The Fixed Base Percentage in Idaho R&D Tax Credit: Compliance, Calculation, and Strategic Implications
I. Executive Summary: The Fixed Base Percentage Defined
The Fixed Base Percentage (FBP) is a crucial historical metric used in the calculation of the Idaho Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit. It quantifies a company’s past intensity of qualified research spending relative to its historical gross receipts.
The FBP is subsequently applied as a multiplier to the company’s recent average gross receipts to establish the “Base Amount,” which represents the minimum threshold of current R&D investment necessary before any tax credit can be claimed in Idaho.
The Strategic Context of Idaho’s R&D Credit (Idaho Code §63-3029G)
Idaho’s R&D tax credit serves as a significant financial incentive, rewarding businesses that commit resources to innovative activities within the state.1 The credit calculation methodology is structured specifically to stimulate incremental technological advancements; the benefit is not granted for baseline research expenditure but only for the increase in spending over a historical benchmark.1
This incentive is codified under Idaho Code §63-3029G and provides a 5% credit on Qualified Research Expenditures (QREs) that exceed a predetermined Base Amount.2 The Base Amount itself is a product of the Fixed Base Percentage multiplied by the average annual gross receipts from the four tax years immediately preceding the current credit year.1 By directly linking the credit to historical R&D intensity (the FBP), the Idaho system ensures that the benefit accrues primarily to companies demonstrating genuine expansion of their research footprint in the state.
Key Distinction: FBP and the 5% Incremental Credit Rate
It is essential to distinguish the components of the credit calculation. The Fixed Base Percentage is a historical ratio that helps determine the tax base (the Base Amount), but it is not the credit rate itself. The Idaho credit rate applied to the incremental QREs (the amount exceeding the Base Amount) is 5%.2 This 5% rate also applies to basic research payments that exceed the qualified organization base period amount, provided the research is conducted in Idaho (applicable only to corporations).2
II. Statutory and Regulatory Foundation of the Idaho R&D Credit
The Idaho R&D tax credit framework is derived heavily from federal standards, yet mandates strict adherence to state-specific data sourcing and compliance mechanisms, which are overseen by the Idaho State Tax Commission.
Legal Authority: Idaho Code §63-3029G and the Alignment with IRC §41
The Idaho Research Credit operates under the authority of Idaho Code §63-3029G.2 The state legislature aligned this credit closely with the methodology of the federal Internal Revenue Code (IRC) §41 regular research credit.2 This alignment means that federal definitions for qualified research, QREs, and basic research payments are adopted by Idaho.5
However, the state application introduces a critical limitation: the credit is strictly limited to amounts related to research conducted and expenditures incurred exclusively within Idaho.5 Furthermore, Idaho mandates the use of the traditional, FBP-dependent calculation method, explicitly excluding the calculation of the federal Alternative Simplified Credit (ASC).5 This statutory limitation increases the importance and complexity of the Fixed Base Percentage calculation in Idaho relative to jurisdictions that permit the simpler ASC election.
Claiming the Credit: Required Filing via Idaho Form 67
To accurately compute and claim the tax credit for research activities, taxpayers must utilize the state-specific Form 67 (Credit for Research Activities).1 The final calculated credit is then reported on the applicable Idaho business income tax forms, such as Form 41 (Corporate Income Tax) or Form 44 (Business Income Tax Credits).8 Form 67 contains designated sections (Part A and Part B) specifically for computing the FBP, reflecting the different rules for established companies versus those electing start-up treatment.7
Credit Mechanics: Nonrefundable Status and the Carryforward Provisions
The Idaho R&D credit is classified as nonrefundable. This means that the credit can only be used to offset the taxpayer’s Idaho income tax liability and cannot generate a cash refund.2
A significant feature of the credit is its longevity. Any unused portion of the credit can be carried forward for up to 14 tax years, offering substantial long-term tax relief, which is particularly beneficial for high-growth companies that may not achieve taxable income immediately.2
For corporations included as members of a unitary group, special rules apply concerning the allocation of the credit. While sharing the Idaho research credit with other members is permissible, the corporation that earns the credit must first claim it against its own Idaho income tax liability to the extent allowable before any excess can be shared within the group.5 This requirement establishes a priority rule for credit utilization within consolidated corporate structures operating within the state.
III. Deconstructing the Fixed Base Percentage (FBP) Calculation
The determination of the FBP is the most technically challenging aspect of the Idaho R&D credit, requiring access to historical financial data that must be strictly sourced according to contemporary Idaho tax law.
FBP Purpose: Establishing the Historical R&D Intensity Baseline
The fundamental purpose of the FBP is to establish a ratio that represents the taxpayer’s historical commitment to R&D relative to its total economic activity (gross receipts).10 This percentage is used to define the Base Amount—the level of investment that the state expects the taxpayer to maintain before awarding an incentive for growth. This mechanism is critical because it ensures the state subsidizes only research efforts that are incremental to the taxpayer’s established operational norms.
Standard FBP Calculation for Established Companies (Non-Start-up)
For taxpayers that do not elect start-up company treatment, Idaho strictly follows the federal standard base period for the regular research credit calculation.
Base Period Mandate
The mandatory base period for calculating the FBP involves data from tax years beginning after December 31, 1983, and before January 1, 1989.12 Therefore, established Idaho taxpayers must utilize the aggregate Idaho QREs and aggregate Idaho Gross Receipts for the five-year period from 1984 through 1988.7
The necessity of using this specific 1984-1988 data introduces a substantial compliance challenge. For many corporations, reconstructing state-specific QRE and gross receipts data from decades past poses a significant burden, especially if the company’s historical record-keeping or state-level tracking was limited. If a taxpayer did not track or cannot reconstruct these state-sourced figures accurately, they may be forced into relying on the statutory 50% QRE floor, as detailed in Section V.
Formulaic Calculation
The calculation process, detailed in Part A of Form 67 instructions, requires summing the Idaho QREs (Column A) and Idaho Gross Receipts (Column B) for each year in the base period.7
The FBP is calculated as follows:
$$FBP_{established} = \frac{\text{Aggregate Idaho QREs (1984-1988)}}{\text{Aggregate Idaho Gross Receipts (1984-1988)}}$$
7
FBP Limitation
In adherence to federal rules, the resulting percentage must not exceed a maximum cap of 16%.2 The FBP must also be rounded to the nearest 1/100th of 1 percent.7
Special Provisions for Start-up Companies
Idaho recognizes that established companies relying on the 1984–1988 period may face documentation hurdles or may have begun research activities long after that period. For these taxpayers, Idaho provides an alternative.
The Irrevocable Start-up Election
A taxpayer has the option to make an irrevocable election on Form 67 to be treated as a start-up company for Idaho research credit purposes.2 Crucially, this election is permitted even if the company does not qualify for start-up status under the federal research credit rules.5
Application of Federal Start-up Rules with Idaho Data
If the start-up election is exercised, the taxpayer is required by Idaho Code §63-3029G to use the fixed-base percentage methodology that applies to federal start-up companies under IRC §41.13 This alternative generally involves a phased-in approach using data from the company’s first five years of conducting QREs, establishing a ratio that applies to the subsequent years, all subject to the 16% cap.2 The critical state modification is that all QREs and gross receipts used in this calculation must be exclusively Idaho-sourced.6
The decision to utilize the irrevocable start-up election requires careful financial forecasting. While the election provides a compliant calculation path using more recent, auditable Idaho data, it forecloses the possibility of attempting to reconstruct the 1984-1988 records, which might, under certain conditions, yield a lower, more advantageous FBP. Taxpayers must balance the immediate compliance relief against the long-term, fixed nature of this choice.
IV. Idaho State Tax Commission Guidance: Sourcing and Apportionment Rules
Idaho’s tax credit compliance requires strict adherence to state-specific rules regarding the sourcing of both expenditures (QREs) and receipts (gross receipts), which impacts the integrity of the FBP calculation.
Determining Idaho Gross Receipts (IGR)
The Idaho State Tax Commission guidance, reflected in Form 67 instructions, explicitly requires that gross receipt calculations must include only those receipts attributable to Idaho.7 This applies not only to the current calculation of the Base Amount but also to the historical gross receipts used to determine the FBP.5
The Multistate Apportionment Mandate
For multistate corporations, the calculation of Idaho Gross Receipts (IGR) must adhere to the state’s multistate corporation apportionment rules.2 This means that receipts are allocated based on Idaho’s specific apportionment formula, net of returns and allowances.2
The requirement to apply current Idaho multistate apportionment rules retroactively to the 1984–1988 gross receipts for FBP calculation is a significant audit focus area. Idaho’s apportionment methods may have changed over the decades; therefore, a taxpayer must be able to justify the consistent application of current sourcing rules to the vintage financial data used in the base period determination. Part C of Form 67 is specifically dedicated to computing the average annual gross receipts attributable to Idaho sources.7
Data Sourcing Mandates for QREs
Similar to gross receipts, all Qualified Research Expenses (QREs) utilized in the FBP calculation (historical) and the credit calculation (current year) must meet rigorous sourcing requirements.
Idaho-Sourced Activities Only
While the definitions of QREs align with IRC §41 (including the four-part test for qualified research activity 6), only the amounts related to research conducted exclusively within Idaho qualify for the state credit.5 Furthermore, Idaho specifies that qualified research must be focused on technological activities and explicitly excludes research in areas such as economics, business management, behavioral sciences, arts, or humanities.7
V. Calculation of the Base Amount: The Role of FBP as a Multiplier
The Base Amount is the critical link between the Fixed Base Percentage and the final tax credit benefit. Its calculation integrates the historical FBP, recent gross receipts, and a statutory minimum requirement.
Step 1: Calculating Average Annual Idaho Gross Receipts (AAIGR)
The calculation begins with identifying the Idaho Gross Receipts (IGR), utilizing apportionment rules, for the four tax years immediately preceding the current credit year.1
The Average Annual Idaho Gross Receipts (AAIGR) is computed by summing the IGRs from the four prior years and dividing by four 2:
$$\text{AAIGR} = \frac{\sum_{i=1}^{4} \text{IGR}_{i}}{\text{4}}$$
Step 2: Determining the Preliminary Base Amount
Once the FBP and the AAIGR are calculated, the Preliminary Base Amount is determined by multiplying these two components:
$$\text{Preliminary Base Amount} = FBP \times AAIGR$$
2
Step 3: Application of the Statutory Floor: The 50% Rule
The state of Idaho, following federal tradition, imposes a statutory minimum on the Base Amount to ensure that the credit incentivizes increased investment rather than simply subsidizing existing research operations.
The 50% Requirement
The Final Base Amount used in the calculation must be the greater of two figures:
- The Preliminary Base Amount (FBP $\times$ AAIGR).
- The 50% Statutory Floor, defined as 50% of the taxpayer’s current year Idaho QREs.2
If a company experiences significant growth in QREs or if their historical FBP is low, the calculated Preliminary Base Amount will often fall below the statutory 50% minimum. In this scenario, the 50% floor of the current year’s QREs is adopted as the Final Base Amount. This constraint prevents the Base Amount from dropping too low, effectively capping the maximum incremental QREs at 50% of the current year’s spending, and thus limiting the effective credit rate to 2.5% (5% of 50%) of total QREs.
Final Credit Calculation: 5% of Incremental QREs
The Final Base Amount is subtracted from the Current Year Idaho QREs to determine the Incremental QREs—the amount subject to the credit.
The Idaho R&D Tax Credit is calculated as 5% of this resulting incremental amount 2:
$$\text{Idaho R\&D Tax Credit} = 5\% \times (\text{Current Year Idaho QREs} – \text{Final Base Amount})$$
VI. Detailed Example: Applying Fixed Base Percentage and the 50% Floor
To illustrate the critical interplay between the FBP, the Average Gross Receipts, and the 50% Statutory Floor, a numerical example for a multi-state manufacturer claiming the credit in the 2024 tax year is provided below. All figures represent Idaho-sourced activities, determined using Idaho’s multistate apportionment rules.
Case Study Setup: Data for an Established Idaho-Sourced Manufacturer (Year 2024 Credit Claim)
| Period | Idaho QREs | Idaho Gross Receipts (IGR) | Calculation Purpose |
| 1984-1988 (Aggregate) | $1,200,000 | $15,000,000 | FBP Determination (Base Period) |
| 2020 (PY-4) | $200,000 | $1,500,000 | AAIGR Determination |
| 2021 (PY-3) | $220,000 | $1,800,000 | AAIGR Determination |
| 2022 (PY-2) | $250,000 | $2,000,000 | AAIGR Determination |
| 2023 (PY-1) | $300,000 | $2,200,000 | AAIGR Determination |
| 2024 (Current Tax Year) | $450,000 | N/A | Current QREs |
Calculation 1: Determining the Fixed Base Percentage (FBP)
The FBP uses the aggregate 1984–1988 Idaho data.7
$$\text{FBP} = \frac{\text{Aggregate Idaho QREs (1984-1988)}}{\text{Aggregate Idaho Gross Receipts (1984-1988)}} = \frac{\$1,200,000}{\$15,000,000}$$
$$\text{FBP} = 0.08 \text{ or } 8.00\%$$
Since 8.00% is less than the 16% maximum cap 12, the FBP utilized is 8.00%.
Calculation 2: Determining Average Annual Idaho Gross Receipts (AAIGR)
The AAIGR is calculated using the four years preceding 2024 (2020–2023).2
- Total IGR: $\$1,500,000 + \$1,800,000 + \$2,000,000 + \$2,200,000 = \$7,500,000$
- AAIGR: $\frac{\$7,500,000}{4} = \mathbf{\$1,875,000}$
Calculation 3: Determining the Final Base Amount, Factoring in the 50% Floor
- Preliminary Base Amount: FBP $\times$ AAIGR
$$\text{Preliminary Base Amount} = 8.00\% \times \$1,875,000 = \mathbf{\$150,000}$$ - 50% Statutory Floor: 50% of Current Year QREs ($450,000).2
$$\text{50\% Floor} = 0.50 \times \$450,000 = \mathbf{\$225,000}$$ - Final Base Amount: The Final Base Amount is the greater of the Preliminary Base Amount ($150,000) or the 50% Floor ($225,000).2
$$\text{Final Base Amount} = \text{Max}(\$150,000, \$225,000) = \mathbf{\$225,000}$$
In this instance, the company’s research growth has outpaced the historical benchmark, causing the 50% statutory floor to dictate the final Base Amount.
Final Credit Computation and Analysis
- Incremental QREs: Current Year QREs – Final Base Amount
$$\text{Incremental QREs} = \$450,000 – \$225,000 = \mathbf{\$225,000}$$ - Idaho R&D Tax Credit: 5% of Incremental QREs.2
$$\text{Idaho R\&D Credit} = 5\% \times \$225,000 = \mathbf{\$11,250}$$
The analysis demonstrates that, due to the high historical data compliance burden often associated with the 1984-1988 base period, the Fixed Base Percentage often results in a calculated Preliminary Base Amount that is lower than the 50% statutory floor. When this occurs, the 50% floor automatically limits the incremental benefit, establishing a ceiling on the tax savings that can be realized through the Idaho R&D credit.
VII. Conclusion and Strategic Considerations for Idaho Taxpayers
The Fixed Base Percentage (FBP) is not merely a component of the Idaho R&D tax credit calculation; it is the fundamental historical determinant of eligibility and magnitude. By using the FBP to establish the Base Amount, Idaho reinforces its incentive structure, rewarding taxpayers only for spending that exceeds their established, historical research intensity relative to state-sourced gross receipts.
Multistate corporations seeking to maximize their Idaho R&D credit must dedicate significant compliance resources to accurate data sourcing. The need to apply Idaho’s multistate apportionment rules to historical 1984–1988 gross receipts, coupled with the strict requirement for Idaho-sourced QREs, demands meticulous documentation and expert interpretation of historical financial records. This need for historical reconstruction, or justification for the unavailability of such records, poses a primary audit risk.
For newer entrants or businesses demonstrating rapid R&D growth, the irrevocable start-up election, available via Part B of Form 67, presents a strategic compliance option. This election allows the taxpayer to bypass the reconstruction of decades-old data, substituting it with a calculable FBP based on more recent, auditable Idaho operations. However, the permanence of this election requires long-term modeling to ensure it optimizes tax benefits over the lifecycle of the company’s R&D efforts.
Ultimately, regardless of whether a company uses a high or low calculated FBP, the statutory 50% floor acts as the primary governor of the incremental credit amount for growing businesses. This minimum Base Amount ensures the state credit functions strictly as an incentive for expenditure growth, guaranteeing that no more than 50% of current year QREs are eligible for the 5% credit rate. This regulatory structure effectively caps the immediate benefit, focusing the tax relief on companies that consistently increase their investment in Idaho-based innovation.
Are you eligible?
Why choose us?
Pass an Audit?
What is the R&D Tax Credit?
The Research & Experimentation Tax Credit (or R&D Tax Credit), is a general business tax credit under Internal Revenue Code section 41 for companies that incur research and development (R&D) costs in the United States. The credits are a tax incentive for performing qualified research in the United States, resulting in a credit to a tax return. For the first three years of R&D claims, 6% of the total qualified research expenses (QRE) form the gross credit. In the 4th year of claims and beyond, a base amount is calculated, and an adjusted expense line is multiplied times 14%. Click here to learn more.
Never miss a deadline again
Stay up to date on IRS processes
Discover R&D in your industry
R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services
Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.
If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.
R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services
creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.
Our Fees
Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/
Choose your state
