The Michigan Research and Development Tax Credit: An Exhaustive Analysis of the Mandatory Tentative Claim and Administrative Framework

The Tentative Claim is a mandatory preliminary application submitted via Michigan Treasury Online that serves as a non-optional prerequisite for any taxpayer intending to claim the Michigan Research and Development tax credit. It requires the reporting of actual, non-estimated qualifying research expenses by April 1, 2026, for the inaugural 2025 expense year, and by March 15 annually thereafter, to facilitate a statewide proration calculation against the $100 million aggregate credit cap.1

The introduction of the Michigan Research and Development (R&D) tax credit through Public Acts 186 and 187 of 2024 represents a significant revitalization of the state’s industrial policy, designed to foster innovation in high-tech sectors such as automotive engineering, semiconductor manufacturing, and life sciences.4 At the heart of this legislative framework is the “Tentative Claim” mechanism, a regulatory gatekeeper that distinguishes the Michigan credit from most other state and federal R&D incentives.2 While traditional tax credits are typically claimed directly on an annual return, the Michigan Department of Treasury utilizes the Tentative Claim as a mandatory pre-filing tool to manage fiscal exposure and ensure that the total credit distribution does not exceed the statutory $100 million annual limit.7 This process is not merely a formality; it is a rigid eligibility requirement where a failure to file by the prescribed deadline—regardless of the validity of the underlying research activities—results in a total forfeiture of the credit for that period.2 By requiring taxpayers to report actual expenses before the final tax return is due, the Treasury can perform a statewide aggregation, determine if proration is necessary, and issue a public notice that allows taxpayers to adjust their final claims accordingly.2 This complex interplay between individual taxpayer reporting and statewide budgetary limits creates a unique compliance environment that necessitates early and accurate data collection by Corporate Income Tax (CIT) filers and flow-through entities alike.2

Legislative Context and Economic Objectives

The re-establishment of the Michigan R&D credit follows a period of over a decade during which the state lacked a broad-based incentive for research activities, following the repeal of the Michigan Business Tax (MBT) and its associated credits in 2012.12 The new legislation, effective for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, is strategically timed to coincide with a global shift toward electrification and advanced computing, positioning Michigan as the “Silicon Mitten”.4 The policy intent is to provide immediate liquidity to innovative companies, particularly those struggling with the federal capitalization requirements under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 174.13

The credit is structured to be fully refundable, a feature that provides significant value to early-stage startups and research-intensive firms that may not yet have a positive tax liability.4 By providing cash refunds rather than mere carryforwards, Michigan directly subsidizes the “burn rate” of high-tech firms, encouraging them to maintain and expand their physical research footprints within the state.4 This is especially critical because Michigan has explicitly decoupled from recent federal changes that allow for immediate expensing of R&D costs; instead, Michigan requires these costs to be amortized over five years for state tax purposes.13 The refundable credit thus acts as a vital financial offset to the increased tax burden created by this amortization requirement.13

Comparison of Credit Structures by Employer Size

The legislation differentiates between “small” and “large” businesses based on employee headcount, applying different rates and caps to ensure equitable distribution of the $100 million pool.1

Data compiled from.1

The Mechanics of the Mandatory Tentative Claim

The Tentative Claim is a mandatory preliminary step that occurs after the close of the calendar year but before the filing of the annual tax return.2 The Michigan Department of Treasury has emphasized that this filing must be made electronically through the Michigan Treasury Online (MTO) portal.3 The “Mandatory Pre-Filing” serves as the basis for the state’s budgetary control; without it, the Treasury would be unable to calculate the proration factor required to keep the total credit volume within the $100 million cap.7

Deadlines and the “No-Grace” Policy

The deadlines for the Tentative Claim are statutory and leave no room for administrative extensions. For the inaugural year (2025 expenses), the deadline is set for April 1, 2026, providing a slightly longer window as businesses adjust to the new system.2 For all subsequent years, the deadline moves to March 15.2

Deadlines and timelines based on.2

The Department of Treasury has issued clear guidance that late submissions will not be accepted.2 This creates a high-stakes environment for tax departments, as a missed filing window—even by a single day—renders the entire year’s R&D expenditure ineligible for the state credit.2 Furthermore, the claim must be based on “actual” expenses rather than estimates.2 Because these figures are used to determine the proration for all other taxpayers in the state, reporting inflated estimates could lead to significant legal and administrative repercussions.6

Information Required for the Tentative Claim

When submitting through the MTO portal, the taxpayer must provide a granular breakdown of their research activities and expenses.3 This information is used not only for the proration calculation but also to verify the taxpayer’s eligibility under the specific tiers of the law.8

1. Entity Classification: Identification as a CIT taxpayer or a flow-through entity subject to withholding.7
2. Headcount Verification: The number of employees subject to Michigan income tax withholding, which determines if the taxpayer is subject to the $250,000 cap or the $2 million cap.7
3. Michigan Qualified Research Expenses (MQREs): The total dollar amount of expenses incurred physically within the state borders, categorized by wages, supplies, and contract research.4
4. Base Amount Data: A detailed calculation of the average annual MQREs for the three preceding calendar years.4
5. University Partnership Details: If claiming the additional 5% bonus, the taxpayer must identify the Michigan research university involved and confirm the existence of a written agreement.4

Statewide Aggregate Cap and the Proration Mechanism

The $100 million statewide cap is the primary reason for the Tentative Claim requirement.8 If the sum of all “unadjusted” credits reported in the Tentative Claims exceeds $100 million, the Treasury must reduce each claimant’s credit proportionally.1 The legislation includes specific protections for small businesses to ensure they are not crowded out by large multinational corporations.4

The Small Business Reserve and Proration Hierarchy

The law reserves $25 million of the $100 million pool specifically for businesses with fewer than 250 employees.4 The proration follows a strict hierarchical logic designed to prioritize these smaller innovators.8

• Primary Small Business Protection: If total small business claims are $25 million or less, they are funded in full (subject to individual caps). Only the remaining large business claims are prorated against the leftover $75 million.7
• Dual Bucket Proration: If small business claims exceed $25 million and large business claims exceed $75 million, each group is prorated within its own “bucket” ($25M for small, $75M for large).7
• The Pro-Rata Shift: If small business claims are so high that they exceed 25% of the total aggregate claims for both groups, the “bucket” system is abandoned. In this case, all claimants—regardless of size—receive a flat pro-rata share of the $100 million.7

The Proration Trap and Timing Risks

The Treasury plans to publish the proration notice by April 30 each year.3 This date is critical because it is also the standard filing deadline for many corporate income tax returns.6 Analysts at BDO and Plante Moran have noted that this creates a “timing trap”.6 If a taxpayer files their final return on April 15 using their unadjusted credit amount, and the Treasury subsequently announces a 10% proration on April 30, the taxpayer’s return will be incorrect, necessitating an amended filing.6 To mitigate this risk, professional guidance suggests that any taxpayer claiming the R&D credit should proactively file for a return extension to ensure they have the final, adjusted credit figures before submitting their annual return.6

Qualifying Research Expenses (QREs) and the Geography of Research

Michigan’s R&D credit relies on the federal definition of “qualified research expenses” under IRC Section 41(b) but adds a strict geographical constraint: the research must be conducted “in Michigan”.2 This means that federal QREs associated with research performed in other states or countries must be stripped out of both the current-year calculation and the three-year base amount average.4

Defining Eligible In-State Expenditures

The Treasury’s guidance confirms that eligible expenses generally fall into three buckets, provided they are tied to a “process of experimentation” conducted within the state.4

Expense criteria based on.4

For Unitary Business Groups (UBGs), the “taxpayer” is the group as a whole.10 Consequently, the $2 million cap and the 250-employee threshold apply to the entire UBG, not to individual members.2 If a group includes one subsidiary with 300 employees and another with 50 employees, the entire group is classified as a “Large Business” subject to the 10% incremental rate and the $2 million cap.9

The Base Amount and the Incremental Nature of the Credit

The Michigan R&D credit is an “incremental” credit, meaning it is designed to reward businesses that increase their research spending over time.4 The “base amount” is the benchmark against which current-year spending is measured.4

Calculating the Three-Year Average

The base amount is generally defined as the average annual MQREs for the three calendar years immediately preceding the credit year.8 For a business that has never conducted R&D in Michigan, the base amount is zero, allowing for a 10% or 15% credit on the entirety of their first year’s expenditure.5 However, a notable “drafting anomaly” exists for companies with only one or two years of history.6 The law states that if expenses were incurred in only one or two years, the average is based on only those years.1

For example, if a company had $0 in R&D in 2022 and 2023, but $100,000 in 2024, the law suggests the base amount is the average of only the year(s) with expenses.6 This would make the base $100,000 (100k / 1), rather than $33,333 (100k / 3).6 This counterintuitive rule penalizes businesses with a recent but sparse R&D history compared to those with no history at all, highlighting the need for careful historical data review before filing the Tentative Claim.6

Mathematical Formulas for Credit Determination

The unadjusted credit is calculated using a two-tiered formula based on the base amount and the excess expenditure.1

For Small Businesses (< 250 Employees):

$$Unadjusted Credit = (0.03 \times \text{Base Amount}) + (0.15 \times (\text{Current MQRE} – \text{Base Amount}))$$

Capped at $250,000.

For Large Businesses (≥ 250 Employees):

$$Unadjusted Credit = (0.03 \times \text{Base Amount}) + (0.10 \times (\text{Current MQRE} – \text{Base Amount}))$$

Capped at $2,000,000.

These calculations must be performed on a calendar year basis.6 For fiscal year filers, the Treasury is developing an optional conversion method to allow them to “calendarize” their fiscal year R&D expenses for the purpose of the base amount years.4

University Collaboration Bonus: Strategic Partnerships

To incentivize deeper ties between industry and academia, Michigan offers an additional 5% credit on R&D expenses incurred through collaboration with a Michigan research university.1 This bonus is distinct and additive to the primary R&D credit, though it is subject to its own $200,000 annual cap per taxpayer.1

Prerequisites for the Bonus Rate

The university bonus is not automatic for all academic spending; it requires formal documentation and a focus on Michigan-based institutions.4

1. Eligible Institutions: The collaboration must be with a Michigan public research university or an independent non-profit research institute located in the state.4
2. Written Agreement: A formal, signed contract must be in place prior to the research activity.4
3. Nature of Research: The expenses must qualify as R&D under IRC 41(b) and be conducted physically within Michigan.4

This bonus effectively shifts the marginal tax benefit for small businesses to 20% on university-related research, making partnerships with institutions like the University of Michigan or Michigan State University a highly efficient tax planning strategy.1

Interaction with Federal Tax Law and Section 174 Decoupling

The timing of Michigan’s new credit is particularly relevant due to the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) and the subsequent “One, Big, Beautiful Bill” (OBBBA).13 Historically, federal law allowed for the immediate expensing of R&D costs under IRC Section 174.13 However, beginning in 2022, the federal government required these costs to be capitalized and amortized over five years.13

Michigan’s Deliberate Decoupling

In October 2025, Michigan enacted House Bill 4961, which updated the state’s tax code to decouple from the federal treatment of Section 174.5 While federal law may periodically restore immediate expensing, Michigan law currently mandates that R&D expenses must be capitalized and amortized over five years for state income tax purposes.13

This decoupling creates a significant “timing difference” that increases a company’s Michigan taxable income in the short term.13 The new refundable R&D credit is designed to act as a liquidity buffer against this increased tax liability.13 Because the credit is refundable, a company that is forced to pay more in Michigan taxes due to amortization can use the credit to recoup that cash immediately, rather than waiting five years for the amortization to fully reflect on their returns.4

Flow-Through Entities (FTEs) and Withholding Tax Filers

A unique and often misunderstood aspect of the Michigan R&D credit is its treatment of flow-through entities such as S-corporations, partnerships, and LLCs.5 Unlike many other Michigan credits, the R&D credit cannot be assigned or transferred to the individual owners or members of the entity.1

Entity-Level Claiming and Refundability

For an FTE to benefit from the credit, it must be an “authorized business” that is subject to Michigan income tax withholding on its employees.2 The credit is claimed at the entity level against the entity’s withholding tax liability.2

• Offsetting Payments: Once the Treasury issues the proration notice, an FTE can reduce its periodic withholding payments for the remainder of the year to reflect the credit.2
• Refunds: If the credit exceeds the entity’s total annual withholding liability, the Treasury will issue a cash refund directly to the entity.2
• Owner Exclusion: The law explicitly prohibits individual members of the flow-through entity from claiming any portion of the credit on their personal income tax returns.1

This structure ensures that the financial incentive remains within the business unit that is actually performing the research, providing the entity with the capital needed to continue its technical operations.2

Practical Example: The Mandatory Tentative Claim in Action

To demonstrate the critical importance of the Tentative Claim and the subsequent proration, consider the following scenario for a fictional Michigan-based firm, “Great Lakes Aero,” which specializes in drone propulsion systems.

Step 1: Pre-Filing Data Collection (January 2026)

Great Lakes Aero, which has 180 employees, concludes its 2025 calendar year with $2,000,000 in Michigan-based research expenses. They calculate their base amount (2022-2024 MQRE average) to be $1,200,000.8

• Employee Count: 180 (Small Business Tier)
• Current MQRE: $2,000,000
• Base Amount: $1,200,000
• Unadjusted Credit Calculation: $(3% \times 1.2M) + (15% \times 800k) = 36,000 + 120,000 = $156,000$.1

Step 2: Submitting the Mandatory Tentative Claim (February 2026)

The company logs into MTO and submits its Tentative Claim before the April 1, 2026, deadline.2 They provide their actual 2025 expenses and base amount data. This secures their spot in the $100 million pool.2

Step 3: Reviewing the Proration Notice (April 30, 2026)

The Michigan Department of Treasury reviews all claims and finds that total small business claims reached $30 million, exceeding the $25 million reserve.7 Consequently, a proration factor of 83.33% ($25M / $30M) is applied to all small business claims.8

Step 4: Filing the Annual Return (May 2026)

Great Lakes Aero, having filed for a return extension, calculates its final adjusted credit using the proration factor.3

• Adjusted Credit: $156,000 \times 0.8333 = $129,994.80$.
• Filing: They report $129,994.80 on their annual CIT return (Form 4891).3
• Refund: If their tax liability for the year is $40,000, they receive a refund check for $89,994.80.8

The Cost of Non-Compliance

If Great Lakes Aero had missed the April 1 Tentative Claim deadline, they would have been entirely ineligible for the credit, resulting in a loss of nearly $130,000 in cash liquidity.2

Administrative Oversight and Audit Readiness

Given the refundable nature of the credit and the limited $100 million pool, the Michigan Department of Treasury is expected to implement rigorous audit procedures.4 Taxpayers should maintain a “defense-ready” posture by documenting their research activities contemporaneously.15

Essential Recordkeeping Requirements

The Treasury and professional tax analysts recommend maintaining documentation for at least four years, focused on the “Four-Part Test” inherent in IRC Section 41.4

Documentation standards based on.4

Fraud and Scam Awareness

The Department of Treasury has issued a potential scam alert regarding the R&D credit and broader business taxes.16 Some “Reminder of Tax Due” letters have been found to contain incorrect toll-free numbers that lead to fraudulent services.10 Taxpayers are urged to communicate with the Treasury solely through the official Michigan Treasury Online portal or via the verified phone numbers provided on the Treasury’s official website.3

Strategic Implications for Michigan Corporations

The introduction of the R&D tax credit is a game-changer for fiscal planning in Michigan.5 However, the Mandatory Tentative Claim requires a shift in how tax departments operate. Instead of viewing R&D as a year-end calculation, it must now be viewed as a first-quarter compliance priority.6

Integration with Unitary Business Groups (UBGs)

For corporations that are part of a UBG, the credit must be claimed by the group taxpayer.10 This requires a higher degree of coordination between subsidiaries, as the $2 million cap and the 250-employee threshold must be determined using aggregated data from all members of the group.2 A subsidiary conducting high-value research might find its credit reduced if other members of the UBG have high employee counts, pushing the group into the “Large Business” tier with its lower incremental credit rate.9

The Role of Research Universities

The 5% bonus for university collaboration is more than just a financial incentive; it is a call for structural partnerships.5 Companies should evaluate their existing academic spending to ensure they have the “written agreements” necessary to qualify for the higher rate.4 For many firms, shifting research from private contractors to public universities may yield a higher after-tax return on investment.4

Conclusion: A New Era for Michigan Innovation

The Michigan Research and Development tax credit, as established by Public Acts 107-111 and PAs 186-187 of 2024, is a potent economic tool with significant administrative complexity.7 The Tentative Claim (Mandatory Pre-Filing) is the cornerstone of this system, serving as both a budgetary safeguard for the state and a critical compliance milestone for the taxpayer.2 By requiring businesses to report actual expenses early in the year, the state has created a predictable fiscal environment that prioritizes small businesses and academic collaboration.4

For businesses operating in Michigan, the message is clear: the R&D credit offers substantial rewards, particularly in the form of cash refunds and offsets to IRC 174 amortization, but these rewards are contingent upon strict adherence to the March 15/April 1 pre-filing deadlines.2 As the January 1, 2026, “live date” for the first application window approaches, companies must transition from estimated budgeting to actual data collection, ensuring that every dollar of research performed in Michigan is accurately captured, documented, and reported through the Michigan Treasury Online portal.3 Failure to navigate this mandatory pre-filing process correctly will result in the loss of a vital financial incentive, while those who master the mechanics of the Tentative Claim will find themselves well-positioned to lead Michigan’s next wave of technological innovation.4

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services

Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725.
Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services

creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit insurance and AI-driven risk management platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees

Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We are also able offer fixed fees and success fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/about-us/research-tax-credit-consulting/our-fees/