The Strategic Role of the Department of Business, Economic Development, and Tourism (DBEDT) in the Hawaii Tax Credit for Research Activities (TCRA)

The Department of Business, Economic Development, and Tourism (DBEDT) serves as the primary certifying authority for the Tax Credit for Research Activities (TCRA), verifying Qualified Research Expenses (QREs) and managing the program’s statutory $5 million annual allocation limit. DBEDT’s administrative function is critical, as eligible high-technology businesses (QHTBs) must secure a signed certificate from DBEDT before successfully claiming the refundable credit on their state income tax returns via the Department of Taxation (DOTAX).

The State of Hawaiʻi enacted the TCRA (also known as the R&D tax credit) to stimulate economic growth by fostering innovation and technological advancement within the state.1 This incentive offers a refundable tax credit against corporate or personal income tax liability for expenses incurred in qualified research activities, providing substantial benefit, particularly to early-stage technology enterprises. The program is currently slated to expire for tax years beginning after December 31, 2029.2 However, the strategic administration of the credit is split between DBEDT and DOTAX, creating a complex dual compliance structure that demands rigorous adherence to specialized statutory deadlines and filing sequences.

I. The Department of Business, Economic Development, and Tourism: Mandate and Context

DBEDT is central to the state’s economic strategy, tasked with achieving a Hawaiʻi economy defined by innovation, global competitiveness, dynamism, and productivity, thereby providing opportunities for all citizens.4 The department uses targeted fiscal tools, such as the TCRA, to promote job creation within the innovation sector. The administration of the TCRA is viewed not merely as a tax function but as an economic development mandate designed to cultivate high-tech industries within the state.

A. Defining the Qualified High Technology Business (QHTB)

DBEDT is responsible for ensuring that applicants meet the statutory criteria defining a Qualified High Technology Business (QHTB). To be eligible for certification, a business must meet several strict requirements 3:

1. Local Registration and Activity: The company must be registered to conduct business in Hawaiʻi. Critically, it must conduct more than 50% of its total activities in qualified research within the state of Hawaiʻi.1
2. Size Restriction: The company must employ no more than 500 total employees.2

The policy requirement stipulating that a QHTB must conduct over 50% of its activities locally ensures that the state’s fiscal subsidy translates directly into tangible economic activity and innovation sector job growth within the islands.4 This stringent eligibility threshold is designed to prevent the subsidy of research activities primarily conducted or domiciled outside Hawaiʻi, thereby maximizing the incentive’s impact on the local economy.

Furthermore, the 500-employee cap limits the TCRA to small and medium enterprises (SMEs) and startup ventures, rather than large, established corporate entities. This policy decision maximizes the breadth of innovation supported by distributing the limited annual funding cap across a greater number of developing local enterprises, aligning the program with DBEDT’s mission to foster widespread economic opportunity across the innovation ecosystem.

II. Statutory Authority and DBEDT’s Mandated Duties under HRS §235-110.91

The legal framework for the TCRA is codified primarily under Hawaiʻi Revised Statutes (HRS) §235-110.91. This statute places clear and specific duties upon DBEDT regarding the verification, certification, and policy analysis of the credit.

A. Verification and Certification Mandate

Under HRS §235-110.91(e) and related provisions, DBEDT is vested with the authority and responsibility to administer the core elements of the credit 6:

• Verification: DBEDT must verify the nature of the qualifying research activity and the amount of the underlying qualified costs or expenditures.6
• Totaling Costs: DBEDT must aggregate and total all qualifying and cumulative costs or expenditures that the department certifies.
• Credit Certification: Upon determination, DBEDT must certify the amount of the tax credit for each taxable year and issue a certificate to the QHTB.6 This certificate is known administratively as Part II of Form N-346A.7 DBEDT, not the QHTB, signs the certificate, validating the claim.7

B. The Critical Nexus: Static Conformity to IRC §41 (December 31, 2011)

A defining characteristic of the Hawaiʻi TCRA is its reliance on a static reference date for determining qualified research activities (QREs) and calculating the credit. The statute dictates that the credit is based on the provisions of Section 41 of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC), as that section was enacted on December 31, 2011.6

This static conformity mandates that any federal tax provisions or amendments to IRC §41 enacted after December 31, 2011, are entirely disregarded for the purpose of determining the Hawaiʻi state income tax credit.6 This creates a significant operational and audit complexity for QHTBs, as they must maintain dual compliance: current federal law for their Form 6765 filing, and a historical snapshot of federal law for DBEDT certification. DBEDT must possess and apply expertise in this static version of federal tax law to ensure accurate verification and certification across all applications.10

C. The Economic Reporting Mandate and Penalty

To ensure accountability and provide data for policy evaluation, HRS §235-110.91 mandates that any QHTB claiming the credit must complete and file an annual survey electronically through the DBEDT website.11

The requirements for this survey are strictly enforced:

• Deadline: The annual survey must be filed before June 30 of each calendar year following the year for which the credit is claimed.2
• Data Requirements: The survey collects crucial economic indicators, including identification of the industry sector, total and qualified expenditures, detailed revenue and expense data (including licensing or intellectual property income), and specific Hawaiʻi employment and wage data (such as job numbers and payroll).6
• Penalty for Non-Compliance: Failure to complete and file the annual survey by the June 30 deadline constitutes a waiver of the right to claim the credit.2

This strict penalty emphasizes that the policy objective of data collection is a priority for the state, reflecting the legislative necessity for DBEDT to measure the program’s effectiveness—particularly given the TCRA’s 2029 sunset clause.3 The comprehensive data collected is then used by DBEDT, in collaboration with DOTAX, to study the credit’s efficacy and submit a required annual report to the legislature by September 1.11

III. DBEDT’s Administrative and Capacity Management Functions

DBEDT’s most critical administrative function lies in managing the program’s funding constraint, which transforms the application process from a standard tax procedure into a time-sensitive competition.

A. Management of the $5 Million Annual Cap

The refundable TCRA is subject to a strict statutory maximum of $5 million in total certified credits per year.2 This constraint necessitates a rationing mechanism, which DBEDT is required to enforce on a “first-come, first-served” basis.2

Historical data demonstrates that demand for the TCRA significantly exceeds the allocated budget. Between 2020 and 2023, the total amount of tax credit claimed by QHTBs ranged from $11.9 million to $13.3 million annually. As a result of the $5 million cap, an average of 17 to 30 QHTBs were not certified each year, even though their research activities qualified.14 The intense demand means that the cap is often met almost immediately upon the application window opening.13

B. Procedural Requirements for DBEDT Certification

To secure certification and access the cap, QHTBs must file the certification form, Form N-346A.

• Application Submission: QHTBs must submit the completed, signed Form N-346A—the certified declaration detailing qualified expenses incurred in the prior tax year—to DBEDT.13
• Deadline Urgency: For calendar year filers, the deadline for submitting Form N-346A has historically been March 30 or March 31 following the taxable year end.2

This accelerated March deadline is crucial. Because DBEDT certifies credits on a first-come, first-served basis, the timing of the application is the dominant regulatory constraint, overshadowing the complexity of the calculation itself. The need to finalize research expenses and submit the application in the first quarter, months before typical corporate extended filing deadlines, effectively transforms the TCRA application into a high-stakes race where speed is prioritized to ensure placement under the strict cap.

IV. Local State Revenue Office Guidance: The Role of the Department of Taxation (DOTAX)

While DBEDT certifies eligibility and manages the cap, the Department of Taxation (DOTAX) is the final processing agency that administers the tax claim and issues any resultant refund.

A. Inter-Agency Responsibilities and Key Forms

The dual administrative structure requires sequential compliance. A QHTB cannot claim the credit until DBEDT has issued the signed certificate (N-346A Part II). The following table outlines the division of compliance authority:

Table I: DBEDT vs. DOTAX Responsibilities in TCRA Administration

B. Tax Filing Requirements and Deadlines

The credit must be claimed by the taxpayer within 12 months after the end of the taxable year for which the credit applies.11 This typically aligns with the taxpayer’s final income tax return filing deadline, including extensions. Failure to claim the credit properly within this period constitutes a waiver of the right to claim it.11

To properly claim the credit with DOTAX, the taxpayer must attach the following forms to their Hawaiʻi income tax return 12:

1. Hawaiʻi Form N-346: The specific form used to calculate and claim the TCRA.
2. Federal Form 6765: The federal form used to calculate the basis of the R&D credit, which is foundational to the Hawaiʻi calculation.
3. Certified Form N-346A (Part II): The official certificate signed and issued by DBEDT, which validates the maximum certified credit amount.7

The credit is fully refundable. If the certified tax credit amount exceeds the taxpayer’s net income tax liability for the taxable year, the excess amount is refunded to the taxpayer, provided the refund is $1 or greater.11 This refundability is a significant component of the credit’s value, particularly for QHTBs that may not yet have substantial tax liability.

C. Treatment of Flow-Through Entities

For QHTBs structured as pass-through entities (S corporations, partnerships, estates, trusts, or cooperatives), the credit is allocated to the owners. The flow-through entity must attach a detailed list to the N-346A application showing the names, identifying numbers (SSN or FEIN), and the allocated or distributive share of the credit for each partner, shareholder, or beneficiary.15

Upon successful certification, DBEDT mails the certified N-346A Part II to the QHTB. The flow-through entity is then responsible for distributing copies of this official, signed certificate to all owners claiming their allocated portion of the credit on their respective returns.7

V. Calculation Methodology for the Hawaii TCRA

The amount of the Hawaiʻi TCRA is derived directly from the amount of the corresponding federal R&D tax credit, adjusted by a local proration ratio.9

A. The Proration Formula

The final Hawaiʻi credit amount is determined using the following formula:

$$\text{Hawaii TCRA} = \text{Federal R\&D Credit (IRC 2011 basis)} \times \left(\frac{\text{Hawaii QREs}}{\text{Total Federal QREs}}\right)$$

16

B. Determining the Federal R&D Credit Basis

The calculation of the federal base credit amount must strictly adhere to the provisions of IRC §41 as enacted on December 31, 2011.6 This calculation requires determining the amount of “Excess QREs,” which are current QREs that exceed the calculated fixed base amount.16

1. Base Amount Computation: The fixed base amount is typically calculated by multiplying the fixed-base percentage (which can start at 3% for startups) by the average annual gross receipts for the four preceding tax years.16
2. Minimum Base Check: A critical structural constraint is the rule that the calculated federal base amount cannot be less than 50% of the current year’s total QREs.16
3. Credit Calculation: The Excess QREs (current QREs minus the final base amount) are then multiplied by the applicable federal credit rate (typically 20%) to determine the Federal R&D Credit basis.16

The application of the 50% minimum base rule acts as a structural cap within the calculation itself. For QHTBs experiencing rapid growth, where current QREs significantly outweigh historical gross receipts, this rule forces the base amount higher, thereby lowering the “Excess QREs” and reducing the calculated credit amount. This self-regulatory mechanism limits disproportionately large claims before the state’s $5 million administrative cap is even applied.

C. Proration of Expenses

The calculated federal credit basis is then scaled using the proration ratio: the quotient of Hawaii QREs (expenses incurred solely within the state) divided by total Federal QREs (expenses incurred nationally).16 This step ensures that Hawaiʻi’s fiscal incentive is strictly confined to the proportion of research activity conducted locally, directly rewarding companies that centralize their research and development operations within the state.

VI. Illustrative Case Study: Calculation and Certification Flow

To illustrate the technical calculation and administrative flow required for compliance with both DBEDT and DOTAX, consider a hypothetical example:

A. Profile of Aloha Bio-Renewables, Inc. (ABR)

• Tax Year: 2024 (Calendar Year)
• Status: A QHTB registered in Hawaiʻi, under 500 employees, with 100% of R&D activities occurring locally.
• Financial Data:

• Federal Average Annual Gross Receipts (4 prior years): $1,500,000
• Total Qualified Research Expenses (Federal QREs): $900,000
• Hawaiʻi Qualified Research Expenses (Hawaiʻi QREs): $900,000

B. Step-by-Step Calculation of the Hawaii TCRA

The calculation adheres to the 2011 version of IRC §41.

Table II: Detailed Calculation Example of the Hawaii R&D Tax Credit (TCRA)

In this scenario, ABR’s $900,000 QREs triggered the 50% minimum base rule, raising the fixed base amount from $45,000 to $450,000 (Step 6), reducing the Excess QREs to $450,000 (Step 7), and resulting in a $90,000 credit basis (Step 8). Since 100% of QREs were incurred locally, the final refundable Hawaiʻi TCRA is $90,000.

C. Administrative Compliance Sequence

1. DBEDT Certification: ABR must submit its Form N-346A to DBEDT by the March 31, 2025 deadline. The urgency of this submission is paramount to ensure the $90,000 claim is successfully certified under the $5 million annual cap.2
2. Certification Issuance: DBEDT reviews and verifies the $900,000 in QREs and, assuming the cap has not been met, issues the signed N-346A Part II certificate.
3. Economic Survey Compliance: ABR must complete the mandatory Annual Economic Survey online before June 30, 2025.11 Failure to meet this requirement would waive the entire $90,000 credit, even if already certified.
4. DOTAX Claim: ABR files its 2024 income tax return, attaching Form N-346, Federal Form 6765, and the certified N-346A Part II. DOTAX processes the claim and issues the refundable credit of $90,000 (assuming it exceeds ABR’s tax liability).11

VII. Policy Implications and Expert Recommendations

The Hawaiʻi TCRA is a powerful, yet severely capacity-constrained, fiscal tool administered through a complex partnership between DBEDT and DOTAX. The administrative structure introduces unique compliance risks that QHTBs must actively mitigate.

A. The Challenge of Competing for Limited Capital

The most significant policy implication is the rationing of innovation funding. The $5 million annual cap restricts the program’s reach, as evidenced by the large number of QHTBs that qualify but fail to secure certification due to the rapid exhaustion of funds.14 This capacity shortage forces companies to prioritize early R&D tax finalization and application over meticulous year-end accounting schedules, elevating the risk of procedural errors under pressure.

B. Navigating Statutory and Administrative Complexity

The required use of the static December 31, 2011 version of IRC §41 necessitates specialized tax counsel. QHTBs cannot assume conformity with current federal tax preparation standards; instead, they must adjust their computations to this historical definition, introducing specialized complexity that increases compliance cost and audit risk.

Furthermore, the threat of credit waiver for failing to file the mandatory economic survey by June 30 underscores the legislative priority placed on policy data.11 DBEDT leverages this administrative requirement to gather robust metrics on job creation, IP generation, and expenditures, using this information to annually evaluate and justify the program’s existence and potential renewal against the 2029 sunset clause.11

C. Conclusion and Expert Recommendations

DBEDT’s central role is to strategically manage the state’s investment in technology by acting as the primary gatekeeper for the TCRA, verifying technical compliance, and administering the strict $5 million annual cap.

To successfully utilize this valuable incentive, QHTBs should implement the following expert recommendations:

1. Prioritize the DBEDT Deadline: Treat the March 30/31 deadline for Form N-346A submission as the definitive annual financial closing date for R&D documentation to secure a spot under the cap.
2. Ensure Dual Compliance: Secure specialized tax expertise capable of calculating the credit using the static IRC §41 (2011) basis and managing the separate economic survey filing with DBEDT by the June 30 deadline.
3. Strictly Control Flow-Through Documentation: Flow-through entities must establish clear internal protocols for distributing the certified N-346A Part II immediately upon receipt from DBEDT, as this document is non-negotiable for owners claiming the refundable credit through DOTAX.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/