Qualified Research Expenses (QREs) and the Idaho R&D Tax Credit: A Detailed Analysis

Qualified Research Expenses (QREs) are defined costs—primarily covering wages, supplies, and contract research—incurred during activities intended to develop or materially improve a product, process, or technology through a defined process of experimentation. In Idaho, QREs must be sourced entirely to research conducted within the state, strictly adhering to the fundamental framework established by federal Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 41.

The Idaho Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit, enacted under Idaho Code §63-3029G, serves as a crucial nonrefundable financial incentive designed to stimulate technological advancement within the state. This credit requires precise alignment with federal qualification standards for both activities and expenditures while imposing strict jurisdictional limits regarding where the work must be performed. For taxpayers, particularly multi-state entities, understanding the geographical sourcing rules and the intricate base amount calculation methodology is essential for effective compliance and credit maximization.

The Foundational Framework: Qualified Research Expenses under IRC §41

The structure of the Idaho R&D Tax Credit is inextricably linked to the federal R&D tax credit framework. Idaho Code §63-3029G mandates that the definitions used for “qualified research expenses,” “qualified research,” and “basic research payments” must align precisely with those specified in IRC Section 41.1 Consequently, federal eligibility is the non-negotiable prerequisite for claiming the Idaho state credit.

QREs Defined: Categorization of Eligible Expenditures

QREs are costs that represent a research and development expenditure in the experimental or laboratory sense.4 These expenses must be incurred in connection with the taxpayer’s trade or business and fall into one of three primary categories defined by IRC §41.5

1. Wages for Qualified Services

This category includes 100% of wages paid or incurred to an employee for performing, supervising, or supporting qualified services.5 Wages are defined according to IRC Section 3401(a).5 Qualified services consist of activities engaging in qualified research or directly supporting such research.5

For audit defense and compliance, determining the percentage of an employee’s time spent on qualified activities is crucial. The determination should not rely solely on job descriptions or titles, but rather on verifiable documentation proving the employee’s time was directly spent on activities meeting the Four-Part Test criteria and conducted physically within Idaho.7 This necessitates robust time-tracking mechanisms, such as project calendars, logs, and performance evaluations, to accurately substantiate the QRE claim.

2. Cost of Supplies Consumed

QREs include 100% of the cost of supplies.6 The term “supplies” is defined as tangible property other than land or improvements to land.5 These materials must be consumed or used up during the research process, such as raw materials used in the fabrication of a prototype or testing components.

3. Contract Research Expenses

Taxpayers may include 65% of amounts paid or incurred to unrelated third-party contractors for qualified research performed on the taxpayer’s behalf.6 If the research is prepaid, the expense is considered paid in the year the research is actually performed.8 This inclusion rate is subject to enhancement in Idaho under specific circumstances (detailed in Section 2.3).

Additionally, costs related to the rental or lease of computers used in qualified research conducted in Idaho may qualify. This expenditure is included if the computer is located off the taxpayer’s premises and the taxpayer is not the operator or primary user of the equipment.8

The Four-Part Test for Qualified Research Activity

To be eligible for inclusion as a QRE, the expense must relate to an activity that successfully meets all four criteria of the IRC §41(d) test.4

1. Purpose of Discovery: Elimination of Uncertainty

The activity must be undertaken for the purpose of discovering information that resolves technical uncertainty regarding the capability, design, or methodology used to develop or improve a business component.4 Taxpayers must demonstrate that they lacked certainty about how to achieve the desired result, requiring research to acquire the necessary information.

2. Technological Nature

The research must rely fundamentally on the principles of engineering, physics, chemistry, biology, or computer science.9 Activities rooted purely in social sciences, humanities, or management functions are explicitly disqualified.4

3. New or Improved Business Component

The activity must be intended to develop a new or improved business component. A business component can be a product, process, software, technique, invention, or formula.9 The improvement must relate to the function, performance, reliability, or quality of the component.

4. Process of Experimentation

The activity must involve a systematic process of experimentation, which typically includes evaluating alternatives, testing hypotheses, and documenting the iterative steps of trial and error.4 Demonstrating the existence of failed or iterative design efforts is often paramount to substantiating this element during an audit.

Exclusionary Activities

Certain activities, even if they appear to meet the general criteria, are explicitly excluded from qualified research 4: research conducted after commercial production has begun; work done solely to adapt an existing product to meet a specific customer’s requirements; duplication of an existing business component; consumer surveys and market studies; and research funded by grants or contracts.4

Idaho’s Adaptation: Sourcing and Statutory Requirements

Idaho’s tax law, specifically Idaho Code §63-3029G, adopts the federal standards but overlays a critical set of state-specific constraints, focusing intensely on geographical sourcing and calculation methodology.

Statutory Basis of the Idaho Credit

Idaho allows a nonrefundable credit against taxes imposed by Idaho Code sections 63-3024, 63-3025, and 63-3025A.10 The credit allowed is the sum of two distinct components 10:

1. Five percent (5%) of the excess of qualified research expenses for research conducted in Idaho over the calculated base amount; and
2. Five percent (5%) of basic research payments (BRPs) allowable under IRC Section 41(e) for basic research conducted in Idaho.

The Critical Sourcing Limitation

The most significant distinction between the federal and Idaho R&D credits is the sourcing requirement. Idaho law explicitly restricts eligibility to QREs and BRPs associated with research physically conducted within the state.3

Idaho Administrative Code Rule 35.01.01.720 reinforces this mandate, stating that only the amounts related to research conducted in Idaho qualify for the state credit, even though the definitions themselves conform to IRC Section 41.3 This geographic constraint dramatically increases the compliance burden for multi-state taxpayers. They must implement sophisticated cost accounting methodologies to prove the physical location of the employees performing the qualified services, the place where supplies were consumed, and the location where contract research was carried out. Accurate apportionment of these costs is the primary area of exposure for multi-state firms claiming the Idaho credit.

Modified Contract Research Provisions and Incentives

While the standard inclusion rate for contract research is 65% 6, Idaho offers an enhanced incentive for collaborations with specific educational and research institutions.8

Taxpayers may utilize a 75% inclusion rate for amounts paid or incurred to a Qualified Research Consortium, provided the consortium conducts the research in Idaho.8 A Qualified Research Consortium must be a tax-exempt organization described in IRC Section 501(c)(3) or 501(c)(6), organized and operated primarily to conduct scientific research, and must not be a private foundation.8 This increased rate is a deliberate state strategy to foster and incentivize partnerships between businesses and local institutional research bodies, potentially yielding greater credit value than utilizing commercial, for-profit contract research organizations.

Credit Management and Carryforward Provisions

The Idaho R&D Tax Credit is nonrefundable.6 The credit offsets Idaho income tax liabilities but cannot result in a tax refund.6 If the earned credit exceeds the limitation against the current year’s tax liability, the excess amount may be carried forward for a period not exceeding the next fourteen (14) taxable years.6 This lengthy carryforward period provides crucial long-term tax relief, especially valuable for research-intensive start-up companies or firms that may experience initial operating losses.

Idaho State Tax Commission Guidance and Compliance Procedures

Compliance with the Idaho R&D credit involves strict adherence to filing mandates and complex rules governing credit attribution and limitations, as enforced by the Idaho State Tax Commission (IDTC).

Filing Requirements and Documentation

The required mechanism for computing and claiming the state credit is Form 67, Credit for Idaho Research Activities.9 This form facilitates the application of Idaho-specific data—such as Idaho-sourced QREs and Idaho Gross Receipts—to the federal calculation structure.8

Taxpayers must maintain comprehensive records and documentation detailing eligible expenses and activities to substantiate the claim for verification purposes.12 Given the IDTC’s experience with processing substantial claims, the required level of documentation is rigorous and must be capable of surviving an audit, mirroring the scrutiny applied to federal R&D claims.2

Attribution and Sharing Rules for Complex Entities

Pass-Through Entities

In the case of S corporations, partnerships, trusts, or estates, the credit earned is a flow-through item. The credit is attributed to the shareholders, partners, or beneficiaries in proportion to their share of the entity’s income.11 This flow-through credit is reported to the recipient on Form ID K-1.8

Unitary Corporate Groups

For a group of corporations filing a combined report under Idaho Code §63-3027(22), the law permits the sharing of unused credit.2 A corporation that earns the credit but cannot utilize the full amount against its own tax liability may allow another member of the combined group to use the excess credit.2

Corporations claiming the research credit within a combined group must provide a detailed schedule with their return. This schedule must clearly identify the calculation of the credit earned and used by each member, the portion of the credit that is shared, and the computation of any carryovers.8

Credit Ordering and Limitations

The Idaho research credit is a nonrefundable credit subject to strict usage limitations. The total amount of the current year’s credit, combined with any credits carried forward, cannot exceed 100% of the tax due after the allowance of all other income tax credits that must be claimed before the R&D credit.3

The IDTC enforces a priority order for applying nonrefundable credits.3 Since the R&D credit typically ranks late in this sequence, higher-priority credits (such as the investment tax credit or credits for contributions to educational entities 8) will reduce the final tax liability first. This sequence frequently results in a substantial portion of the R&D credit being carried forward, emphasizing the strategic value of the 14-year carryforward period.

The Idaho Calculation Methodology: Incremental Credit Approach

The calculation of the Idaho R&D credit follows the federal regular method, focusing on the incremental increase in current-year QREs relative to a historically determined baseline.

The fundamental formula for the incremental credit component is:

$$\text{Credit} = 5\% \times (\text{Qualified Research Expenses Conducted in Idaho} – \text{Base Amount})$$

Calculation of Idaho Gross Receipts (IDGR)

The base amount is calculated using historical gross receipts. For Idaho purposes, gross receipts include only those amounts attributable to sources within the state, as determined by the multistate corporation apportionment rules (subsections (12) and (13) of Idaho Code §63-3027).2 These Idaho Gross Receipts (IDGR) are averaged over the four preceding taxable years.2

Determining the Fixed-Base Percentage (FBP)

The Fixed-Base Percentage (FBP) is the ratio of QREs to gross receipts during a specific historical base period. Taxpayers follow the instructions for Form 67, Part A or Part B, to compute this percentage.8

The Irrevocable Start-Up Election

Idaho offers a unique strategic advantage by allowing taxpayers to elect to be treated as a start-up company, even if they do not meet the strict criteria for federal start-up status under IRC Section 41(c)(3)(B).2

This irrevocable election permits the use of the federal start-up formula, applying Idaho-sourced data, which typically results in a favorable fixed-base percentage (federally capped at 16%).2 This provision is particularly valuable for established multi-state companies initiating new research operations in Idaho. By electing start-up status, these companies can establish a lower FBP based on their limited Idaho history, thereby significantly maximizing the incremental QREs eligible for the 5% credit during their growth phase in the state. Once made, this election cannot be revoked.6

Calculation of the Base Amount and the 50% Floor Rule

The Calculated Base Amount is determined by multiplying the Fixed-Base Percentage (FBP) by the average annual Idaho Gross Receipts (IDGR) for the preceding four years.6

$$\text{Calculated Base Amount} = \text{FBP} \times \text{Average Annual IDGR}$$

Crucially, Idaho law includes a floor rule: the Base Amount cannot be less than 50% of the current year’s total Idaho QREs.6 This 50% floor acts as a limiter, guaranteeing that a company must have QREs exceeding half of its current spending before generating an incremental credit. In practice, for rapidly growing companies, the 50% floor frequently becomes the Applicable Base Amount, meaning the maximum effective credit rate applied to total QREs is 2.5% (5% of the 50% excess).6

Comprehensive Calculation Example

To illustrate the mechanics of the Idaho R&D Tax Credit, consider a hypothetical entity, Advanced Circuitry, Inc. (ACI), which performs all its research activities within Idaho. The calculation demonstrates how the 50% floor rule impacts the final base amount determination.

Key Data Points for ACI (2024 Tax Year):

Step-by-Step Idaho R&D Credit Calculation (Form 67 Analog)

In this scenario, the historical average (Line 4) establishes the base at $\$1,200,000$. The $\$15,000$ credit is then subject to ACI’s Idaho income tax liability limitation. If ACI’s final tax liability is only $\$10,000$, the credit utilized in the current year is capped at $\$10,000$, and the remaining $\$5,000$ is carried forward for up to 14 years.11

Conclusion: Maximizing the Idaho R&D Credit Opportunity

The Idaho R&D Tax Credit provides a substantial incentive for companies engaged in innovation within the state, offering a 5% incremental credit rate and an exceptionally long 14-year carryforward period.6 Successful utilization of Idaho Code §63-3029G hinges not only on meeting the federal IRC §41 Four-Part Test but also on mastering Idaho’s specific sourcing, apportionment, and base calculation rules.

The critical compliance areas for Idaho taxpayers are rooted in geographic attribution and strategic planning. Multi-state companies must implement rigorous dual-jurisdiction cost accounting to ensure that wages, supplies, and contract research are demonstrably sourced to Idaho activities. Furthermore, the ability to make the irrevocable start-up election, even for mature companies expanding into Idaho, presents a valuable opportunity to establish a lower fixed-base percentage, thereby maximizing the incremental credit during periods of growth.

Taxpayers must also manage expectations regarding immediate utilization. Given that the credit is nonrefundable and ranks late in the application order for state tax credits, generating significant carryforwards is common. The longevity of the 14-year carryforward provision mitigates this, guaranteeing the credit’s long-term economic impact. Given that the state has successfully managed and committed large R&D incentives and observed substantial corporate claims 2, adherence to high standards of documentation and technical analysis for the Idaho claim is paramount for mitigating audit risk.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/