Qualified Research Expenses: A Technical Analysis of the Illinois R&D Tax Credit Landscape

The Illinois Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit is a nonrefundable, statutory incentive designed to drive in-state technological investment by leveraging the federal definition of Qualified Research Expenses (QREs).

Qualified Research Expenses (QREs) are defined as costs (primarily wages, supplies, and contract research) incurred during activities aimed at discovering technological information to eliminate uncertainty about the development or improvement of a business component. The Illinois credit equals 6.5% of these QREs that exceed the average of the QREs incurred over the preceding three tax years, provided the research is physically conducted within the state of Illinois.1

I. Executive Summary: Investing in Innovation in the Prairie State

The Illinois R&D Tax Credit serves as a critical fiscal mechanism to encourage innovation and technological advancement across various sectors, including manufacturing, pharmaceuticals, and technology.2 Codified under the Illinois Income Tax Act (IITA) Section 201(k) (35 ILCS 5/201(k)), the program is directly linked to federal tax law while imposing strict geographical limitations specific to Illinois operations.2

1.1. Strategic Value of the Illinois R&D Tax Credit

The core incentive offers a significant 6.5% credit against Illinois income tax liability for qualified research expenditures that exceed a calculated base amount.1 This nonrefundable credit provides substantial financial planning stability for companies operating in Illinois, as the state legislature extended the credit through tax years ending on or before December 31, 2031.2

The method of calculating the credit, which focuses on the increase over a base amount, fundamentally rewards growth in research spending within Illinois.2 This structure is not merely a subsidy for maintaining existing research efforts; rather, it is intentionally designed to accelerate investment. Companies must continually invest more heavily year-over-year relative to their historical average QREs to realize a substantial tax benefit. If a taxpayer’s current QREs remain static or decline relative to the average of the three immediate preceding years, the incremental excess will be zero or negative, resulting in no credit earned for the current tax year. This incremental model serves as a clear incentive for scaling manufacturers and technology firms to expand their R&D footprint within the state.2

II. The Foundational Definition of Qualified Research Expenses (QREs)

The State of Illinois defines Qualified Research Expenses by adopting, in full, the federal framework established under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 41.5 This reliance means that the highly detailed statutory and regulatory requirements of the federal credit must be met before any expense can be considered qualifying for the Illinois credit.

2.1. QREs Defined by Statute: IRC Section 41 and Illinois Alignment

QREs are costs incurred during the systematic process of developing or improving products, processes, techniques, formulas, inventions, or software that meet specific IRS requirements.6 The overarching principle is that the expense must be attributable to qualified research activities (QRAs).

The key eligible cost categories mirrored by Illinois from the federal definition include 6:

1. In-house Wages: Wages paid for qualified services performed by an employee, including direct research, supervision of research, or direct support of research.7
2. Qualified Supplies: Costs of tangible property consumed in the research process, such as raw materials used to fabricate and test prototypes. Crucially, this excludes depreciable properties, land or improvements to land, and general office materials.6
3. Contract Research Expenses: Amounts paid or incurred to third parties (contract researchers) for performing qualified research on behalf of the taxpayer. Only 65% of these expenses are typically includible in QREs.6

Because Illinois aligns its definition of qualified research expenditures with IRC § 41, the rigorous documentation and substantiation standards recently enforced by the IRS automatically apply to the state claim.8 If the IRS were to disallow QREs for inadequate documentation or technical justification during a federal examination, the basis for the corresponding Illinois QREs is simultaneously invalidated. This critical thematic link means corporate tax departments must prepare for the highest level of audit scrutiny for both federal and state claims simultaneously, emphasizing the necessity of robust federal compliance as a non-negotiable prerequisite for state tax benefit realization.

2.2. The Four-Part Test for Qualified Research Activities (QRA)

For any expense to be classified as a QRE, the underlying activity must satisfy all four elements of the test outlined in IRC Section 41(d). The failure to meet any single criterion results in the disallowance of all related expenses.9

2.2.1. Permitted Purpose (The Business Component Rule)

The R&D activity must be intended to develop or improve the functionality, performance, reliability, or quality of a new or existing business component.9 A business component may be a product, process, software, technique, formula, or invention.6

2.2.2. Elimination of Uncertainty (Technical Risk Assessment)

The objective of the research must be to discover information that resolves technological uncertainty regarding the development of the business component. This uncertainty can relate to the appropriate design, the capability of the component, or the method of its development.9 Establishing this element requires demonstrating that, at the project’s outset, technical unknowns existed regarding the component’s creation or performance characteristics.10

2.2.3. Process of Experimentation (Systematic Approach)

The taxpayer must demonstrate that the development process involves a systematic approach to resolving the technical uncertainty identified in the previous step. This process often includes systematic trial-and-error, modeling, simulation, or testing of alternatives.9 The documentation supporting this process is paramount. Recent Tax Court rulings, such as Phoenix Design Group v. Commissioner, have highlighted that a lack of contemporaneous, activity-level documentation proving this systematic experimentation is a critical reason for federal disallowances and upheld penalties.11 Consequently, Illinois taxpayers must be prepared to map their iterative tests and development phases directly to this statutory requirement.

2.2.4. Technological in Nature (Hard Science Requirement)

The fundamental principles used to resolve the technical uncertainty must be grounded in the physical sciences, biological sciences, computer science, or engineering.9 This criterion ensures that the credit is limited strictly to technical innovation and excludes soft sciences.

To provide a clear compliance overview, the necessary conditions for QRA are summarized below.

Table 1: Federal Four-Part Test for Qualified Research Activities

2.3. Explicit Statutory Exclusions from QREs

In aligning with federal law, Illinois specifically excludes several activities from qualifying for the credit. Taxpayers must meticulously screen their expenditures to ensure they do not claim costs related to these disqualified categories 7:

• Commercial Production: Research conducted after the beginning of commercial production of the business component.7
• Adaptation: Any research related to the adaptation of an existing business component to satisfy a particular customer’s requirement or need.7
• Duplication: Research aimed at duplicating an existing component by reverse engineering or similar methods.7
• Foreign Research: Activities conducted outside the geographic boundaries of the United States.7
• Social Sciences and Humanities: Research in the social sciences, arts, or humanities, or the conducting of surveys or studies.7
• Funded Research: Research where the taxpayer retains no financial risk or rights to the research results.7

III. Illinois R&D Credit (35 ILCS 5/201(k)): Statutory Mechanics

While the definition of QREs is federal, the calculation and application of the credit are governed by Illinois state law (35 ILCS 5/201(k) and 86 Ill. Adm. Code 100.2160).3 This state-specific framework introduces critical requirements regarding geography, calculation methodology, and utilization.

3.1. Legislative Authority and Extension

The Illinois R&D credit is a nonrefundable tax credit.2 This means it can only offset a current or future Illinois income tax liability; it cannot result in a cash refund to the taxpayer.2 The credit may be carried forward for a maximum of five years until it is fully utilized.2 The program’s statutory stability is reinforced by its extension through tax years ending on or before December 31, 2031.2

3.2. The Illinois Sourcing Mandate: QREs Must Be Performed In-State

The single most critical divergence from the federal credit is the requirement that qualifying research activities must be physically performed in Illinois.2

Strict In-State Focus

Illinois law dictates that QREs must be directly sourced to research activities performed within the state.2 Any expenditure associated with research conducted outside of Illinois, even if part of a broader development effort, is strictly disallowed for the state credit.2 This applies even to large unitary business groups, which must compute the credit on a combined basis but adhere to the Illinois sourcing rules for QRE identification.2

Allocation Requirements

For businesses with mobile or remote research personnel, meticulous allocation is mandatory. QREs claimed for employee wages and contract research must be accurately allocated based on the time and effort devoted to qualified activities specifically performed within Illinois borders.2

The combination of the stringent federal Four-Part Test and the demanding Illinois Sourcing Mandate creates a high compliance burden, particularly for multi-state or geographically distributed firms. Taxpayers must not only prove that the activity meets the technological uncertainty and experimentation criteria required by federal law, but they must also provide verifiable, location-based records to satisfy the state that the QREs were incurred entirely within Illinois. Illinois Department of Revenue (IDOR) auditors frequently focus on verifying the precision of this allocation methodology, necessitating detailed time logs, travel records, or location data for research personnel and subcontractors to ensure that no expenses generated outside the state are improperly included in the calculation base.

3.3. Credit Rate and Calculation Method: The 6.5% Incremental Model

Illinois mandates the use of the incremental calculation method, which measures the growth in research investment compared to the taxpayer’s historical average.2

3.3.1. Establishing the Base Amount: The Three-Year Lookback Rule

The credit rate is 6.5% of the current year’s qualified expenditures that exceed the base amount.1 The base amount is calculated as the average of the qualifying expenditures (QREs) incurred for the three taxable years immediately preceding the tax year for which the determination is being made.3

3.3.2. Rules for Base Calculation

The Illinois Administrative Code (86 Ill. Adm. Code 100.2160) provides specific rules for calculating the base period QREs 13:

• Zero Base Rule: If the taxpayer incurred no qualifying expenditures during any year in the three-year base period, the qualifying expenditures for that specific year are zero. This applies even if the taxpayer was not in existence or was not conducting business in Illinois during that time.13 This rule significantly benefits startups that have recently initiated R&D operations in Illinois.
• Annualization for Partial Years: If a taxpayer was conducting business in Illinois for only a portion of a base period year, the QREs actually incurred must be annualized. The calculation involves multiplying the incurred QREs by 365 and dividing by the number of days the taxpayer was doing business in Illinois during that partial year.13
• Mandatory Inclusion of Prior QREs: QREs incurred in base period years must be included in the base calculation, even if the taxpayer did not claim the Illinois R&D credit in those years.13

3.3.3. Non-Applicability of Alternative Methods

Unlike the federal R&D tax credit, which allows taxpayers to elect the Alternative Simplified Credit (ASC) method, Illinois strictly adheres to the incremental calculation based on the three-year average base.2 Taxpayers are not permitted to use alternative fixed-base percentage calculations.2

3.4. Credit Utilization: Non-Refundability and the Five-Year Carryforward

As a nonrefundable credit, the benefit is realized only to the extent the taxpayer has an Illinois income tax liability.2 Any unused credit may be carried forward for five subsequent years, or until fully utilized, whichever occurs first.5

The statutory mechanics of the credit are summarized in the following table.

Table 2: Key Parameters of the Illinois R&D Tax Credit (35 ILCS 5/201(k))

IV. Illinois Department of Revenue (IDOR) Guidance and Compliance

The Illinois Department of Revenue (IDOR) administers the credit, requiring specific forms and adherence to rigorous record-keeping standards to mitigate audit risk.

4.1. Claiming the Credit: Required Tax Forms and Schedules

4.1.1. Corporate Filing: Schedule 1299-D and Worksheet 1299-I

Corporations, trusts, and other fiduciary entities claim the Research and Development credit on Schedule 1299-D.2 The actual mathematical calculation of the credit earned in the current year is performed using the Research and Development Worksheet found within Schedule 1299-I.15 The resulting credit amount is then reported on Schedule 1299-D using Credit Code 5340.4 All dollar amounts reported on Schedule 1299-C (for individuals) and Schedule 1299-D must be rounded to the nearest whole dollar.17

Schedule 1299-D is used to calculate the available credit, combining credits earned in the current year (determined via Schedule 1299-I) and any amounts carried forward from previous years. The final claimable amount is capped by the current year’s remaining income tax liability after all prior credits have been applied.16 Taxpayers must reference their previous year’s Schedule 1299-C or 1299-D to determine the correct carryforward amount and the remaining years left to utilize the credit.15

4.1.2. Pass-Through Entities (PTEs): Distribution and Reporting

Partnerships, S corporations, and Limited Liability Companies (LLCs) acting as pass-through entities (PTEs) calculate the credit at the entity level but must distribute the benefit to their partners, shareholders, or members.5

• Distribution: The distributed credit amount is reported to the owners on Illinois Schedule K-1-P.4
• Claiming: Individuals or other entities receiving a distributive share claim the credit on Schedule 1299-C (for individuals filing IL-1040) or Schedule 1299-A.2 Supporting documentation, including the Schedule K-1-P, must be provided to validate any distributed credit claimed.4

A critical legislative update, effective beginning with the 2023 tax year, permits partnerships, S corporations, and LLCs to distribute the credit to owners based on a written agreement, rather than being strictly limited to the owners’ distributive share of income.5 This provision offers expanded tax planning flexibility for PTEs regarding the allocation of the R&D benefit.

The IDOR has explicitly cautioned taxpayers that administrative completeness is essential. Failure to follow these instructions and attach required documentation, such as supporting Schedule K-1-P forms for distributive shares, will result in a delay in processing, correspondence from the IDOR, or the outright disallowance of the claimed credit.4

4.2. IDOR Audit Risk and Documentation Standards

IDOR emphasizes that taxpayers must maintain records that sufficiently support the line-by-line items reported on their tax returns.20 For the R&D credit, audit scrutiny typically focuses on two major areas: the technical justification (federal standard) and the location substantiation (state standard).

4.2.1. Nexus of Activities and Expenses

Taxpayers must not only produce sufficient records proving the incurred costs but also demonstrate the nexus between the expenditures and the qualified research activities.20

• Technical Documentation: The technical documentation must be granular and robust enough to prove that the activity met all four parts of the federal test—particularly the existence of technological uncertainty and a systematic process of experimentation.11
• Sourcing Documentation: Given the strict Illinois geographic mandate, all documentation must verify that the research activities associated with the claimed wages, supplies, and contract research occurred within Illinois. For wages, this requires maintaining detailed time logs or payroll records that confirm the location where the research effort was expended.2

IDOR consistently identifies the failure to maintain proper records or the production of insufficient records as a persistent issue during audits, leading to delays and the establishment of liabilities.21

4.2.2. Audit Retention Period

While general income tax record requirements exist, taxpayers claiming the Illinois R&D credit are strongly advised to retain detailed documentation for a period extending beyond the standard statute of limitations.2 Because unused credits can be carried forward for up to five years, taxpayers must ensure they retain documentation supporting the year the credit was earned until five years after the credit is fully utilized, guaranteeing support in the event of an audit targeting any year of utilization.2

V. Practical Case Study: Calculating the Illinois Incremental R&D Credit

The calculation of the Illinois R&D credit adheres strictly to the incremental method, rewarding companies for increasing their QREs over their historical spending average. This methodical approach is mandatory; no alternative simplified methods are permitted.2

5.1. Methodology Step-by-Step

The calculation process involves four distinct steps based on the Illinois statutory requirements 2:

1. Determine Current Illinois QREs: Identify the total QREs incurred and sourced to Illinois for the current tax year (CY). This includes wages, supplies, and 65% of contract research expenses.
2. Compute the Base Amount: Calculate the average of the total Illinois QREs incurred during the three taxable years immediately preceding the current tax year (PY-1, PY-2, PY-3).
3. Calculate Excess QREs: Subtract the computed Base Amount from the Current Illinois QREs. If the result is negative, the excess QREs are zero.
4. Apply the Credit Rate: Multiply the Excess QREs by the statutory rate of 6.5% (0.065).

5.2. Numerical Example: Applying the 6.5% Incremental Rate

Consider an Illinois-based manufacturing company filing its Current Year (CY) return. The company incurred $1,000,000 in qualifying, Illinois-sourced QREs in the current year. The historical QREs for the three preceding tax years are as follows 2:

• Prior Year -1 (PY-1) QREs: $900,000
• Prior Year -2 (PY-2) QREs: $700,000
• Prior Year -3 (PY-3) QREs: $500,000

Table 3: Illinois R&D Credit Calculation Example (Incremental Method)

In this scenario, the company earned an Illinois R&D tax credit of $19,500 for the current tax year. This amount represents the incentive for the company’s investment growth relative to its three-year average spending.

5.3. Special Consideration: Maximization for Startups

The base calculation rules provide a significant advantage for startups or entities initiating qualified research activities in Illinois. If a company has been in existence for three years but has incurred zero Illinois QREs in those preceding years, or if it is a new entity, the base amount for the current year calculation is zero.2

When the base amount is zero, the entire amount of current Illinois QREs constitutes the “excess QREs,” allowing for a maximum credit realization.

• Example: Assume a company has $1,000,000 in Current Illinois QREs and $0 QREs in all three preceding years.

• Excess QREs = $1,000,000 – $0 = $1,000,000.
• Credit Earned = $1,000,000 $\times$ 6.5% = $65,000.2

VI. Strategic Recommendations and Conclusion

6.1. Strategic Best Practices for Compliance and Substantiation

To maximize the benefits of the Illinois R&D Tax Credit while mitigating exposure to IDOR audits, businesses must adopt rigorous, proactive compliance measures that address both federal definitions and state-specific sourcing rules.

1. Integrate Federal and State Compliance Protocols: Due to Illinois’ dependence on IRC § 41, all documentation supporting the technical eligibility of a project must meet or exceed the requirements for a federal audit. This includes meticulous records demonstrating the systematic process of experimentation and resolution of technological uncertainty for every business component claimed. Relying solely on financial records without corresponding technical narratives places the entire credit claim at risk of disallowance.11
2. Mandate Location-Based Tracking and Allocation: For companies with multi-state operations, implementing precise time-tracking and expense allocation methodologies is non-negotiable. Records must verifiably prove the physical location (Illinois) where qualified services were performed by employees and contract researchers to ensure compliance with the strict in-state sourcing mandate.2 Failure to allocate accurately based on time and effort will lead to automatic disallowance of those QREs by IDOR.
3. Proactive Management of PTE Credit Distribution: Pass-through entities should utilize the flexibility provided in the 2023 legislative update, allowing credit distribution based on a written agreement among owners. This planning step must be executed in conjunction with the preparation of Illinois Schedule K-1-P to ensure administrative compliance and prevent processing delays or disallowances by IDOR.4
4. Rigorous Record Retention: Given the five-year carryforward period, comprehensive technical and financial documentation for each claimed credit year must be retained for at least five years past the last year the credit is utilized, ensuring that the necessary records are available to support the claim should the IDOR initiate an audit.2

6.2. Conclusion

The Illinois Research and Development Tax Credit is a powerful, legislatively stable incentive for businesses committed to innovation within the state. The credit’s structure—offering 6.5% on incremental QREs over a three-year average—is intentionally designed to reward firms that exhibit sustained growth in their research investment. However, accessing this benefit requires navigating a complex compliance landscape.

Successful claiming of the Illinois R&D credit depends entirely on satisfying the strict federal definition of Qualified Research Expenses via the four-part test, coupled with meeting the mandatory state requirement that all activities generating the QREs be physically sourced to Illinois. This dual compliance burden demands sophisticated documentation practices, meticulous expense allocation, and rigorous audit preparedness to ensure the credit, which is nonrefundable and limited by a five-year carryforward, is fully and correctly realized against the taxpayer’s Illinois income tax liability.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/