Credit Carry-over

In the context of the South Carolina Research and Development tax credit, credit carry-over refers to the statutory provision allowing taxpayers to apply unused portions of a nonrefundable credit to future tax years. This mechanism is activated when the current year’s earned credit exceeds the fifty percent annual utilization limit, permitting the excess to be carried forward for up to ten years from the date of the original expenditure. [cite: 3]

The functional utility of the South Carolina Research and Development (R&D) tax credit is fundamentally rooted in its ability to provide long-term fiscal relief for innovative enterprises. Unlike a standard tax deduction, which merely reduces the amount of income subject to taxation, the R&D credit offers a dollar-for-dollar reduction in the actual tax liability owed to the state. However, because the credit is designed as a nonrefundable incentive, its immediate value is constrained by the taxpayer’s current profitability and tax burden. The credit carry-over serves as a vital bridge, ensuring that the economic incentive is not lost simply because a taxpayer lacks sufficient liability in the year of the research expenditure. [cite_start]Under South Carolina Code Section 12-6-3415, this carry-over is subject to a rigorous ten-year lifespan, necessitating a highly structured approach to tax accounting and strategic planning. [cite: 3]

Statutory Foundation and Legal Architecture

The Research Expenses Credit, as defined in S.C. Code Section 12-6-3415, represents the state’s primary mechanism for incentivizing scientific and technological advancement. [cite_start]The law establishes a direct linkage between state-level benefits and federal standards by adopting the definitions and criteria found in Section 41 of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC). [cite: 3] This architectural choice ensures that the state’s tax environment remains consistent with federal expectations, thereby reducing the compliance overhead for multi-state entities and sophisticated research organizations.

[cite_start]

To qualify for the South Carolina credit, a taxpayer must first satisfy the federal requirements for the Credit for Increasing Research Activities under IRC Section 41 for the same taxable year. [cite: 3] This federal claim requirement acts as a prerequisite; without a valid federal claim, the South Carolina credit and any subsequent carry-over cannot be established. [cite_start]The state credit is calculated as five percent of the taxpayer’s qualified research expenses (QREs) incurred within South Carolina. [cite: 3] [cite_start]Unlike the federal credit, which often utilizes a “base amount” or “incremental” calculation, the South Carolina credit is applied directly to the total QREs incurred in-state during the tax year, simplifying the initial calculation but placing a greater emphasis on the annual utilization limits and the resulting carry-overs. [cite: 3]

Mechanics of Credit Utilization and the Fifty Percent Limitation

The primary driver of credit carry-overs is the statutory limitation on the amount of credit that can be absorbed in a single tax period. [cite_start]S.C. Code Section 12-6-3415(B) stipulates that the credit taken in any one taxable year may not exceed fifty percent of the taxpayer’s remaining tax liability after all other credits have been applied. [cite: 3] This “after all other credits” clause is a cornerstone of South Carolina’s credit ordering rules and has profound implications for the accumulation of carry-overs.

Taxpayers in South Carolina often benefit from an array of incentives, such as the New Jobs Credit (Section 12-6-3360) or the Corporate Headquarters Credit (Section 12-6-3410). [cite_start]The South Carolina Department of Revenue (SCDOR) provides guidance stating that credits must generally be used in the year they are earned based on tax liability, but specific credits like the Research Expenses Credit must be applied after others. [cite: 3] By forcing the R&D credit to the end of the line, the law effectively minimizes the “remaining tax liability” against which the fifty percent limit is calculated. [cite_start]This sequence frequently results in a substantial portion of the R&D credit being unable to find a “home” in the current year, thereby forcing it into carry-over status. [cite: 3]

[cite_start]

[cite_start]

The Ten-Year Carry-over Lifespan and Expiration Logic

[cite_start]

The ten-year carry-over period defined in S.C. Code Section 12-6-3415(B) is a critical constraint that distinguishes the R&D credit from other state incentives that may offer longer or even indefinite carry-over windows. [cite: 3] [cite_start]The statute explicitly states that the credit carry-over may not be used for a taxable year that begins on or after ten years from the date of the qualified research expenses. [cite: 3] This phrasing is significant because it ties the expiration of the credit to the date the expenses were incurred, not the date the credit was first claimed or the tax return was filed.

For companies engaged in multi-year research projects or those navigating extended periods of low profitability (such as startups), the ten-year limit creates a “use it or lose it” scenario. Meticulous tracking of credit “vintages” is required. [cite_start]Under the SCDOR’s First-In, First-Out (FIFO) logic, the oldest credits are generally absorbed first to prevent expiration, but because the R&D credit is capped at fifty percent of the remaining liability, a company with continuous R&D spending may find itself in a perpetual state of credit surplus, where the oldest credits eventually “age out” before they can be utilized. [cite: 3] [cite_start]This expiration risk is exacerbated during economic downturns or periods of significant capital investment where other credits (like the Capital Investment Credit) take priority and further reduce the available tax base. [cite: 3]

SCDOR Administrative Guidance and Compliance Protocols

[cite_start]

The SCDOR provides specific procedural instructions for the establishment and tracking of R&D credit carry-overs, primarily through Form SC Schedule TC-18. [cite: 3] Taxpayers are required to complete this schedule annually to report their current year’s qualified research expenses and to account for any carry-overs from prior years. [cite_start]The form acts as the official ledger for the credit, requiring taxpayers to list the research expenses credit carried forward from previous years on line 3, which is then added to the current year’s earned credit to arrive at the total credit before limitations. [cite: 3]

A vital aspect of SCDOR guidance relates to the amendment of tax returns. [cite_start]Taxpayers who failed to claim the R&D credit in a prior year can generally amend their returns within the three-year statute of limitations to capture those credits. [cite: 3] [cite_start]However, the SCDOR offers a unique provision for carry-overs: a taxpayer may file an amended return for a year that is “out of statute” (older than three years) to claim a credit that can be carried forward into one or more open years. [cite: 3] [cite_start]The critical caveat is that the carry-overs being brought forward must be reduced by the amount of credit that could have been used in the years that are out of statute. [cite: 3] This requires a retrospective tax liability analysis for the closed years to ensure the carry-over balance is accurately stated when it finally hits an open tax return.

Pass-through Entity Nuances and Ownership Changes

The application of R&D credit carry-overs within pass-through entities (PTEs) such as S corporations, partnerships, and LLCs introduces layers of complexity. [cite_start]In a traditional PTE structure, the credit is earned at the entity level based on the QREs incurred by the business, and then it is allocated to the owners via Schedule K-1 based on their ownership share. [cite: 3] [cite_start]The individual owners then carry the credit to their personal income tax returns (SC1040), where the fifty percent utilization limit and ten-year carry-over clock apply at the individual level. [cite: 3]

[cite_start]

Recent shifts in South Carolina law, specifically Revenue Rulings #21-15 and #22-5, have introduced an optional election for “qualified” PTEs to pay tax at the entity level on “active trade or business income” at a rate of three percent. [cite: 3] This election, designed as a workaround for federal SALT deduction limits, significantly alters the R&D credit landscape. [cite_start]If the entity-level tax is elected, the R&D credit can be used to offset this three percent tax. [cite: 3] [cite_start]This may allow for faster absorption of the credit if the owners have multiple sources of income or other personal tax attributes that would otherwise limit their ability to use the credit at the individual level. [cite: 3]

Furthermore, the transfer of R&D credits during corporate reorganizations or ownership changes is governed by strict “successor taxpayer” rules. [cite_start]S.C. Code Section 12-6-3415, in conjunction with broader provisions for economic development, allows a taxpayer to assign unused credits to a succeeding taxpayer if all or substantially all of the assets of the business or a trade division are transferred. [cite: 3] [cite_start]In such cases, the successor inherits the remaining carry-over period of the original credits. [cite: 3] [cite_start]However, SCDOR guidance warns that under IRC Section 382 principles (which South Carolina generally adopts), a change in ownership may impose annual limitations on the amount of pre-change carry-overs that can be used, similar to the treatment of Net Operating Losses (NOLs). [cite: 3]

Interaction with Other Major South Carolina Tax Credits

To accurately model a credit carry-over, one must understand the landscape of competing incentives. The SCDOR’s ordering rules and the specific caps on each credit determine the ultimate tax due and the amount of credit that falls into the carry-over bucket.

[cite_start]

[cite_start]

[cite_start]

[cite_start]

[cite_start]

[cite_start]

The New Jobs Credit, for instance, provides a fifteen-year carry-over, making it a more “durable” asset than the ten-year R&D credit. [cite: 3] However, because the R&D credit is applied after other credits, it is often “squeezed” by the Jobs Credit. If a company has $100,000 in tax and a $60,000 Jobs Credit, they can only use $50,000 of that Jobs Credit (due to its own 50% cap), leaving $50,000 in remaining liability. [cite_start]The R&D credit is then limited to 50% of that remaining $50,000, allowing only $25,000 of R&D credit to be used. [cite: 3] This interplay illustrates how the R&D credit’s “last-in” priority and shorter carry-over period make it one of the most volatile components of a corporate tax strategy.

Comprehensive Example of Credit Carry-over Mechanics

To demonstrate the application of the law and SCDOR guidance, consider the case of “South Carolina Bio-Tech, Inc.,” a mid-sized corporation specializing in pharmaceutical research.

Year 1: Initial Credit Generation

In Year 1, the company incurs $5,000,000 in qualified research expenses in its Charleston facility.

[cite_start]
• SC R&D Credit Earned: $5,000,000 x 5% = $250,000. [cite: 3]
• Gross Tax Liability: $300,000.
• Other Credits (e.g., Jobs Credit): The company uses $50,000 in other credits.

[cite_start]

• Remaining Tax Liability: $300,000 – $50,000 = $250,000. [cite: 3]

[cite_start]

• R&D Utilization Cap: 50% x $250,000 = $125,000. [cite: 3]
• Credit Used in Year 1: $125,000.

[cite_start]

• Credit Carry-over to Year 2: $250,000 – $125,000 = $125,000. [cite: 3]

[cite_start]

• Expiration Date: This carry-over must be used before a tax year beginning on or after ten years from the Year 1 expenditure date. [cite: 3]

Year 2: Expansion and New Credit

In Year 2, the company’s research activities expand, incurring $6,000,000 in QREs.

• New SC R&D Credit Earned: $6,000,000 x 5% = $300,000.
• Gross Tax Liability: $200,000 (Profitability decreased due to expansion costs).
• Remaining Tax Liability (after other credits): $200,000.
• R&D Utilization Cap: 50% x $200,000 = $100,000.

[cite_start]

• Order of Use: The $100,000 limit is first satisfied by the carry-over from Year 1. [cite: 3]
• Year 1 Carry-over Balance: $125,000 – $100,000 = $25,000.
• Year 2 Credit status: The entire $300,000 earned in Year 2 is added to the carry-over pool.
• Total Carry-over Pool for Year 3: $25,000 (from Year 1) + $300,000 (from Year 2) = $325,000.

Year 3: Acquisition Scenario
[cite_start]

Midway through Year 3, South Carolina Bio-Tech, Inc. is acquired by a larger firm, “Global Pharma Corp,” in a deal involving substantially all assets. [cite: 3]

[cite_start]
• Successor Rights: Global Pharma Corp acquires the right to the $325,000 carry-over. [cite: 3]

[cite_start]

• Compliance: Global Pharma Corp must maintain the records of the original Year 1 and Year 2 expenditures to defend the carry-over in an audit. [cite: 3]

[cite_start]

• Utilization: Global Pharma Corp applies the carry-over against its own South Carolina tax liability, still subject to the 50% cap and the original 10-year clocks for each vintage. [cite: 3]

Legislative Evolution: 2025 and 2026 Tax Reforms

The strategic value of R&D credit carry-overs is undergoing a period of significant uncertainty due to legislative activities in the 2025-2026 session of the 126th General Assembly. [cite_start]Key bills, such as House Bill 4216 and Senate Bill 131, have proposed sweeping changes to the state’s income tax structure, including movement toward a flat tax or the eventual elimination of individual income taxes. [cite: 3]

[cite_start]

One of the most impactful proposals involves switching the state tax starting point to Federal Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) and incrementally reducing the top marginal rate to as low as 1.99% or even zero percent, provided certain revenue triggers are met. [cite: 3] While lower tax rates are generally favorable for business, they present a paradoxical challenge for taxpayers holding large R&D credit carry-overs. Because the R&D credit utilization is restricted to fifty percent of the tax liability, a reduction in the tax rate directly reduces the “ceiling” for credit absorption. If a company’s tax rate drops from 6% to 2%, its total liability decreases significantly, which in turn slashes the amount of R&D carry-over that can be used each year. [cite_start]For companies with multi-million dollar carry-over balances, these legislative changes could make it mathematically impossible to exhaust their credits before the ten-year expiration date, effectively devaluing the incentive retroactively. [cite: 3]

Documentation and Audit Readiness for Carry-overs

The SCDOR maintains a rigorous audit posture regarding the Research Expenses Credit and its carry-overs. [cite_start]Success in an audit requires more than just showing a federal Form 6765; the taxpayer must prove the nexus of the expenses to South Carolina. [cite: 3] [cite_start]Guidance from industry experts suggests that taxpayers should maintain contemporaneous records for each project, including time-tracking data for employees, detailed invoices for supplies, and contract research agreements that clearly specify the location of the work. [cite: 3]

For the carry-over itself, the SCDOR requires a clear “paper trail.” [cite_start]When filing Form TC-18, the instructions for line 3 (carry-overs from previous years) imply that a supporting schedule must be attached. [cite: 3] This schedule should include:

• The tax year in which the credit was originally earned.
• The total amount of credit earned in that year (5% of SC QREs).
• The amount of that specific year’s credit used in each subsequent tax year.
• The remaining balance of that specific vintage.
• The calculated expiration date (10 years from the expenditure).

Failure to provide this granular tracking can lead to the disallowance of the entire carry-over during an audit. [cite_start]Furthermore, if a taxpayer is claiming a credit passed through from a partnership or S corporation, they must provide the name and Federal Employer Identification Number (FEIN) of the entity that made the qualifying research expense. [cite: 3] [cite_start]The SCDOR’s MyDORWAY portal and modern filing systems have increased the department’s ability to cross-reference these claims, making accurate data entry and consistency between entity-level and owner-level filings more important than ever. [cite: 3]

Second-Order Insights: Economic Implications and Ripple Effects

The 10-year carry-over provision for the R&D credit creates a unique set of second-order economic effects for the state. First, it encourages long-term commitment to South Carolina’s innovation ecosystem. Because the credits are nonrefundable and have a specific lifespan, companies are incentivized to maintain a consistent presence in the state to ensure they have enough future tax liability to “spend” their accumulated credits. [cite_start]This acts as a form of “retention incentive,” where the value of past research acts as a sunk-cost benefit that is only realizable through continued operation in South Carolina. [cite: 3]

Second, the interaction between the R&D credit carry-over and Net Operating Losses (NOLs) creates a complex capital management challenge. [cite_start]Under South Carolina law, NOLs can be carried forward for twenty years, significantly longer than the ten-year R&D credit carry-over. [cite: 3] For pre-revenue biotech or high-tech firms, this creates a “timing gap.” If a company takes twelve years to reach profitability, its initial NOLs will be available to offset its first profits, but its initial R&D credits will have already expired. This dynamic may force innovative companies to prioritize the use of R&D credits over NOLs where possible—though the law generally requires the calculation of taxable income (including NOL deductions) before the application of tax credits. [cite_start]Consequently, the shorter lifespan of the R&D credit carry-over effectively makes it a “riskier” tax asset than an NOL, potentially influencing the way venture-backed firms value their South Carolina-based intellectual property and tax attributes. [cite: 3]

Finally, the 2025 legislative focus on tax rate reduction could lead to a surge in “credit-clearing” activities. If companies foresee a permanent reduction in their tax rates that will render their carry-overs unusable, they may seek to accelerate their South Carolina tax liability—perhaps by deferring other deductions or opting out of certain entity-level elections—to absorb as much of the R&D carry-over as possible while the tax rates are still high enough to provide a sufficient 50% cap. [cite_start]This behavior demonstrates how the interplay of carry-over durations and fluctuating tax rates can drive corporate behavior in ways that extend far beyond simple tax compliance. [cite: 3]

Summary of SCDOR Procedural Requirements

Taxpayers navigating the R&D credit carry-over must adhere to a strict sequence of administrative steps as outlined in SCDOR revenue procedures and form instructions.

[cite_start]
1. Establishing the Base: Verify that all research activities were conducted within South Carolina and that a federal R&D credit was claimed on Form 6765 for the same year. [cite: 3]

[cite_start]

2. Annual Calculation: Compute the current year credit (5% of SC QREs) and aggregate it with existing carry-overs using Form TC-18. [cite: 3]

[cite_start]

3. Applying the Ordering Rules: Calculate the “remaining tax liability” after applying all other credits, then apply the 50% cap to determine the maximum usable R&D credit for the year. [cite: 3]

[cite_start]

4. Tracking the Vintages: Record the remaining unused credit in a carry-over ledger, ensuring each portion is assigned its correct 10-year expiration date. [cite: 3]

[cite_start]

5. Successor Management: If the business is sold, ensure the transfer of credits is documented via a “Transferor Affidavit” or certificate of compliance to protect the successor’s right to the carry-overs. [cite: 3]

[cite_start]

6. Amending for Closed Years: If claiming missed credits from years beyond the three-year statute of limitations, perform the “look-back” analysis to reduce the carry-over by any amounts that could have been used in the closed years. [cite: 3]

The South Carolina R&D credit and its carry-over mechanism represent a sophisticated component of the state’s tax code. While the five percent rate is straightforward, the fifty percent limitation and the ten-year expiration window create a high-stakes environment for tax planning. [cite_start]As the state moves toward broader tax reforms in 2026, the management of these carry-over “vintages” will remain a top priority for corporate tax departments and their advisors, requiring a vigilant approach to both statutory compliance and administrative guidance. [cite: 3]

Final Thoughts

Managing tax credits in South Carolina requires precise accounting and long-term vision. The 10-year carry-over for R&D expenses is a powerful tool, but its utility is sensitive to profitability and legislative shifts. Effective management ensures that innovative activities translate into lasting fiscal value.