The Iowa Supplemental R&D Tax Credit: Analyzing the Enterprise Zone Program’s Legacy and the Looming 2026 Sunset

The Enterprise Zone (EZ) Program served as a prior administrative gateway allowing businesses approved for economic incentives to claim the highly valuable Supplemental Research Activities Tax Credit (Supplemental RAC). This Supplemental RAC provides an additional, tiered tax benefit (up to 10% of incremental research expenditures) beyond the standard Iowa Research Activities Credit (RAC).

The eligibility derived from the Enterprise Zone designation remains a critical reference point for many long-term corporate tax strategies in Iowa, though the program has largely been succeeded by the High Quality Jobs (HQJ) Program.1 The Supplemental RAC is distinct because its procurement requires successful qualification through a separate economic development framework, making it a powerful financial tool reserved for businesses that commit to significant in-state investment and job creation goals. Critically, businesses must understand that this lucrative incentive structure, along with the entire Research Activities Credit framework, is scheduled for repeal effective January 1, 2026, under Senate File 657 (SF 657).3

II. Foundational Context: The Iowa Research Activities Credit (RAC) Framework

The Supplemental Research Activities Credit is inherently linked to the state’s primary R&D incentive, the Iowa Research Activities Credit (RAC). The RAC is an incremental credit, meaning it only applies to Qualified Research Expenditures (QREs) that exceed a calculated base amount.5

A. Defining Qualified Research Expenditures (QREs)

Iowa’s R&D framework closely follows the standards established in Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 41 for defining eligible research activities.3 QREs must be incurred within Iowa and include four primary categories of expense 5:

1. Wages: Compensation paid for qualified research services performed in Iowa.
2. Supplies: The cost of supplies utilized directly in conducting qualified research.
3. Rental or Lease Cost: Expenses related to personal property used in conducting qualified research within the state. If the property is used both inside and outside of Iowa, the cost must be prorated based on the days used in Iowa versus total days used.6
4. Contract Expenses: Sixty-five percent (65%) of expenses paid to a qualified organization (such as a university or nonprofit) for basic research performed in Iowa.

B. Calculation Methodologies: Regular vs. Alternative Simplified Credit

The credit amount is determined using one of two methods, which must correspond to the method used to compute the federal R&D credit.5

1. The Regular Calculation Method

Under the Regular Method, the Iowa credit rate is 6.5% of the state’s apportioned share of the excess qualified expenditures.6 The core complexity lies in defining the base amount:

• Base Amount Definition: The base amount is the product of the fixed-base percentage multiplied by the taxpayer’s average annual gross receipts apportioned to Iowa for the four taxable years immediately preceding the credit year.3
• The 50% Floor: A crucial statutory provision dictates that the calculated base amount may, in no event, be less than fifty percent (50%) of the qualified research expenses incurred during the current credit year.3 This 50% floor ensures that the R&D incentive primarily rewards businesses that are actively growing their research investment beyond a minimum threshold, rather than merely subsidizing maintenance spending. Since the high-value Supplemental RAC is applied against these same “Excess QREs,” the rigor applied to the base calculation is financially critical.

2. The Alternative Simplified Credit (ASC) Method

If a taxpayer elects to use the ASC federally, they must use the equivalent method for Iowa purposes. The Iowa ASC rate is 4.55% of the difference between the current year’s QREs and 50% of the average of the prior three years’ Iowa QREs.3

III. The Enterprise Zone (EZ) and High Quality Jobs (HQJ) Supplemental Gateway

The Supplemental RAC is not a universally available credit; rather, it is reserved exclusively for businesses approved under specific state economic development programs administered by the Iowa Economic Development Authority (IEDA).

A. The EZ Program as the Original Gateway

Historically, businesses approved for incentives under the Enterprise Zone (EZ) program were granted eligibility for an “additional research activities credit”.11 The EZ program was designed to encourage investment, job creation, and economic activity in specified geographic areas, often by offering a suite of incentives including property tax exemptions, sales tax refunds, and investment tax credits.1 The additional R&D credit provided an extra impetus for innovation-intensive companies to establish or expand operations within these designated zones.

B. Transition to the High Quality Jobs (HQJ) Program

The HQJ Program has succeeded the EZ program as the primary mechanism through which the Supplemental RAC is awarded.8 The shift reflects a state policy focus on ensuring that tax incentives are explicitly tied to the creation or retention of high-paying, quality jobs.15

Crucially, the Iowa Administrative Code provides explicit grandfathering guidance for legacy claims. Any supplemental research activities credit earned by businesses approved under the enterprise zone program prior to July 1, 2014, remains valid and can be claimed on subsequent tax returns.16 This guidance confirms that the original EZ certification provides an enduring source of eligibility, provided the contractual mandates (e.g., job maintenance and investment obligations) were or continue to be met. For tax directors managing older projects, defending a Supplemental RAC claim requires meticulous historical documentation demonstrating compliance with the original EZ or HQJ agreement. The tax credit is viewed as an inseparable part of the underlying economic development contract.

IV. Statutory and Administrative Guidance: Claiming the Supplemental RAC

Successfully claiming the Supplemental RAC necessitates interaction with both the IEDA, which awards the underlying contract, and the Iowa Department of Revenue (IDR), which oversees the tax filing and calculation.

A. The Mandatory Tiered Rate Structure

The Supplemental RAC is structured with distinct rates depending on the size of the company, quantified by annual gross revenue. This tiered structure is a clear legislative effort to maximize the proportional incentive provided to small, growing businesses.5

• Small Firms (Revenue Less than $20 Million): These businesses can claim a supplemental credit of up to an additional 10% of their qualifying incremental research expenditures.5
• Large Firms (Revenue $\ge$ $20 Million): These businesses are eligible for a supplemental credit of up to an additional 3% of their qualifying incremental research expenditures.5

This Supplemental RAC is calculated using the same method (Regular or ASC) used for the standard RAC calculation.7

Table 1: Iowa Supplemental R&D Tax Credit Rate Structure

The maximum total effective rate is calculated as the sum of the standard 6.5% Regular RAC rate plus the supplemental percentage. This dual structure, which can achieve effective tax rates up to 16.5% on incremental research activity, underscores the strategic value of achieving the EZ or HQJ designation.

B. IDR Filing Requirements and Enhanced Refundability

The IDR administers the ultimate claim process. Taxpayers must file Form IA 128 (Regular Method) or IA 128S (ASC Method) and aggregate the results onto the IA 148 Tax Credits Schedule.10

A prerequisite for filing is obtaining certification from the IEDA, as the tax filing requires the inclusion of the tax credit certificate number.17 This requirement enforces the administrative link, confirming that the claimed tax incentive is tied to an official economic development award.

Iowa’s R&D credit system is notable for its refundability, a feature offered by only a minority of states.19 Furthermore, the Supplemental RAC receives preferential treatment regarding cash refund limits 3:

• The Regular RAC is subject to an 80% refundability limit on the excess credit amount.
• The Supplemental RAC is subject to an enhanced 90% refundability limit.

This enhanced refundability for the supplemental portion is a key policy mechanism. By guaranteeing 90% refundability on the most significant portion of the credit, especially for small firms benefiting from the 10% tier, the state effectively minimizes the cost of capital for qualified R&D activities within its targeted economic zones. This mechanism is structured for immediate economic stimulus and liquidity, as neither the Regular nor the Supplemental RAC permits the carryforward of any non-refunded excess credit amount.3

V. Case Study: Calculating the Full R&D Tax Benefit with the Supplemental RAC

This example demonstrates the comprehensive calculation of the Iowa R&D Tax Credit for a small firm (Annual Gross Revenue less than $20 Million) approved under the EZ/HQJ program, utilizing the Regular Method.

A. Scenario Inputs

A business has been approved under the EZ/HQJ program and has annual gross revenue of $18,000,000, qualifying it for the maximum 10% supplemental rate.

B. Step-by-Step Regular Method Calculation

The total credit is calculated by first determining the incremental research amount and then applying the two distinct tax rates (Regular and Supplemental) to that amount.

The Supplemental RAC generates $40,000 of the total $66,650 credit, meaning the EZ/HQJ designation is responsible for approximately 60% of the financial benefit in this scenario. This transformation of the R&D tax strategy from a marginal offset into a core financing mechanism is the primary advantage of obtaining the supplemental status.3

C. Total Refundable Value

The final cash refund is determined by applying the separate refundability limits to the components:

Table 2: Calculation of Total Refundable Tax Credit

The total cash refund of $57,320 underscores the program’s power to immediately inject capital into R&D efforts in Iowa, with a substantial portion of the cash flow originating from the EZ/HQJ supplemental benefit.

VI. The Legislative Horizon: Phase-Out and Strategic Planning (SF 657)

The generous incremental and supplemental credit structure, which has provided an uncapped incentive for R&D expansion, is facing a complete legislative overhaul driven by Senate File 657 (SF 657), signed in 2025.4

A. Repeal of the RAC and Supplemental RAC Structure

Effective for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2026, the existing Research Activities Credit (RAC), along with all supplemental credit provisions tied to the EZ/HQJ programs, will be repealed.3 This abolishes the complex incremental calculation based on the fixed-base percentage and four years of gross receipts data.

The repeal signals an end to the current system, which resulted in significant, uncapped outlays (taxpayers claimed $77.6 million in RAC in fiscal year 2024 alone).4

B. The Successor R&D Tax Credit Program

The new R&D Tax Credit Program, implemented through SF 657, fundamentally shifts the state’s approach from a formulaic, entitlement-based system to a capped, discretionary incentive program controlled by the IEDA.4

1. Reduced Rate and Program Cap

The new program severely curtails the financial incentive available:

• Maximum Credit Rate: The credit is capped at a maximum of 3.5% of QREs, regardless of incremental activity.3 This is less than a quarter of the total potential effective rate previously offered by the Supplemental RAC for small firms.
• Statewide Annual Cap: The IEDA is limited to awarding a total of $40 million in credits statewide annually.3 This imposes a stringent budget constraint, replacing the previous uncapped commitment.

2. Narrowed Eligibility and Application Requirements

Eligibility under the new program is highly restrictive. Businesses must be primarily engaged in one of four targeted industries—advanced manufacturing, bioscience, insurance/finance, and technology/innovation—and must fit into specific, highly defined sectors (e.g., second-generation food innovation, chip technology, aerospace, and pharmaceuticals).3

Furthermore, the process is now application-based, requiring businesses to first pre-apply with IEDA for certification and approval, demonstrating that they meet the defined sector and qualifying research standards.4 The shift from an uncapped, incremental credit to a limited, capped, and application-based program signifies a legislative transition toward strict fiscal control and highly targeted industrial policy. The formulaic incentive to aggressively grow R&D expenditures (as rewarded by the incremental structure) is replaced by a necessity to compete for limited funds based on meeting predetermined state economic development goals.

VII. Conclusion and Strategic Implications

The Supplemental Research Activities Tax Credit, rooted in the legacy Enterprise Zone Program and maintained through the High Quality Jobs Program, offered Iowa businesses one of the most generous R&D incentives in the United States, providing cumulative credit rates up to 16.5% on incremental research expenses with a highly favorable 90% refundability rate.

The strategic utilization of this credit required expertise in two distinct areas: economic development compliance (IEDA oversight) and complex incremental tax accounting (IDR calculation).5 The superior refundability rate provided substantial cash flow, transforming the incentive into an effective subsidy for targeted research projects.

The impending repeal of the RAC structure on January 1, 2026, necessitates immediate and aggressive strategic planning. Taxpayers currently claiming the Supplemental RAC must prioritize maximizing their final claims for the 2025 tax year. This means ensuring that comprehensive QRE documentation is finalized and that the incremental calculation base is optimized to maximize the utilization of the 10% or 3% supplemental rates before they sunset. After 2025, the incentive will shrink dramatically in both rate (maximum 3.5%) and availability (capped at $40 million statewide), requiring firms to pivot rapidly toward application and certification strategies under the new, highly discretionary IEDA-controlled program.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/