The Strategic Architecture of Refundable Research and Development Tax Credits for Maryland Small Businesses

A refundable research and development tax credit is a fiscal instrument that permits a small business to receive a direct cash payment from the state when its certified credit exceeds its annual tax liability. Within the Maryland regulatory framework, this mechanism serves as a critical liquidity engine, transforming theoretical tax offsets into immediate working capital for entities maintaining less than $5 million in net book value assets. 1

Theoretical Foundations and the Refundability Mechanism

The concept of tax credit refundability represents a departure from traditional nonrefundable offsets, which merely reduce a taxpayer’s liability to zero. For established corporations with significant revenues, nonrefundable credits are sufficient because these entities typically generate enough tax liability to absorb the credit. However, in the innovation-heavy sectors of biotechnology, software development, and advanced manufacturing, early-stage small businesses often operate at a net loss or with minimal tax obligations during their most research-intensive years. 4 Without a refundability provision, the Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit would offer no immediate value to the very startups the State of Maryland intends to foster. By authorizing refunds for credits certified after December 15, 2012, Maryland law ensures that innovative capacity is not hampered by the lack of immediate profitability. 1

This mechanism is codified primarily within the Maryland Tax-General Article § 10-721 and is administered through a collaborative effort between the Maryland Department of Commerce and the Comptroller of Maryland. 7 The program is designed to be “growth-oriented,” meaning it rewards businesses that expand their research activities over time rather than those that maintain a static baseline of expenditure. 5 This focus on growth was solidified through legislative alterations in 2021, which eliminated the “Basic” R&D tax credit—a 3% credit on baseline expenses—in favor of a consolidated and more robust “Growth” credit. 5

The distinction between a standard tax deduction and a refundable credit is paramount for strategic financial planning. While a deduction only reduces the amount of income subject to taxation, a credit provides a dollar-for-dollar reduction in the tax itself. 13 When that credit is refundable, it acts as a government grant delivered through the tax system, providing non-dilutive capital that does not require the surrender of equity or the assumption of debt. 5

Legislative Evolution: Senate Bill 196 and the 2021 Overhaul

The modern landscape of Maryland’s R&D incentives was fundamentally reshaped by Senate Bill 196 (2021), which went into effect on July 1, 2021. 5 This legislation was born from an administrative realization that the previous dual-credit structure was failing to optimize the distribution of state funds. Prior to the overhaul, large corporations were capturing a disproportionate share of the available $12 million annual cap through the “Basic” R&D credit, which did not require any increase in year-over-year research spending. 5

The 2021 reforms introduced several critical pillars to the program:

1. Elimination of the Basic Credit: The 3% credit for baseline spending was repealed to focus resources on entities that are actively expanding their innovation footprint. 5
2. Consolidation into the Growth Credit: The Growth R&D Tax Credit, now set at 10% of expenditures exceeding a historical base amount, became the primary vehicle for research incentives. 2
3. Statutory Set-Asides for Small Businesses: To protect the interests of smaller innovators, $3.5 million of the $12 million annual cap was reserved exclusively for businesses meeting specific asset criteria. 2
4. Individual Per-Applicant Caps: A maximum credit value of $250,000 per applicant was established to ensure that the fund could support a larger volume of companies rather than being exhausted by a few dominant players. 2

This legislative shift underscored a policy pivot toward “turbocharging” the economy by ensuring that everyone, particularly smaller entities with high growth potential, has a chance to benefit from state incentives. 17

Statutory Definitions: The Small Business Asset Test

Eligibility for refundability hinges entirely on the statutory definition of a “small business.” In the context of the Maryland R&D tax credit, small business status is determined not by headcount or revenue, but by the “net book value assets” of the entity. 2

Calculating Net Book Value Assets

An entity is classified as a small business if it is a for-profit corporation, limited liability company (LLC), partnership, or sole proprietorship with net book value assets totaling less than $5 million. 1 This assessment must be made as of either the first day or the last day of the taxable year for which the Maryland qualified research and development expenses are incurred, as reported on the entity’s balance sheet. 3

The calculation of “net book value assets” follows a specific formula defined by the Department of Commerce and clarified in the Tax-General Article: 2

• Inclusions: All tangible and intangible assets owned by the business (e.g., equipment, property, software, patents, and goodwill). 2
• Reductions: The value of these assets is reduced by accumulated depreciation and amortization. 2
• Exclusions: Liabilities (debt, accounts payable, loans) are not subtracted from the asset value for the purposes of this test. 2

This methodology is often counterintuitive for business owners accustomed to calculating “net worth” or “equity.” A company with $6 million in equipment and $4 million in debt would have $2 million in equity, but for Maryland R&D tax purposes, it has $6 million in assets and would therefore fail the small business test, precluding it from the refundability provision. 2

Mechanics of the Maryland Growth R&D Tax Credit

The growth credit is calculated as 10% of the amount by which a company’s Maryland Qualified Research Expenses (QREs) exceed its “Maryland Base Amount.” 1

Defining Qualified Research Expenses (QREs)

Maryland strictly follows the federal definition of QREs as established in Section 41(b) of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC). 2 To qualify, expenses must be incurred for research conducted within the State of Maryland and generally fall into three categories: 2

1. Wages: Taxable wages paid to employees directly engaged in research, as well as those providing direct supervision or support. 2
2. Supplies: Tangible property consumed during the research process (excluding land or depreciable property). 2
3. Contract Research: Fees paid to third-party consultants or organizations to perform research on behalf of the taxpayer, typically capped at 65% of the actual cost for the credit calculation. 2

The Four-Part Test for Activity Qualification

Before an expense can be considered a QRE, the underlying activity must pass the IRS’s four-part test: 14

• Technological in Nature: The research must rely on the hard sciences (engineering, computer science, biology, chemistry). 15
• Permitted Purpose: The goal must be to improve the functionality, performance, reliability, or quality of a business component (product or process). 15
• Elimination of Uncertainty: The activity must seek to resolve a technical uncertainty regarding the design or method of achieving a result. 14
• Process of Experimentation: The business must use a systematic approach, such as modeling, simulation, or trial-and-error, to evaluate alternatives. 14

Calculating the Maryland Base Amount

The “Maryland Base Amount” is the threshold that research spending must exceed to trigger the 10% credit. 1 This base is calculated using a “fixed-base percentage” derived from the company’s history. 1

1. Fixed-Base Percentage: This is the ratio of Maryland QREs to Maryland gross receipts for the four tax years preceding the credit year. 1
2. Average Annual Gross Receipts: The average Maryland gross receipts for the four preceding tax years. 1
3. Base Amount Formula:
   
   $$\text{Maryland Base Amount} = \text{Fixed-Base Percentage} \times \text{Average Annual Gross Receipts}$$
   2

For a startup in its first year of research expenditure, the Maryland Base Amount is zero, effectively allowing the company to claim a credit on 10% of its total QREs for that initial year. 2

Financial Constraints: Caps and the Proration Formula

The Maryland R&D tax credit is a finite resource governed by strict budgetary limits. The state authorizes a maximum of $12 million in total credits annually. 2 These funds are allocated into two distinct categories to ensure broad participation. 2

The Two-Tiered Allocation System

• The Small Business Set-Aside: $3.5 million is reserved for applicants meeting the asset test. 2
• The Non-Small Business Pool: $8.5 million is available for all other certified entities. 2

A unique administrative feature of the Maryland program is the “spillover” provision. If the total credits requested by small businesses are less than $3.5 million, the remaining balance is transferred to the non-small business pool. 3 Conversely, if the non-small business pool is underutilized (less than $8.5 million requested), those funds are shifted to increase the small business set-aside. 3

The Impact of Oversubscription and Proration

Because the program is consistently oversubscribed, particularly by technology and life science firms, the Department of Commerce is required by law to prorate the credits. 1 Proration occurs independently within each of the two pools. 8

If the total amount of credits applied for by small businesses exceeds $3.5 million, each applicant’s credit is reduced using the following formula: 8

$$\text{Certified Credit} = \text{Requested Credit} \times \left( \frac{\$3,500,000}{\text{Total Credits Requested by All Small Businesses}} \right)$$

In recent years, proration has significantly reduced the actual benefit received by businesses. For instance, if small businesses apply for $7 million in total credits, each business only receives 50% of the credit it calculated on its application. 8 This “irrevocable proration” makes it impossible for businesses to precisely predict their exact refund until they receive the final certification letter from the Department of Commerce in February. 2

State Revenue Office Guidance: The Application and Claim Process

Navigating the Maryland R&D credit requires careful adherence to a timeline that spans two calendar years and involves two different state agencies. 2

Phase 1: Certification through the Department of Commerce

A taxpayer cannot claim the credit directly on their tax return without first obtaining a certification letter. 1

• Application Deadline: November 15 of the calendar year following the tax year in which the expenses were incurred. 1 For example, 2024 expenses must be applied for by November 15, 2025. 3
• Submission Requirements: Small businesses must provide a balance sheet to verify the asset test and a detailed breakdown of QREs and gross receipts for the current and prior four years. 2
• Notification of Approval: The Department of Commerce reviews the applications and issues a certification letter to the business by February 15 of the following year (e.g., February 15, 2026, for 2024 expenses). 1

Phase 2: Claiming the Credit through the Comptroller’s Office

Upon receiving the certification letter, the taxpayer moves to the revenue administration phase managed by the Comptroller of Maryland. 2

• Filing an Amended Return: Because the certification letter is usually issued after the tax return for the expense year has been filed (or is due), businesses typically must file an amended tax return (Form 500X for corporations or Form 502X for individuals) for the year in which the research was conducted. 1
• Form 500CR and Electronic Filing: The credit is formally claimed on Form 500CR (Business Income Tax Credits). 21 In Maryland, any return claiming a business tax credit from Form 500CR must be filed electronically. 21
• The Waiver Provision (Form 500CRW): If a business cannot file electronically due to undue hardship or reasonable cause, it must submit a waiver request (Form 500CRW) alongside its paper return. 21

Guidance for Pass-Through Entities (PTEs)

For small businesses organized as S-Corporations, Partnerships, or LLCs taxed as partnerships, the credit calculation happens at the entity level, but the benefit flows through to the individual members or shareholders. 2

Entity-Level Reporting

The PTE must file an electronic Form 510 or Form 511 (Pass-Through Entity Income Tax Return) and complete the Form 500CR section to pass the credit to its members. 21 The PTE provides each member with their pro-rata share of the credit via a Schedule K-1 or a similar composite statement. 2

Member-Level Claiming

Individual members claim their share of the credit on their personal Maryland income tax return (Form 502) using Form 502CR. 18 For these individuals, the credit remains refundable because it originated from a certified small business at the entity level. 2

Special care must be taken regarding Taxpayer Identification Numbers (TINs). The certification letter will list the PTE’s Federal Employer Identification Number (FEIN). Individual members must ensure they check the box on their return indicating the credit is from a PTE and provide that FEIN to avoid having the credit disallowed. 27

Comprehensive Example: A Software Development Firm’s Path to a Refund

To demonstrate the application of these rules, consider “CodeMaryland Solutions LLC,” an innovative software firm developing AI-driven cybersecurity tools. 2

Step 1: Year-End Asset Verification (Tax Year 2024)

At the end of 2024, CodeMaryland’s balance sheet shows:

• Computers & Servers: $1,500,000 (after depreciation). 2
• Intellectual Property: $3,000,000 (purchased patents, after amortization). 2
• Cash on Hand: $200,000.
• Total Net Book Value Assets: $4,700,000. 2
• Liabilities: $3,500,000 (Venture debt). (Note: This is ignored for the test). 2
  Result: Asset value is $4.7M (< $5M), so the firm is a “small business.” 2

Step 2: R&D Expense Calculation (Tax Year 2024)

• Research Salaries: $800,000. 2
• Cloud Computing/Supplies: $50,000. 14
• Total Maryland QREs: $850,000. 2

Step 3: Base Amount Determination

CodeMaryland has been in business for 4 years.

• Average Annual Gross Receipts (2020-2023): $2,000,000. 1
• Fixed-Base Percentage: 15% (calculated as prior QREs / prior Gross Receipts). 1
• Maryland Base Amount: $2,000,000 x 0.15 = $300,000. 1

Step 4: Application and Proration

• Growth Portion: $850,000 – $300,000 = $550,000. 1
• Calculated Credit (10%): $55,000. 1
• CodeMaryland applies to Commerce by November 15, 2025. 1
• Proration Adjustment: Commerce determines that the small business pool is oversubscribed, and the proration factor is 0.75. 2
• Certified Credit: $55,000 x 0.75 = $41,250. 8

Step 5: Tax Filing and Refund

CodeMaryland receives its certification letter on February 15, 2026. 1

• The company files an amended 2024 Maryland return (Form 500X) electronically. 1
• Maryland Income Tax Liability: $10,000.
• Certified R&D Credit: $41,250.
• Net Result: The first $10,000 of the credit eliminates the tax liability. The remaining $31,250 is issued as a cash refund check to the company. 2

Administrative Release No. 20: Timelines and Overpayments

The Comptroller’s Administrative Release No. 20 serves as the primary guidance for the statute of limitations on refund claims. 29

The Three-Year Rule

Generally, a claim for a refund must be filed within three years from the date the original return was filed or within two years from the date the tax was paid, whichever is later. 21 For R&D credits, this means the amended return to claim the refund must be filed within this window. 21

Limitations on Amount

Administrative Release No. 20 specifies that if a claim is filed within three years of the original filing, the refund is limited to the amount of tax paid within that three-year period (plus any extensions). 21 If the claim is filed after three years but within two years of payment, the refund is limited to the tax paid within those two years. 21 Because the R&D credit involves a separate certification from the Department of Commerce, it is categorized as a reduction in tax established by an administrative board. 29

The Role of Documentation and Audit Defense

Maryland and the Internal Revenue Service both maintain rigorous audit standards for R&D claims. 2 Businesses must be prepared to defend their “Four-Part Test” eligibility through contemporaneous documentation. 2

Essential Record Keeping

The Department of Commerce and the Comptroller expect to see: 2

• Innovation Logs: Project-level summaries describing the technical challenges and uncertainties being solved. 18
• Records of Changes: Bug logs, version control histories for software, or trial-run data for manufacturing processes. 18
• Labor Time Sheets: Documentation that clearly distinguishes between “Qualified” time (direct research) and “Non-Qualified” time (general administration). 10
• Balance Sheet Substantiation: Since asset value is the gatekeeper for refundability, businesses must keep detailed records of asset purchases, depreciation schedules, and amortization to prove they remain under the $5 million threshold. 2

Under § 10-721(g), the Department of Commerce is required to report on the credits approved. 8 This public reporting underscores the need for accuracy, as any “clawback” of credits due to an audit could result in public embarrassment and financial penalties. 10

Emerging Policy: The Income Tax Benefit Transfer Program (HB 35)

A significant expansion of Maryland’s innovation strategy is the introduction of the Income Tax Benefit Transfer Program, established by House Bill 35 (2025). 16 While it does not change the core “refundable” nature for small businesses, it offers a new liquidity path for businesses that might be “asset-heavy” (over $5 million) but still “profit-light.” 16

Effective July 1, 2025, and applying to tax year 2025 and beyond, this program allows “eligible technology companies” with fewer than 225 employees in the U.S. to transfer (sell) their unused R&D tax credits to other unaffiliated Maryland taxpayers. 16

• The 80% Rule: The credits must be transferred in exchange for cash consideration equal to at least 80% of the value of the credit. 16
• Recapture Risk: If the company fails to use the cash received from the transfer to fund state-based operating expenses (fixed assets, materials, startup costs), the state may recapture the tax benefit. 16
• Strategic Implication: This program provides a “secondary market” for R&D credits. If a business fails the $5 million asset test for refundability, it can now sell its credits to a larger profitable company at a slight discount, effectively achieving the same liquidity result as a refund. 16

Federal Context: Section 174 Amortization and the OBBBA

Maryland businesses must also coordinate their state claims with federal tax changes. Under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (2017), starting in 2022, businesses were required to capitalize and amortize R&D costs over 5 years (15 years for foreign research) instead of deducting them immediately. 4

However, the “One Big Beautiful Bill Act” (OBBBA) has restored full expensing for domestic R&D for tax years after December 31, 2024. 4 Most significantly for small businesses, the OBBBA allows those with under $31 million in gross receipts to elect to apply the immediate expensing rules retroactively to 2022. 4

This creates a powerful “double benefit” for Maryland small businesses:

1. Federal: Immediate deduction of all 2022-2024 R&D costs (through amended returns). 4
2. State: 10% refundable growth credit on the same expenditures. 2

Coordination between these two incentives is essential, as the Maryland Base Amount calculation relies on figures that may be altered by amended federal returns. 8

Comparative Analysis of Maryland Business Incentives

The R&D tax credit is part of a broader ecosystem of incentives that small businesses should consider. 17

Notably, the Small Business Relief Tax Credit for paid sick and safe leave was repealed effective June 1, 2024, through the Budget Reconciliation and Financing Act. 22 This repeal makes the R&D credit even more significant as one of the few remaining robust refundable cash-back options for small Maryland innovators. 22

Economic Impact and Statistics

The Maryland R&D credit is heavily utilized, and the data suggests a highly competitive environment. 2

• Total Annual Appropriation: $12,000,000. 2
• Oversubscription Rate: The program is frequently “oversubscribed,” with the full $12 million typically allocated well before all valid applications are satisfied. 2
• Regional Concentration: A significant percentage of credits are awarded to companies in the “I-270 Tech Corridor” (Montgomery and Frederick Counties) and the “Greater Baltimore” region, reflecting the state’s density of life science and aerospace activity. 10
• Asset Test Impact: While the $3.5 million set-aside is generous, many “medium-sized” companies in Maryland find themselves in a “gap”—too large to meet the $5 million asset test for refundability but not profitable enough to use the nonrefundable credits. 2 This is the primary driver behind the new Benefit Transfer Program. 16

Conclusion: Strategic Imperatives for Small Business Leadership

The Maryland Research and Development Tax Credit is more than a mere tax reduction; it is a fundamental component of a small business’s capital stack. By understanding the nuance of the $5 million asset test and the growth-based calculation methodology, leadership teams can effectively “engineer” their research spending to maximize their refund. 2

The transition from the “Basic” credit to a pure “Growth” model emphasizes that the State of Maryland is no longer interested in subsidizing static innovation. Instead, it is investing in companies that are aggressively expanding their R&D efforts. 5 For small businesses, the refundability of this credit represents a critical safety net, ensuring that even in years of loss or intense reinvestment, the state remains a partner in their technical evolution. 4

As we look toward 2025 and beyond, the integration of federal relief under the OBBBA and the new transferability options under HB 35 will offer unprecedented opportunities for liquidity. However, the path to these funds is paved with administrative hurdles—electronic filing mandates, November 15 deadlines, and rigorous asset-book-value tests. 1 Small businesses that approach the R&D credit with the same precision they apply to their technical research will find the Maryland tax system to be a reliable and substantial source of innovation funding.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/