×
Answer Capsule: Under 26 U.S.C. § 41(d)(2), the Four-Part Test for qualified research must be applied separately to each business component, meaning any product, process, computer software, technique, formula, or invention held for sale, lease, or license, or used in the taxpayer’s trade or business. If the overall component fails, the shrinking-back rule under Treas. Reg. § 1.41-4(b)(2) applies the tests to successively smaller subsets of elements. Cases such as Little Sandy Coal, Trinity Industries, and Tell City Boatworks show that claims succeed only when taxpayers link activities, uncertainties, experimentation, and expenses to specific components with reliable evidence.

Section 41(d)(2) Business Component Test: Federal and State Analysis

26 U.S. Code Section 41(d)(2) defines a “business component” as a product, process, computer software, technique, formula, or invention to be held for sale, lease, or license, or used in the taxpayer’s trade or business. Qualification tests must be applied separately to each component. If the overall component fails, the evaluation must “shrink back” to its most significant subset of elements until a qualifying subset is identified or the most basic element is reached and fails.

This legislative architecture separates qualifying research from nonqualifying commercial activities. Under the Research and Development (R&D) tax credit framework, the statutory tests require component-level substantiation rather than unsupported high-level project estimates. Under federal law and state frameworks such as those in Indiana, California, and Idaho, taxpayers must maintain sufficient records under the applicable rules. Documentation should link employee activities, technological uncertainties, experimental processes, and claimed expenses to the relevant component or qualifying subset.

This research study provides an exhaustive, expert-level examination of the business component test, the shrinking-back rule, federal legislative history, state executive branch interpretations, state judicial precedent, and the profound practical implications for taxpayers seeking to claim the research credit across multiple jurisdictions.

The Federal Statutory Architecture of Qualified Research

Legislative Genesis: The Tax Reform Act of 1986

The federal research tax credit was initially enacted in 1981 to encourage investment in research. Congress subsequently narrowed the definition of qualified research through the Tax Reform Act of 1986 (TRA 1986), adding requirements that distinguish qualifying experimentation from activities such as routine development and cosmetic changes.

Central to this sweeping legislative reform was the establishment of the Business Component Test under 26 U.S.C. § 41(d)(2). The statute strictly dictates that the qualification tests for research must be applied separately to each “business component” of the taxpayer. The statute explicitly defines a business component as any product, process, computer software, technique, formula, or invention which is to be held for sale, lease, or license, or used by the taxpayer in a trade or business of the taxpayer. Furthermore, Congress mandated that any plant process, machinery, or technique for the commercial production of a business component shall be treated as a separate and distinct business component, structurally partitioned from the end-product it produces.

This segmentation helps identify the technological uncertainty being addressed. By requiring taxpayers to identify the component undergoing experimentation, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and state taxing authorities can evaluate integration, design, and construction activities. Reliance on established engineering principles does not itself disqualify research; the uncertainty and experimentation requirements must still be satisfied.

The legislative history in H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 99-841 provides insight into this intent. The Conference Report describes experimentation as evaluating alternatives when the means of achieving the intended result are uncertain at the outset. Research must fundamentally rely on physical or biological sciences, engineering, or computer science. Improvements to existing products may qualify when they satisfy the statutory tests.

The Shift from the Discovery Rule to Treasury Decision 9104

The interpretation of “technological uncertainty” has evolved through IRS rulemaking. Under Treasury Decision 8930, the Discovery Rule required research to seek knowledge beyond or refining the common knowledge of skilled professionals in the relevant scientific or engineering field. This imposed a broader knowledge requirement than the taxpayer-specific uncertainty standard subsequently adopted.

Following criticism and reconsideration, the Treasury Department approved final regulations in December 2003 under Treasury Decision 9104 (T.D. 9104), published and effective in January 2004. T.D. 9104 eliminated the Discovery Rule. Research need not exceed existing industry knowledge, but information merely being new to a taxpayer is insufficient: all applicable qualification requirements must still be met.

Under T.D. 9104, uncertainty may exist even when a taxpayer knows that achieving a goal is technically possible, provided the available information does not establish the method or appropriate design. These regulations remain central to evaluating research under 26 U.S.C. § 41(d), subject to subsequent amendments and state conformity rules.

The Four-Part Test of Qualified Research

To fully comprehend the business component test, it must be contextualized within the Four-Part Test in 26 U.S.C. § 41(d)(1). For a component to yield qualified research expenses (QREs), all four criteria must be satisfied:

The Four-Part Test of Qualified Research under 26 U.S.C. § 41(d)(1)
Statutory Test Internal Revenue Code Core Requirement and Application standard
Research Expenditure Test (Elimination of Uncertainty) 26 U.S.C. § 41(d)(1)(A) Current federal law refers to domestic research or experimental expenditures under § 174A; earlier periods referenced § 174. Research must address uncertainty regarding capability, method, or appropriate design. State conformity must be evaluated separately.
Technological in Nature Test 26 U.S.C. § 41(d)(1)(B)(i) The research must fundamentally rely upon the hard principles of physical sciences, biological sciences, engineering, or computer science.
Business Component Test 26 U.S.C. § 41(d)(1)(B)(ii) The research must be intended to develop a new or improved business component. The improvement must relate specifically to function, performance, reliability, or quality, not aesthetics.
Process of Experimentation Test 26 U.S.C. § 41(d)(1)(C) Substantially all (80% or more) of the relevant research activities must constitute elements of experimentation, measured on a cost or other consistently applied reasonable basis. Experimentation evaluates alternatives through methods such as modeling, simulation, or systematic trial and error.

Each test is applied to the discrete business component. If a taxpayer cannot substantiate technological uncertainty for a software module or experimentation for a mechanical valve, associated claimed QREs may be disallowed, subject to any supported shrinking-back analysis.

The Mechanics of the Shrinking-Back Rule (Treas. Reg. § 1.41-4(b)(2))

When a taxpayer develops a complex system—such as a naval vessel, manufacturing facility, or enterprise software suite—the overall component may fail the Four-Part Test. Routine construction, integration of off-the-shelf parts, or aesthetic design does not automatically qualify. The substantially-all test requires at least 80% of the relevant research activities, measured on a cost or other consistently applied reasonable basis, to constitute elements of a process of experimentation. It is not simply a ratio of experimental costs to all project costs.

To prevent the disallowance of otherwise qualifying research within a larger component, the Department of the Treasury promulgated the “shrinking-back rule” under Treas. Reg. § 1.41-4(b)(2). The regulation dictates that if the requirements of the Four-Part Test are not satisfied at the level of the discrete overall business component, the tests are applied iteratively to the most significant subset of elements.

Shrinking back continues through subsets of the business component until a subset satisfies the requirements or the most basic element is reached and fails. The system, subsystem, assembly, and part levels below are illustrative rather than a mandatory hierarchy.

Illustrative Hierarchy for Applying the Shrinking-Back Rule
Hierarchical Level Conceptual Definition Application of Treas. Reg. § 1.41-4(b)(2)
Macro System The overall product held for sale (e.g., an entire naval vessel or industrial dry dock). Test applied first. Routine construction and integration may prevent satisfaction of the 80% substantially-all requirement.
Sub-System A major operational segment (e.g., the vessel’s propulsion system or electrical grid). If the overall component fails, evaluate its most significant subset. Uncertainty may concern capability, method, or appropriate design.
Sub-Assembly A functional mechanical grouping (e.g., a newly engineered carburetor within the engine). If the larger subset fails, evaluate a smaller subset. Qualification depends on activities and evidence, not assembly size.
Discrete Element The most basic material component (e.g., an individual titanium alloy valve). If the most basic element fails, shrinking back cannot qualify that element.

The shrinking-back rule applies only if the taxpayer fails the overall test. The regulation expressly states that the rule is not itself a reason to exclude research activities from credit eligibility.

The taxpayer generally bears the burden of substantiating eligibility. Shrinking back requires evidence identifying qualifying subsets and their associated activities and expenses. Contemporaneous time, cost, and technical records are valuable, but there is no universal requirement for subcomponent timesheets. An unsupported “all or nothing” approach may leave a court without a reasonable basis for determining qualifying activities or expenses.

Statutory Exclusions to Qualified Research

Even if a business component theoretically meets the four-part test, 26 U.S.C. § 41(d)(4) outlines strict statutory exclusions that disqualify research from the credit.

  • Adaptation Exclusion: Research related to the adaptation of an existing business component to a particular customer’s requirement or need is strictly excluded. If a company takes an existing software product and merely customizes the interface or integrates it into a client’s specific server environment using known coding parameters, the activity is disqualified.
  • Duplication and Reverse Engineering: Any research related to the reproduction of an existing business component (in whole or in part) from a physical examination of the component itself, or from plans, blueprints, or publicly available information, is excluded.
  • Funded Research: Research is excluded to the extent funded by a grant, contract, or otherwise by another person or governmental entity. Contract terms and surrounding facts determine whether payments are contingent on successful research and whether the taxpayer retains substantial rights in the results. Neither a fixed-price label nor ownership of all intellectual property is, by itself, controlling.

Federal Judicial Interpretation and Precedent

The jurisprudence surrounding the business component test, the substantially all fraction, and the shrinking-back rule forms the backbone of how audits are defended, negotiated, and ultimately litigated. Recent federal appellate and Tax Court decisions have crystallized the evidentiary standards required to survive IRS scrutiny.

Little Sandy Coal Co. v. Commissioner (7th Circuit, 2023)

Little Sandy Coal Co., Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 62 F.4th 287 (7th Cir. 2023), is an important federal appellate decision. It governs within its applicable federal jurisdiction and may inform state interpretations; Indiana state tax proceedings are not directly subject to the Seventh Circuit’s appellate jurisdiction.

Little Sandy Coal, the parent of a shipbuilding subsidiary, claimed research credits for vessel design and construction, including a tanker barge and a dry dock. The taxpayer presented its claims at the entire-vessel level. The courts found insufficient proof that substantially all—at least 80%—of the relevant research activities constituted elements of a process of experimentation.

The U.S. Tax Court ruled against the taxpayer. Its analysis treated pilot-model production activities characterized as direct support as outside the numerator of the 80% test while potentially including them in the denominator. It also found insufficient evidence to apply the shrinking-back rule to qualifying vessel subsets.

The Seventh Circuit rejected that categorical exclusion while affirming the judgment. Direct support and supervision activities may count in both the numerator and denominator when they independently satisfy the applicable research and experimentation requirements.

The Seventh Circuit affirmed the denial because the taxpayer lacked a principled basis for allocating activities to experimentation. General descriptions, novelty claims, and arbitrary estimates did not establish the required proportion. Its whole-vessel approach also lacked sufficient evidence to support shrinking back.

Trinity Industries, Inc. v. United States (U.S. District Court, N.D. Texas, 2010)

The application of the macro-level test versus the shrink-back rule was similarly highlighted in Trinity Industries, Inc. v. United States. Trinity Industries sought tax credits for the design and construction of several “first-in-class” prototype vessels.

For two vessels, the district court allowed qualification at the whole-vessel level, accepting costs that included paint and insurance under its application of the 80% rule. This case-specific treatment should not be read as making insurance a qualifying supply or allowing every cost of a qualifying project.

For four other vessel projects, the district court denied the claimed credits. Trinity took an “all or nothing” approach and provided no evidence permitting meaningful estimates of qualifying costs for vessel subsets. The court therefore could not apply shrinking back on the record before it.

Betz v. Commissioner and Phoenix Design Group v. Commissioner

Recent Tax Court decisions reinforce the importance of substantiating uncertainty and experimentation with evidence beyond general engineering assertions.

In Betz v. Commissioner (Tax Court, July 2023), taxpayers claimed credits for air-pollution-control systems, including catalytic and thermal oxidizers, and argued that the units were experimental pilot models. The court found insufficient proof of qualifying uncertainty and experimentation. It rejected the asserted pilot-model treatment on the evidence rather than imposing a universal requirement for a particular hypothesis-log format.

Similarly, in Phoenix Design Group v. Commissioner (Tax Court, December 2024), the court found that standard engineering design did not itself establish qualifying uncertainty or experimentation. The projects considered at trial failed the applicable requirements. The decision does not establish a blanket prohibition on sampling or require a particular project-narrative format.

Software Adaptation: United States v. Davenport

The strictness of the adaptation exclusion within the business component test was heavily litigated in United States v. Davenport (N.D. Tex. 2013). The government sought to recover erroneously issued refunds related to the Davenport’s implementation of a J.D. Edwards OneWorld software application suite.

The Davenports argued that customization and implementation involved qualifying design and testing. The court concluded that the project fell within the adaptation exclusion. It also rejected the proposed shrinking-back analysis because the taxpayers did not identify and substantiate a qualifying smaller business component.

State-Level R&D Tax Credit Frameworks and Conformity

While 26 U.S.C. § 41 defines the federal parameter of the credit, individual states frequently conform to this definition while imposing their own geographical, administrative, and evidentiary requirements. A review of executive interpretations and judicial rulings in Indiana, California, and Idaho illustrates how state taxing authorities enforce the business component test.

The Indiana Framework: Executive Interpretation and Tell City Boatworks

The Indiana Research Expense Credit (REC) is established under Indiana Code (IC) 6-3.1-4 et seq. Indiana incorporates federal research-credit concepts subject to its own conformity provisions and modifications. Taxpayers must substantiate qualified research, identify relevant business components, and support any shrinking-back analysis under the applicable state rules. Qualified expenses must relate to research conducted in Indiana.

The Indiana Department of Revenue (IDOR) examines project-level and component-level substantiation. Unsupported percentage estimates or retrospective allocations can lead to disallowance; estimates are not automatically invalid solely because they were prepared after the work.

In brewing, developing new recipes may involve technical uncertainty, but ordinary production does not qualify merely because a recipe is new. A defensible study should distinguish experimental activities from production labor and substantiate the component. Similarly, a construction contractor’s use of established professional knowledge does not itself establish qualifying uncertainty or experimentation. Outcomes depend on the activities and evidence in the particular claim.

An important state-level interpretation is Tell City Boatworks, Inc. v. Indiana Department of State Revenue, 162 N.E.3d 603 (Ind. Tax Ct. 2020). Tell City claimed Indiana RECs involving six vessel projects. After the Department denied the refund claim and the court held a five-day trial, the Indiana Tax Court affirmed the denial.

The court examined the relevant vessels and found failures to establish the business component or experimentation requirements. It recognized that some activities met other elements of the test, but an iterative design process alone did not establish qualifying experimentation. The evidence did not sufficiently identify qualifying subcomponents and link them to claimed expenses to permit shrinking back.

The California Framework: Appeal of Walden and Appeal of Abramson

California establishes its corporate research credit under Revenue and Taxation Code (RTC) Section 23609 and its personal income tax research credit under RTC Section 17052.12. California incorporates federal I.R.C. § 41 concepts subject to state modifications, including the requirement that qualifying research be conducted in California. The California Franchise Tax Board (FTB) administers claims, and the Office of Tax Appeals (OTA) hears relevant appeals.

In the Appeal of Walden, et al., taxpayers claimed credits for

Are you eligible?

R&D Tax Credit Eligibility AI Tool

Why choose us?

R&D tax credit

Pass an Audit?

R&D tax credit

What is the R&D Tax Credit? The Research & Experimentation Tax Credit (or R&D Tax Credit), is a general business tax credit under Internal Revenue Code section 41 for companies that incur research and development (R&D) costs in the United States. The credits are a tax incentive for performing qualified research in the United States, resulting in a credit to a tax return. For the first three years of R&D claims, 6% of the total qualified research expenses (QRE) form the gross credit. In the 4th year of claims and beyond, a base amount is calculated, and an adjusted expense line is multiplied times 14%. Click here to learn more.

Never miss a deadline again

R&D tax credit

Stay up to date on IRS processes

Discover R&D in your industry

R&D Tax Credit Preparation Services Swanson Reed is one of the only companies in the United States to exclusively focus on R&D tax credit preparation. Swanson Reed provides state and federal R&D tax credit preparation and audit services to all 50 states. If you have any questions or need further assistance, please call or email our CEO, Damian Smyth on (800) 986-4725. Feel free to book a quick teleconference with one of our national R&D tax credit specialists at a time that is convenient for you.

R&D Tax Credit Audit Advisory Services creditARMOR is a sophisticated R&D tax credit AI agent driven risk mock audit platform. It mitigates audit exposure by covering defense expenses, including CPA, tax attorney, and specialist consultant fees—delivering robust, compliant support for R&D credit claims. Click here for more information about R&D tax credit management and implementation.

Our Fees Swanson Reed offers R&D tax credit preparation and audit services at our hourly rates of between $195 – $395 per hour. We do not offer contingency fees but we can offer fixed fees in special circumstances. Learn more at https://www.swansonreed.com/services/our-fees/

R&D Tax Credit Training for CPAs

R&D tax credit

Upcoming Webinars

R&D Tax Credit Training for CFPs

bigstock Image of two young businessmen 521093561 300x200

Upcoming Webinars

R&D Tax Credit Training for SMBs

water tech

Upcoming Webinars
Contact Us

Send us a message and we will be in touch shortly!

Start typing and press Enter to search