Exhaustive Analysis of Qualifying Expenditures for the Illinois Research and Development Tax Credit

1. Executive Summary: The Illinois R&D Credit at a Glance

Qualifying Expenditures (QEs) for the Illinois Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit are defined as the research expenses allowable under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 41 that are conducted entirely within the State of Illinois.1 The credit is a nonrefundable incentive, equal to 6.5% of the increase in current-year QEs over a calculated 3-year historical base amount.3

The Illinois R&D Tax Credit, codified under the Illinois Income Tax Act (IITA) Section 201(k), serves as a crucial state incentive to encourage investment in innovation across key sectors like manufacturing and technology.4 The credit has demonstrated legislative endurance, having been extended multiple times, with its current authorization applying to tax years ending on or before December 31, 2031, providing significant long-term planning certainty for businesses investing in the state.4 Eligible entities include C corporations, S corporations, partnerships, and LLCs, with credits for flow-through entities passing down pro-rata to owners.4 Any credit claimed that exceeds the current year’s income tax liability may be carried forward for five years.6

2. Legal Foundation and Federal Nexus: Defining Qualified Research

The determination of what constitutes an Illinois QE begins and is fundamentally tied to the federal tax code, specifically IRC Section 41, which governs the federal Credit for Increasing Research Activities.1 Illinois law, governed by 35 ILCS 5/201(k) and detailed in 86 Ill. Admin. Code 100.2160, explicitly adopts the federal definition of “qualifying research expenses” but imposes a critical geographical limitation.1

2.1. The Requirement to Carry on a Trade or Business

To be considered a QE, an expense must first be a qualified research expense (QRE) under federal standards. This mandates that the expense be paid or incurred by the taxpayer in carrying on a trade or business.1 This is a fundamental requirement, ensuring the research activity is linked to the taxpayer’s commercial purpose rather than a hobby or pure academic pursuit.

2.2. The Dual Compliance Burden: Technical and Geographical

For a business operating in Illinois, the process of qualification involves navigating a complex dual compliance structure. The taxpayer must first prove that the activity meets the stringent federal technical requirements of qualified research. Subsequently, the taxpayer must apply a critical second filter: proving that the expenditure was incurred for activities physically conducted within the geographical boundaries of Illinois.1

This dual compliance necessity requires sophisticated recordkeeping. Simply passing a federal review on the technical merits of the research is insufficient for the Illinois credit. Taxpayers must meticulously track and allocate costs based on physical location, demanding robust time-tracking and expense allocation systems that specify precisely where R&D work was performed to establish the required geographical nexus for the state credit. This emphasis on in-state performance is vital, as the Illinois Department of Revenue (IDOR) considers claiming research activities conducted outside of Illinois a common audit error.10

2.3. The 4-Part Test: Activity Qualification Standards

All research activities associated with QEs must satisfy the four criteria established under IRC § 41(d), which Illinois incorporates.11 These criteria ensure that the claimed activities represent true innovation and systematic scientific endeavor:

1. Permitted Purpose (Qualified Purpose): The activity must be intended to develop a new or improved business component—a product, process, software, formula, or technique—that results in increased function, performance, quality, or reliability.12
2. Elimination of Technical Uncertainty: The activity must seek to resolve uncertainty related to the capability, design, or appropriate methodology necessary to achieve the desired new or improved business component.13
3. Process of Experimentation: A systematic approach must be implemented to identify, evaluate, and test alternatives to reach the desired result. This often involves modeling, simulation, or systematic trial and error.12
4. Technological in Nature: The experimentation process must rely on principles of the hard sciences, specifically engineering, physics, chemistry, biology, or computer science.11

2.4. Explicit Exclusions for Illinois QEs

Illinois law adopts federal exclusions, ensuring the credit is focused on specific types of research. Activities related to the following are not eligible for the credit 2:

• Research conducted after the beginning of commercial production.
• Research adapting an existing product or process to meet a particular customer’s needs.
• Duplication of an existing product or process.
• Surveys, studies, market research, or research in the social sciences, arts, or humanities.
• Research relating to certain internal-use computer software (though many software development costs do qualify).
• Research that is funded by another person or government entity.

3. Detailed Breakdown of Qualifying Expenditures (QEs)

QEs are categorized into specific costs incurred during the qualified research process. For the Illinois credit, these costs must be allocated only to research performed within the state.2

3.1. Wages for Qualified Services

Wages represent the compensation paid to employees engaged in qualified research activities in Illinois. The definition of “wages” aligns with IRC Section 3401(a) (W-2 income subject to withholding).8 Qualified services include three categories 8:

1. Performing Qualified Research: Hands-on execution of the experimental process.
2. Directly Supervising Qualified Research: Immediate oversight of the research team or process.
3. Directly Supporting Qualified Research: Services (e.g., technical writing, maintenance, administrative support) that are essential to the research activity.

A rigorous approach to compliance is mandatory, as wage documentation is a frequent target for audit adjustments. Due to the requirement that research must be conducted in Illinois 10, taxpayers must use sophisticated tracking mechanisms—such as time sheets or project allocation studies—to substantiate not only the percentage of time spent on qualified activities but also the physical location of the employee when those services were performed.15 This is particularly critical for remote or hybrid R&D teams, where claiming wages based solely on the company’s Illinois headquarters address, while the employee works in another state, poses a substantial audit risk.

3.2. Supplies and Raw Materials

Supplies included in QEs are the costs of tangible property, other than land or depreciable property, that are consumed or used up during the qualified research process.8

• Eligible Costs: Examples include raw materials, chemicals, small lab components, and materials used to build and test prototypes.16
• Ineligible Costs: Excluded expenses include capital equipment, general overhead, administrative costs, subscriptions, rent, leasing expenses (other than computer leases), travel, and meals.16

The cost of supplies is subject to close scrutiny by IDOR. Taxpayers must ensure that the financial records distinguish between materials consumed in the experimental phase and materials used in commercial production or capital assets that are subject to depreciation.16

3.3. Contract Research Expenses (65% Limitation)

When a taxpayer contracts with a third party (e.g., a university lab or specialized consultancy) to perform qualified research on the taxpayer’s behalf, only 65% of the amount paid to the contractor is eligible for inclusion as a QE.2

The restriction that contract research must be performed within Illinois is an essential distinction between the federal and state credits.2 If an Illinois company hires a research firm in California, that expense is eligible for the federal credit (subject to other limitations) but is entirely ineligible for the Illinois credit. This rule incentivizes Illinois businesses to utilize local research partners.

3.4. Rental or Lease Costs of Computers

Illinois explicitly specifies the inclusion of rental or lease costs of computers used in the conduct of qualified research.4 This is emphasized in the IDOR’s calculation worksheets, such as the Research and Development Worksheet in Schedule 1299-I.2 This category is especially relevant for modern R&D, covering costs associated with leased high-performance computing (HPC) resources, cloud services, and specialized software tools necessary for simulations, modeling, and data analysis directly related to the qualified activity, provided the use occurs in Illinois.

3.5. Basic Research Payments

For corporations only, QEs also include basic research payments, which are defined under IRC Section 41(e).1 These are payments made to qualified educational organizations for basic research performed within the state.2

Table: Eligible Illinois Qualifying Expenditures (QEs) Summary

4. Illinois Department of Revenue Calculation Mechanics

The Illinois R&D credit is calculated as 6.5% of the taxpayer’s incremental QEs. The term “incremental” refers to the amount by which current year QEs exceed the calculated base amount.3

4.1. The Incremental Calculation Methodology

The calculation requires three primary steps, as detailed in IDOR instructions and administrative code 4:

1. Current Year QEs: Determine the sum of all Illinois-sourced QEs incurred during the current taxable year (Line 6, Column B of the Schedule 1299-D worksheet).2
2. Base Amount Determination: Calculate the average of the Illinois QEs incurred during the three taxable years immediately preceding the current taxable year. This average constitutes the Base Amount (Line 6, Column A of the Schedule 1299-D worksheet).2 The three-year period is known as the “base period”.19
3. Credit Calculation: Calculate the excess of Current Year QEs over the Base Amount. The resulting figure is multiplied by the state credit rate of 6.5%.3

4.2. Rules Governing the Base Period

The rules governing the base period ensure a standardized calculation for all business types, particularly those new to the state or new to R&D.

• Three-Year Look-Back: The base period is strictly the three taxable years immediately preceding the tax year for which the credit is calculated.19
• Rewarding Growth and Supporting Startups: The structure of the incremental credit is designed to reward businesses that commit to increasing their R&D spending in the state. If a taxpayer was not in existence, or if they incurred no QEs during a base period year, the QE for that year is treated as zero.20 This rule is highly beneficial for startups or companies establishing new R&D facilities in Illinois, allowing them to potentially claim the 6.5% credit on their entire current-year QE amount if they have zero historical QEs.4
• Partial-Year Operations: If a taxpayer was doing business in Illinois for only part of a base period year, the QEs for that year must be annualized to determine the proper base calculation (QEs actually incurred multiplied by 365, divided by the number of days the taxpayer operated in Illinois).20

4.3. Reporting Requirements (IDOR Forms)

The Illinois R&D credit (Credit Code 5340) is claimed against the state’s income tax liability (IITA Section 201(a) and (b)).4 The calculation and claim are formalized on specific IDOR schedules:

• Corporations and Fiduciaries: Utilize Schedule 1299-D.15
• Individuals and Pass-Through Entities: Utilize Schedule 1299-C (Individuals) or Schedule 1299-A (Partnerships/S-Corps).3
• Unitary Groups: A unitary business group filing a combined Illinois return must complete a single Schedule 1299-D for the entire group, aggregating QEs only from activities conducted within Illinois.4
• Rounding: IDOR requires that all dollar amounts entered on Schedule 1299-D be rounded to the nearest whole dollar.23

5. Practical Application: Detailed Calculation Example

This example illustrates the calculation of the Illinois R&D Credit for a corporation (C-Corp) in its current tax year, Year 4, using incremental QEs conducted exclusively in Illinois.

5.1. Scenario Data

5.2. Calculation Steps (Tax Year 4)

Step 1: Calculate Base Period Average QEs (Years 1, 2, and 3)

The sum of QEs for the three-year base period is calculated:

$$\$500,000 + \$582,500 + \$725,000 = \$1,807,500$$

The average base amount is:

$$\frac{\$1,807,500}{3} = \$602,500$$

Step 2: Calculate Incremental (Excess) QEs

Incremental QEs are the current year’s QEs exceeding the base amount:

$$\text{Incremental QEs} = \$900,000 – \$602,500 = \$297,500$$

Step 3: Calculate Illinois R&D Credit

The credit is 6.5% of the incremental QEs:

$$\text{Credit} = \$297,500 \times 0.065 = \$19,337.50$$

Final Claim: Following IDOR rounding rules 23, the final nonrefundable credit claimed is $19,338.

6. Audit Risk Mitigation and Strategy

The nonrefundable nature of the Illinois R&D credit means that documentation standards must be exceptionally high, particularly regarding the state’s key compliance requirement: the geographical restriction.

6.1. IDOR Audit Adjustments and Geographical Nexus

IDOR auditors frequently challenge R&D claims, often finding that taxpayers incorrectly claimed credit for research activities that were conducted outside of Illinois.10 This constitutes a substantial audit risk. The underlying reason for this issue is that businesses often assume that if a QRE is valid federally and the company is domiciled in Illinois, the expense automatically qualifies for the state credit. This assumption overlooks the fact that the work must be physically performed in Illinois.2

To mitigate this risk, documentation must clearly establish the Illinois nexus for every dollar claimed. For employee wages, this means maintaining records that prove the employee was physically located in Illinois when performing the qualified services.15 For contract expenses, the taxpayer must obtain verification from the contractor as to where the services were executed.

6.2. Managing Federal Audit Outcomes

A critical consideration for Illinois taxpayers is the relationship between the federal and state claims. Taxpayers are required to report changes resulting from a federal Revenue Auditor’s Report (RAR) to Illinois within 120 days of the federal finalization date.10

If the IRS reduces the total federal QREs, that adjustment will inherently reduce the taxpayer’s Illinois QEs as well, forcing an amendment of the state return. For instance, if the IRS determines that certain activities failed the 4-Part Test, those expenditures must also be removed from the Illinois QE calculation. However, if a federal audit adjustment is based on QREs performed outside the US (which would be ineligible for the federal credit) but the remaining US-based QREs qualify, the Illinois claim may only be affected by the technical standard, not the location standard (assuming the taxpayer already filtered for non-Illinois domestic QREs). The requirement to proactively report these changes highlights the need for careful coordination between federal and state tax filings to avoid subsequent penalties.10

6.3. Documentation and Record Retention Requirements

IDOR requires robust documentation to support all line-item claims.24 Beyond the financial ledgers, taxpayers must retain records that demonstrate 16:

• Technical Justification: Project plans, technical reports, and experimental logs detailing the technological uncertainty addressed and the systematic experimentation performed.
• Personnel Allocation: Detailed time tracking (e.g., project codes, time sheets) accurately allocating employee time (and physical location) to qualified activities versus non-qualified activities.
• Expense Segregation: Clear separation in the general ledger between QEs and non-QEs, including distinguishing capital equipment from consumable supplies.

7. Strategic Conclusions

The Illinois R&D Tax Credit is a well-defined incentive, strategically mirroring the robust definitions of IRC Section 41 while adding the crucial constraint of in-state activity. This structure ensures that the credit dollar yields maximum economic benefit within Illinois, focusing on local job creation and research infrastructure.

The structural element defining the base amount—the three-year preceding average—provides a significant advantage for new businesses or those initiating large-scale R&D expansion in Illinois. By setting the historical base to zero for periods where no QEs existed, the state effectively offers the 6.5% credit on the entire first-year investment, acting as a powerful magnet for new corporate research investment.4

However, the state’s primary compliance challenge lies in the stringent geographical requirement. Businesses must move beyond generalized cost allocation and establish systems that accurately pinpoint the location of R&D labor and resource consumption. Proactive documentation of the Illinois nexus, combined with rigorous adherence to federal technical standards, is the definitive strategy for minimizing audit risk and maximizing the nonrefundable credit available under 35 ILCS 5/201(k).

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/