Strategic Report on Corporations Filing Combined Returns and the Maine Research Expense Tax Credit

A combined return for Maine corporations occurs when an affiliated group of businesses is treated as a single entity to accurately reflect their collective economic activity and tax liability. In the context of the Maine Research and Development tax credit, this filing method allows unitary group members to share credits across the organization after the generating member has exhausted its own liability.

The mechanism of combined reporting represents a sophisticated tax policy designed to capture the economic reality of modern corporate structures. By aggregating the income and losses of all unitary entities—those under common ownership and engaged in a shared economic enterprise—Maine ensures that the tax base is not eroded by intercompany transactions or the artificial shifting of profits to lower-tax jurisdictions.1 For businesses heavily invested in innovation, understanding how this reporting structure interacts with the Maine Research Expense Tax Credit, governed by 36 M.R.S. § 5219-K, is essential for maximizing tax attributes and maintaining compliance with Maine Revenue Services (MRS).3

Foundations of Combined Reporting in Maine

The principle of combined reporting is the hallmark of a “unitary business” tax methodology. Under this regime, the state views a parent company and its various subsidiaries not as isolated legal units, but as a single economic organism.1 This approach was identified in the mid-20th century as the primary solution for preventing multinational and multi-state corporations from reducing their tax liabilities through income-shifting strategies.1

The Unitary Business Concept

The determination of whether a group of corporations constitutes a unitary business is a factual inquiry focused on the degree of interdependence between the entities. Maine Revenue Services Rule 810 defines a unitary business as one where the activities of the group members are integrated with, dependent upon, and contributive to each other and to the operations of the group as a whole.2 The presence of centralized management, functional integration, and economies of scale creates a strong presumption of a unitary relationship.6

When an affiliated group is engaged in a unitary business and at least one member has nexus with Maine, a combined report is mandatory.2 This report serves as the basis for determining the taxable income of the unitary business, starting from the federal taxable income and adjusting for state-specific modifications.2

Water’s Edge Reporting versus Worldwide Combined Reporting

Maine currently utilizes a “water’s edge” methodology for its combined reporting regime. This means that only the income and attributes of unitary members that are required to file a federal income tax return in the United States are included in the state’s tax base.2 This methodology specifically excludes foreign subsidiaries that do not have a domestic filing requirement, unless they have elected to be treated as domestic corporations for federal purposes under the Internal Revenue Code (IRC).7

While the water’s edge approach is standard in most states, Maine has historically explored the potential for Worldwide Combined Reporting (WWCR). Under WWCR, the state would include the income of all unitary affiliates, including those operating entirely outside the U.S..1 The state’s history with this concept is punctuated by the “Augusta Formula,” developed in response to the Tambrands case. In that instance, the Law Court held that Maine could not include dividends from foreign affiliates in a taxpayer’s apportionable base without also including the factors of those foreign affiliates in the apportionment calculation.9 Consequently, the Augusta Formula allows for a calculation that uses a water’s edge method as a lower bound and a worldwide method as an upper bound in certain circumstances to ensure fair apportionment.9

Nexus Thresholds and Economic Presence

For tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2022, Maine established bright-line economic nexus thresholds. A corporation, or a member of a unitary group, is deemed to have nexus with the state if it exceeds specific financial benchmarks within a taxable year.10

These thresholds ensure that even if a corporation lacks a physical presence in Maine, its economic engagement is captured for tax purposes.10 In a combined return scenario, if any member of the unitary group meets these thresholds, the group must report its combined income, and the group’s total Maine sales are used to determine the apportionment factor.2

Statutory Framework of the Maine R&D Credit

The Maine Research Expense Tax Credit, authorized under 36 M.R.S. § 5219-K, is designed to reduce the financial risk associated with technological investments within the state.13 It is a non-refundable credit that closely aligns with the federal definitions found in IRC § 41 but is strictly limited to research conducted within the geographic boundaries of Maine.4

Calculation of the Credit

The credit is fundamentally incremental, meaning it rewards businesses for increasing their research efforts over time. The total credit is the sum of two distinct components 3:

1. The Incremental Component: This is equal to 5% of the amount by which the taxpayer’s qualified research expenses (QREs) for the current year exceed their “base amount.”
2. The Basic Research Component: This is equal to 7.5% of the basic research payments made to qualified organizations, such as universities or scientific research institutes, as defined under IRC § 41(e)(1)(A).

The “base amount” is uniquely defined in Maine as the average annual QREs incurred during the three taxable years immediately preceding the year the credit is claimed.3 This rolling average approach differs from the federal credit’s complex fixed-base percentage or alternative simplified credit (ASC) methods.4 For new businesses or those just beginning research activities in Maine, the base amount for the first year is zero, effectively allowing the 5% credit to apply to the entire first-year QRE spend.4

Qualified Research Expenses and Federal Alignment

Maine adopts the federal definition of QREs, which includes wages, supplies, and contract research expenses.4 However, the state imposes a strict “in-state” requirement. Only expenses directly related to research performed in Maine are eligible.16 The activities must also pass the federal “four-part test,” ensuring the research is technological in nature, intended for a permitted purpose, aimed at eliminating uncertainty, and involved in a process of experimentation.16

Guidance from the Maine Bureau of Revenue Services

Maine Revenue Services provides extensive guidance on the administration of combined returns and the R&D credit through a series of rules, most notably Rule 810 (Unitary Business Taxable Income, Combined Reports, and Tax Returns).

Rule 810: Unitary Business Taxable Income

Rule 810 explains the standards for determining Maine income tax for unitary businesses. A critical requirement is that the combined report must provide a bridge between federal taxable income and Maine net income.2 For members of a federal consolidated group, the separate federal taxable income of each member must be adjusted for eliminations and deferrals related to intercompany transactions.2

These intercompany transactions are eliminated or deferred to reflect the income of the unitary business as a separate economic unit, mirroring the logic of federal consolidated filing regulations.2 For instance, if one member of the unitary group sells inventory to another member, any gain or loss is deferred until the inventory is sold to an outside party.21

Rule 810.05: Unitary Business Returns

Unitary groups have two primary options for filing their Maine corporate income tax returns 2:

1. Single Return: Taxable corporations that are members of a unitary group may file a single return reporting the aggregate Maine income tax liability. This return is typically filed in the name and FEIN of the parent corporation if the parent has Maine nexus. All members in a single return are jointly and severally liable for the tax.12
2. Separate Returns: If the single return option is not chosen, each member with Maine nexus must file its own return. However, these separate returns must still be based on the same combined report, and each member must report the total combined income and modifications of the unitary business.8

Rule 810.03: Federal Deferrals and Modifications

When a unitary member is part of a federal consolidated group but the group also includes non-unitary members, special adjustments are required. If a unitary member did not receive the full benefit of a federal deduction (like a charitable contribution) because of the losses of a non-unitary member in the federal return, that member is permitted to take the adjustment on the Maine return to reflect what its benefit would have been as part of a standalone unitary unit.2

The Interaction: Credit Sharing and Limitations

The most complex aspect of combined returns in the context of the R&D credit is the mechanism for sharing credits among group members. This is governed by 36 M.R.S. § 5219-K(4) and Rule 810.07.

Section 5219-K(4) and the Hierarchy of Application

Under Maine law, credits generated by a specific corporation within a unitary group follow a “generator-first” rule.3 The statute outlines a strict hierarchy for credit usage:

• Priority 1: Generator’s Liability: The credit must first be applied against the Maine income tax liability attributable to the corporation that actually incurred the research expenses.3
• Priority 2: Group Sharing: If the generator has an “excess” credit—meaning the credit exceeds its own attributable tax liability—it may apply that excess against the tax due of another member of the unitary group.3
• Priority 3: Limitation Compliance: The shared credit can only be used by another member to the extent that the other member has remaining tax liability and has not hit its own corporate credit limitations.3

This sharing provision is an exception to the general rule found in Rule 810.07, which typically isolates tax credits to the entity that generated them unless the law “specifically provides otherwise”.23 Because § 5219-K(4) explicitly allows for this sharing, it provides a significant strategic advantage to unitary groups, allowing them to monetize credits that might otherwise be trapped in a loss-making or low-revenue subsidiary.3

Corporate Limitations and the $25,000 Threshold

The R&D credit is subject to a cap that prevents corporations from entirely wiping out their tax liability. The credit is limited to 3:

• 100% of the first $25,000 of the corporation’s tax due.
• 75% of the tax due in excess of $25,000.

For a group filing a combined return, these thresholds are applied with precision. The Assessor is authorized to adopt rules similar to IRC § 38(c)(5)(B) to apportion the $25,000 threshold among members of a controlled group.22 This ensures that a large group cannot multiply its $25,000 “full-offset” buckets by creating numerous small subsidiaries.24

Rule 810.07: Apportionment for Credit Sharing

When a credit is shared across the group, the tax liability of the group must be disaggregated to determine the individual member’s “share” of the tax. Rule 810.07 stipulates that the credit must be apportioned to each taxable corporation using its “separate apportionment factor”.23

This separate factor is calculated by taking the member’s own Maine sales (the numerator) and dividing it by the group’s total everywhere sales (the denominator), as adjusted for non-nexus entity sales.12 This ensures that the credit is shared proportional to the actual economic activity each member conducts in Maine.

Practical Application and Group Dynamics Example

To understand how the combined return rules interact with the R&D credit calculation and sharing mechanics, we can examine a hypothetical scenario involving a technology group operating in Maine.

Group Profile and Financial Data

Consider “Innovative Maine Group,” a unitary business consisting of three domestic corporations:

• Research-Unit Inc. (Generator): Conducts all R&D. No Maine sales.
• Sales-Unit Co. (Affiliate): Conducts all sales. High Maine nexus.
• Holdco Corp (Parent): Passive management. No Maine sales.

Step 1: Calculate the Maine R&D Credit Generated

Research-Unit is the only generator.

• Incremental Credit = 5% of ($1,000,000 – $600,000) = $20,000.
• Total Generated Credit = $20,000.

Step 2: Determine Combined Maine Tax Liability

The group files a single return.

• Combined Federal Taxable Income = $3,000,000.
• Apportionment Factor = $2,000,000 / $10,000,000 = 20%.
• Maine Net Income = $3,000,000 * 20% = $600,000.
• Assuming a flat 8.93% tax rate for this income bracket: Tax Due = $53,580.5

Step 3: Attribution and Sharing Hierarchy

Research-Unit incurred a federal loss of ($500,000). Its “attributable tax” is effectively zero.3

Because Research-Unit cannot use any of its $20,000 credit, the entire amount is “excess credit”.3

The group may share this $20,000 with Sales-Unit Co.

Step 4: Apply Corporate Limitations

Before Sales-Unit can use the shared credit, the limitation of § 5219-K(3) must be applied to the group’s tax due 3:

• Total Tax Due = $53,580.
• Offset allowed on first $25,000 = $25,000 (100%).
• Offset allowed on remaining $28,580 = $21,435 (75%).
• Total Maximum Credit Allowed = $46,435.

Since the generated credit of $20,000 is less than the maximum allowed offset of $46,435, the entire $20,000 can be used in the current year to reduce the group’s tax liability from $53,580 to $33,580.

Economic Statistics and Policy Evaluation

The Maine Research Expense Tax Credit is not just a regulatory requirement but a significant component of state economic policy. The Office of Program Evaluation and Government Accountability (OPEGA) regularly reviews the credit’s efficacy and fiscal impact.

Utilization and Claim Statistics

Historical data indicates that the R&D credit is a stable but relatively modest expenditure for the State of Maine.13

OPEGA’s evaluations highlight a critical policy tension: while the credit is essential to remain competitive with the 70% of states that offer similar incentives, Maine’s overall R&D performance has historically lagged.13 This has led to recommendations for better data collection to understand whether the credit is actually driving “new” innovation or simply subsidizing existing activity.25

Proposed Legislative Changes

Legislative efforts, such as LD 308, have sought to bolster the credit’s attractiveness. Proposals included 17:

• Doubling the incremental rate from 5% to 10%.
• Doubling the basic research rate from 7.5% to 15%.
• Increasing the 100% offset threshold from $25,000 to $50,000.

These measures aimed to stimulate higher-quality job creation, as businesses taking the credit are statistically likely to be spending on highly skilled research positions in the state.25 However, such changes are often weighed against the immediate fiscal impact on the state’s biennial budget, which saw general fund expenditures reach $5.4 billion in FY 2025.27

Compliance Procedures and Filing Requirements

Maintaining eligibility for the R&D credit in a combined return environment requires meticulous procedural compliance. Maine Revenue Services utilizes optical scanners for processing, meaning forms must be exact and unaltered.10

Mandatory Forms and Documentation

To claim the credit within a unitary group, the taxpayer must provide a comprehensive set of documents 16:

1. Form 1120ME: The primary Corporate Income Tax Return.
2. Form CR (Combined Report): Detailed breakdown of each member’s income, modifications, and sales.2
3. Schedule C (Tax Credits): The summary form where various credits, including R&D, are listed.29
4. Research Expense Tax Credit Worksheet: The granular calculation form for the current year.18
5. Federal Form 6765: A copy of the federal “Credit for Increasing Research Activities” must be attached to support the state-level claim.14

Electronic Filing and Payment

Maine has strict electronic mandates for larger taxpayers. Corporations with total assets of $5 million or more must file Form 1120ME electronically via the Maine Tax Portal (MTP).10 Furthermore, any taxpayer with a combined annual tax liability for all Maine taxes (sales, withholding, corporate) of $10,000 or more is required to make all payments electronically.10

Estimated Tax and Penalties

Unitary groups filing a single return must manage their estimated payments as a collective unit. Payments should be made under the name and FEIN of the corporation that will eventually file the Form 1120ME.10

• Due Dates: Estimated payments are due on the 15th day of the 4th, 6th, 9th, and 12th months of the tax year.10
• Safe Harbors: Payments must equal at least 90% of the current year’s tax or 100% of the previous year’s tax. “Large corporations” (those with $1 million+ in taxable income) cannot use the prior-year safe harbor.10
• Underpayment Penalty: For 2024, the penalty is 10%, compounded monthly, for insufficient or late quarterly payments.10

Conclusion

The intersection of combined reporting and the Research Expense Tax Credit in Maine represents a sophisticated regulatory framework that prioritizes the “economic unit” over individual legal entities. By allowing for the sharing of credits under 36 M.R.S. § 5219-K(4), Maine provides a powerful incentive for unitary groups to consolidate their innovation activities within the state. However, the non-refundable nature of the credit and the 75% limitation on higher tax offsets require strategic, long-term tax planning rather than simple annual calculations.

For corporate taxpayers, the value of the R&D credit is maximized through a deep understanding of Rule 810’s apportionment and sharing mechanics. As state policy continues to evolve—informed by OPEGA’s rigorous evaluations and legislative debates over credit rates—businesses that maintain meticulous contemporaneous records and align their federal and state filing strategies will be best positioned to leverage Maine’s support for technological advancement. Ultimately, the combined return is not merely a filing obligation but a strategic tool for managing the fiscal footprint of a modern, innovation-driven enterprise.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/