Modernizing Arizona’s Innovation Infrastructure: A Policy Whitepaper on Streamlining University Research and Development Tax Credit Administration

Executive Summary

The State of Arizona stands at a critical juncture in its evolution as a global leader in high-technology manufacturing, aerospace, and biotechnology. Central to this competitive positioning is the Arizona Research and Development (R&D) tax credit, a robust fiscal tool designed to incentivize private sector investment in scientific discovery. While the general credit framework has proven successful in attracting large-scale capital investments, a specific and highly valuable component—the University Research and Development Tax Credit—remains underutilized due to a “dual-certification” administrative bottleneck. To claim the additional 10% credit for university-led research, businesses must navigate a redundant, multi-agency approval process, obtaining separate letters of certification from both the Arizona Commerce Authority (ACA) and the Arizona Department of Revenue (ADOR).

This administrative friction creates a disproportionate burden for small to medium-sized businesses (SMBs), which lack the extensive legal and tax departments of multinational corporations. The requirement effectively doubles the compliance workload for academic collaborations, discouraging the very industry-university partnerships that are vital for technology transfer and long-term economic growth. This whitepaper analyzes the current statutory framework, provides a deep dive into the economic multipliers associated with Arizona’s public university system, and proposes two primary solutions: the implementation of an Inter-Agency Unified Certification Portal and a legislative shift toward a single-agency oversight model. By integrating robust anti-fraud mechanisms—informed by recent Auditor General findings—Arizona can reduce “red tape” for innovative SMBs while ensuring fiscal integrity. The following analysis demonstrates that the cost of inaction includes the stagnation of Arizona’s knowledge economy, while a strategic shift toward administrative modernization will yield high-multiplier returns that more than compensate for the initial programmatic investment.

The Foundation of Arizona’s Research and Development Framework

The Arizona R&D tax credit is a cornerstone of the state’s strategy to foster an environment conducive to innovation. Enacted initially for corporations in 1992 and expanded to individual taxpayers in 1999, the credit aligns with the federal Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 41 but includes significant state-specific enhancements.¹ The primary objective is to lower the marginal cost of research activities conducted entirely within the state of Arizona, thereby encouraging businesses to maintain and expand their scientific operations here rather than in competing jurisdictions.²

Statutory Tiers and Post-2030 Sunsets

The current credit structure is aggressively tiered to support businesses across various scales of operation. For taxable years beginning before December 31, 2030, the credit is calculated based on “excess” qualified research expenditures (QREs) over a historical base amount.³ The following table summarizes the existing and future rate structures as established by A.R.S. § 43-1168 and § 43-1074.01.

Table 1: Arizona R&D Credit Rate Structure

Data Source: 4

The 24% tier is particularly vital for the SMB sector, as it provides a higher rate of return for the first $2.5 million in research investment. This structure recognizes that for smaller firms, the initial capital outlay for R&D is often the most significant barrier to entry. However, the scheduled reduction in rates starting in 2031 highlights a finite window of opportunity for the state to maximize the impact of these incentives.⁴

The University R&D Add-on: A Strategic Imperative

In 2011, as part of the Arizona Competitiveness Package, the legislature enhanced the R&D framework by introducing an additional 10% credit for “basic research payments” made to universities under the jurisdiction of the Arizona Board of Regents (ABOR), namely Arizona State University (ASU), the University of Arizona (UA), and Northern Arizona University (NAU).² This credit is cumulative, meaning a business could potentially realize a combined state tax credit of 34% on its first $2.5 million of university-led research expenditures.⁸

Basic research, as defined by IRC § 41(e), refers to original investigation for the advancement of scientific knowledge not having a specific commercial objective.⁹ By incentivizing this foundational work, the state aims to capitalize on the vast research infrastructure of its universities. These institutions collectively conduct billions of dollars in research annually, funded by federal grants and private partnerships.¹¹ The university credit seeks to ensure that more of this research is funded by, and eventually commercialized by, Arizona-based companies.

The Policy Issue: The Dual-Certification Bottleneck

Despite the high theoretical value of the University R&D credit, the administrative process required to claim it has become a significant deterrent, particularly for SMBs. Unlike the general R&D credit, which is largely self-assessed through the filing of Arizona Form 308 or 308-I, the university-led research credit requires a mandatory, two-step pre-approval process involving two distinct state agencies before any credit can be claimed.⁸

Phase I: The Arizona Commerce Authority Certification

The taxpayer must first apply to the Arizona Commerce Authority for a certification of the basic research payments. This application is typically submitted through the ACA’s Electronic Application System (EASY).¹³ The ACA’s role is to verify that the payments were indeed “basic research payments” and that they were made to a qualified ABOR university pursuant to a written contract.⁸

Crucially, the ACA must also manage a $10 million annual statewide cap on these certifications.¹ Once the ACA has verified the eligibility and confirmed the availability of space under the cap, it issues a certification letter to the taxpayer. This process is governed by A.R.S. § 41-1507.01.¹

Phase II: The Arizona Department of Revenue Approval

Possessing the ACA certification letter is only the first step. The taxpayer must then submit a separate “Application for Approval” to the Arizona Department of Revenue (ADOR).¹ This second application must include the ACA certification as an attachment.¹ ADOR then reviews the application and, if satisfied, issues its own “Letter of Approval,” which certifies the precise dollar amount of the credit the taxpayer is authorized to claim on their tax return using Arizona Form 346.¹

Redundancy and SMB Impact

For a large corporation with a dedicated tax and compliance team, this two-step process is a manageable administrative task. For an SMB, however, the dual-certification requirement presents several critical challenges:

• Redundant Data Entry: The taxpayer is required to provide much of the same information—business identification numbers, research descriptions, and payment proofs—to two different agencies on two different platforms.¹
• Sequential Delay: Because Phase II cannot begin until Phase I is complete, the total time required to obtain final approval can span several months. For SMBs operating on tight fiscal cycles, this delay creates uncertainty in tax planning and financial reporting.
• Compliance Costs: Many SMBs must hire outside consultants to navigate this bifurcated system. The professional fees associated with managing two separate state applications can consume a significant portion of the 10% credit’s value, particularly for smaller research projects.⁵
• “Soft Cap” Deterrence: The $10 million cap is a legislative control on the state’s fiscal exposure, but the administrative burden acts as a “soft cap,” discouraging eligible firms from even applying. This leads to an underutilization of the program and a missed opportunity for industry-university collaboration.⁶

Contextualizing SMB Challenges within the R&D Framework

To understand why the dual-certification issue is so critical for SMBs, one must examine the broader Arizona R&D landscape for small firms. Arizona is one of the few states that offers a “true” refundable R&D tax credit, but it is exclusively for companies with fewer than 150 full-time employees.³

The Refundable Credit Mechanism

For pre-revenue startups or loss-position SMBs, a nonrefundable credit has little immediate value. To address this, A.R.S. § 41-1507 allows qualified small businesses to elect a partial refund of 75% of their excess R&D credits, while forfeiting the remaining 25%.³ This refund is capped at $100,000 per taxpayer per year and is subject to a $5 million annual statewide aggregate cap.⁵

The application for this refund is highly competitive and operates on a first-come, first-served basis. Applications submitted on the first business day of the year are often entered into a random lottery because the demand ($6.7 million in 2022) regularly exceeds the $5 million supply.⁴

The Administrative Complexity Matrix

An SMB engaging in university research and seeking a refund for its general research expenses must manage a dizzying array of requirements.

Table 2: The Administrative Complexity Matrix for SMBs

Data Source: 1

When an SMB navigates the “general” refund process, they are already under extreme temporal pressure due to the $5 million cap. Adding the dual-certification requirement for university-led work essentially creates a “compliance trap” where an error in one sequence can lead to the forfeiture of the entire incentive.

Economic Multipliers: The Impact of University-Industry Collaboration

The primary justification for streamlining the University R&D credit administration is the outsized economic impact of university research. These institutions do not operate in a vacuum; they serve as magnets for talent and capital.

The Arizona Public University Enterprise

In fiscal year 2024, Arizona State University’s total economic impact in the state was estimated at $6.1 billion from operating and construction expenditures alone.²² When accounting for the higher wages of alumni and the impact of university-linked businesses, that figure rises to approximately $32 billion.²³ The University of Arizona’s Tech Parks drive an annual economic impact of $2.6 billion, supporting nearly 16,000 jobs in 2024.²⁴

The Technology Research Initiative Fund (TRIF), established in 2001, provides a baseline for research expansion, with the university system receiving over $138 million in TRIF revenue in FY 2025.¹¹ This public investment is designed to be leveraged by private sector partnerships. For example, ASU’s TRIF investments fueled $834 million in outside-related sponsored project funding in a single year.¹¹

The Multiplier Effect of R&D Incentives

Research and development activities have high “multiplier effects” because they create high-wage employment for scientists, engineers, and technicians.²² These employees, in turn, spend their income in the local economy, supporting secondary jobs in retail, housing, and services. According to ASU’s Office of the University Economist, student and faculty spending alone supports tens of thousands of Arizona jobs.²²

By streamlining the 10% university credit, the state can:

• Increase Technology Transfer: Facilitate the movement of inventions from university labs to the marketplace. UA’s Tech Launch Arizona (TLA) saw 324 invention disclosures and 94 patents issued in FY 2025.²⁸
• Support Deep Tech Startups: Enable early-stage companies to access specialized university equipment and expertise that they could not afford to build in-house.³
• Enhance Workforce Development: Research partnerships provide graduate students with real-world industry experience, increasing the likelihood that they will remain in Arizona after graduation.¹¹

Proposed Solution 1: The Inter-Agency Unified Certification Portal

The most immediate and practical solution for the Arizona Legislature is to leverage existing digital government initiatives to eliminate redundancy.

Integration with Arizona Business One-Stop

The state has already launched the “Arizona Business One-Stop” (B1S) portal, a secure digital experience intended to provide a single online location for entrepreneurs to plan, start, and run their businesses.²⁹ Currently, B1S handles entity formation, tax licensing, and trade name registration.²⁹

Mechanism for Implementation:

• Unified R&D Module: Expand the B1S portal to include an R&D Incentive Module. A business would submit a single application for the university research credit.
• Digital Data Routing: Upon submission, the portal would automatically route the “research verification” data to the ACA and the “tax liability/calculation” data to the ADOR.
• Automated Cross-Verification: The system could pull actual research payment data directly from the universities via a secure API, eliminating the need for the business to upload redundant invoices and bank statements.³²
• Single Innovation Certificate: Instead of two separate letters, the agencies would collaborate on the back-end to issue a single “Arizona University Research Certification.” This digital certificate would contain a unique identifier that the business simply enters on Form 346 when filing their taxes.

Benefit to the State and SMBs

This solution respects the statutory roles of both agencies but hides the complexity from the taxpayer. It aligns with Governor Katie Hobbs’ recent executive orders aimed at cutting bureaucracy and “unleashing” the economy by putting “common sense before outdated policies”.³³

Proposed Solution 2: Statutory Consolidation and the “Deemed Approval” Model

While technology can mask administrative friction, statutory reform can remove it entirely. The legislature should consider a “Single Agency Certification” model for the University R&D credit.

ACA as the Sole Certifying Authority

The legislature could amend A.R.S. § 41-1507.01 to empower the ACA as the sole agency responsible for both certifying the research and approving the credit amount. Under this model:

• The ACA would manage the $10 million cap and verify the basic research payments.
• The ACA would issue the final approval letter, which would be legally binding for tax purposes.
• The ADOR would shift to a “post-performance audit” role, much like it does with the general R&D credit.⁵

The “Deemed Approval” for Established Partnerships

To further benefit SMBs that engage in recurring collaborations with Arizona universities, the state could implement a “Deemed Approval” mechanism.

• Pre-Authorized Research Agreements: Universities could submit standard basic research contract templates to the ACA for pre-approval.
• Expedited Certification: If a business uses a pre-authorized contract and the university confirms receipt of the cash payment, the certification would be “deemed approved” within 10 business days. This provides the business with the certainty required to move forward with scientific project milestones without waiting for bureaucratic cycles.

Implementation: Ensuring Integrity and Preventing Fraud

A primary concern when streamlining any tax incentive is the potential for fraud and wastage. Recent reports from the Arizona Auditor General provide a clear roadmap for what must be avoided.

Lessons from Auditor General Report 23-116

In September 2023, a sunset review of the ACA revealed significant gaps in documentation and verification procedures for other incentive programs, such as the Quality Jobs tax credit and A1 grants.³⁴ The Auditor General found that the ACA:

• Lacked evidence that it verified business-reported information (such as wage targets and capital investments) before approving incentives.³⁵
• Did not frequently conduct wage verifications for tax credits.³⁵
• Approved incentives for businesses that did not meet all statutory requirements.³⁵

Built-in Safeguards for the R&D Credit

To avoid these pitfalls in a streamlined R&D process, the state must implement the following controls:

• Independent University Confirmation: The “loophole” of relying solely on business-reported data can be closed by requiring the recipient university to electronically confirm the receipt of the research payment. This creates an “independent third-party verification” that is far more reliable than internal company spreadsheets.³⁷
• Automated Compliance Checks: The unified portal should automatically cross-reference applications against the state’s E-Verify records and Department of Economic Security (DES) payroll data to ensure the business meets all employer requirements set forth in A.R.S. § 23-214 (B).¹
• Strict Documentation Requirements: Following the Auditor General’s recommendations, the new system must require and store digital copies of actual invoices, bank transfers, and executed research contracts.³⁶
• Transparent Reporting: The ACA already publishes annual and quarterly reports on incentive performance.³⁷ A streamlined R&D system should include a “Transparency Dashboard” where the public can see the aggregate amount of university credits certified, the specific universities involved, and the resulting economic impact (e.g., patent filings and spin-off companies).

Cost Analysis: Initial Outlay and Future Dividends

Modernizing the R&D tax credit administration requires a targeted investment, but this cost must be framed within the context of Arizona’s multi-billion dollar research economy.

Initial Outlay: Modernization Costs

The primary cost would be the development of the R&D module within the Business One-Stop portal. In FY 2024 and 2025, the state budget already allocated significant funds (millions of dollars) for IT automation and “One-Stop” funding.³⁹ Diverting a fraction of these resources to R&D integration would represent a marginal increase in the state’s digital government spend.

Table 3: Estimated Initial Outlay

Data Source: Projected based on 32

Future Benefits: The ROI of Streamlining

The return on this investment will manifest in several high-value areas:

• Administrative Efficiency: By eliminating redundant data entry and manual hand-offs between agencies, the state reduces the labor hours required to process applications. This allows agency staff to focus on high-value audit and verification tasks rather than clerical oversight.
• Incremental Tax Revenue: The University R&D credit is designed to attract new research spending. If a streamlined process increases participation by just 10-15%, the resulting high-wage jobs and corporate activity will generate significant new revenue from personal income tax, sales tax (as researchers spend their wages), and the “multiplier effect” of university-linked startups.²²
• Competitive Edge: As states like Utah and Texas aggressively recruit Arizona tech firms, a modernized, frictionless incentive system serves as a powerful “retention” tool. Utah’s “post-performance” model, for example, has seen record success by focusing on ease of use for the private sector.⁴¹

The Importance of Change: The Cost of Inaction

The decision to reform the dual-certification process is not merely a matter of administrative convenience; it is a matter of strategic survival in a hyper-competitive national landscape.

Consequences of Maintaining the Status Quo

If Arizona fails to modernize its R&D administration, the following negative consequences will likely accelerate:

• Stagnation of the SMB Innovation Pipeline: SMBs are the primary engines of disruptive innovation. If they are boxed out of university research by “red tape,” Arizona will see fewer locally grown “unicorns” and a higher reliance on attracting established out-of-state giants.
• The “Brain Drain” of Research Talent: ASU, UA, and NAU produce world-class PhDs and researchers. If local SMBs cannot easily partner with these universities to hire and fund these graduates, they will leave for states with more integrated “innovation ecosystems”.¹¹
• Fiscal Wastage through Underutilization: The state has already authorized the $10 million cap. Maintaining an administrative system that makes it too hard to access this authorized support is an inefficient use of legislative intent.
• Increased Audit Friction: The current bifurcated system is prone to honest administrative errors. These errors lead to unnecessary audits, which drain the resources of both the state and the taxpayer.⁵

The Vision: A Frictionless Innovation State

Arizona has already proven that it can be a leader in specific sectors like semiconductors and renewable energy.³³ By applying that same “pro-growth” mindset to its R&D tax credit administration, the state can create a frictionless environment where a startup can partner with a university lab as easily as it can register a business name. This reform will signal to the national market that Arizona is not just open for business, but is the premier destination for the most advanced scientific operations in the world.

Conclusions and Actionable Recommendations

The evidence presented in this whitepaper indicates that the current dual-certification requirement for the Arizona University Research and Development Tax Credit is an anachronistic hurdle that undermines the state’s innovation goals. To address this, the following recommendations are proposed:

1. Immediate B1S Integration: The Governor should direct the Arizona Commerce Authority and the Department of Revenue to prioritize the integration of R&D credit applications into the Arizona Business One-Stop portal by the 2027 fiscal year.
2. Statutory Simplification: The Legislature should introduce a bill to amend A.R.S. § 41-1507.01, moving to a single-agency certification model for the 10% university credit, with the ACA as the lead agency and ADOR in a post-filing audit capacity.
3. Third-Party Data Verification: Implement a digital confirmation system where ABOR universities directly verify research payments, reducing the documentation burden on SMBs while significantly strengthening anti-fraud protections.
4. Small Business Advocacy: The state’s Small Business Advocate should be tasked with monitoring the utilization of the University R&D credit and reporting annually on the effectiveness of these streamlining efforts.⁴³

By taking these steps, Arizona will demonstrate a commitment to regulatory fairness, fiscal integrity, and the long-term prosperity of its citizens. The time to modernize the state’s innovation infrastructure is now, before the 2030 sunset provisions further reduce the inherent value of these critical incentives.

Works Cited

1. Arizona R&D Tax Credit | AndreTaxCo, PLLC, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.andretaxco.com/arizona-rdcredits
2. Arizona Incentives – Research and Development Tax Credit Program for Business in AZ, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azcommerce.com/incentives/research-development-tax-credit/
3. Arizona R&D Tax Credits, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.striketax.com/state-rd-credits/arizona-r-d-tax-credits
4. Arizona Commerce Authority REFUNDABLE RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT TAX CREDIT – Program Rules & Guidelines0F, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azcommerce.com/media/ipolf0kc/aca-ruling-24-04-rd-website.pdf
5. Arizona R&D Tax Credit: Everything You Need To Know – Boast, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.boast.ai/en-ca/blog/innovation-insights/arizona-rd-tax-credits
6. Arizona Form 300 Instructions – Swanson Reed, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.swansonreed.com/research-tax-credit/arizona/glossary/arizona-form-300-corporate-compliance/
7. Certificate of Qualification – Swanson Reed, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.swansonreed.com/research-tax-credit/arizona/glossary/arizona-certificate-qualification-strategic-compliance-liquidity/
8. University Research and Development Income Tax Credit, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azcommerce.com/incentives/research-development-tax-credit/university-research-and-development-income-tax-credit/
9. Form 346: Claim Your Research Tax Credit – Swanson Reed, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.swansonreed.com/glossary/arizona/form-346/
10. 2023 Income Tax Credit Review – JLBC, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azjlbc.gov/revenues/jlitcrcrpt121223.pdf
11. FY 2025 TECHNOLOGY AND RESEARCH INITIATIVE FUND REPORT – | Arizona Board of Regents, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azregents.edu/sites/default/files/reports/2025-Technology-Research-Initiative-Fund-Annual-Report-R1.pdf
12. fiscal year 2024 – research and technology transfer activity report – | Arizona Board of Regents, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azregents.edu/sites/default/files/reports/2024_Annual_Research-Report.pdf
13. Arizona Commerce Authority REFUNDABLE RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT TAX CREDIT – Program Rules & Guidelines1, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azcommerce.com/media/1544133/rd-guidelines.pdf
14. R&D Refundable Tax Credit – Arizona Commerce Authority, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azcommerce.com/incentives/research-development-tax-credit/rd-refundable-tax-credit/
15. Arizona Revised Statutes Title 43. Taxation of Income § 43-1168 – Codes – FindLaw, accessed March 16, 2026, https://codes.findlaw.com/az/title-43-taxation-of-income/az-rev-st-sect-43-1168/
16. Arizona Revised Statutes § 41-1507.01 (2025) – Certification of basic research payments to a university – Justia Law, accessed March 16, 2026, https://law.justia.com/codes/arizona/title-41/section-41-1507-01/
17. University R&D Credit App – Swanson Reed, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.swansonreed.com/research-tax-credit/arizona/glossary/arizona-university-rd-tax-credit-approval-guide/
18. Arizona Form 346 Instructions – Swanson Reed, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.swansonreed.com/research-tax-credit/arizona/glossary/arizona-form-346-university-research-and-development-tax-credit/
19. How to apply for Arizona’s refundable R&D tax credit | Baker Tilly, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.bakertilly.com/insights/new-cap-for-arizona-rd-refundable-credit
20. R&D Tax Credit Explained for Arizona Companies – Swanson Reed, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.swansonreed.com/research-tax-credit/arizona/
21. Arizona Commerce Authority REFUNDABLE RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT TAX CREDIT – Program Rules & Guidelines, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azcommerce.com/media/32116/RD-Guidelines-1-2-13.pdf
22. The Economic Impact of Arizona State University on the Arizona Economy, Fiscal Year 2024, accessed March 16, 2026, https://ccpr.wpcarey.asu.edu/sites/g/files/litvpz1326/files/2024-11/asuimpact11-24_0.pdf
23. ASU boosts the economic vitality of Arizona, accessed March 16, 2026, https://news.asu.edu/20250124-local-national-and-global-affairs-asu-boosts-economic-vitality-arizona
24. Economic Impact Studies | AURP – Association of University Research Parks, accessed March 16, 2026, https://aurp.org/resources/economic-impact-studies/
25. Research & Development Tax Credit: The Basics for Employers – 3Sixty Advisors, accessed March 16, 2026, https://3sixtyadvisor.com/research-development-tax-credit-the-basics-for-employers/
26. Community Impact – Office of Research and Partnerships, accessed March 16, 2026, https://research.arizona.edu/impact/community-impact
27. Economic and Fiscal Impact of the Arizona Public University Enterprise, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azregents.edu/sites/default/files/reports/Economic-Impact-Report-FY17.pdf
28. Fiscal year 2025, the University of Arizona breaks record (again) for impactful inventions, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azbio.org/fiscal-year-2025-the-university-of-arizona-breaks-record-again-for-impactful-inventions
29. Arizona Business One Stop – STRATEGIC ENTERPRISE TECHNOLOGY, accessed March 16, 2026, https://aset.az.gov/programs/arizona-business-one-stop
30. Arizona Business One Stop | Home, accessed March 16, 2026, https://businessonestop.az.gov/
31. Partnerships – Arizona Business One Stop, accessed March 16, 2026, https://businessonestop.az.gov/tags/partnerships
32. Update: Business One Stop (B1S) Portal Integration with Arizona Business Connect, accessed March 16, 2026, https://businessonestop.az.gov/news/update-business-one-stop-b1s-portal-integration-arizona-business-connect
33. Governor Katie Hobbs Acts to Cut Red Tape, Unleash Arizona Energy, and Lower Energy Costs, accessed March 16, 2026, https://azgovernor.gov/office-arizona-governor/news/2025/09/governor-katie-hobbs-acts-cut-red-tape-unleash-arizona-energy
34. Arizona Commerce Authority – Auditor General, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azauditor.gov/sites/default/files/2023-11/23-116_Auditor%2520General%2520Comments%2520on%2520the%2520ACA%2520Response.pdf
35. Arizona Commerce Authority – Auditor General, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azauditor.gov/sites/default/files/2023-11/23-116_Report.pdf
36. Arizona Commerce Authority – Auditor General, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azauditor.gov/sites/default/files/2023-11/23-116_Highlights.pdf
37. Arizona Commerce Authority, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azauditor.gov/sites/default/files/2023-11/23-116_Response.pdf
38. Employer Bill of Rights – Arizona Department of Economic Security, accessed March 16, 2026, https://des.az.gov/content/employer-bill-rights
39. 2024 Legislative Summary – Arizona Legislature, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azleg.gov/alispdfs/56leg/2R/Senate/SummaryComplete.pdf
40. Auditor General: Home, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azauditor.gov/
41. Business Recruitment and Expansion – Governor’s Office of Economic Opportunity – Utah.gov, accessed March 16, 2026, https://business.utah.gov/recruitment/
42. Utah’s Business Incentives Program Achieves Record Successes in FY 2025, accessed March 16, 2026, https://business.utah.gov/news/utahs-business-incentives-program-achieves-record-successes-in-fy-2025/
43. 41-1001.01 – Regulatory bill of rights; small businesses, accessed March 16, 2026, https://www.azleg.gov/ars/41/01001-01.htm
44. Relevant Statutory Provisions – Small Business Bill of Rights – ACC Portal – Arizona Corporation Commission, accessed March 16, 2026, https://efiling.azcc.gov/online-services/small-business