Contract Research Expenses and the Illinois R&D Tax Credit: A Comprehensive Analysis

Contract Research Expenses (CRE) represent payments made to third parties for qualified research activities, and only 65 percent of these amounts are eligible for inclusion in the taxpayer’s Qualified Research Expenses (QREs). This limitation, derived from federal law, is directly adopted by Illinois to calculate its state-level Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit.

The subsequent analysis details the technical definition of CRE, its specific application within the Illinois statutory framework (35 ILCS 5/201(k)), guidance from the Illinois Department of Revenue (IDOR), and the essential methodologies required for compliant credit calculation and maximization.

I. Executive Summary: Contract Research Expenses and the Illinois R&D Tax Incentive

The Illinois Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit is a vital, non-refundable incentive authorized under 35 ILCS 5/201(k), designed to encourage business investment in qualified research activities within the state.1 The credit is highly specific, aligning closely with the definitions and requirements of the federal Internal Revenue Code (IRC) § 41, while imposing a mandatory jurisdictional constraint that activities must be conducted in Illinois.1

The primary mechanism of the Illinois credit is its incremental structure, offering a rate of 6.5% applied to the excess of current-year Illinois-sourced QREs over a defined base amount.1 This incentive, which benefits sectors such as manufacturing, technology, and pharmaceuticals, has been consistently extended, providing crucial legislative certainty for long-term planning. Current extensions cover tax years ending on or before December 31, 2031.1

Strategic Importance of CRE Management

For many innovative companies, Contract Research Expenses (CRE) constitute a substantial and often variable component of their total QREs. The proper management of CRE is paramount, as failure to correctly apply the mandatory 65% reduction or failure to document the Illinois-sourcing of the contracted work can lead to significant disallowance upon audit. Furthermore, volatility in the timing and magnitude of CRE payments can strategically influence the three-year base amount calculation, which dictates the future availability and efficiency of the incremental credit. Thus, understanding the precise statutory and administrative treatment of CRE is fundamental to maximizing the overall Illinois R&D tax benefit.

II. The Federal Foundation: Defining Qualified Research Expenses (QREs) and CRE

The framework for Illinois’s R&D credit relies entirely on the federal definition of qualified research expenditures as set forth in IRC § 41.6 Under this federal statute, qualified research expenses are generally categorized into three main components: in-house research expenses (wages and supplies), contract research expenses, and basic research payments.6 Illinois adopts these foundational categories but mandates that the research activities and expenditures must be attributable to work performed within the state.1

A. Deep Dive into Contract Research Expenses (CRE) and the 65% Rule

Contract research expenses are defined under IRC § 41(b)(3) as a specific percentage of any amount paid or incurred by the taxpayer to any person, excluding employees, for the performance of qualified research.9 The precise statutory measure is that only 65 percent of the amount paid for contract research is eligible for inclusion in the taxpayer’s QRE calculation.8 If an expense does not meet the requirements set forth in IRC § 41(b), the expense cannot be claimed as a QRE.9

This 65% limitation serves a specific structural purpose within the tax code. When a taxpayer engages a third-party contractor, the total payment typically includes elements beyond the direct cost of research labor and supplies, such as the contractor’s profit margin, general overhead, administrative costs, and marketing expenses. By restricting the includible amount to 65%, the federal tax regime, and consequently the Illinois regime, accounts for these non-research components, aiming to standardize the value claimed to reflect only the taxpayer’s direct investment in the qualified research activity itself. This rule creates an immediate tax planning discount factor: every dollar outsourced for qualified research results in only $0.65 of incremental QRE value.

B. Differentiating Research Contracts from Service Contracts

Proper classification of agreements with third parties is critical, as federal guidance, which is applicable to the Illinois standard, differentiates between dedicated research contracts and general service contracts.9

In cases where a contract specifies a fixed price amount solely for the performance of qualified research, the entire amount paid under the contract is generally subject to the 65% limitation.9 This structure simplifies calculation, as the primary task is to confirm that the research meets the four-part test for qualification under IRC § 41(d).

Conversely, if a service contract is based on time-and-materials, such as an hourly rate for a vendor who may perform both research and non-research functions, the taxpayer must exercise detailed scrutiny. In such cases, only the amounts paid for the specific qualified research work performed by the vendor may be included in QREs, and these amounts are then subject to the 65% limitation.9 This necessitates robust tracking mechanisms to ensure the hourly work corresponds directly to technical activities designed to eliminate technological uncertainty.

For Illinois companies, this documentation requirement imposes a concentration of compliance risk. Because the Illinois Department of Revenue (IDOR) aligns with federal auditing techniques, taxpayers must maintain explicit evidence—such as detailed time sheets, project logs, or specific service work orders—that isolates the qualified research portion of a contractor’s billing. The absence of such clear demarcation may lead IDOR examiners to disallow the expense entirely during an audit review.

III. Illinois Department of Revenue (IDOR) Guidance and Legal Application

The Illinois R&D Tax Credit is codified under 35 ILCS 5/201(k), and the operational rules are further detailed in 86 Ill. Admin. Code § 100.2160.10 The credit is non-refundable and calculated at a rate of $6.5\%$ of the increase in qualifying research expenditures over the base amount.1 The extended sunset date for the credit, covering tax years ending on or before December 31, 2031, confirms its status as a reliable, long-term state incentive.1

A. The Mandatory Illinois-Sourced Activity Requirement

A critical divergence from the federal credit is the jurisdictional constraint imposed by Illinois law: “Qualifying expenses must be from research activities conducted in Illinois”.2 This geographic limitation applies uniformly across all types of QREs, including wages, supplies, and contract research.

For Contract Research Expenses, the “Illinois-sourced” mandate requires that the actual performance of the qualified research activities by the third-party contractor must physically take place within the boundaries of the State of Illinois. This goes beyond the mere location of the contracting company or the situs of the payment. For instance, if an Illinois-based firm contracts a research lab for $100,000, but the lab performs the necessary testing, prototyping, and analysis at a facility located in an adjacent state, the CRE payment is ineligible for the Illinois credit, even if the final report is delivered to the Illinois headquarters and the invoice is processed there.

This statutory requirement mandates that taxpayers maintain documentation—such as contractor invoices, detailed work reports, or certifications of the performance location—that explicitly confirms the physical geography of the research labor, placing a significant substantiation burden on businesses that utilize out-of-state contractors.

B. Administrative Guidance (86 Ill. Admin. Code § 100.2160)

The Illinois Administrative Code reinforces that “Qualifying expenses” are expenditures defined for the federal credit for increasing research activities that would be allowed under IRC § 41 and that are conducted in Illinois.2 This seamless incorporation of the federal definition automatically imports the 65% limitation on CRE into the state calculation.10

The Illinois statute also explicitly adopts the federal statutory exclusions, detailing activities that do not qualify for the state credit, even if costs are incurred:

• Research conducted after the beginning of commercial production.
• Research adapting an existing product or process to a particular customer’s need.
• Duplication of an existing product or process.
• Surveys or studies.
• Research relating to certain internal-use computer software.
• Research conducted outside Illinois (reinforcing the sourcing rule).
• Research in the social sciences, arts, or humanities.
• Research funded by another person (or government entity).2

The exclusion of “research funded by another person” is particularly pertinent to CRE. If a company enters into a contract research agreement where the payments are derived from a government grant, or where the research risk has been effectively transferred (constituting “funded research” under IRC § 41), those CRE payments are rendered entirely ineligible for inclusion in Illinois QREs, irrespective of the 65% rule or the Illinois-sourcing of the activity.2

C. Compliance and Filing Procedures

Taxpayers claiming the Illinois R&D credit must utilize specific forms issued by the IDOR. Corporations typically file Schedule 1299-D, while other entities like S-Corporations and partnerships use the appropriate variant (Schedules 1299-A or 1299-C), completing the required Research and Development Worksheet.1 Illinois also permits the use of unitary filing for combined groups, which requires complex internal allocation of QREs to ensure only eligible, Illinois-sourced expenses are included in the calculation.1

IV. Calculation Mechanics: The Incremental CRE Model

The Illinois R&D Tax Credit is fundamentally an incremental incentive, providing a $6.5\%$ benefit only on QREs that exceed a pre-determined historical average.3 The integration of CRE into this calculation follows a precise, multi-step process.

A. Defining and Calculating the Base Amount

The core of the incremental calculation is the base amount. The base period is defined as the three taxable years immediately preceding the current tax year for which the credit is being calculated.2 The base amount itself is computed as the average of the qualifying expenditures for each year in the base period.1

The formula for the base amount is:

$$\text{Base Amount} = \frac{\text{QRE}_{\text{Year}-1} + \text{QRE}_{\text{Year}-2} + \text{QRE}_{\text{Year}-3}}{3}$$

The inclusion of CRE significantly influences the long-term effectiveness of the credit. Since CRE often involves large, irregular payments for specific projects, a high level of CRE incurred during one of the three base years can disproportionately raise the average base amount. When the base increases, the threshold for incremental QREs in the current and future years rises, potentially decreasing the amount of “excess QREs” available for the 6.5% credit. Companies must therefore carefully model the effects of substantial CRE expenditures to manage the growth of the base period and maintain predictable credit generation.

For startup businesses that have no prior QREs in the three-year base period, the base amount is defined as $0.1 In this scenario, the entire current year’s Illinois QREs (including the 65% of CRE) are considered incremental, providing a significant initial credit opportunity.1

B. Integration of CRE into Total QREs (Step-by-Step)

The calculation process requires combining the federally defined CRE value with other Illinois-sourced expenditures before comparing the total to the historical base.

1. Identify Gross Contract Payments: The first step is to accurately determine the total gross payments made to non-employees for qualified research activities that were physically performed in Illinois.
2. Apply the 65% Rule: The gross payments for contract research must be multiplied by 65% to determine the specific dollar amount of Contract Research Expenses eligible for inclusion in QREs.
3. Sum Total Illinois QREs: The eligible CRE amount (65% of gross payments) is then aggregated with the other categories of Illinois-sourced QREs (100% of qualified wages, supplies, and computer rentals) to determine the Total Current Year Illinois QREs.1
4. Calculate Incremental QREs: The calculated Base Amount (average of prior three years’ Illinois QREs) is subtracted from the Total Current Year Illinois QREs. The result constitutes the “qualifying expenditures for increasing research activities in Illinois”.2
5. Apply the Credit Rate: The resulting positive amount of Incremental QREs is multiplied by the Illinois credit rate of $6.5\%$ to determine the final, non-refundable state tax credit.1

V. Case Study: Maximizing CRE in the Illinois R&D Tax Credit Calculation

To illustrate the practical application of the 65% rule and the incremental structure, consider a detailed scenario for a company relying on substantial contract research.

A. Scenario Setup: Research Dynamics Inc.

Research Dynamics Inc. (RDI) is an Illinois-based technology firm specializing in material science R&D. RDI regularly utilizes both in-house researchers and specialized third-party labs within Illinois. The following table summarizes their QRE components over a four-year period, demonstrating how CRE affects both the base and the final credit calculation in the Current Tax Year (Year 4).

Table I: Components of Illinois Qualified Research Expenses (QREs)

B. Step-by-Step Calculation Table

In Year 4, RDI invested heavily in a new prototyping project, incurring $800,000 in gross payments to an Illinois contract lab. This investment is compared against the QRE history from Years 1-3.

Table II: Illinois R&D Tax Credit Incremental Calculation (Demonstrating CRE Impact)

Note on Base Amount Calculation:

$$\text{Base Amount} = \frac{\$795,000 + \$1,042,500 + \$1,125,000}{3} = \$987,500$$

C. Case Analysis and Strategic Implications

The case study reveals several critical aspects of applying the CRE rules in Illinois. First, the gross investment of $800,000 in contract research in Year 4 only contributed $520,000 to the qualifying research expense pool due to the mandatory 65% limitation. This $280,000 exclusion demonstrates the cost of outsourcing qualified research activities relative to performing them in-house, where 100% of wages and supplies would qualify.8

Second, the calculation highlights the significance of the incremental hurdle. RDI incurred strong QREs of $1,720,000 in Year 4. However, the consistent and high level of prior-year spending, particularly the $1,125,000 QREs in Year 3 (which included $500,000 of gross CRE), resulted in a high base amount of $987,500. This high base substantially compresses the incremental QREs to $732,500, demonstrating that even significant current-year spending is heavily penalized by volatile spending in the base period. The resulting credit of $47,612.50 is available to offset RDI’s Illinois income tax liability, and any unused portion can be carried forward for a maximum of five years.4

VI. Compliance, Documentation, and Strategic Planning for CRE

Effective utilization of the Illinois R&D Tax Credit, especially involving Contract Research Expenses, necessitates rigorous documentation and forward-looking tax planning.

A. Best Practices for CRE Documentation

Taxpayers must ensure that all contract research documentation meets both federal standards for qualification and Illinois standards for sourcing. The underlying contracts themselves must clearly establish that the purpose of the agreement is to engage in qualified research designed to resolve technical uncertainty, distinguishing the work from routine testing or general consulting services.9

The most demanding requirement is geographic verification. Because the Illinois statute requires that the research be conducted in Illinois 2, documentation must explicitly confirm the location where the research labor was physically performed. This can include obtaining detailed invoices from contractors that break down labor hours by location, securing contractual certifications regarding the performance situs, or requiring internal log reports from the contractor’s research facility. If a contractor conducts the research across multiple states, the taxpayer must secure evidence allowing for a clear allocation of the research expense to Illinois before the 65% rule is applied.

Finally, internal financial tracking must separate CRE payments from in-house expenditures. This separate tracking ensures the accurate application of the 65% limitation before the CRE is aggregated with 100% of qualified wages and supplies to establish the total current-year QREs required for Schedule 1299-D filing.

B. Strategic Planning and Base Period Management

Given the incremental nature of the Illinois credit, taxpayers should treat the base amount not merely as a historical calculation but as a strategic planning variable. Large, irregular CRE payments, while generating an immediate credit, raise the three-year moving average base amount, which acts as a permanent hurdle for all subsequent credit years. This structural mechanism reduces the efficiency of future CRE spending in generating the state tax benefit.

Tax analysts must quantify the net present value of the immediate state credit generated by a large CRE payment versus the long-term cost of elevating the incremental threshold. When possible, businesses should consider timing large contract research projects or distributing the payments over multiple tax years. This helps manage base growth more predictably, preserving the long-term effectiveness of the Illinois incentive.

Furthermore, because in-house research expenses qualify at 100% while CRE is capped at 65%, there is a clear tax-efficiency incentive favoring internal R&D over outsourcing. Taxpayers should model whether the marginal costs of hiring internal personnel or acquiring equipment, whose associated costs are QRE-eligible at 100%, outweigh the expense of external contractors whose fees suffer the mandatory 35% reduction before inclusion.

VII. Conclusion: Leveraging Contract Research for Illinois Innovation

The Illinois R&D Tax Credit is a robust mechanism for encouraging innovation, leveraging the foundational definitions established by federal IRC § 41, particularly regarding Contract Research Expenses. CRE is limited to a 65% inclusion rate for QRE calculation, a critical constraint that must be meticulously factored into outsourcing budgets.

The successful utilization of this credit hinges on navigating two specific state-level requirements: first, ensuring that 100% of the contracted research activities are physically performed within Illinois, and second, accurately managing the incremental calculation against the three-year historical base. Companies that proactively document the geographic sourcing of contracted work and strategically manage the year-to-year volatility of their CRE spending will be best positioned to maximize the non-refundable 6.5% tax credit, realizing significant tax liability reductions through the credit’s confirmed extension period ending in 2031.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/