The Evolution of Maryland Innovation: The Department of Business and Economic Development and the Research and Development Tax Credit

The Department of Business and Economic Development (DBED), renamed the Maryland Department of Commerce in 2015, serves as the primary administrative authority for certifying eligibility and allocating the state’s Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit under Tax-General Article § 10-721. In this context, the agency functions as the state’s strategic gatekeeper, transitioning from a broad industrial promoter to a specialized certifier of technological innovation tasked with managing the state’s $12 million annual credit cap. 1

The structural and nomenclatural shift from the Department of Business and Economic Development (DBED) to the Maryland Department of Commerce (DOC) represents a fundamental pivot in the state’s approach to fiscal policy and industrial growth. Founded in 1995 to consolidate the state’s job creation efforts, DBED was the original home of the Research and Development Tax Credit when it was established by the General Assembly in 2000. 5 Over the ensuing decades, the department’s mandate evolved from general business assistance to high-stakes management of specialized incentive programs designed to anchor the life sciences, aerospace, and cybersecurity industries within Maryland’s borders. 2 This evolution culminated in 2015 when Governor Larry Hogan, acting on the recommendations of the Augustine Commission, reorganized the agency to prioritize economic competitiveness. 1 Under current law, the Department of Commerce acts as the first of two critical hurdles for taxpayers; while the Maryland Comptroller’s Office oversees the collection of revenue and the final processing of returns, it is the Department of Commerce that must first issue a tax credit certificate—a prerequisite without which the R&D credit cannot be legally claimed. 3 This dual-agency coordination ensures that the R&D Tax Credit is not merely a passive deduction but a proactive instrument of state economic policy, specifically tailored to reward companies that increase their research footprint in the state relative to a historical base. 3

The Institutional Lineage of Maryland’s Economic Authority

The historical trajectory of the Maryland Department of Commerce is characterized by periodic reorganizations that mirror the shifting priorities of the American economy. The department’s roots can be traced to 1948 with the formation of the Department of Information, a division of the Hall of Records Commission authorized by the Board of Public Works. 5 Initially tasked with compiling data on industry, natural resources, and outdoor recreation to foster tourism, the agency’s focus was primarily promotional. 5 By 1959, this entity was superseded by the Department of Economic Development, which introduced a more formalized mandate to advance the economic welfare of Maryland citizens through industrial opportunities and loans for small businesses. 5

As the late 20th century demanded more integrated approaches to labor and community stability, the agency underwent several transitions: the Department of Economic and Community Development in 1970, and the Department of Economic and Employment Development (DEED) in 1987. 5 The most significant precursor to the modern R&D tax credit era was the creation of the Department of Business and Economic Development (DBED) in 1995. 5 DBED was established specifically to emphasize the state’s mission of bringing new jobs and new businesses to Maryland, reflecting the aggressive interstate competition for high-growth sectors. 5 It was under the DBED banner that the Maryland Research and Development Tax Credit Program was launched in 2000 (Chapters 515 and 516), creating the fundamental framework that remains in place today. 6

In October 2015, the agency was briefly renamed the Department of Economic Competitiveness and Commerce before the Governor finalized the name as the Maryland Department of Commerce via Executive Order. 1 This 2015 restructuring was more than a rebranding; it moved the department’s nearly 230 team members into more customer-facing positions and created a Commerce Subcabinet involving the departments of Labor, Transportation, Environment, and Planning to ensure a holistic response to business issues. 2 The most recent reorganization in January 2025 further refined the Department of Commerce into three main divisions: Administration and Technology; Business Attraction and Special Projects; and Innovation and Growth, the latter being the spiritual successor to the R&D initiatives first envisioned in the 1990s. 1

The Department of Commerce’s role in the R&D tax credit is one of “Certification Authority.” 4 Unlike federal credits where a taxpayer simply reports activity to the IRS, a Maryland taxpayer must submit a detailed application to the Department of Commerce by November 15 of the year following the tax year in which the expenses were incurred. 3 This certification process serves to verify that the research was indeed “qualified” under federal guidelines and conducted within the borders of Maryland. 3

Statutory Foundations: Tax-General Article § 10-721

The legal lifeblood of the Maryland R&D Tax Credit is found in § 10-721 of the Tax-General Article of the Annotated Code of Maryland. 4 This section establishes the Research and Development Tax Credit Program with the explicit purpose of fostering increased research activities and expenditures in the state. 4 The statute relies heavily on federal definitions while inserting specific state-level caps and proration rules to manage Maryland’s fiscal impact. 4

Definitions of Qualified Research and Expenditures

The Maryland statute explicitly links its definitions to the Internal Revenue Code (IRC). 3 Maryland qualified research and development is defined as qualified research as described in § 41(d) of the IRC that is conducted within the State. 4 Similarly, Maryland qualified research and development expenses (QREs) are those expenses defined in § 41(b) of the IRC, provided they were incurred for research conducted within Maryland. 4 This alignment allows the Department of Commerce to utilize existing federal jurisprudence and IRS guidelines to determine if an activity qualifies, thereby reducing the administrative burden on both the state and the taxpayer. 3

However, Maryland’s definition of a “Small Business” is uniquely restrictive and serves as a primary point of differentiation in how credits are allocated. 3 A small business is defined as a for-profit corporation, LLC, partnership, or sole proprietorship with net book value assets totaling less than $5 million at the beginning or the end of the taxable year for which the expenses are incurred. 3 The “Net Book Value Assets” is further defined as the total value of assets, including intangibles, but not including liabilities, minus depreciation and amortization. 6 This specific definition ensures that the state’s refundable credit—a rare feature in state-level R&D policy—is reserved for firms that are truly in the startup or early-growth phase. 10

The Incremental Nature of the Credit

Maryland uses a “Growth” methodology to calculate the credit. 6 Prior to the 2021 legislative session, the state offered two distinct credits: a “Basic” credit (3% of expenses up to a base amount) and a “Growth” credit (10% of expenses exceeding a base amount). 6 In a major reform via Senate Bill 196 (2021), the General Assembly repealed the Basic credit to streamline the program and focus state resources on incentivizing increased research spending rather than merely maintaining baseline activity. 6

Under the current framework, the credit is equal to 10% of the amount by which the Maryland qualified R&D expenses paid or incurred during the taxable year exceed the “Maryland Base Amount.” 4 The Maryland Base Amount is calculated by taking the “Maryland Base Percentage”—the ratio of Maryland QREs to Maryland gross receipts for the four taxable years preceding the credit year—and multiplying it by the average Maryland gross receipts for those same four years. 4 If a company is a startup or had no prior R&D expenses in Maryland, the base amount is effectively zero, allowing the company to claim the full 10% on its current-year expenditures, subject to the $250,000 cap and proration. 3

Maryland Revenue Office (Comptroller) Guidance and Administrative Releases

While the Department of Commerce certifies the credits, the Maryland Comptroller’s Office is responsible for the actual “revenue side”—the processing of tax returns, the auditing of claims, and the issuance of regulations regarding the application of credits against various tax types. 4 The Comptroller provides this guidance through formal Administrative Releases and regulations in COMAR (Code of Maryland Regulations). 11

Administrative Release No. 34: Tax-Exempt and Withholding Rules

One of the more nuanced aspects of the Maryland R&D Tax Credit is its application to tax-exempt organizations and the mechanism of applying business credits against employer withholding. Administrative Release No. 34 serves as the primary guidance for these entities. 12 Although the release is often cited in the context of the “Employment Opportunity” tax credit, it establishes the procedure for any tax-exempt organization claiming business credits. 12

For a tax-exempt organization to leverage the R&D credit, it must follow a specific reconciliation process. 12 The organization may estimate the amount of the credit for the taxable year and divide that amount evenly over the periods for filing employer withholding returns (Form MW506). 12 For instance, if the entity files quarterly, it reduces its quarterly withholding payment to the Comptroller by one-quarter of the estimated credit. 12 At year-end, the organization must file Form MW508 (Annual Employer Withholding Reconciliation Report) and attach Form 500CR, along with the Department of Commerce certification, to reconcile the estimated credits with the actual certified amount. 12 If the credit exceeds the withholding liability, the excess may be carried forward for five years, but it is generally limited to the sum of the state income tax payable and the taxes withheld from employee wages. 12

Administrative Release No. 6: Pass-Through Entities (PTEs)

Administrative Release No. 6 outlines the taxation of pass-through entities, which is critical for the R&D credit because many innovation firms are organized as LLCs or S-corporations. 15 The R&D tax credit is not claimed at the entity level for these organizations but is instead “passed through” to the individual members or shareholders. 8 The credits are allocated among the members in the same proportion as their distributive share of income, unless a written agreement provides for a different allocation that has economic substance. 4

Members who are nonresidents of Maryland must report their share of the credit on their Maryland nonresident income tax return. 15 Administrative Release No. 6 clarifies that the tax paid by the pass-through entity on behalf of nonresident members is treated as a credit on that member’s return, and any R&D credit passed through further reduces that member’s tax liability. 15

COMAR 03.04.10: The Regulatory Framework

The regulations under COMAR 03.04.10 provide the technical details for credit computation, particularly regarding mergers, acquisitions, and short tax years. 11 For example, Regulation.10 clarifies that in a transaction involving an asset purchase, unused R&D credits do not transfer to the buyer; they remain with the selling corporation because the selling entity continues to exist as a legal person. 3 Conversely, in a stock purchase or a merger where the federal law allows for the carryover of tax attributes, the surviving corporation may utilize the acquired entity’s R&D credits. 11

The Mathematics of the Maryland R&D Tax Credit

To understand how the law applies, one must navigate the multi-step calculation process mandated by both the Department of Commerce and the Comptroller. The core of the calculation is the “Maryland Base Amount,” which reflects the historical research intensity of the business. 4

Calculating the Base Amount and Growth Credit

The Maryland Base Amount is designed to ensure that the state only rewards research spending that is “above and beyond” a company’s normal business operations. 4 The formulas are as follows:

1. Maryland Base Percentage:
   
   $$\text{Base \%} = \frac{\sum \text{Maryland QREs (Prior 4 Years)}}{\sum \text{Maryland Gross Receipts (Prior 4 Years)}}$$
2. Average Annual Maryland Gross Receipts:
   
   $$\text{Avg Gross Receipts} = \frac{\sum \text{Maryland Gross Receipts (Prior 4 Years)}}{4}$$
3. Maryland Base Amount:
   
   $$\text{Base Amount} = \text{Base \%} \times \text{Avg Gross Receipts}$$
4. Growth R&D Credit:
   
   $$\text{Credit} = 10\% \times (\text{Current Maryland QREs} – \text{Base Amount})$$

Proration and the Allocation Mechanism

Because the total amount of credits approved by the Department of Commerce cannot exceed $12,000,000 per year, and the program is routinely oversubscribed, the department employs a proration formula. 3 The statute divides the total cap into two buckets: $3.5 million for small businesses and $8.5 million for non-small businesses. 3

If the total growth credits applied for by all non-small business applicants exceed $8.5 million, the Department must approve a credit for each applicant equal to the product of the credit applied for and a fraction: the numerator being $8,500,000 and the denominator being the total credits applied for by all non-small businesses. 3

$$\text{Certified Credit} = \text{Applied Growth Credit} \times \frac{8,500,000}{\text{Total Non-Small Business Claims}}$$

A similar calculation is applied to the small business pool using the $3,500,000 limit. 3 Furthermore, no single applicant can receive a credit exceeding $250,000 in a single calendar year. 3 If an applicant’s prorated amount still exceeds $250,000, the amount is capped at that limit, and any excess funds are typically redistributed within the pool. 3

Illustrative Case Study: CyberNet Defense Corp

To demonstrate the application of these rules, consider “CyberNet Defense Corp,” a Maryland-based cybersecurity firm. CyberNet is not a “small business” for tax purposes as its net book value assets are $8 million. 3 In 2024, the company incurred $2,000,000 in Maryland qualified R&D expenses. 16

Historical Data (2020–2023)

Step 1: Calculate Base Percentage and Base Amount

• Maryland Base Percentage: $4,600,000 / 46,000,000 = 10\%$. 10
• Average Maryland Gross Receipts: $46,000,000 / 4 = $11,500,000$. 10
• Maryland Base Amount: $10% \times 11,500,000 = $1,150,000$. 4

Step 2: Calculate the Applied Credit

• Excess QREs: $2,000,000 (\text{Current Year}) – 1,150,000 (\text{Base}) = $850,000$. 4
• Applied Growth Credit: $10% \times 850,000 = $85,000$. 4

Step 3: Apply the Proration and Cap

Assume that for the 2024 tax year, non-small businesses applied for a total of $17,000,000 in credits against the $8.5 million pool. 3

• Proration Fraction: $8,500,000 / 17,000,000 = 0.50$. 3
• Certified Amount: $85,000 \times 0.50 = $42,500$. 3

CyberNet Defense Corp will receive a certification letter from the Department of Commerce for $42,500. Since this is less than the $250,000 individual cap, the company may claim the full certified amount on its Maryland tax return. 3 If CyberNet were a “small business” (assets < $5M), and this $42,500 credit exceeded its tax liability, it could claim the entire amount as a refund from the Comptroller. 3

Small Business Refundability: A Critical Incentive for Startups

The most powerful component of the Maryland R&D Tax Credit for the state’s burgeoning tech and biotech sectors is the refundability provision for small businesses. 4 While standard corporate tax credits only provide value if the company has an income tax liability to offset, the Maryland R&D credit (certified after December 15, 2012) is fully refundable for qualifying small businesses. 3

The $5 Million Asset Test

The eligibility for refundability hinges on the “Small Business” definition in § 10-721. 4 The Department of Commerce requires a balance sheet as of the beginning or end of the tax year to prove that net book value assets are below $5 million. 3 This calculation—Total Assets (including intangibles) minus Liabilities, Depreciation, and Amortization—is a specific “Net Value” test. 9 It is designed to capture the true capitalization of the company rather than its gross assets, which might be inflated by debt or rapid expansion. 10

For early-stage biotech firms, which may spend millions on clinical trials and lab supplies without generating a single dollar of revenue for a decade, this refund is a critical source of non-dilutive capital. 10 It effectively acts as a state grant that scales with the company’s investment in research. The Department of Commerce reported that the $3.5 million small business set-aside is frequently oversubscribed, highlighting the intense utilization of the credit by Maryland’s innovation startups. 3

Carryforward and Application Timeline

For businesses that are not eligible for a refund, or for any excess credits that a small business chooses not to claim as a refund, the law provides a seven-year carryforward. 3 The certification letter issued by the Department of Commerce by February 15 must be attached to the tax return for the year in which the expenses were incurred. 3 Because the certification letter is often issued after the tax filing deadline for the expense year, taxpayers typically file an amended return to claim the credit once they have the letter in hand. 3 Alternatively, they may claim the credit on any income tax return filed for any of the following seven tax years. 3

Compliance and the “Four-Part Test” in Maryland

Since the Maryland Department of Commerce follows the federal definition of qualified R&D, firms must be prepared to defend their claims under the IRS “Four-Part Test” outlined in IRC § 41(d). 10 State auditors from the Comptroller’s office or Department of Commerce reviewers will look for evidence of:

1. Technological in Nature: The research must rely on principles of physical or biological sciences, engineering, or computer science. 17
2. Permitted Purpose: The activity must relate to a new or improved function, performance, reliability, or quality of a “business component.” 8
3. Elimination of Uncertainty: The taxpayer must intend to discover information that eliminates uncertainty regarding the capability or method for developing or improving the component. 8
4. Process of Experimentation: The taxpayer must undergo a systematic process (such as trial and error, modeling, or simulation) to evaluate alternatives. 8

Required Documentation and Audit Defense

Maryland businesses are advised to maintain a “contemporaneous record” of their research activities. 10 In the event of a review, the Department of Commerce may request project descriptions, employee time logs, and records of testing results. 8 The Department of Commerce application specifically requires the North American Industrial Classification Code (NAICS) and the address of the Maryland facility where the research occurred. 16

Strategic Context: The Augustine Commission and Competitive Positioning

The renaming of the Department of Business and Economic Development to the Department of Commerce was not merely aesthetic; it was a recommendation of the Economic Development & Business Climate Commission, also known as the “Augustine Commission.” 2 This commission emphasized that Maryland needed to be more “competitive” in attracting and retaining businesses. 2 The R&D Tax Credit is the state’s primary weapon in this competitive landscape. 10

By increasing the cap to $12 million and maintaining a dedicated pool for small businesses, Maryland has signaled its intent to protect its high-tech core. 4 Furthermore, the state provides a sales and use tax exemption for tangible personal property used in R&D, which stacks with the income tax credit to provide a multi-layered incentive for firms to build labs and manufacturing facilities within the state. 6

Interaction with Other Incentives

The Department of Commerce also manages other credits that can be paired with the R&D credit, such as:

• Biotechnology Investment Incentive Tax Credit: Provides a 50% credit for investors in qualified Maryland biotech companies. 20
• Cybersecurity Investment Incentive Tax Credit: Offers a refundable credit for investors in early-stage cybersecurity firms. 20
• Employer Security Clearance Costs Tax Credit: Reauthorized through 2027 to help defense contractors offset the high costs of SCIF (Sensitive Compartmented Information Facility) construction. 20
• One Maryland Tax Credit: Incentivizes businesses to locate or expand in “Tier 1” counties (e.g., Baltimore City, Allegany, Somerset) with credits of up to $5 million based on jobs created and project costs. 22

Future Outlook and the 2027 Sunset

The Maryland Research and Development Tax Credit is currently set to expire on June 30, 2027. 3 While the General Assembly has historically extended the program, its future will depend on the findings of ongoing evaluations by the Department of Legislative Services (DLS). 13 The DLS is required to reevaluate the program in 2024 to determine if it is meeting its original intent of fostering increased research spending. 13

As the Department of Commerce enters its next phase of reorganization in 2025, the R&D credit remains a central pillar of the “Innovation and Growth” division. 1 The department’s continued emphasis on data-driven results—as seen in the “State of the Economy” series and the focus on core industries like life sciences and aerospace—suggests that the R&D credit will continue to be a priority for the state’s economic planners. 2

Conclusion: Navigating the Maryland Innovation Ecosystem

The Department of Business and Economic Development may have changed its name to the Maryland Department of Commerce, but its mission to cultivate a world-class innovation economy remains constant. In the context of the R&D Tax Credit, the department serves as the indispensable administrative link between the statutory intent of the General Assembly and the fiscal reality of the Maryland taxpayer. By meticulously managing the certification process, the $12 million annual cap, and the small business refundability pool, the Department of Commerce ensures that state incentives are directed toward the companies that are most active in expanding Maryland’s technological frontiers.

For businesses operating in Maryland, the R&D Tax Credit offers a substantial financial reward—up to 10% of increased research spending—but it demands a high level of procedural rigor. From ensuring “Good Standing” with the SDAT to navigating the proration rules of § 10-721 and following the withholding guidance of Administrative Release No. 34, firms must be proactive and meticulous. As the program evolves toward its 2027 expiration date, companies that master the interplay between the Department of Commerce and the Comptroller will be the most successful in leveraging these state resources to fuel their next generation of breakthroughs. 3

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/