Navigating Compliance and Claiming: The Central Role of Hawaii Schedule CR in Securing the Research Activities Tax Credit (TCRA)

I. Executive Summary: Schedule CR as the State’s Credit Ledger

Schedule CR, officially titled the Schedule of Tax Credits, serves as the centralized reporting mechanism for all refundable and nonrefundable tax credits claimed by Hawaii taxpayers.1 This form is mandatory for summarizing current credit claims, tracking the utilization of credits against the final tax liability, and managing unused carryover amounts across multiple tax years.1

Detailed Overview of Schedule CR’s Purpose and Significance

The Hawaii Department of Taxation (DOTAX) requires Schedule CR to maintain a rigorous and systematic accounting ledger for all applicable state tax incentives, including the Tax Credit for Research Activities (TCRA), Renewable Fuels, Historic Preservation, and others.2 Schedule CR is critical for reconciling the total available credits before computing the final tax liability or refund.

The form is structured as a mandatory four-column ledger designed to enforce consistent credit application and tracking:

1. Column (a): Total Unused Carryover Credit from Prior Tax Year.2
2. Column (b): Total New Credit Claimed for the current tax year.2
3. Column (c): Total Credit Applied to the current year’s tax liability.2
4. Column (d): Unused Credit to Carryover to the subsequent tax year.2

This structure is integral to the state’s enforcement of tax law, as the finalized Schedule CR is attached to the primary income tax returns (e.g., Form N-11, N-30, N-40, or N-70NP).2

Strategic Context: The Refundable TCRA and Its Interaction with Schedule CR’s Carryover Mechanism

The Hawaii Tax Credit for Research Activities (TCRA), authorized under HRS § 235-110.91, is categorized as a refundable income tax credit.3 This classification is exceptionally beneficial because any certified credit amount that exceeds the taxpayer’s income tax liability is paid out directly as a cash refund.3 Consequently, the TCRA generally bypasses the need for multi-year carryover tracking in Schedule CR’s Column (d).

However, Schedule CR’s importance is not diminished for TCRA claimants. Taxpayers frequently claim the refundable TCRA alongside other, distinct state incentives that are explicitly nonrefundable and designed for multi-year use (such as the Capital Goods Excise Tax Credit). The principal regulatory necessity of Schedule CR is to uniformly administer and enforce the stringent annual forfeiture rules that apply specifically to these nonrefundable credit balances.6 By requiring all carryover activity to be summarized in one place, the DOTAX ensures comprehensive control and verification of every taxpayer’s total credit portfolio.

II. Statutory and Legislative Context of the Research Activities Tax Credit (TCRA)

A. HRS § 235-110.91: The Foundation of R&D Incentives

The TCRA is statutorily designed to promote high-technology economic development by providing a refundable credit against income tax for Qualified High Technology Businesses (QHTBs) that invest in qualified research activities (QRAs) within the state.3 The credit supports specific, targeted high-tech fields, including biotechnology, the development and design of computer software for commercial sale, ocean sciences, astronomy, and non-fossil fuel energy-related technology.3

Eligibility is strictly defined. A business qualifies as a QHTB if it is registered to do business in Hawaii, conducts more than 50% of its activities in qualified research within the state, and is classified as a small business (having no more than 500 employees).1

The state calculation is mandatory linked to federal tax law. HRS § 235-110.91 requires that the state credit be based on the federal credit for research activities defined in Section 41 of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC).7 A crucial prerequisite for claiming the state credit is that the taxpayer must also claim a federal tax credit for the same qualified research.7

B. Impact of Act 139, SLH 2024 (Tax Year 2024 and Beyond)

The legislative session in 2024 yielded critical amendments to the TCRA through Act 139, SLH 2024. This legislation became effective on July 1, 2024, and its provisions apply to all taxable years beginning after December 31, 2023.1

Extension of the Sunset Date

Act 139 provided long-term assurance for the incentive by extending the statutory expiration, or sunset date, of the TCRA. The credit, which was previously scheduled to be repealed at the end of 2024 7, is now extended through December 31, 2029.1 This extension is critical for incentivizing substantial, multi-year research investments, as it guarantees the continuity of the benefit.

Reinstatement of the Federal Base Amount Calculation

The most significant technical change for tax compliance involves the calculation methodology. Prior Hawaii law provided a simplification, allowing QHTBs to take the credit for all qualified research expenses without applying the complex IRC $\S$ 41 base amount calculation.7

Act 139 repealed this simplification. The updated law explicitly requires the application of the base amount as defined under IRC $\S$ 41.3 Specifically, the federal tax provisions in IRC $\S$ 41, as that section was enacted on December 31, 2011, must be used for determining the state income tax credit.4

This reinstatement substantially increases the complexity of the calculation and the compliance burden on QHTBs. Taxpayers must now perform the full federal calculation, which involves establishing a fixed-base percentage derived from the average annual gross receipts of the four preceding tax years. The resulting base amount serves as a floor against which current-year Qualified Research Expenses (QREs) are compared, and the calculation must ensure the base amount is not less than 50% of the current-year QREs.3 The resulting federal credit, derived from the expenses exceeding this base, forms the necessary input (Line 1 of Form N-346) for the Hawaii proportional calculation. This change effectively lowers the overall magnitude of the maximum allowable Hawaii TCRA compared to the previous simplified statutory regime.

III. The TCRA Allocation Challenge: DBEDT Certification and the Annual Cap

A. The Competitive Nature of the $5 Million Aggregate Cap

A primary constraint on the TCRA is the strict statewide aggregate cap of $5 million on the total amount of credit certified annually.5 The allocation of this limited resource is administered by the Department of Business, Economic Development, and Tourism (DBEDT) and presents a significant operational risk for QHTBs.

The cap is historically and consistently oversubscribed, creating intense competition. Research data indicates that the total amount of credit claimed by QHTBs has dramatically exceeded the available cap, often by a factor of two or three. For example, previous years saw claims totaling $11.9 million to $13.3 million against the constant $5 million certified cap.8 This oversubscription has historically resulted in many qualified companies being denied credit certification.8

DBEDT allocates the certified credit based on a strict “first-come, first-served” rule, determined by the time stamp of the application submission.3 DBEDT guidance emphasizes the severity of this competition, noting that the $5 million cap has been reached almost instantaneously upon the opening of the online application portal.4 This regulatory environment mandates that QHTBs treat the preparation of the application (Form N-346A) as an immediate priority, often overriding typical tax calendar sequencing. Failure to successfully submit the application during the initial hours of the designated application window significantly compromises the ability to claim the credit for the entire tax year.

B. Required Documentation and Application Process (Dual Agency Compliance)

Compliance requires navigating requirements from two separate state agencies: DBEDT for initial certification and DOTAX for final tax filing.

DBEDT’s Certification Role

DBEDT manages the pre-filing certification process. QHTBs must submit Form N-346A (the application for certification) by March 31 of the year following the taxable year in which the research was conducted.4 This application must include a certified statement identifying the qualified expenditures and the amount of credit being claimed.3 DBEDT reviews this information and issues an approved N-346A certificate, typically around June 30 4, confirming the QHTB status and the tentatively certified credit amount.

Additionally, every certified QHTB must file an Annual Compliance Survey detailing their expenditures and credits claimed by June 30.3 Failure to submit this survey by the deadline will result in the forfeiture of the certified credit.5

DOTAX’s Filing Role

Once the DBEDT certification is secured, the taxpayer proceeds to file the claim with DOTAX. This involves completing Hawaii Form N-346 to calculate the precise credit amount and summarizing the credit on Schedule CR. The approved N-346A certificate, Form N-346, Federal Form 6765, and Schedule CR must all be attached to the final income tax return.5

The final deadline for claiming the credit with DOTAX, including amended claims, is 12 months after the close of the taxpayer’s taxable year.9 This deadline applies to the submission of the completed Schedule CR and supporting forms.

Table: Hawaii TCRA Key Parameters and Compliance Milestones

IV. Calculation Methodology: Linking Federal Research to Hawaii Activity

A. Form N-346: The Detailed Credit Computation

The computation of the Hawaii TCRA is a proportional calculation performed on Hawaii Form N-346. The fundamental requirement is that the taxpayer must first determine the federal tax credit amount using Federal Form 6765, incorporating the complex IRC $\S$ 41 base calculation as mandated by Act 139.4 This federal credit amount is entered on Line 1 of Form N-346.9

Form N-346 requires a precise geographical segregation of the Qualified Research Expenses (QREs):

• Column A (Total QREs): This represents the aggregate amount of QREs used to compute the federal credit, encompassing research conducted anywhere.9
• Column B (Hawaii QREs): This column records the specific portion of QREs that are strictly attributable to research activity conducted IN HAWAII. Importantly, only these locally derived expenses qualify for the state credit, and they must be a direct subset of the amounts reported in Column A.9

B. The Proportional Allocation Formula

The final Hawaii TCRA amount is derived by applying a proportional ratio to the federal credit, ensuring that the benefit scales directly with the QHTB’s local research investment.9

The calculation proceeds in two steps:

1. Calculate the Hawaii Percentage: This ratio is determined by dividing the total Hawaii QREs (Line 2g, Column B) by the total Federal QREs (Line 2g, Column A). This result must be reported as a decimal rounded to six (6) decimal places.9
2. Calculate the Tentative Hawaii TCRA: This figure is calculated by multiplying the Federal Tax Credit (Line 1) by the Hawaii Percentage (Line 3).9

If the QHTB is structured as a pass-through entity (such as a partnership or S-corporation), the total credit (Line 6 of N-346) is computed at the entity level and subsequently allocated to the individual owners (partners or shareholders) via Schedule K-1. These owners then claim the flow-through credit on their respective Hawaii income tax returns (e.g., N-11) and include the amount on their individual Schedule CR.3

V. Schedule CR: The Reporting Mechanism and Forfeiture Risk Management (DOTAX Guidance)

A. Schedule CR Structure and Data Flow

Schedule CR serves as the definitive summary document for all tax credits. The TCRA, once certified by DBEDT and calculated on Form N-346, is entered onto the relevant line item on Schedule CR (typically Line 13), populating Column (b), “Total New Credit Claimed”.2

The columns on Schedule CR dictate the methodical application of credits against the income tax liability. Carryover balances (Column (a)) are applied first, followed by the new credit (Column (b)). The sum applied (Column (c)) reduces the tax liability. For the refundable TCRA 4, any residual amount remaining after fully offsetting the tax liability is claimed as a cash refund on the main tax form (N-11, N-30, etc.).3 This refundable status ensures that the balance moving to the Unused Carryover column (Column (d)) for the TCRA is typically zero.

B. Compliance Guidance on Carryovers and Forfeiture

The DOTAX instructions for Schedule CR establish a critical universal compliance mandate for managing carryover credits, which must be scrupulously followed by QHTBs, especially those claiming other nonrefundable credits.

The Critical Forfeiture Mandate

DOTAX guidance explicitly states that unused carryover amounts from prior tax years must be claimed and reported every single tax year until the carryover balance is entirely exhausted.6 This requirement applies to specific nonrefundable credits that are listed on Schedule CR, many of which refer to supporting Form N-323.6

Compliance necessitates completing the designated line on Schedule CR (entering the carryover amount in Column (a)) and attaching the required supporting forms, regardless of whether the taxpayer has a current tax liability or applies any portion of the credit in that particular year.6

The consequence of failing to comply with this annual reporting requirement is immediate and absolute: if the unused carryover amount is not claimed and reported on Schedule CR in a given year, the amount will be forfeited.6 This strict forfeiture rule emphasizes that Schedule CR is not merely a summary tool but a continuous compliance mechanism that tracks the viability of multi-year tax benefits. Although the TCRA’s refundability mitigates this forfeiture risk for the research credit itself, QHTBs claiming other nonrefundable credits must treat Schedule CR as a paramount annual obligation to avoid losing substantial accumulated tax assets.

VI. Illustrative Example: A QHTB’s Compliance Path

The following example demonstrates the practical application of the TCRA calculation and the final reporting on Schedule CR for a certified QHTB.

A. Scenario Setup: Research Tech Inc. (QHTB)

Research Tech Inc., a QHTB certified by DBEDT, files its corporate income tax return on a calendar year basis (Form N-30). The company successfully secured its Form N-346A certification for its 2024 activities.

Financial Data for Tax Year 2024:

• Total QREs (Federal scope, worldwide): $400,000
• Hawaii QREs (Research conducted in Hawaii): $300,000
• Federal Tax Credit (Calculated on Form 6765, Line 44): $80,000
• Hawaii Corporate Income Tax Liability (Before Credit): $15,000
• Prior Year Carryovers (Nonrefundable credits): $0

B. Step-by-Step Calculation (Form N-346 Simulation)

The calculation isolates the Hawaii-specific portion of the federal credit.

Example: Calculation and Reporting Flow for the Hawaii TCRA (Form N-346)

The QHTB’s final calculated Hawaii TCRA is $60,000.

C. Schedule CR Reporting and Refund Outcome

This certified amount is then reported on Schedule CR and applied against the $15,000 income tax liability.

Example: Schedule CR Reporting and Refund Outcome

The reporting on Schedule CR confirms that $15,000 of the TCRA was utilized to reduce the corporate tax liability to zero. Consistent with the refundable nature of the credit 3, the excess balance of $45,000 ($60,000 available credit minus $15,000 tax liability offset) is claimed as a direct cash refund on the taxpayer’s Form N-30.

VII. Conclusion and Strategic Recommendations for QHTBs

The Hawaii Tax Credit for Research Activities offers substantial financial support for Qualified High Technology Businesses, particularly through its refundable status, which ensures immediate monetization of excess credit. However, the mechanism for securing this credit is highly complex, demanding rigorous adherence to the requirements of two separate state agencies (DBEDT and DOTAX).

The recent enactment of Act 139 provides stability by extending the credit’s sunset date through 2029, but it simultaneously heightens the compliance burden by reinstating the complex federal IRC $\S$ 41 base calculation as the starting point for the state credit. This increased computational complexity, combined with the extreme competition for the fixed $5 million annual cap, necessitates that QHTBs adopt a tax strategy prioritizing speed and precision in documentation.

Schedule CR, while serving a straightforward summarization function for the refundable TCRA, is the ultimate compliance gateway for all other state tax incentives. The strict DOTAX instructions regarding the annual reporting and subsequent forfeiture of unused nonrefundable credit carryovers require meticulous attention to Schedule CR, even in years where the TCRA results in a cash refund.

Key Strategic Recommendations for QHTBs:

1. Operationalize for Speed: Due to the $5 million first-come, first-served allocation cap, QHTBs must treat the preparation of the DBEDT certification application (Form N-346A) as an operational emergency. Resources must be deployed to ensure instantaneous submission when the portal opens, mitigating the high risk of credit denial.4
2. Ensure Technical Accuracy: Compliance teams must fully integrate the complex federal IRC $\S$ 41 base calculation, as mandated by Act 139, into the state credit process. This necessitates sophisticated record-keeping of historical gross receipts and QREs to accurately compute the federal credit figure that serves as Line 1 of Form N-346.3
3. Mandatory Annual Schedule CR Management: Taxpayers utilizing any nonrefundable carryover tax credits must understand the DOTAX forfeiture rule. To maintain the viability of these assets, unused carryover amounts must be explicitly reported on Schedule CR every year (Columns (a) and (d)), regardless of whether those credits are applied against the current year’s liability.6
4. Adhere to Dual-Agency Documentation: Successful claimants must ensure all required documentation, including the DBEDT certification (N-346A), the calculation form (N-346), the federal form (6765), and the summary schedule (CR), are compiled and filed by the 12-month post-taxable-year close deadline.5 Failure to meet the mandatory DBEDT compliance survey deadline (June 30) will also lead to forfeiture of the certified credit.5

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/