Partnerships, and Sole Proprietors use specific lines (such as Line 10(a) or 10(b) for corporations) on Form 700 to track the current year credit.7
• Refund Trigger: For C-Corporations, the total approved refundable credit is entered on a dedicated line item of the corporate income tax return (Delaware Form 700, Line 19, Approved Refundable Income Tax Credits).13 When the amount entered on this line exceeds the calculated corporate income tax liability, the surplus is paid out directly as the Unused Credit Refund, fulfilling the mandate of § 2070(c).5

While the DOR publishes general guidance and forms 14, the administrative process relies heavily on the detailed instructions provided in the forms themselves and the implicit incorporation of federal law, as specific Technical Information Memorandums (TIMs) regarding the R&D credit calculation or refund procedure are not frequently issued by the DOR.15 Therefore, strict adherence to the sequential filing requirements and federal documentation standards is paramount.

Section V: Strategic Tax Planning and Economic Impact

Delaware’s refundable R&D credit is intentionally structured as a major competitive tool, serving as both an economic incentive and a mechanism for immediate capital formation.

5.1 Immediate Liquidity and Cash Flow Management

The greatest strategic value of the cash payment provision is the immediate injection of working capital it provides. For a startup or developing company that is incurring significant R&D expenses but generating net losses (thus having zero or minimal tax liability), the refund converts otherwise unusable tax benefits into immediate cash flow. This recovery acts as a direct subsidy for operational expenses such as qualified wages or supplies 2, allowing companies to stretch investment dollars further without resorting to costly or dilutive financing methods.

Furthermore, this benefit provides a predictable financial outcome for R&D investment. For financial reporting purposes, a guaranteed refundable tax credit is generally viewed more favorably than a non-refundable carryforward, bolstering the company’s perceived financial stability.

5.2 State Competitive Advantage: Zero Cap and Predictability

Delaware is uniquely positioned because it combines its full refundability policy with the absence of a maximum annual expenditure cap.3 Most states that offer refundable or transferable R&D credits restrict them to small businesses or impose state-wide limits.6 For example, neighboring states often cap their programs, such as Virginia’s $7.77 million annual cap or Pennsylvania’s $55 million cap.6 These limits introduce the risk of pro-ration, where companies may receive less than their calculated credit if the program is oversubscribed.

Delaware’s zero-cap policy eliminates this uncertainty. This structural guarantee is essential not only for small, growing businesses but also for large multinational corporations planning multi-million dollar R&D activities, ensuring they can rely on receiving the full benefit calculated under the statute. This high degree of fiscal certainty is a strong policy signal designed to secure long-term investment and high-value employment within the state.

5.3 Optimization through Timing and Business Classification

Effective tax planning necessitates precise modeling of gross receipts relative to the $20 million small business threshold.5 Companies must project their growth to ensure they maximize R&D expenditures during the years they qualify for the enhanced small business rate (20% Method A or 100% Method B). Timing R&D investments to remain under the $20 million threshold ensures the highest possible refundable cash payout, providing maximum support during the phase when external capital is often most difficult to obtain. Companies transitioning beyond the threshold must be prepared for the corresponding reduction to the standard 10% or 50% rates.

Section VI: Case Study: Modeling a Small Business Unused Credit Refund

This example illustrates the direct conversion of an approved R&D tax credit into a cash refund payment for a small, research-focused business.

6.1 Scenario Setup: Pioneer Robotics LLC (S-Corp)

Pioneer Robotics is a small Delaware S-Corporation that qualifies for the small business enhancement. Since it is an S-Corporation, the credit flows through to the owners’ personal income tax returns, but the principle of refundability remains the same, ensuring a cash refund for unused credit.

6.2 Step-by-Step Calculation using the Small Business (100% ASC) Method

Pioneer Robotics elects Method B (100% ASC) to maximize the refundable credit.5 Since all QREs are in Delaware, the apportionment ratio is 100%.

1. Calculate Apportioned ASC Share:

• Apportionment Ratio ($\frac{\text{Delaware QREs}}{\text{Total QREs}}$): $100\%$
• Apportioned Share: $\$65,000 \times 100\% = \$65,000$

1. Apply Small Business Rate (100%):

• Delaware R&D Credit (Approved Amount on Form 2070AC): $\$65,000 \times 100\% = \mathbf{\$65,000}$

1. Credit Allocation and Offset:

• Assume Owner 1 holds 50% ownership (allocated on Form 700, Line 10(b) for S-Corps 7).
• Owner 1 Share of Credit: $\$65,000 \times 50\% = \$32,500$
• Owner 1 Tax Liability: $5,000$
• Credit used to offset liability: $\$(5,000)$
• Remaining Credit: $\$27,500$

1. Unused Credit Refund (Cash Payment):
   The unused credit amount of $\$27,500$ is claimed on Owner 1’s personal tax return, triggering the mandatory cash refund specified in § 2070(c).5

In this scenario, the combination of the enhanced credit rate and the refundability statute transforms a potential tax offset into a direct cash injection of $\$27,500$ for the owner, providing tangible, immediate financial support derived from qualified research activities.

Section VII: Conclusion: Sustaining Innovation Through State Fiscal Incentives

The Unused Credit Refund (Cash Payment) is the defining feature of the Delaware R&D Tax Credit, establishing the state as a premier jurisdiction for technological development. The mandate enshrined in Delaware Code § 2070(c) guarantees that any approved credit exceeding a taxpayer’s liability is converted into a tax refund.5 This assurance provides immediate, non-dilutive working capital, a crucial benefit particularly for small businesses that qualify for double the standard credit rate (up to 100% of the apportioned federal ASC).5

The strategic absence of a state-wide expenditure cap further solidifies Delaware’s competitive edge, ensuring that the benefit is fully realized without the risk of proration common in capped state programs.3 Successful utilization, however, depends on strict procedural compliance with the Division of Revenue (DOR). Taxpayers must secure formal credit approval by submitting Form 2070AC by the September 15th deadline and properly transfer the approved amount to Form 700, ultimately claiming the refundable portion on the income tax return (e.g., Line 19 for C-Corps).11 By adhering to these steps, businesses can effectively monetize their research investments, translating innovation directly into sustained cash flow and reinforcing Delaware’s commitment to a predictable and generous fiscal environment for R&D.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/