What an R&D Tax Credit Engagement Letter Should Establish
The engagement letter records what the advisor has agreed to do, what the client must provide, how work will be charged, and when each party’s responsibilities begin and end. It should identify the client entities, tax years, jurisdictions, deliverables, and any work expressly excluded. Clear written acceptance helps both parties understand the arrangement.
A written agreement can reduce misunderstandings, but it does not guarantee service quality, tax eligibility, or an audit outcome. Check the actual terms and resolve uncertainties before work begins. General website descriptions do not replace the accepted engagement.
Contract Terms That Deserve Closer Review
- Scope and deliverables: Identify whether the work includes eligibility analysis, interviews, calculations, technical documentation, forms, return filing, or only specified advisory services.
- Fees and changes: Confirm the fixed fee or hourly rates, payment schedule, any estimate or cap, and the process for agreeing additional work. An estimate is not necessarily a binding fee cap.
- Expenses: Identify any separately charged software, travel, third-party, or other costs and the approval process.
- Responsibilities and timing: State what information the client must provide, who files the return, who monitors deadlines, and how delays will be handled.
- Renewal and termination: Check automatic renewals, notice periods, termination rights, and charges for work already performed. Automatic renewal is not inherently improper, but its effect should be clear.
- Audit assistance: Define the examinations, services, limits, and professional representation included, together with any separate fees or exclusions.
- Data and records: Address confidentiality, secure access, retention, subcontractors or software providers, and the records available when the engagement ends.
Unclear terms are a reason to seek clarification. They do not, by themselves, establish misconduct or make a contract invalid. Material liability limits, dispute provisions, or unusual obligations should be assessed for the particular engagement.
Checking the Proposed R&D Methodology
The contract should describe how the advisor will assess qualifying activities and expenses and develop supporting documentation. An R&D claim requires evidence addressing the applicable section 41 requirements and the amount claimed. Review the IRS Instructions for Form 6765 for the relevant filing requirements.
Current-year facts and historical records: Prior-year records and calculations may be relevant, including to the credit’s base calculations. However, descriptions and allocations should be checked against the activities and expenses in the claim year. Reusing a template is not itself improper; copying unsupported conclusions is a concern.
Technical substance: Describing work as custom, bespoke, or innovative is not enough. The advisor should explain the relevant technical uncertainty, the alternatives evaluated, and the experimentation. A U.S. claim does not require an advance in the knowledge of the entire industry. Narratives should explain the actual work and supporting evidence.
Expense allocations: Ask how employee services, supplies, and other claimed costs are linked to qualifying activities. Avoid unsupported blanket percentages. A full wage allocation is not automatically an audit trigger; it must be supported by the facts and any applicable rules. The length of a report or the size of a claim does not establish its accuracy.
| Point to Review | Potential Concern | What to Ask |
|---|---|---|
| Unchanged prior-year narratives | Descriptions may not reflect the activities and expenses in the claim year. | How are current-year facts checked and prior-year information used? |
| Unsupported reconstructed records | Later explanations may lack a reliable factual basis. | What original records support the explanation, and when was it prepared? |
| Marketing labels instead of evidence | Words such as custom or innovative do not establish eligibility. | How do the activities satisfy the applicable section 41 requirements? |
| Unsupported wage allocations | Claimed percentages may not reflect qualifying services. | What evidence and applicable rules support each allocation? |
Understanding Fee Structures and Outcome Conditions
Read both how the fee is calculated and what makes it payable. A fixed amount can still be outcome-dependent if the agreement makes payment conditional on obtaining or retaining a tax benefit. Likewise, a refund promise may change the arrangement even where the initial invoice is described as a fixed fee.
Outcome-dependent compensation can create incentives that should be considered when evaluating an advisor. It does not, by itself, prove that the advisor will overstate a claim. Fixed and hourly arrangements also require competent work, reliable evidence, and clear scope controls.
Professional-conduct and tax-disclosure requirements depend on the specific services, terms, and applicable rules. Certain refundable or contingent fee arrangements can raise contractual-protection disclosure questions, and exceptions may apply. Do not infer the answer solely from a pricing label. See the IRS Instructions for Form 8886 and IRS guidance on Circular 230.
Swanson Reed’s Fixed-Fee and Hourly Approach
Only fixed fees or hourly rates for paid services: A fixed fee is agreed in advance for a defined scope. Hourly rates range from $195 to $395 per hour, depending on the professional assigned, and the total depends on the time spent. Where an assignment has phases, the written terms identify the fixed fee or hourly basis for each phase. Swanson Reed does not charge success-based or contingency fees or fees calculated as a percentage of the credit.
Fees are independent of the tax outcome: Paid work remains subject to the agreed pricing even if an assessment identifies no eligible credit, the benefit is lower than expected, or a tax authority later reduces or denies a claim. The fee is based on the agreed work or professional time, not the benefit obtained. A complimentary scoping discussion and any expressly accepted pro bono services are separate, limited arrangements.
Scope and additional work: A fixed fee covers the services stated in the engagement. It does not promise unlimited work or all later audit assistance. Additional services and their fees must be agreed before that work begins. For hourly work, the engagement should explain the rates, billing arrangements, and any agreed estimate or limit.
Expenses: Swanson Reed does not ordinarily charge separately for disbursements. Any unforeseen, substantial expense necessary for an assignment is agreed with the client in advance. The engagement should make these arrangements clear. Read the fees page alongside the proposal and accepted terms.
Quality Review, Information Security, and Risk Management
Swanson Reed’s Six-Eye Review involves a qualified engineer, a scientist, and a CPA or Enrolled Agent. This combines technical and financial review of the claim. It is an internal control, not an IRS approval, an audit-proofing guarantee, or a substitute for supporting evidence.
Information-security and risk-management processes address different aspects of an engagement. ISO/IEC 27001 sets requirements for an information security management system. ISO 31000 provides risk-management guidance and is not a certifiable risk-management standard. Neither establishes that a particular tax credit qualifies or guarantees how an examination will be resolved.
| Process or Standard | Focus | What It Does Not Establish |
|---|---|---|
| Six-Eye Review | Technical and financial review by a qualified engineer, a scientist, and a CPA or Enrolled Agent. | It does not guarantee IRS acceptance or remove the need for supporting evidence. |
| ISO/IEC 27001 | Requirements for an information security management system. | It does not establish eligibility for an R&D tax credit or eliminate every security risk. |
| ISO 31000 | Guidelines for identifying, assessing, and managing risk. | It is guidance, not a certifiable risk-management standard or a promise of an audit result. |
| Professional practice requirements | Competence, diligence, conduct, and authority to act for a taxpayer. | A credential or fee model alone does not prove that a particular claim is correct. |
Defining Audit Assistance in the Engagement
The agreement should state whether audit assistance is included in the preparation fee, charged separately, or excluded. Identify the tax years, issues, included tasks, limits, and expenses for which the client remains responsible. Appeals and litigation should be addressed expressly rather than assumed to be included.
creditARMOR: The platform supports AI-assisted mock audits and audit management. It helps organize information and identify potential documentation gaps for professional evaluation. AI output can contain errors and requires verification. The services described do not provide an insurance policy, financial indemnity, or reimbursement of third-party professional fees, taxes, interest, penalties, denied credits, or other losses.
Qualifying existing examinations: Swanson Reed offers its own specified audit services pro bono for an examination already underway when the claim passes the qualifying creditARMOR mock audit, the result is confirmed in writing, and the engagement is accepted. Assessment criteria, any mock audit fee, and the service limits are explained before the assessment. The agreement identifies the examination, tax years, included work, and client expenses. Any paid mock audit or additional services use an agreed fixed fee or hourly rates.
The pro bono offer does not reimburse third-party fees or financial losses. Appeals and litigation are excluded unless expressly included in writing and handled by appropriately authorized professionals. Passing a mock audit or subscribing to software does not itself reserve future audit assistance. Any separate accepted engagement continues to govern its own scope and obligations. See the audit-assistance terms.
Representation and deadlines: Representation requires an appropriately authorized professional and any necessary taxpayer authorization. The engagement should identify when responsibility for agreed responses and deadlines begins. Contacting Swanson Reed or supplying information does not extend a government deadline or establish that an engagement has been accepted. No claim or audit outcome is guaranteed.
Termination and Access to Records
Check how either party can end the engagement, the notice required, and the treatment of unpaid invoices, advance payments, and work in progress. Any opportunity to remedy a breach depends on the contract and applicable law; a particular notice period should not be assumed to apply to every engagement.
Clarify which records and completed deliverables will be provided, the format and timing of handover, and any arrangements for transition assistance. Distinguish client-supplied records from the advisor’s internal workpapers and other materials governed by separate rights or duties. The contract should also explain retention and confidentiality obligations that continue after termination.
Before Accepting the Engagement
Confirm that the written terms match the services and pricing discussed. Resolve unclear scope, fees, audit assistance, data handling, or exit arrangements before work starts. The objective is an understood and workable engagement, with responsibilities documented and supporting evidence assessed on its merits.
Engagement Letter Questions
What are the common red flags in an R&D tax credit engagement letter?
Review unclear service boundaries, undisclosed charges, unexplained fee changes, renewal and termination provisions, vague audit-support promises, and incomplete arrangements for access to records. Ask for specific written terms rather than relying on broad assurances.
How does Swanson Reed charge for R&D tax credit services?
Swanson Reed charges only fixed fees or hourly rates for paid services. Fixed fees cover an agreed scope. Hourly rates range from $195 to $395, with the total based on time spent. Fees do not depend on the credit amount or claim outcome, and no success-based or contingency fees are charged.
Are fees payable if an assessment finds no eligible credit?
Paid services remain subject to the agreed fixed fee or hourly terms even if the work finds no eligible credit or a claimed credit is later reduced or denied. A complimentary scoping discussion and any expressly accepted pro bono services are separate, limited arrangements.
Does a claim-preparation engagement automatically include audit representation?
No. The engagement must identify any included audit assistance, its limits, and any additional fees. Appeals, litigation, and future examinations should be addressed expressly. Representation requires an appropriately authorized professional and any necessary taxpayer authorization.
Does creditARMOR provide insurance?
No. creditARMOR is an AI-assisted mock audit and audit management platform. The services described do not provide insurance, financial indemnity, or reimbursement of third-party professional fees or losses. AI output requires professional review, and no audit outcome is guaranteed.
This page provides general information. The accepted written engagement, applicable law, and professional requirements govern the services, fees, and responsibilities. Contact Swanson Reed to discuss the terms relevant to your circumstances.








