Strategic Analysis of Average Annual Gross Receipts within the Maryland Research and Development Tax Credit Framework

Average Annual Gross Receipts (4 Prior Years) refers to the arithmetic mean of a business entity’s Maryland-sourced revenue during the four taxable years immediately preceding the year for which the tax credit is claimed. This figure serves as the essential denominator in establishing a taxpayer’s historical research intensity and determining the statutory spending threshold required to qualify for the state’s incremental tax incentives.1

The role of this four-year average is foundational to the “incremental” nature of the Maryland Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit, as codified under Maryland Code, Tax-General $\S 10-721$. Rather than offering a flat rebate on all research expenditures, the Maryland Department of Commerce utilizes the Average Annual Gross Receipts to scale the taxpayer’s “Maryland Base Amount,” which functions as a competitive benchmark.3 By establishing a ratio between historical research spending and historical Maryland revenue, the state ensures that tax benefits are proportional to a firm’s growth in research effort relative to its economic footprint within Maryland’s borders.4 For businesses, this requirement necessitates a sophisticated dual-track accounting approach: one must not only track qualified research expenses (QREs) but also meticulously source gross receipts to Maryland using the complex apportionment rules defined in the Code of Maryland Regulations (COMAR) $03.04.03.08$.5 As the state moves toward more rigorous enforcement and market-based sourcing, the accuracy of this four-year average becomes a primary focus for auditors and a critical variable in the annual proration process that affects the final value of the credit.2

Legislative Context and Statutory Framework of the Maryland R&D Credit

The Maryland R&D tax credit was established to stimulate private sector investment in innovation, with a particular focus on high-technology sectors such as biotechnology, aerospace, and software development.2 The program’s efficacy is rooted in its alignment with federal standards, specifically Internal Revenue Code (IRC) $\S 41$, while maintaining unique state-specific modifications to ensure the economic benefits remain localized.3

The Evolution of the Maryland Credit

Initially, the program consisted of two distinct components: a “Basic” credit and a “Growth” credit.8 The Basic credit traditionally offered a $3\%$ incentive for expenses that did not exceed the Maryland Base Amount, essentially rewarding a baseline level of research activity.9 However, the Department of Legislative Services (DLS) and the General Assembly determined that this structure was less effective at incentivizing new or increased research.11 Consequently, through Chapter 114 of the Acts of 2021, the legislature repealed the Basic credit and consolidated the program’s total annual funding—currently $\$ 12$ million—exclusively into the Growth credit.11

Under the current regime, the Growth credit provides a $10\%$ tax credit for Maryland QREs that exceed the Maryland Base Amount.3 This shift emphasizes the importance of the Average Annual Gross Receipts, as they are the primary driver in determining the Base Amount threshold.2

Statutory Authority and Administration

The program is a joint effort between the Maryland Department of Commerce and the Comptroller of Maryland.3 While the Department of Commerce handles the application, evaluation, and certification of the credits, the Comptroller’s Office oversees the tax filing and audit processes.4

Defining “Average Annual Gross Receipts” (AAGR)

The term “Average Annual Gross Receipts” is not merely a total of a company’s sales but a localized metric that reflects the revenue “reasonably attributable to the conduct of a trade or business in the State”.3 This localization is what separates the Maryland credit from the federal credit, which utilizes global gross receipts for its regular credit calculations.14

The Four-Year Lookback Mechanism

The law requires a taxpayer to provide data for the four taxable years immediately preceding the year for which the credit is claimed (the “credit year”).1 For an application filed in 2025 for expenses incurred in tax year 2024, the lookback period would encompass the tax years 2020, 2021, 2022, and 2023.16

The averaging process follows a specific mathematical protocol 1:

1. Summation: Aggregate the Maryland gross receipts for each of the four prior years.
2. Averaging: Divide the sum by four (or the number of years the entity was in business, if fewer than four).
3. Proportionality: If the business has a short tax year (less than 12 months) in the current cycle, the average is adjusted by the fraction of the year the credit is being claimed.1

Treatment of Zero-Revenue and Pre-Operation Years

Revenue office guidance clarifies how to populate the four-year table on Form 500CR or the Department of Commerce application.1 If an entity was in existence but generated no revenue in a given year, it must enter “0” for that year.1 This “0” is included in the average, which naturally lowers the four-year average and, consequently, the Base Amount hurdle.2

Conversely, if an entity was not yet in business during one of those years, it should enter “NA” (Not Applicable).1 In this case, the denominator used to calculate the average is reduced.2 For example, a firm in business for only two prior years would divide the sum of its Maryland receipts by two, not four.2

Local State Revenue Office Guidance: Sourcing and Apportionment

The most technical aspect of the AAGR calculation is the determination of what constitutes a “Maryland” gross receipt. The Comptroller of Maryland directs taxpayers to COMAR $03.04.03.08$, which provides the definitive rules for attributing income to the state.4

Transition to the Single Sales Factor

Effective for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2021, Maryland transitioned to a single sales factor (SSF) apportionment formula for most corporate taxpayers.5 Prior to this, the state utilized a multi-factor formula that included property and payroll.5 Because the R&D credit requires a four-year lookback, current applicants must be careful to apply the sourcing rules consistently across the transition period, often needing to reconstruct prior-year sales data to align with current “market-based” sourcing standards.5

Market-Based Sourcing for Services and Intangibles

Under COMAR $03.04.03.08(D)$, receipts from the performance of services are sourced to Maryland if the “market” for the service is in the state.5 This is generally determined by the domicile of the customer.5

Sourcing by Customer Type

• Individual Customers: Receipts are sourced to Maryland if the individual is domiciled in Maryland.5
• Business Customers: Receipts are sourced to Maryland if the customer’s “principal impetus for the sale” occurred at an office in Maryland.5 If this cannot be identified, the headquarters or principal place of management is used as the default domicile.5

This market-based approach represents a significant shift from the “cost of performance” method used in many older tax regimes. For R&D-heavy firms—such as software-as-a-service (SaaS) providers—this means that revenue is sourced where the users are located, not where the developers are writing code.5

Sourcing Tangible Personal Property

For manufacturers and wholesalers, the “destination test” remains the primary rule.5 Receipts are included in the Maryland numerator if the property is delivered or shipped to a purchaser within Maryland, regardless of the f.o.b. point.5 This includes property in transit destined for the state.5

Treatment of Other Income Streams

Revenue office guidance provides specific treatments for miscellaneous income that must be included in the gross receipts calculation 5:

• Rental and Lease Income: Sourced to Maryland if the real or tangible personal property is physically located in the state.5
• Royalties and Interest: These are typically sourced based on the average of the property and payroll factors, a vestige of the multi-factor era that remains applicable for specific intangible income types.5
• Capital Gains: Gains from the sale of assets are sourced based on the location of the underlying property (real or tangible).5

The Mathematical Intersection: How AAGR Determines the Base Amount

The “Maryland Base Amount” is the hurdle that a company’s current-year R&D spending must clear to generate the $10\%$ Growth credit.3 The Average Annual Gross Receipts is the most influential variable in this equation.

The Formulas

The calculation follows a two-step process derived from IRC $\S 41(c)$ 3:

1. Maryland Base Percentage: This is the ratio of Maryland QREs to Maryland Gross Receipts over the four-year lookback period.2
   $$\text{Base \%} = \frac{\sum \text{MD QREs (Years -1 to -4)}}{\sum \text{MD Gross Receipts (Years -1 to -4)}}$$
   2
2. Maryland Base Amount: This is the product of the Base Percentage and the Average Annual Gross Receipts.2
   $$\text{Base Amount} = \text{Base \%} \times \text{AAGR}$$
   2

Analysis of the Mathematical Impact

Because the Base Percentage is essentially a ratio of spending-to-revenue, and the AAGR is the average revenue, the formula simplifies such that the Base Amount is often equal to the average R&D spend over the prior four years.2 However, the inclusion of “Gross Receipts” in the formula acts as a stabilizer.2 If a company’s revenue grows significantly while its R&D spend remains flat, its “Base Percentage” will decrease in future years, making it easier to qualify for the growth credit as a larger percentage of its current spend will exceed the (now lower) base amount.2

Conversely, if a company is pre-revenue or has zero gross receipts for the prior years, the “Base Percentage” calculation becomes impossible (division by zero).1 In these cases, guidance from the Department of Commerce states that the Base Amount defaults to the Average Maryland R&D Eligible Expenses.1

Short Tax Year Adjustments

For taxpayers operating on a partial year, the “Maryland Adjusted Base Amount” must be used.4 This prevents companies from claiming a full year’s growth credit for only a few months of operations.6

The adjustment is calculated as follows 6:

$$\text{Adjusted Base Amount} = \text{Base Amount} \times \frac{\text{Days in Tax Year}}{365}$$

4

This adjustment ensures that the historical “hurdle” is appropriately scaled to the length of the current tax period.6

Practical Example: Multi-Year Growth Scenario

To demonstrate the application of the law and guidance, consider a fictional Maryland biotechnology firm, “Chesapeake Bio-Labs,” applying for the credit in tax year 2024.

Chesapeake Bio-Labs: Historical Financial Data

The firm must provide the following data for its application 1:

Step-by-Step Calculation

Step 1: Calculate Average Annual Gross Receipts (AAGR)

$$\text{AAGR} = \frac{\$ 25,000,000}{4} = \$ 6,250,000$$

2

Step 2: Calculate Average Prior QREs

$$\text{Avg QREs} = \frac{\$ 3,200,000}{4} = \$ 800,000$$

2

Step 3: Determine Maryland Base Percentage

$$\text{Base \%} = \frac{\$ 3,200,000}{\$ 25,000,000} = 12.8\%$$

2

Step 4: Determine Maryland Base Amount

$$\text{Base Amount} = 12.8\% \times \$ 6,250,000 = \$ 800,000$$

2

Step 5: Calculate the Growth R&D Credit

$$\text{Excess QREs} = \$ 2,500,000 (\text{Current}) – \$ 800,000 (\text{Base}) = \$ 1,700,000$$

2

$$\text{Tentative Credit} = 10\% \times \$ 1,700,000 = \$ 170,000$$

2

Impact of Proration on the Final Award

Because the total statewide cap is $\$ 12$ million, Chesapeake Bio-Labs may not receive the full $\$ 170,000$.6 If, for instance, the total growth credits applied for by all large businesses in Maryland totaled $\$ 25$ million against an available pool of $\$ 8.5$ million, the proration factor would be $34\%$.6 Chesapeake Bio-Labs would then receive a final certificate for $\$ 57,800$.6

The Small Business Asset Test and Refundability

A critical distinction in the Maryland program is the treatment of “small businesses.” Unlike many other states that use revenue-based definitions for small businesses, Maryland uses an asset-based definition.2

Net Book Value Asset Threshold

A small business is defined as an entity with “net book value assets” totaling less than $\$ 5$ million at the beginning or end of the tax year in which the R&D expenses were incurred.2

The calculation of “net book value assets” is as follows 2:

$$\text{Net Book Value} = \text{Total Assets (including intangibles)} – (\text{Depreciation} + \text{Amortization})$$

2

It is important to note that liabilities are not subtracted for this purpose.2 A firm might have zero net worth due to debt but still fail the “small business” test if its gross assets (less depreciation) exceed $\$ 5$ million.2

The Benefit of Small Business Status

Qualified small businesses receive two significant advantages that large corporations do not:

1. Refundability: If the R&D credit exceeds the company’s tax liability, the state will issue a cash refund for the difference.2
2. Separate Funding Pool: $\$ 3.5$ million of the total $\$ 12$ million annual cap is set aside specifically for small businesses, which often results in a more favorable proration factor than the large business pool.3

Administrative Procedures and Compliance Requirements

Claiming the R&D credit in Maryland is a two-phase process: the Application Phase and the Filing Phase.8

The Application Phase (Department of Commerce)

Businesses must submit an online application to the Maryland Department of Commerce by November 15th of the calendar year following the tax year in which the expenses were incurred.6 This is a “hard” deadline; failure to apply by this date results in the loss of the credit for that year.9

The application requires:

• A detailed breakdown of Maryland QREs (Wages, Supplies, Contract Research).1
• A certified list of Maryland gross receipts for the prior four years.1
• For small businesses, a balance sheet demonstrating compliance with the $\$ 5$ million asset test.2

The Certification Phase

By February 15th of the subsequent year, the Department of Commerce issues a tax credit certificate.2 This certificate identifies the specific amount of credit the taxpayer is authorized to claim after proration.8

The Filing Phase (Comptroller of Maryland)

Once the certificate is received, the taxpayer must file an amended Maryland income tax return for the year in which the expenses were incurred.2 For example, if a company incurred expenses in 2024 and received a certificate in February 2026, it must go back and amend its 2024 return to claim the credit.3

The credit is reported on Maryland Form 500CR.8 The taxpayer must attach a copy of the Department of Commerce certification to the return.8

Strategic Implications for Business Entities

The structure of the Maryland R&D credit, particularly the role of Average Annual Gross Receipts, creates several strategic considerations for corporate tax planners and business executives.

Managing the “Incremental” Hurdle

Because the credit is based on exceeding a four-year average, companies with fluctuating R&D budgets may find it difficult to qualify.2 A “spike” in R&D spending followed by a period of steady-state research can result in a high Base Amount that effectively “locks out” the company from future credits until the four-year average drops.2

Executives responsible for site selection or facility expansion should note that the $10\%$ Growth credit is a substantial incentive for scaling innovative efforts, but it requires a sustained increase in investment to remain beneficial over multiple years.9

The 2025 Income Tax Benefit Transfer Program

Beginning July 1, 2025, a new program will allow eligible technology companies to transfer their unused R&D credits to other taxpayers in exchange for cash.12 This is a major policy shift that addresses the “liquidity trap” faced by large startups that have more than $\$ 5$ million in assets (and thus are not eligible for refunds) but have no tax liability to offset.12

Under this program, the transfer must be for at least $80\%$ of the credit’s value, providing a mechanism for firms to monetize their R&D efforts immediately.12 The maximum lifetime value of tax benefits a single company can transfer is capped at $\$ 15$ million.12

Interaction with Federal Section 174 Capitalization

Recent federal changes under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) require businesses to capitalize and amortize R&D costs over five years (fifteen years for international R&D) rather than deducting them immediately.21 While Maryland generally follows federal income tax laws, the R&D tax credit remains a distinct state-level incentive.13

Notably, for tax year 2025, new federal rules may allow small firms under $\$ 31$ million in gross receipts to accelerate certain R&D deductions.22 Taxpayers should consult with advisors to determine how these federal changes affect the “Maryland Modified Income” used as the starting point for state tax returns.5

Analysis of Recent Program Performance and Statistics

The Maryland R&D tax credit is one of the state’s most heavily utilized incentive programs, frequently reaching its statutory caps.

Program Utilization and Proration Trends

Historically, the program has been oversubscribed, particularly in the “Growth” and “Large Business” categories.2 The Department of Legislative Services reported in its 2024 reevaluation that while the program is popular, the $\$ 12$ million cap often leads to significant proration, which can dilute the incentive’s effectiveness for the largest spenders.11

Economic Impact in Key Sectors

The program is dominated by the information technology and life sciences sectors.2 In comparable state programs (such as Pennsylvania), the information sector receives the largest amount of credit per recipient, with a high concentration among software publishers and computer infrastructure firms.21 Maryland’s data explorer and annual reports suggest a similar concentration, with Montgomery County and the Baltimore corridor serving as the primary hubs for R&D credit activity.25

Conclusion: Navigating the 4-Year Lookback

The Average Annual Gross Receipts (4 Prior Years) is the linchpin of the Maryland R&D Tax Credit’s design. By tying the tax incentive to a ratio of research intensity, the state successfully encourages businesses not just to conduct research, but to increase their commitment to innovation over time.3 However, the complexity of this metric—requiring the integration of federal IRC $\S 41$ standards with state-specific COMAR sourcing rules—presents a significant compliance burden for taxpayers.3

For a business to successfully navigate this program, it must maintain a multi-year perspective on its Maryland-sourced revenue. The transition to single-sales factor apportionment and market-based sourcing means that the definition of a “Maryland gross receipt” is more customer-centric than ever before.5 Companies must meticulously document their prior-year sales, particularly when undergoing mergers or acquisitions, as the state’s successor-in-interest rules will pull that historical data into the current Base Amount calculation.2

Ultimately, the Maryland R&D credit remains a potent tool for corporate tax optimization. For small businesses with fewer than $\$ 5$ million in assets, the refundability feature provides a unique liquidity event that can fund critical development cycles.2 For larger enterprises, the $10\%$ Growth credit offers a meaningful reduction in the cost of scaling Maryland operations.6 By mastering the mechanics of the four-year gross receipts average, businesses can ensure they maximize their certified credits and remain audit-ready in one of the nation’s most innovative states.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/