Conceptual Framework of Qualified Research Conducted in This State Within the Maine Research Expense Tax Credit

Qualified Research Conducted in This State refers to technological experimentation and developmental activities that satisfy the federal Internal Revenue Code Section 41 criteria while being physically performed within the geographic boundaries of Maine. Under 36 M.R.S. § 5219-K, this definition strictly limits eligible expenditures to wages, supplies, and contract costs directly associated with research labor and resource consumption occurring inside the state.1

The Maine Research Expense Tax Credit (RETC) represents a sophisticated intersection of state fiscal policy and federal tax definitions, designed to anchor innovation-driven industries within the local economy. While the credit is fundamentally structured to “piggyback” on the federal Credit for Increasing Research Activities, it diverges significantly by imposing a territorial restriction that necessitates a granular accounting of where every research dollar is spent.1 This distinction is critical for businesses operating in a modern, often decentralized, technological landscape. A corporation may qualify for federal research credits for activities performed across various global locations, but only the subset of those activities occurring within Maine’s jurisdiction is eligible for the 5% incremental state credit.5 This necessitates a rigorous nexus analysis, where the location of the researcher’s desk or the laboratory’s physical address dictates the eligibility of the associated expense. As the global economy becomes increasingly untethered from traditional office structures, the interpretation of “conducted in this state” by Maine Revenue Services (MRS) has become the defining factor in determining the actual net value of the incentive for Maine-based enterprises.2

Statutory Architecture and Federal Alignment

The legal foundation of the Maine Research Expense Tax Credit is codified in 36 M.R.S. § 5219-K, a statute that exemplifies the state’s reliance on federal tax standards to reduce administrative complexity while maintaining a specific regional focus. The law explicitly states that terms such as “qualified research expenses,” “basic research,” and “qualified organization base period amount” are to be interpreted in accordance with Section 41 of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC).2 However, this alignment is immediately qualified by the requirement that such expenditures must be for research conducted specifically within the state.2 This dual-track requirement means that a taxpayer must first satisfy the Internal Revenue Service’s (IRS) “four-part test” for qualified research and then further demonstrate the Maine-based nature of the activity to the satisfaction of Maine Revenue Services.5

The legislative intent behind this structure is to incentivize the physical presence of research operations in Maine, rather than merely rewarding companies with Maine headquarters for research performed elsewhere.1 This territoriality is essential to the state’s economic development goals, as it ensures that the tax benefit is tied to local job creation, laboratory investment, and the consumption of local supplies.1 The credit itself is non-refundable and functions as an incremental incentive, providing a tax reduction based on the increase in research spending relative to a historical average.1

The Incremental Mechanics of § 5219-K

The RETC is calculated as the sum of two distinct amounts, reflecting both internal corporate research and collaborative academic partnerships.1 The first component is an amount equal to 5% of the excess of the taxpayer’s qualified research expenses for the taxable year over the “base amount”.1 The second component is a 7.5% credit for basic research payments, which are typically amounts paid to qualified universities or scientific research organizations for research performed in Maine.1

The “base amount” under Maine law is uniquely tailored to the state’s specific data sets. It is defined as the average annual amount spent on qualified research expenses in Maine over the three taxable years preceding the current tax year.1 This rolling three-year average creates a dynamic baseline that rewards sustained growth in R&D investment. For new businesses or those without prior R&D activity in Maine, the base amount may be zero, allowing for a full 5% credit on initial investments.3

1

Detailed Analysis of “Conducted in This State”

The geographical limitation “conducted in this state” serves as the primary audit focus for Maine Revenue Services. This requirement applies to each of the three major categories of qualified research expenses: wages, supplies, and contract research.3

Qualified Research Wages and the Physical Presence Rule

Wages represent the largest portion of most R&D claims, and their eligibility hinges on the physical location of the employee at the time the qualified services are performed.3 For an employee’s wages to be considered QREs “conducted in this state,” the individual must be physically present in Maine.3 Qualified services include direct involvement in experimentation, direct supervision of researchers, or providing direct support to the research process (such as a lab technician maintaining experimental equipment).6

The shift toward remote and hybrid work models has introduced significant complexity into this determination. Maine Revenue Services has consistently maintained that the location of the services rendered determines the source of the income and the eligibility for the credit.11 If a Maine-based technology company employs a researcher who teleworks from a home office in Massachusetts, the wages paid to that researcher do not constitute expenses for research “conducted in this state,” even if the research results are owned by a Maine corporation and intended for a Maine-based product line.3 Consequently, companies must maintain rigorous time-tracking records that not only document the hours spent on qualified projects but also the physical location of the employee during those hours.3

Supplies and Tangible Property Consumption

Supplies qualify for the Maine RETC if they are consumed or used directly in the research process within the state.1 This typically includes chemicals, laboratory materials, prototype components, and electricity used specifically for research equipment.1 For these costs to meet the “conducted in this state” threshold, the consumption of the supplies must occur at a Maine research facility.3

Maine also offers a separate sales and use tax exemption for machinery and equipment used “directly and exclusively” in research and development.13 While the RETC is an income tax credit for operational expenditures (QREs), the sales tax exemption provides an immediate upfront benefit for capital investments in research infrastructure. To qualify for either, the equipment must be used for research that is “technological in nature” and intended to eliminate technical uncertainty.6

Contract Research and Third-Party Geographic Constraints

Under federal and Maine rules, only 65% of the amount paid to an outside contractor for qualified research is eligible for the credit.15 For Maine purposes, the 65% rule is further restricted by the requirement that the contractor must perform the research within Maine.2 This presents a strategic challenge for Maine businesses that require specialized testing or experimentation that may not be available locally.

If a Maine aerospace firm hires a specialized wind tunnel facility in Ohio to test a new wing design, the associated costs are ineligible for the Maine RETC because the activity was not “conducted in this state”.3 Conversely, if that same aerospace firm partners with a Maine-based engineering firm or a university laboratory within the state, the expense becomes eligible for the Maine credit.3 This geographic bias is a deliberate policy tool intended to foster a localized “innovation ecosystem” by encouraging Maine businesses to source their research needs from within the state’s borders.1

Maine Revenue Services Guidance and Procedural Compliance

Maine Revenue Services (MRS) provides administrative oversight through the issuance of tax bulletins, worksheets, and instructional materials.1 Taxpayers seeking to claim the RETC must navigate several specific procedural requirements to ensure their credits are recognized upon audit.7

The Role of the Research Expense Tax Credit Worksheet

The primary vehicle for claiming the credit is the “Research Expense Tax Credit Worksheet,” which must be enclosed with the taxpayer’s Maine income tax return (such as Form 1120ME for corporations or Form 1040ME for individuals).3 The worksheet requires a line-by-line reconciliation of federal research expenses with Maine-specific activities.7

A cornerstone of this process is the mandatory inclusion of federal Form 6765, Credit for Increasing Research Activities.5 MRS utilizes Form 6765 to verify that the research has met the rigorous federal definitions of qualified research before applying the Maine-specific geographic filters.5 If a taxpayer’s federal claim is adjusted or denied by the IRS, the taxpayer is legally obligated to file an amended Maine return to reflect those changes.16

Nexus and Remote Work: Post-Pandemic Clarifications

The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated temporary shifts in how MRS viewed “nexus” and physical presence.12 During the state of emergency, MRS provided relief stating that a corporation would not establish Maine income tax nexus solely due to the presence of remote employees in the state.12 However, with the end of the state of emergency on June 30, 2021, MRS resumed its standard policy: the presence of an employee in Maine, including a remote worker, is considered in determining both corporate nexus and the sourcing of wages for credit purposes.12

This means that for tax years beginning in 2021 and beyond, an out-of-state corporation with no physical office in Maine could potentially qualify for the Maine RETC if it employs a remote researcher residing in Maine.11 While this may create a small credit opportunity for the employer, it also establishes a tax filing obligation in the state.12 For the purpose of the “conducted in this state” requirement, the researcher’s home office in Maine becomes the location of the research activity.3

Apportionment and Rule 801

For businesses operating in multiple jurisdictions, Rule 801 (“Apportionment”) provides the framework for allocating income and expenses to Maine.17 While the RETC is based on actual Maine-based expenditures (a “direct tracing” method) rather than an apportioned share of total national R&D, Rule 801 remains relevant for determining the overall tax liability against which the credit is applied.17 For pass-through entities, the apportionment of research-related income and expenses follows the distributive share rules, ensuring that the credit flows to the owners in proportion to their interest in the entity’s Maine-based activities.7

Corporate Limitations and Fiscal Constraints

The RETC is designed to be a potent incentive, but it is not unlimited. Maine statute imposes specific caps on how much the credit can reduce a corporation’s annual tax burden.1

The Tiered Tax Liability Limit

The credit is non-refundable and cannot reduce a taxpayer’s liability below zero.1 For corporate taxpayers, the law further restricts the utility of the credit through a tiered formula 1:

1. Full Offset: The credit may offset 100% of the first $25,000 of a corporation’s tax due (as determined before any other credits).1
2. Partial Offset: For tax liability exceeding $25,000, the credit is limited to offsetting only 75% of that excess amount.1

This limitation ensures that corporations with substantial profits still contribute to the state’s general fund, even if their research investments are large.1 Any credit amount that remains unused due to these limitations is not lost; instead, it enters the carryforward pool.1

The 15-Year Carryforward Horizon

One of the most attractive features of the Maine RETC is its 15-year carryforward provision.1 Research-intensive industries, particularly biotechnology and pharmaceutical development, often incur massive R&D expenses for years or even decades before a product is successfully commercialized and generates taxable income.3 The 15-year window allows these firms to accumulate credits during their developmental phases and apply them against future tax liabilities once they achieve profitability.3 This long horizon effectively reduces the long-term cost of capital for startups and innovation-heavy firms.1

Unitary Businesses and Combined Returns

For corporations that are part of a unitary business and file a Maine combined return, specific rules govern the application of the RETC.2 A credit generated by an individual member of the group must first be applied against the tax liability attributable to that specific company’s Maine operations.2 If that company has excess credits, they may be applied to the tax liability of other members of the unitary group, provided those other members could use the credit under the general 75% limitation rules.2 This flexibility allows large corporate groups to maximize the benefit of research performed at specialized Maine subsidiaries.2

Historical Evolution and the Repeal of § 5219-L

To fully understand the current state of R&D incentives in Maine, one must look back at the “Super Credit for Substantially Increasing Research and Development,” formerly codified under 36 M.R.S. § 5219-L.5

The Legacy of the Super Credit

The Super Credit was a more aggressive incentive established in 1997 to reward companies that dramatically increased their R&D spending beyond their levels in the mid-1990s.3 It provided a credit equal to the excess of qualified research expenses over a “super credit base amount,” which was the average QRE for the three years preceding June 12, 1997.10

Because the base amount for the Super Credit was anchored to 1997, it became increasingly lucrative for growing companies as the years passed.1 However, the Super Credit was repealed for tax years beginning after 2013.5 Despite this repeal, the Super Credit remains a relevant topic in Maine tax law because of its carryforward provisions.1 While new Super Credits can no longer be generated, unused credits from prior years may still be carried forward, though for a shorter period (generally 5 years) than the 15 years allowed for the standard RETC.1

Comparative Impacts

The standard RETC under § 5219-K is widely viewed as a more sustainable, if less generous, incentive than the now-defunct Super Credit.1 While the Super Credit rewarded historical growth relative to the 1990s, the RETC rewards ongoing, current-year increases in innovation investment.1

3

Pass-Through Entities and Nonresident Owners

The Maine RETC is accessible to a wide range of business structures, including partnerships, LLCs, and S corporations.7 In these entities, the research activity occurs at the business level, but the credit is realized at the individual owner level.7

Pro Rata Distribution

Owners of pass-through entities are entitled to a share of the RETC in proportion to their ownership interest in the entity.7 This requires the entity to provide each owner with the necessary information (often via a Schedule K-1 and the Maine-specific RETC worksheet) to claim the credit on their personal income tax returns.7

The Nonresident Minimum Taxability Threshold

Nonresident owners of Maine businesses must be aware of the “12-day/3,000-dollar rule” found in Maine Rule 806.11 A nonresident individual is generally not subject to Maine income tax on personal service income unless they are present in Maine for more than 12 days during the year and earn more than $3,000 from Maine sources.11 However, this threshold applies to personal services (wages) and does not necessarily exempt a nonresident from being taxed on their distributive share of Maine-source business income.11 Consequently, a nonresident partner in a research-heavy Maine LLC can still benefit from the RETC, as the credit will reduce the tax liability generated by the LLC’s Maine-based operations.7

Audit Defense and Substantiation Best Practices

Because the RETC is a “piggyback” credit that also involves a strict geographic limitation, it is subject to a high degree of audit scrutiny.1 Taxpayers must be prepared to defend both the scientific validity of their research and the physical location where the research was performed.3

Contemporaneous Recordkeeping Requirements

Maine Revenue Services expects taxpayers to maintain detailed, contemporaneous records of their research activities.3 These records should ideally include:

• Scientific Documentation: Lab notebooks, project plans, and test results that clearly outline the technical uncertainties being addressed and the process of experimentation used to resolve them.6
• Time-Tracking and Location Data: Employee timesheets that allocate hours to specific research projects and identify the physical location where those hours were worked (e.g., a specific Maine laboratory or facility).3
• Supply Chain Records: Invoices and purchase orders for research supplies that document the point of delivery and the specific research project for which the materials were used.10
• Contract Documentation: Agreements with third-party research organizations that explicitly state the work is to be performed within the state of Maine, accompanied by reports from the contractor confirming the location of the work.3

The Four-Part Test as a State Requirement

While Maine Revenue Services focuses heavily on the geographic “conducted in this state” requirement, they also verify compliance with the federal four-part test.6 The research must be:

1. Technological in Nature: Based on physical, biological, or computer sciences.6
2. For a Permitted Purpose: Intended to create a new or improved business component.6
3. To Eliminate Uncertainty: Focused on resolving technical unknowns regarding design or method.6
4. A Process of Experimentation: Involving the systematic evaluation of alternatives.6

Failure to document any of these four elements can lead to a total disallowance of the credit at both the federal and state levels.1

Quantitative Impact and Economic Landscape

Data from the Office of Program Evaluation and Government Accountability (OPEGA) provides a statistical overview of how the RETC has been utilized by Maine businesses over the last decade.1

Statistics on Credit Utilization (2010–2019)

The annual fiscal impact of the RETC is relatively modest in the context of the total Maine budget, generally fluctuating between $2.5 million and $4.5 million in total credits claimed.5

5

Despite the availability of the credit, OPEGA noted that Maine has struggled to keep pace with national R&D benchmarks.4 As of 2021, Maine remained one of 35 states offering such a credit, but its overall R&D investment as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product has historically ranked in the bottom half of U.S. states.4 This has led to ongoing legislative discussions regarding whether the credit’s rates (currently 5% and 7.5%) are high enough to compete with neighboring states like Massachusetts.4

Sector-Specific Impacts: Manufacturing and Biotech

Manufacturing remains a primary beneficiary of the RETC, particularly those firms involved in the development of new medical devices or industrial processes.3 For example, a syringe manufacturer in Augusta has successfully utilized the credit for multi-year studies intended to improve product functionality and safety.6 Similarly, biotechnology firms in the Portland area leverage the 15-year carryforward to offset the high costs of laboratory wages and university collaborations.3

Case Study: Practical Application and Credit Calculation

To illustrate the interplay of state law and local revenue office guidance, consider the example of “Pine Tree Biotics,” a mid-sized C-corporation headquartered in Maine with a satellite research office in Vermont.

Scenario Parameters

For the 2024 tax year, Pine Tree Biotics reports the following:

• Total Employee Wages for R&D: $2,000,000.

• $1,200,000 paid to researchers working in a Portland, Maine laboratory.
• $800,000 paid to researchers working in the Vermont satellite office.

• Total Supplies Consumed in R&D: $200,000.

• $150,000 consumed in the Maine laboratory.
• $50,000 used in the Vermont facility.

• Basic Research Payment: $100,000 paid to the University of Maine for a specific study.
• Maine Base Amount (Average 2021–2023 Maine QREs): $1,000,000.
• Pre-Credit Maine Corporate Income Tax Liability: $100,000.

Step 1: Identify Qualified Research Conducted in Maine

First, the company must filter its federal expenses to identify only those “conducted in this state”.2

• Maine Wages: $1,200,000 (The Vermont wages are excluded).3
• Maine Supplies: $150,000 (The Vermont supplies are excluded).3
• Total Maine QREs for 2024: $1,350,000.

Step 2: Calculate the Qualified Research Expense Credit

The incremental credit is 5% of the amount by which 2024 Maine QREs exceed the 3-year base.1

• Excess QRE: $1,350,000 (Current) – $1,000,000 (Base) = $350,000.
• Credit Amount: $350,000 * 0.05 = $17,500.

Step 3: Calculate the Basic Research Payment Credit

The basic research credit is 7.5% of the qualifying payments made for research in Maine.1

• Credit Amount: $100,000 * 0.075 = $7,500.

Step 4: Determine Total Available Credit

• Total Current Year Credit: $17,500 + $7,500 = $25,000.

Step 5: Apply Corporate Tax Liability Limitations

The corporation has a tax due of $100,000. The § 5219-K(3) limitation must be applied.1

• Tier 1 (First $25,000): 100% of $25,000 = $25,000 limit.
• Tier 2 (Excess over $25,000): $75,000 * 0.75 = $56,250 limit.
• Total Limit: $25,000 + $56,250 = $81,250.

Since Pine Tree Biotics’ total available credit ($25,000) is less than the $81,250 limit, the company can utilize the full amount in the current year, reducing its tax liability to $75,000.3

Future Outlook and Legislative Trends

The landscape for R&D incentives in Maine is not static. Lawmakers frequently consider adjustments to the RETC to enhance its effectiveness and respond to changes in the federal tax code.4

Potential Enhancements: The Doubling Proposal

Recent legislative sessions have seen the introduction of bills like LD 308, which proposed doubling the credit percentages—increasing the QRE credit to 10% and the basic research credit to 15%.5 While such measures would significantly increase the fiscal impact on the state budget, proponents argue they are necessary to move Maine’s R&D ranking closer to the national average and to provide a stronger incentive for high-growth sectors.4

Alignment with the Section 174 Amortization Rule

At the federal level, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 introduced a requirement for companies to amortize R&D expenses over five years (for domestic research) or 15 years (for foreign research), rather than deducting them immediately.26 While this federal change primarily affects the timing of deductions, it has complicated the calculation of tax liability at both the federal and state levels. Maine has generally sought to maintain conformity with federal definitions, but practitioners must carefully track how these amortization rules influence the “base amount” and the final tax due calculation.1

Conclusion

The meaning of “Qualified Research Conducted in This State” within the Maine Research Expense Tax Credit is both a technical definition and a geographic mandate. By anchoring the RETC to physical presence, Maine Revenue Services ensures that the state’s tax expenditures are inextricably linked to the local economy. For businesses, this requires a dual commitment: first, to the scientific rigor of the IRC § 41 standards, and second, to the administrative discipline of tracing labor and supplies to specific Maine locations.

While the 5% and 7.5% rates are conservative relative to some other jurisdictions, the 15-year carryforward and the flexibility for pass-through entities and unitary groups provide a stable, long-term framework for innovation. As Maine continues to evaluate its position in the national R&D landscape, the Research Expense Tax Credit remains the primary fiscal tool for fostering a technological future within the state’s borders. For professional practitioners and business leaders, a thorough understanding of these nuances—from the rolling three-year base to the post-pandemic nexus rules—is essential for maximizing the value of Maine’s innovation incentives and ensuring compliance in an increasingly rigorous audit environment.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/