The Comptroller of Maryland and the Research and Development Tax Credit: A Comprehensive Analysis of Fiscal Administration and Compliance

The Comptroller of Maryland is the state’s chief fiscal officer responsible for collecting tax revenue, enforcing compliance with tax laws, and processing the final application of the Research and Development tax credit on state returns. In this specific context, the Comptroller ensures that credits certified by the Maryland Department of Commerce are accurately reported, that necessary income add-backs are performed to prevent double tax benefits, and that refunds are issued to eligible small businesses.

The relationship between a business entity and the State of Maryland during the lifecycle of a Research and Development (R&D) tax credit is governed by two distinct yet interconnected state agencies: the Maryland Department of Commerce and the Office of the Comptroller. While the Department of Commerce acts as the primary administrator for the application and certification phase, the Comptroller’s Office serves as the ultimate arbiter of the credit’s fiscal realization. This involves a rigorous process of revenue administration, accounting, and compliance enforcement. As the “fiscal watchdog,” the Comptroller’s mandate is to ensure that every penny of tax expenditure—including the $12 million allocated annually to R&D incentives—is accounted for and applied in strict accordance with the Tax-General Article of the Annotated Code of Maryland.1 For the taxpayer, navigating the Comptroller’s guidance is as critical as the initial research activity itself, as a failure to comply with the state’s specific “add-back” requirements or electronic filing mandates can result in the immediate disallowance of the credit.3

The Constitutional and Administrative Role of the Comptroller

The Office of the Comptroller of Maryland is an elected executive position, distinct from the Governor and the Treasurer, designed to provide an independent voice on the state’s fiscal matters.4 This independence is vital when managing high-value tax expenditures like the R&D credit, which involves complex interactions with federal tax law and state-specific revenue goals. The Comptroller’s office is organized into several key divisions that directly influence the administration of business tax credits.

Revenue Administration and Operations

The Revenue Administration Division (RAD) is the most prominent interface for businesses claiming the R&D tax credit. This division is responsible for receiving and processing hundreds of thousands of corporate and individual tax returns each year.2 When a company receives a certification letter from the Department of Commerce, the RAD provides the forms and instructions—such as Form 500CR—that allow the business to technically “claim” the credit on their state filing.3 The division’s role is primarily mechanical but essential; it ensures that the math on the return aligns with the amounts certified by the state and that the taxpayer meets the filing deadlines.

The Bureau of Revenue Estimates (BRE)

While the RAD handles the paperwork, the Bureau of Revenue Estimates (BRE) handles the policy and economic forecasting. The BRE serves as the economic staff for the Comptroller and provides critical data to the Board of Revenue Estimates.2 In the context of the R&D tax credit, the BRE analyzes the fiscal impact of the program and monitors how changes in federal law, such as the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), affect Maryland’s revenue.2 This bureau is responsible for the “60-day report” issued whenever federal tax law changes, determining if those changes have a revenue impact of $5 million or more—a threshold that triggers the state’s automatic decoupling mechanism.6

Compliance and Audit Oversight

The Compliance Division is tasked with the enforcement of Maryland’s tax laws. This includes auditing businesses to ensure that the R&D activities claimed are legitimate and that the expenses incurred were truly Maryland-sourced.2 The Comptroller’s auditors work to verify that the “add-back” requirement (the addition of the credit amount back to the company’s taxable income) has been correctly calculated and reported on the tax return.3 This oversight protects the state’s general fund from “double-dipping,” where a company might otherwise receive both a federal deduction and a state tax credit for the same dollar of expenditure.

Statutory Authority and the Maryland R&D Tax Credit Program

The Maryland Research and Development Tax Credit is codified under § 10-721 of the Tax-General Article. The program was established to foster an environment of innovation, encouraging companies in sectors like biotechnology, pharmaceuticals, and advanced manufacturing to conduct their high-level research within the state.9

The Bifurcated Administration Model

The administration of the R&D credit is unique because it split between two agencies. Understanding this division of labor is crucial for compliance:

• The Department of Commerce: Responsible for the application process, verifying that research meets the federal § 41 definition, and issuing “Certification Letters”.9
• The Comptroller of Maryland: Responsible for the actual application of the credit to the tax return, processing refunds for small businesses, managing carryforwards, and enforcing the “add-back” modification.3

Eligibility and Qualified Expenses

Maryland adopts the federal definition of “qualified research” and “qualified research expenses” (QREs) as set forth in § 41 of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC).9 To qualify, the research must be “technological in nature,” involve a “process of experimentation,” and be intended to create a “new or improved business component”.10 However, Maryland adds a critical geographic restriction: the research must be conducted within the state to be eligible for the Maryland credit.11

Source: 10

Statutory Caps and Allocation

The Maryland General Assembly has set a strict limit on the total amount of R&D credits that can be awarded each year. Currently, the total cap is $12 million.9 Because the program is frequently oversubscribed, the Department of Commerce must prorate the credits among all qualified applicants.9

Note: Small businesses are those with net book value assets of less than $5 million at the beginning or end of the tax year.9

Administrative Guidance: The “Add-Back” Requirement

One of the most frequent points of confusion—and a primary focus of Comptroller guidance—is the “addition modification” or “add-back” requirement. This is the mechanism by which Maryland ensures that the tax credit does not result in an unfair “double benefit” to the taxpayer.3

The Mechanics of the Add-Back

When a business incurs R&D expenses, it typically deducts those expenses from its gross income on its federal tax return. This reduction in federal taxable income naturally flows through to the Maryland return, as Maryland is a “conformity” state whose tax calculation begins with the federal taxable income (for corporations) or federal adjusted gross income (for individuals).6

If Maryland then allows the business to take a tax credit (a dollar-for-dollar reduction in tax liability) based on those same expenses, the business has effectively benefitted twice from the same dollar spent. To prevent this, the Comptroller’s official instructions for Form 500CR and Form 500 (Corporate Income Tax Return) mandate that the taxpayer must add the amount of the credit back to their state income.3

Where to Report the Addition Modification

The Comptroller provides specific guidance on where this modification must be placed on the return. For a corporation, this is typically done on Line 7f of Form 500.3 For individuals, it is reported as an “Other Addition” on Form 502, using Code Letter ‘l’.8

Source: 3

The implication of this guidance is that the net benefit of the 10% R&D credit is slightly less than 10% after the add-back is taxed at the state’s marginal rate. However, for a small business receiving a $250,000 credit (the maximum per applicant), the liquid refund far outweighs the tax cost of the addition modification.9

Small Business Provisions and the Asset Threshold

The Comptroller’s Office plays a vital role in executing the “small business” provisions of the R&D tax credit, which are among the most generous in the nation. The key distinction for small businesses is refundability.9

Defining a Small Business for Tax Purposes

To be certified as a small business, an entity must demonstrate that its “net book value assets” total less than $5 million at the beginning or the end of the taxable year.9 The Comptroller’s guidance, mirroring the statutory language in § 10-721, defines “net book value assets” as the total cost of all assets (including intangibles like patents) minus any accumulated depreciation or amortization. Crucially, liabilities are not subtracted in this calculation; it is a measure of asset scale, not net worth.10

The Refundability Mechanism

For a large corporation, if the R&D credit exceeds their tax liability, they must carry the excess forward to the next year. They do not receive a check from the state. For a certified small business, however, the credit is “fully refundable”.9 This means that if a startup has $0 in tax liability but is certified for a $50,000 R&D credit, the Comptroller’s Revenue Administration Division will issue a refund check for the full $50,000.9

This provides immediate “non-dilutive” capital to early-stage ventures. The Comptroller’s office manages this through Part K-II of Form 500CR (Refundable Research and Development Tax Credits).3

The Technical Calculation of the Maryland Credit

The Maryland R&D credit is an “incremental” credit, meaning it is designed to reward companies for increasing their research spending over time. The calculation involves two components: the “Basic” credit and the “Growth” credit.10

The Maryland Base Amount

The “Base Amount” is the benchmark against which current year spending is measured. It is calculated by multiplying the company’s “Maryland Base Percentage” by its average annual Maryland gross receipts for the preceding four years.10

Step-by-Step Calculation Example

Consider a biotechnology firm with the following financials for the current year (2024) and the prior four years (2020-2023).

1. Calculate the Fixed-Base Percentage:

The sum of prior QREs ($2,400,000) divided by the sum of prior gross receipts ($48,000,000) equals 5.0%.10

2. Calculate the Average Annual Gross Receipts:

The sum of prior gross receipts ($48,000,000) divided by 4 equals $12,000,000.10

3. Determine the Maryland Base Amount:

The Fixed-Base Percentage (5.0%) multiplied by the average annual gross receipts ($12,000,000) equals $600,000.10

4. Calculate the Growth Credit:

Current year QREs ($1,500,000) minus the Base Amount ($600,000) equals the excess QREs of $900,000. The Growth Credit is 10% of this excess, which is $90,000.9

5. Calculate the Basic Credit:

The Basic Credit is 3% of the QREs that do not exceed the Base Amount. In this case, 3% of $600,000 equals $18,000.12

6. Total Potential Credit:

$90,000 (Growth) + $18,000 (Basic) = $108,000.16

Note: This amount is subject to proration by the Department of Commerce if the statewide cap is exceeded.9

Federal Conformity, Decoupling, and the “OBBBA” Impact

The Comptroller of Maryland must constantly interpret how federal tax changes impact the state’s revenue. This is particularly relevant given the recent volatility in federal R&D tax treatment.

The Decoupling Mechanism

Under Maryland Tax-General Article § 10-108, Maryland is a “rolling conformity” state, but it automatically “decouples” from any federal change that has a revenue impact of $5 million or more in the year of enactment.6 The Bureau of Revenue Estimates (BRE) is the agency that makes this determination.6

The Section 174 Controversy

Historically, businesses could “expense” R&D costs immediately under IRC § 174. The federal Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) changed this, requiring businesses to “capitalize and amortize” these costs over five years starting in 2022.21 This change reduced the immediate value of the tax credit for many manufacturers and tech firms.21

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) of 2025

In July 2025, the federal government enacted the OBBBA, which sought to reverse the TCJA’s capitalization rules and restore immediate “full expensing” for domestic R&D costs.22

However, in September 2025, the Maryland Comptroller issued an analysis determining that the OBBBA’s changes to IRC § 174 would have a revenue impact of more than $5 million for the 2025 tax year. Consequently, Maryland has decoupled from the OBBBA’s full-expensing provisions for 2025.7

Implication for Businesses:

A company may be allowed to fully expense its R&D costs on its 2025 federal return, but it must still capitalize and amortize those same costs on its 2025 Maryland return.7 This creates a “timing difference” that requires detailed accounting on the state return to reconcile federal and state taxable income. This is a primary example of how the Comptroller’s “local revenue office guidance” overrides federal simplicity for the sake of state fiscal stability.6

Filing Procedures and the Electronic Mandate

The Comptroller has implemented strict procedural rules for how the R&D credit must be claimed. The goal of these rules is to streamline the processing of thousands of business tax credits and reduce the risk of manual entry errors.

The Electronic Filing Requirement

Since 2017, the Comptroller has mandated that any corporation or pass-through entity (PTE) claiming a business tax credit from Form 500CR must file their return electronically.3 This includes:

• Form 500 for C-corporations.3
• Form 510 for partnerships and S-corps.5

If a business is unable to file electronically, it must submit Form 500CRW (Request for a Waiver), establishing “reasonable cause” or “undue hardship”.3 Without an approved waiver, a paper return claiming the R&D credit will likely be rejected or the credit disallowed.3

The Role of Amended Returns

Because the Department of Commerce does not issue its certification letters until February 15 of the year following the tax year (e.g., Feb 2026 for the 2024 tax year), most businesses have already filed their original tax returns by the time they have the necessary certification.9

To claim the credit, the Comptroller’s guidance requires the business to file an Amended Maryland Income Tax Return for the year in which the expenses were incurred.14 The certification letter from the Department of Commerce must be attached to this amended return as proof of eligibility.14

Source: 9

Pass-Through Entities (PTEs) and Non-Resident Members

For partnerships, limited liability companies (LLCs), and S-corporations, the Comptroller’s guidance focuses on the “flow-through” nature of the credit. A PTE does not “use” the R&D credit itself; instead, it passes it on to its members.5

Reporting on Form 510

The PTE must complete the R&D section of Form 500CR and file it with its Form 510 (PTE Income Tax Return).5 The credit is then allocated among the members in proportion to their ownership interest or as specified in the entity’s operating agreement.12

Guidance for Non-Resident Members

One area where the Comptroller provides critical guidance is for non-resident members of a Maryland PTE. If a PTE pays tax on behalf of its non-resident members, those members may claim their share of the R&D credit against that tax on their non-resident individual returns (Form 505).5 The Comptroller’s Administrative Release No. 42 provides detailed instructions on how residents and non-residents can claim credits for taxes paid to other states, which is often a factor for businesses with operations spanning multiple jurisdictions.27

Controlled Groups

If several corporations are under “common control” (as defined in IRC § 41(f)), the Comptroller’s regulations (03.04.10.09) require them to be treated as a single taxpayer.11 The group applies for the credit as one entity, and the certified amount is then distributed among the subsidiaries based on where the R&D spending actually occurred.12 This prevents a large parent company from “gaming” the $250,000 per-firm cap by creating multiple shell subsidiaries.9

Compliance, Audits, and Recordkeeping

The Comptroller’s Compliance Division enforces the state’s right to verify any credit claimed. While the Department of Commerce certifies the amount of the credit based on the application, the Comptroller has the authority to audit the underlying data during a tax examination.2

Audit Guidelines and Substantiation

The Comptroller aligns its audit standards with federal IRC § 41 requirements. To survive an audit, a business must provide:

1. Project-Level Accounting: Documentation that links employee wages and supply costs to specific, qualified research projects. General ledger entries for “R&D” are often insufficient.10
2. The Four-Part Test Proof: Technical documentation (emails, white papers, lab notes, prototypes) that proves the research involved a process of experimentation and encountered technical uncertainty.10
3. Good Standing Verification: To be approved for the credit in the first place, the business must be in “Good Standing” with the State Department of Assessments and Taxation (SDAT).15 The Comptroller’s office verifies this status before issuing refunds.

Four-Year Record Retention

The Comptroller advises businesses to maintain all R&D-related records for at least four years.10 This includes the federal Form 6765, which Maryland requires as an attachment to the state application to ensure consistency between federal and state claims.15

Macroeconomic Impact and the Future of the Credit

The Comptroller’s role extends beyond collection to policy analysis. Through the State of the Economy (SOTE) reports and the Bureau of Revenue Estimates, the office monitors how tax credits like the R&D program contribute to Maryland’s competitiveness.1

Statistics and Program Utilization

According to data from the Department of Commerce and the Comptroller, the R&D tax credit is one of the most popular business incentives in the state. It is routinely oversubscribed, meaning that for every dollar of credit requested, businesses often receive only a fraction due to the $12 million cap.9

Source: 10

Legislative Sunset (June 30, 2027)

The current statute for the R&D credit is set to expire on June 30, 2027.9 The Comptroller’s office, in conjunction with the Department of Legislative Services (DLS), performs periodic evaluations of the credit’s effectiveness. The 2024 DLS evaluation (as mandated by the Tax Expenditure Evaluation Act) provides the General Assembly with the data needed to decide whether to extend the program.29

Conclusion: Strategic Recommendations for Maryland Businesses

The Comptroller of Maryland is the essential final link in the chain of the R&D tax credit. While the Department of Commerce provides the promise of a credit through its certification, the Comptroller’s Revenue Administration Division provides the actual cash benefit or tax reduction. For a business to successfully navigate this process, it must view the credit not as a “one-off” application, but as a continuous compliance obligation.

The most critical strategic takeaways from the Comptroller’s guidance are as follows:

1. Prioritize the Add-Back: Ensure that the addition modification is correctly calculated and placed on the correct line of the return. This is the single most common cause of audit adjustments for the R&D credit.3
2. Embrace Electronic Filing: Do not risk the disallowance of a credit by filing a paper return without a waiver. The Comptroller’s systems are designed for digital reconciliation of credits.3
3. Track Asset Thresholds: For companies approaching the $5 million asset mark, the loss of “refundable” status can have massive cash-flow implications. Proper valuation of “net book value assets” is essential.9
4. Monitor Decoupling Alerts: As the 2025 tax season approaches, stay informed about the Comptroller’s stance on the OBBBA and federal expensing. The state’s decision to decouple means that “tax-basis” depreciation schedules will differ significantly between federal and Maryland returns.7

By adhering to these principles and maintaining rigorous project-level documentation, Maryland businesses can maximize the value of the R&D tax credit while minimizing their risk of an unfavorable Comptroller audit. The Office of the Comptroller, as the state’s fiscal steward, provides the framework through which innovation is rewarded and the state’s economic future is secured.1

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/