The Kansas R&D Tax Credit: Strategic Analysis of the “Taxpayer Without a Current Tax Liability” Provision

A Taxpayer Without a Current Tax Liability (TWCTL), in the context of the Kansas Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit (K.S.A. 79-32,182b), is a qualified entity that has generated a credit but possesses insufficient or zero current state income tax liability against which to apply it. This statutory status grants the taxpayer the exclusive right to transfer (sell) the full face value of the generated R&D credit to a profitable third party for immediate monetization.

This provision, effective for tax years commencing after December 31, 2022, fundamentally redefines the utility of the Kansas R&D credit, shifting its benefit from a long-term, non-refundable tax offset to a powerful instrument of immediate liquidity for high-growth, innovation-focused companies.

I. Introduction to the Enhanced Kansas R&D Tax Credit Landscape

The Kansas R&D Tax Credit, governed by K.S.A. 79-32,182b, is a key fiscal tool designed to incentivize investment in qualified research activities performed within the state.1 Historically, the credit provided an offset against state income tax liability.3 However, the program underwent a significant transformation through legislative amendments, dramatically improving its scope and market value, particularly for businesses that lack immediate profitability.

Legislative Mandate: K.S.A. 79-32,182b and the 2023 Amendments

The legislative changes introduced by House Bill 2239, effective for tax year 2023 and all years thereafter, established the modern framework for the credit.4 These changes were comprehensive, targeting both the calculation and the monetization potential of the credit:

1. Increased Credit Rate: The credit rate was raised substantially from 6.5% to 10%.1 The calculation remains based on the amount by which current-year expenditures exceed the taxpayer’s average expenditures for the current and two preceding taxable years (the base period calculation).3
2. Expanded Eligibility: Eligibility was broadened to include all Kansas income taxpayers, effectively removing the limitation that historically restricted the credit primarily to C corporations. Now, individuals, partnerships, S corporations, limited liability companies, and other pass-through entities may claim the credit.1
3. Introduction of Transferability: Crucially, K.S.A. 79-32,182b(d) was amended to permit the credit to be transferred by a taxpayer who meets the definition of a TWCTL.1

Defining “Expenditures in Research and Development Activities”

The foundation of the credit calculation rests on defining the activities eligible for the incentive. K.S.A. 79-32,182b specifies that the term “expenditures in research and development activities” refers to expenses that are allowable for deduction under the provisions of the Federal Internal Revenue Code (IRC).1 Specifically, these activities align with the federal definition of Qualified Research Expenses (QREs) under IRC Section 41, provided those activities were conducted within Kansas.2

The Dual Incentive Effect of HB 2239

The concurrent enhancement of the credit rate (to 10%) and the introduction of transferability for entities lacking tax liability created a powerful dual incentive. By increasing the rate and expanding eligibility to include high-growth, early-stage pass-through entities 1, the state maximized the potential volume of credit generation. Simultaneously, by allowing the credit to be transferred away from entities that could not utilize it due to losses or lack of profitability, the state secured immediate monetization for the R&D investment.3 This strategic coupling ensures that the incentive achieves its intended purpose: directly funding capital-intensive R&D projects in sectors like technology, advanced manufacturing, and agriculture, even when the generating companies are not yet revenue-positive.

II. Statutory Interpretation of “Taxpayer Without a Current Tax Liability”

The status of being a TWCTL is the single statutory prerequisite enabling the monetization of the R&D credit through transfer. Understanding the definition and its application is crucial for compliance and strategic planning.

Statutory Foundation and the Transfer Trigger

Subsection (d) of K.S.A. 79-32,182b states clearly that the income tax credit “shall be transferable by a taxpayer without a current tax liability”.5

The practical, operational meaning of “current tax liability” refers to the calculated Kansas income tax due for the specific taxable year before attempting to apply any non-refundable tax credits, including the R&D credit. If this amount is calculated as zero, or if the taxpayer’s computed R&D credit exceeds the amount of tax liability, thus rendering the credit unusable in that tax year, the taxpayer satisfies the TWCTL criterion.

Practical Application of TWCTL Status

The TWCTL provision is primarily beneficial for two types of entities:

1. High-Growth Startups: Companies heavily focused on R&D often report Net Operating Losses (NOLs) during their initial growth phases, eliminating any state income tax liability. While these businesses are generating significant QREs, they cannot use a non-refundable credit internally. Their TWCTL status allows them to sell the credit for cash, providing critical funding for ongoing research.
2. Pass-Through Entities with Loss Allocation: The expansion of eligibility to pass-through entities (S-Corps and LLCs) necessitates flexibility. If a pass-through entity generates a credit but reports minimal entity-level income in Kansas, or if the owners’ individual tax situations prevent immediate utilization, the entity can qualify as a TWCTL. This enables the entity to transfer the credit en masse, which is often preferable to tracking and allocating dormant, unused credits among potentially numerous partners or shareholders.7

Liquidity vs. Non-Refundability

The R&D credit is inherently non-refundable.3 This means that, absent the transfer provision, a taxpayer lacking current liability would be forced to carry the unused credit forward indefinitely.3 While an indefinite carryforward is highly beneficial compared to credits that expire, it represents delayed cash flow and is subject to the risk that the company may never achieve sufficient future liability to fully utilize the credit.

The transferability provision transforms this dilemma. By qualifying as a TWCTL, the generating entity can sell the credit for immediate cash consideration, effectively creating a direct subsidy for their R&D investments, much like a refundable credit, but funded by the private market. This mechanism transfers the time value of money risk and the administrative burden of tracking the indefinite carryforward to the purchasing party, typically a large, profitable corporation seeking tax offsets.

III. Pre-Transfer Compliance: Credit Generation and Certification Guidance (KDOR Requirements)

The Kansas Department of Revenue (KDOR) requires strict adherence to specific forms and procedures to ensure the validity and proper tracking of R&D credits before and after a transfer.

Mandatory Application and Certification (Form K-204)

Unlike prior years, taxpayers wishing to claim or transfer the R&D credit must first complete and submit Form K-204, the Research and Development Credit Application.1 This application process is a crucial prerequisite for transferability. The mandate for pre-certification arose directly from the ability to transfer the credit, ensuring that the total eligible amount is validated by KDOR before the credit becomes a market asset.

Calculating the Transferable Amount (KDOR Schedule K-53, Part A)

The calculation of the credit amount is standardized through the use of KDOR Schedule K-53. The transferor (the TWCTL) is responsible for completing Part A of this schedule to establish the face value of the credit being sold.

The calculation steps are precise, based on K.S.A. 79-32,182b 3:

1. Current Year QREs (Line 1): Enter the amount expended for R&D activities in Kansas during the taxable year.
2. Base Period Calculation (Lines 2a, 2b, 3, 4): Enter the QREs for the two preceding tax years. The current year’s QREs are added to the QREs of the two preceding years (Line 3), and this total is divided by three to establish the average expenditures (Line 4).3 This average forms the base amount.
3. Eligible Excess (Line 5): Subtract the average expenditures (Line 4) from the current year’s QREs (Line 1). This yields the excess amount eligible for the credit.9 If the current expenditures are less than or equal to the base, no credit is generated.
4. Total Credit (Line 6): Multiply the eligible excess (Line 5) by the 10% credit rate.5 This figure represents the total face value of the credit generated and the exact dollar amount that must be transferred.

The KDOR procedural guidance states that the transferor must complete K-53 through Line 7 (which determines the 25% annual cap) and then STOP. This partially completed K-53 (Part A) must then be provided to the transferee.9 This procedure ensures that the calculation of the credit is complete and certified, while reserving the utilization steps (Part B) for the party that will actually apply the credit against a tax liability.

IV. The Credit Transfer Process: Exhaustive KDOR Regulatory Requirements

The formal conveyance of the R&D tax credit is governed by specific documentation requirements and statutory constraints designed to maintain program integrity and market transparency.

Documentation Requirement: Form K-260 (Tax Credit Transfer Notification)

The transferor and the transferee must jointly complete and submit Form K-260, the Tax Credit Transfer Notification form, to KDOR.10 The purpose of K-260 is to formally notify the Department of Revenue that the credit has been transferred by agreement between the parties.10 It is explicitly noted that K-260 serves as a notification form only; it is not the legal transfer agreement between the transferor and transferee.10

Crucially, the K-260 requires detailed financial transparency regarding the transaction. The form mandates the disclosure of the “Dollar amount received by transferor in payment for credits” and the “Dollar amount paid by transferee for credit”.10 By requiring this market data, the state gains vital information necessary for fiscal planning and program evaluation. KDOR is able to calculate the effective market discount rate applied to these credits, quantifying the true cost of the incentive and assessing the level of immediate financial support being channeled to R&D companies.

Essential Statutory Limitations on the Transfer Transaction

To prevent the development of a complex, unregulated secondary market and to simplify KDOR’s tracking obligations, the legislature placed strict limitations on the transfer itself:

1. Transfer in Full Only: The statute requires that only the full amount of the credit generated (K-53, Line 6) may be transferred.2 Partial transfers are not permissible.
2. Single Transfer Limitation: The R&D tax credit may only be transferred once.2 Only the entity that originally earned the credit is allowed to execute the transfer. The transferee cannot subsequently resell the credit.
3. Transferee Liability: The credit remains a tax offset. The transferee is not entitled to a refund if the transferred credit exceeds their tax liability in any given year.8 Excess credit must be carried forward.

The table below summarizes these essential limitations and their operational necessity.

Table 3: Transfer Constraints and Strategic Rationale

V. Utilization and Carryforward Rules for the Transferee

Once the transfer is complete and Form K-260 is filed, the transferee assumes ownership of the credit, subject to the established utilization rules codified in K.S.A. 79-32,182b.

The Annual Claim Limitation: The 25% Throttle

The primary constraint on utilizing the R&D credit is the annual limitation defined in subsection (b) of the statute.5 In any one taxable year, the amount of the credit allowable for deduction from the taxpayer’s tax liability cannot exceed 25% of the total amount of the credit generated, plus any applicable carryforward amount from previous years.3

This 25% utilization cap mandates that, assuming a taxpayer has sufficient tax liability, the credit must be utilized over a minimum of four tax years.11 This time constraint is a critical element influencing the market valuation of the credit, as the profitable transferee must discount the future value of the tax offset when determining the current price paid to the TWCTL.

Indefinite Carryforward Provisions for Transferees

Any amount of the credit that cannot be claimed in the current year, either due to the 25% limitation or due to insufficient tax liability, is subject to a carryforward provision.5 Unused credits may be carried forward indefinitely until the total amount of the credit is utilized.3 This indefinite carryforward substantially mitigates the risk for the transferee. If the transferee experiences unexpected financial losses or a significant reduction in tax liability, the value of the purchased credit is preserved, ensuring that the full investment in the tax credit will eventually be realized.

Claiming the Credit: Transferee’s Role on Schedule K-53, Part B

The transferee completes Part B of Schedule K-53, using the credit amount provided by the transferor (K-53, Line 6) to manage the annual deduction.9

The utilization process in Part B involves:

1. Tax Liability Confirmation (Line 8): Enter the amount of the current year’s Kansas tax liability.
2. Allowed Credit (Line 9): The allowed credit is the lesser of the maximum annual claim (the 25% cap) or the current year’s tax liability.9 This is the amount actually claimed against the tax due.
3. Carryforward Calculation (Line 10): The amount of credit that remains unused (total credit minus the amount claimed on Line 9) becomes the carryforward amount for the next taxable year.9

VI. Practical Application Example: Transferring a $200,000 R&D Credit

To illustrate the mechanism, consider the transfer cycle of an R&D credit from a generating TWCTL to a profitable purchasing corporation.

Scenario Setup: InnovateTech LLC (The TWCTL)

InnovateTech LLC, an early-stage biotechnology firm, conducts substantial R&D in Kansas but incurred an overall loss for the tax year 2023.

• Credit Generated: InnovateTech successfully calculates a total R&D credit of $200,000 (K-53, Line 6).
• TWCTL Status: InnovateTech has $0 current Kansas income tax liability, fulfilling the requirement for transferability.5
• Annual Utilization Limit: The statutory cap is 25% of the total credit, equaling $200,000 $\times$ 0.25 = $50,000.9
• Transfer Transaction: InnovateTech sells the full $200,000 credit to MegaCorp, a profitable Kansas manufacturer, for $160,000. InnovateTech files Form K-204 (Application) and jointly files Form K-260 (Transfer Notification) with MegaCorp, documenting the $160,000 payment.1

Transferee Utilization Model: MegaCorp Tax Planning

MegaCorp purchases the $200,000 credit. Since the credit is subject to the 25% annual utilization cap, MegaCorp must spread the utilization over multiple years, managing the interaction between the cap and its fluctuating liability.

Table 4: Multi-Year Utilization Schedule for $200,000 Transferred R&D Credit

Financial Analysis of Economic Benefit

The transfer mechanism creates distinct and immediate benefits for both parties:

• InnovateTech (Transferor Benefit): By qualifying as a TWCTL, InnovateTech transforms a $200,000 potential future tax reduction into $160,000 of immediate, liquid capital. This capital is immediately available for reinvestment in R&D or operations, far exceeding the economic utility of a non-refundable credit that would otherwise sit unused for several years.3
• MegaCorp (Transferee Benefit): MegaCorp secures a $200,000 tax offset for a cost of $160,000, resulting in a net tax savings of $40,000. This saving is realized over the five-year utilization period, offering a direct, favorable return on investment calculated at a 25% premium (200,000 / 160,000 = 1.25).

The example demonstrates the necessity of the indefinite carryforward and the non-refundable constraint. In Year 3, MegaCorp’s liability ($40,000) was less than its maximum annual claim ($50,000). Since the credit is non-refundable, MegaCorp could only claim $40,000 that year.8 The remaining portion of the credit was preserved and added to the carryforward, ensuring the credit’s value is maintained until sufficient liability arises.

Conclusion: Strategic Implications and Future Outlook

The definition and application of “Taxpayer Without a Current Tax Liability” is the fulcrum of the modernized Kansas R&D Tax Credit. By permitting transferability for TWCTLs, the state has decoupled the incentive’s economic value from the generating company’s immediate profitability. This legislative design ensures that R&D investment receives immediate, market-based funding, regardless of whether the business is currently generating taxable income. This strategy is critical for supporting the small business and startup ecosystem, which frequently drives innovation but suffers from acute cash-flow demands.

For corporations operating in Kansas, the availability of these transferred credits presents a significant opportunity for managing effective tax rates and securing predictable tax offsets over multiple periods. However, successful engagement with the R&D credit transfer market requires rigorous compliance, including pre-certification via Form K-204, precise calculation via Schedule K-53, and mandatory market transparency reporting via Form K-260. Furthermore, transferees must model their utilization strategy carefully, factoring in the non-refundable nature of the credit and the strict 25% annual claim limitation. The indefinite carryforward provision serves as a robust mechanism stabilizing the value of the acquired credits against future market volatility.

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/